Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL’s Restaurant Choice-not sure what to say/do?

517 replies

HamBone · 02/11/2023 13:00

This is a very first-world dilemma, but I’d welcome opinions on how to handle this.

Thanksgiving is coming up here in the US and we’re having a family get-together with DH’s side. Yesterday, DH told me that one of his sister’s wants to arrange a meal out to a specialist restaurant that weekend and I’ve just taken a look at the menu. Its’s very limited and I can’t see a single item that I’d like to eat. DS won’t be keen either. We’re not fussy eaters at all, but there’s nothing available that we’d want to pay for. Plus, it’s not particularly cheap.

How should I approach this with SIL? I think that she wants to try this restaurant and likes the idea of arranging a family outing, but it’s daft to waste money on food people don’t want. Will we be party poopers if I gently say that it’s not to our tastes, but we’re happy for everyone else to go and we’ll see them later?

I feel bad about this though. ☹️

OP posts:
ShirleyPhallus · 03/11/2023 14:26

WiddlinDiddlin · 03/11/2023 13:51

I have ARFID, gastroparesis and IBS, some days theres next to fuck all I'll eat! I get branded a 'fussy eater' all the time.

But saying it's OK to be a fussy eater, it clearly fucking isn't, one poster has been driven to post a shitty poem about how awful fussy eaters are.

And as PP says, people who have one or two hard nopes over things they have tried and really don't like, are branded 'fussy eaters'.

It's like you all think we do it on purpose? 'Attention seeking' has been mentioned in the thread already, 'hard work' as well...

If we go, say nothing then ask for something off menu or just order a side dish - we're attention seeking.

If we decline to go because theres nothing on the menu we'll enjoy - we're hard work.

If we ask if theres another restaurant that would suit everyones needs better - again, we're attention seeking AND hard work.

If you have a limited range of foods, for whatever reason, you absolutely cannot fucking win.

Having medical conditions doesn’t make you a fussy eater, imo!

Catxxxxxxxxxx · 03/11/2023 14:25

You cant say youre not fussy then not find something you'd eat from a choice of 12

WiddlinDiddlin · 03/11/2023 13:51

I have ARFID, gastroparesis and IBS, some days theres next to fuck all I'll eat! I get branded a 'fussy eater' all the time.

But saying it's OK to be a fussy eater, it clearly fucking isn't, one poster has been driven to post a shitty poem about how awful fussy eaters are.

And as PP says, people who have one or two hard nopes over things they have tried and really don't like, are branded 'fussy eaters'.

It's like you all think we do it on purpose? 'Attention seeking' has been mentioned in the thread already, 'hard work' as well...

If we go, say nothing then ask for something off menu or just order a side dish - we're attention seeking.

If we decline to go because theres nothing on the menu we'll enjoy - we're hard work.

If we ask if theres another restaurant that would suit everyones needs better - again, we're attention seeking AND hard work.

If you have a limited range of foods, for whatever reason, you absolutely cannot fucking win.

Munkimoo · 03/11/2023 13:47

Sounds like you are actually fussy. I would contact the venue, explain that you are a large booking but have two people with restrictive dietary requirements and could you book a meal that's using the ingredients off the menu with your unique tastes in mind or at least close to the menu ingredients.
Alternatively, tell sil you're not keen on the menu as you say and that you can catch up afterwards

silverbubbles · 03/11/2023 13:45

Hi Sil, This restaurant is a bit too specialist for us and our child. Any chance we could so somewhere a bit more main stream and you can eat crickets and frogs legs another day?

Xiaoxiong · 03/11/2023 13:44

@gannett it's the "within reason" part where insects become relevant. Someone not liking pasta is very different from not liking insects, fermented tofu, balut, century eggs, duck gizzards, jellyfish - these are much farther outside the mainstream of US/UK food culture and to choose a restaurant that not only has them on the menu but has few to no options that don't include those things is far more unreasonable than choosing an italian restaurant when one member of the group isn't keen on pasta.

UnderwaterSpaceCadet · 03/11/2023 13:41

MasterBeth · 03/11/2023 13:38

Then you're a fussy eater.

Some people are fussy eaters. It's OK.

But saying "I'm not a fussy eater but I won't eat fish MAKES NO SENSE!"

So the only people who you’d define as non-fussy eaters are people who will literally eat anything?

I think literally everyone I know would fall into the fussy eater category, then, including the person who will happily eat chicken feet, crickets and aubergine but doesn’t like capers.

Teeny1977 · 03/11/2023 13:38

Are there other kids going, you could be the cool Aunt and say why don't you and DS take the kids for Pizza or stay at sil House and have pizza and a movie night and the other adults can enjoy the fancy restaurant. Just say that the menu looks a bit too much for the kids to enjoy

MasterBeth · 03/11/2023 13:38

WiddlinDiddlin · 02/11/2023 13:19

Whats with the drama and insistence the OP is a 'fussy eater'... this is short hand for 'I don't like certain foods' and surely adults ARE allowed to not like certain foods.

What if its a fucking fish restaurant, that literally only serves a limited, set menu, that is just fish.

I'd not eat there. I'd not go to a meal there as I would be sat with nothing, I can't eat fish (makes me vomit really spectacularly which isn't fun for me or other diners).

OP - tell them the truth, theres nothing on the menu you'd eat and it won't be enjoyable for you, or presumably for them to watch you sit there not eating anything so you'll give it a miss if everyone else is set on going there, and join them another time.

Then you're a fussy eater.

Some people are fussy eaters. It's OK.

But saying "I'm not a fussy eater but I won't eat fish MAKES NO SENSE!"

gannett · 03/11/2023 13:36

LadyR77 · 03/11/2023 13:01

I mean, it was a massive drip feed about the bugs - if you'd said in your OP that the menu focused on crickets & grasshoppers etc., I think you'd have had very different responses! Going on about beans and aubergines made it sound like you were just being really fussy, but most people would probably baulk at forking out to eat insects.

I actually don't think the bugs are that relevant, even if they're more outside the norm than aubergine.

The nature of the dietary preference doesn't matter. Posters in this thread have said they don't like spices, cauliflowers and even pasta. If you're getting people together for a meal surely it's in everyone's interest that everyone enjoys the meal. It's not too hard to find a good restaurant that everyone, within reason, is happy with. (The obnoxiously fussy types who object to everything are a different matter for a different thread.) I'd happily eat bugs (and have done in the past).

The point of the thread is that it shouldn't be considered unreasonable for OP to opt out or suggest another restaurant, and yet she's enmeshed in family dynamics where this potentially leads to conflict.

Xiaoxiong · 03/11/2023 13:34

This is why everyone was asking you to post the menu - not because we want to out you but because it does have a bearing on who's being unreasonable.

Insects are not aubergines or beans. If it's a restaurant with so few options that every dish has fried crickets or stewed mealy grubs or whatever then your SIL is OF COURSE being completely U to expect everyone to go along with it.

I would say the same about eating horse in France/Belgium, eating whale in Japan, eating sheep head in Iceland or eating balut in the Philippines.

Deathbyfluffy · 03/11/2023 13:18

Catsfrontbum · 02/11/2023 13:17

If it is a specialist cuisine like an Indian Restaurant and you don't like spicy food then I can see what you mean....

However I would still go and give it a go, widen your horizons and all that!

There’s plenty of Indian food that isn’t even remotely spicy.

HamBone · 03/11/2023 13:17

@Peachy2005 Exactly, I’m not stopping anyone else from going, I’m quite happy to stay home alone and make myself a sandwich if everyone else goes. Or feed the children if just DH goes with his parents and siblings. 🤷

OP posts:
Peachy2005 · 03/11/2023 13:11

Saw your update, not sure why you asked her permission to sit it out (!) but it’s a move in the right direction. If she replies, just say the kids won’t eat anything there either and it’d be a massive waste of money. Hopefully it’ll be nice for DH to have some time alone with his family and he can suffer the food. Hold firm! 👍

HamBone · 03/11/2023 13:09

Diva’s abit strong, @Ibravedaflood, but theirs a tendency in DH’s family to do what she wants, she has a touch of the Golden Child.

She and I get on fine, there’s no animosity, but perhaps that’s because I’ve never disagreed with her before? 😂

OP posts:
LadyR77 · 03/11/2023 13:01

I mean, it was a massive drip feed about the bugs - if you'd said in your OP that the menu focused on crickets & grasshoppers etc., I think you'd have had very different responses! Going on about beans and aubergines made it sound like you were just being really fussy, but most people would probably baulk at forking out to eat insects.

Ibravedaflood · 03/11/2023 13:00

She sounds a pandered - to diva... Def a good idea to swerve the meal. Would love to know about the actual Thanksgiving meal too!

HamBone · 03/11/2023 12:51

@Cosywintertime I’m not preventing anyone else from going.

OP posts:
HamBone · 03/11/2023 12:50

I haven’t heard a peep from SIL.

The more I think about it, the less guilty I feel about being honest with her. She refuses to travel, which is why everyone has to travel to her for Thanksgiving. So she can hardly be upset if I’m not keen on doing something, she’s bloomin’ awkward herself!

OP posts:
Cosywintertime · 03/11/2023 12:16

HamBone · 02/11/2023 20:24

I texted SIL an hour ago saying that I’ve heard about the idea and is it ok if I sat this one out as I’m a less adventurous eater. No response yet (she’s read it).

Suspect she already knows that about you. But I do hope you let your son go. Starting to suspect the reason is financial.

LoobyDop · 03/11/2023 12:09

WorriedWitch18 · 03/11/2023 10:32

YANBU & I don't think you are fussy. I'm not a fussy eater but there's lots of foods that I have tried and don't like - fish, aubergine, chickpeas, Indian cuisine, coriander, anything spicy, chillies - I absolutely hate black pepper and can taste it in any dish. We're all different and have different tastes.

I like SEASONED food as in salt, umami seasoning etc - I don't like 'seasoning' that is spicy peppery or too herby

From that list, you are a fussy eater.

Overthehillbutnotveryfar · 03/11/2023 11:12

How can you know you in advance you won’t like it ? It’s so unusual
most people
wont ever have tried food like that . Give it a whirl - you might find it fun !

Charliechick86 · 03/11/2023 10:58

Not all of us in the UK like plain food some of us actually enjoy seasoning!

TheBerry · 03/11/2023 10:50

HamBone · 02/11/2023 13:11

DS is 15 so can’t do a lunchbox.

I know it sounds ridiculous, but it’s very specialized, 12 items on the menu, all seasoned, nothing plain. If I could order a bowl of soup or a plate of chips, for example, I’d be happy to go (and eat more else later!) but there’s nothing like that.

I think she wants to try this particular cuisine, but hadn’t considered that others might not be so keen.

You sound like quite a fussy eater???

If you only want “plain” things. I mean, I’m pretty sure most restaurants season all of their dishes. Unless you just want a burger from McDonald’s or something.

I’m sure there’s SOMETHING out of the 12 options you’d like, and your son too, but if you really think not then I guess just meet them after the meal 🤷🏻‍♀️

WorriedWitch18 · 03/11/2023 10:32

YANBU & I don't think you are fussy. I'm not a fussy eater but there's lots of foods that I have tried and don't like - fish, aubergine, chickpeas, Indian cuisine, coriander, anything spicy, chillies - I absolutely hate black pepper and can taste it in any dish. We're all different and have different tastes.

I like SEASONED food as in salt, umami seasoning etc - I don't like 'seasoning' that is spicy peppery or too herby