Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if boss was being unreasonable here?

61 replies

ArethaQ · 02/11/2023 07:34

Yesterday I felt really unwell with a pounding head, just felt dreadful. It was meant to be my office day and I have a very long commute. I asked my boss with plenty of notice if I'd be able to work from home. The job doesn't require me to be in the office, I can do it on my laptop and I'm easily contactable throughout the day.
She is normally quite reasonable but she replied almost implying that I was taking advantage and that everybody would be doing the same if they could. I don't necessarily think that's true, some people prefer going into the office and feel isolated at home. She said that it should be classed as a sick day.
I ended up going in. I sort of see what she's saying but it's the first time I ever requested to work from home on an office day and I was still going to get the work done, there was no purpose for me to be in the office that day, I'm in a very junior role.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
stichguru · 06/11/2023 18:29

I would say sick days are days off, unless it's really something that doesn't how you feel, but does affect your being or getting to the office. "I've broken my ankle and am fine sitting on my bum on a chair, but can't drive and don't feel safe wiggling about on a bus." WFH is fair enough. Also should be a bit different for people managing a chronic condition - the lines of "well" and "ill" become different and adaptations should be taken in much the same way as making the office ok for a wheelchair user.

moomoomoo27 · 05/11/2023 23:32

I'm an employer and we set the same rule for our company. If you're not well, it's a sick day. You're either well enough to work or you're not, and that applies in the office or at home. We don't want people to be "pushing through" when they're sick, they're sick and they need to rest.

If you had a headache and wanted to see how you felt in the second half of the day and you worked from home because you felt better in the afternoon, that makes sense. Your boss would be unreasonable if they didn't let that happen.

But generally, not enough people actually take time to rest when they're sick.

Tahlullah · 04/11/2023 20:40

I would generally agree where employees live locally. You sound quite black and white though. Do you have the same stance irrelevant of distance to the office? If someone for example had a 4 hour round trip commute would you still feel the same?

paulthepython · 04/11/2023 20:29

I think anyone should be able to work from home it it's reasonable and possible...so I think the company is unreasonable if they don't allow it when they could....but I think you were very unreasonable if you were saying you were too sick to commute as a reason to work from home. That simply makes it look like you weren't actually going to work, you wanted to be sick at home and be paid for it, and asking under those circumstances will likely make your boss paranoid about people working from home. If you are sick you are sick, you should of had the day off, or if you thought you were well enough to work you should have just called and asked to work from home - saying it would be a more efficient and effective day for you as it would cut out the travel time and you would be fresher to focus on your work.

Luxell934 · 04/11/2023 12:36

I don't think its unreasonable if it's the first time you've asked, if you can do the job at home anyway and only have to come in to meet a certain number of days then it's pointless waste of time anyway.

Give and take works both ways though, and I'm sure there will be a time when a favour is asked of you and you can happily say "No sorry" with no guilt.

LeedsMum87 · 04/11/2023 11:52

She sounds like a jobs worth who’s let power get to her head. Unfortunately there are people like this, you just have to nod and smile to. It’s not worth your energy to argue with her. I hope you’re feeling better x

Segway16 · 04/11/2023 11:00

Alwaysanotherwine · 02/11/2023 08:03

our olive is sick is sick

no wfh for any other reason inc childcare - that would be emergency leave and unpaid

wfh is getting a bit lax i feel

peoppe use it to fit round their lives but resulting in less productivity

Why shouldn’t people want a job to fit around their lives?

My team is far more productive when given the autonomy, flexibility and trust to decide what works best for them.

Segway16 · 04/11/2023 10:55

My employer would’ve just let me wfh. In fact they much prefer that to people coming in and spreading germs about. Sounds short sighted and ridiculous but different employees do things differently.

Circumferences · 04/11/2023 10:31

There isn't a "one size fits all" for WFH to those naysayers on this thread.
Some people are more productive WFH because they avoid travel problems and lateness, they aren't distracted by other people around, it gives a higher degree of job satisfaction etc.
For other people WFH is a total nightmare eg if there is a baby or toddler in the house, or they are the sort to crave human interaction.

In this case I presume your boss needs you to go into the office at certain times so they can do their job of monitoring and comparing your productivity on days in to days wfh.

They'll be checking your typing speed, email reply speed, click speed, time spent offline etc etc then comparing results for in office or wfh. Your boss will be frustrated if you chop and change your days. She'll need to make reports to send higher up the chain.

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 04/11/2023 10:14

Your boss sounds like a twat.

Fae1234 · 04/11/2023 07:39

The reason her boss wants here there is because she said so. I know some people on here may be in similar managerial roles but stop trying to make excuses for workplaces that treat junior employees like children.

Fae1234 · 04/11/2023 07:38

My old job was exactly like this. None of us were particularly happy about it. On a day when my period comes for example I don't feel like travelling for an hour to just show my face at my junior office role. My boss was generally unreasonable though and I left and moved to another department where I get treated like an actual grown up and nonsense like this doesn't happen.

KC2023 · 04/11/2023 07:35

Do you get sick pay? If so I would have taken the sick day. By going in you kinda proved your bosses point that you were able to.

Coolblur · 03/11/2023 09:57

I know you weren't taking the mick, but she has clearly dealt with some who do. It might also be that you said you were unwell and company policy is that you should take time off to recover.

Those who think that your work can be done at home and it makes no difference whether you're at your workplace or not, it really does, particularly if you support others who aren't sat at a computer all day so can't just drop you a message or call on Teams and continue working while awaiting a response.

My job can't be done anywhere but the workplace, but the office staff and management could work anywhere. For them there is a policy of being present in the building. There is some flex for unexpected issues, and a few people have agreements to wfh on particular days always Fridays Hmm. For the rest of us it's very frustrating when we can't get hold of someone quickly because they're wfh, it's so much easier when they're in the building and we can just pop to the office for 5 minutes to speak to them. It's a running joke among the rest of us that the office staff and management think the week ends on Thursday at 5 pm, meanwhile operations continue 24/7 without them, which begs the question, how essential are they?

I realise this is quite a specific example, but it'll be the same everywhere that people are expected to be present in the workplace. Your boss wants you there for a reason, if you're sick take a day off.

LlynTegid · 03/11/2023 08:39

Come in Friday instead would have been a better response.

PloddingAlong21 · 03/11/2023 08:36

This isn’t taking the mick on your part and not unreasonable on her part. She has a point. If you’re not well enough to be in the office you’re not well enough to work. If you’ve a terrible headache you shouldn’t be looking at your screen. If you can, go into work and work as expected.

I can see the company side of this if they’re struggling with visibility in the office etc and snowball effect.

Personally I don’t care if my team work from office or home providing work gets done. We have 1 mandatory office day per month where all 12 of us do a team day, training, etc. that’s non negotiable. The rest is upto them. At a company level they were trying to get everyone back in, but it just didn’t work as it’s a London office and recruitment during covid allowed people to recruit further afield so WFH had to stay in place because as a business we can’t ask people to reasonably commute a round trip of 4+ hours per day.

manticlimactic0 · 02/11/2023 19:59

ArethaQ · 02/11/2023 07:34

Yesterday I felt really unwell with a pounding head, just felt dreadful. It was meant to be my office day and I have a very long commute. I asked my boss with plenty of notice if I'd be able to work from home. The job doesn't require me to be in the office, I can do it on my laptop and I'm easily contactable throughout the day.
She is normally quite reasonable but she replied almost implying that I was taking advantage and that everybody would be doing the same if they could. I don't necessarily think that's true, some people prefer going into the office and feel isolated at home. She said that it should be classed as a sick day.
I ended up going in. I sort of see what she's saying but it's the first time I ever requested to work from home on an office day and I was still going to get the work done, there was no purpose for me to be in the office that day, I'm in a very junior role.

My manager says that her senior manager doesn't like people working from home when I've asked before. Fine

We're mega busy and the office doesn't open on weekends but she asked us to do overtime from home - on a weekend.

Nope, can't change your mind when it suits. Now she's got the monk on with us. 😂

stichguru · 02/11/2023 19:58

I think businesses have to be really careful about this. There's an extremely line between ALLOWING work from home if people don't want to travel/spread their germs, and PRESSURING people to work from home when they should be off poorly. While it's fine if the employee says they are ok to work from home, there could still be subtle pressures on others. You see others working from home, you know you have a huge workload, and you feel you SHOULD work from home, even if you feel like staying in bed, because maybe not doing so will push your workload onto others who managed to work from home when they had a bug. I think it's very reasonable NOT to allow work from home unless it is a very clear problem where working is fine and travelling is not. "I've broken my ankle, I can't drive, I don't want to risk wobbling around on the bus" is clear "I feel a bit sick and floppy, but probably have the energy to work" is very different.

DistantSkye · 02/11/2023 18:59

I'm undecided here. On one hand, I think there's no point in coming in just for the sake of it so taking the day to WFH seems reasonable - I probably would have asked to swap the office day in your situation too.

On the other hand, all the comments about "spreading germs" and the office cold seem quite melodramatic to those of us who always work in person. I'm in a school, obviously no option to WFH and the idea that you'd not go into work because of something fairly minor just to avoid spreading germs seems weird. But then again in teaching you're either at work, or too ill to work at all. There's no middle ground of sitting on the couch sending emails because you're a bit tired/headachey.
So I don't think YABU here but I can see why some bosses might be hesitant in some situations.

Miaminmoo · 02/11/2023 17:10

The problem is getting a balance of continuity between staff - in my opinion as an employer - if you’re not well enough to travel then you should take the day off sick. Since COViD started an endemic of people WFH my workforce have a bad habit of saying they are not well enough to travel to see customers but can do emails from home. As an employer it isn’t best practice when people to feel like they can’t take a day off sick - and we pay them for sick days so this isn’t financially driven - you’re either fit to work or you aren’t. I’m at my wits end (with my staff) of half measures just because they don’t appear to want sick days on their record. It could be that your boss is trying to make a clear line between being able to
work and not and doesn’t want to risk getting half a job done when you should be taking the day off. Just my opinion.

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 15:27

(Wonders what rocket surgery is... 🤔).

cstaff · 02/11/2023 14:41

They have been very flexible in my workplace in this regard. They would rather me wfh rather than spreading germs around to everyone else on my floor.

I would generally swap my days around if that was feasible. In fact, since covid I haven't had any sick days because of this.

RollerGirl7 · 02/11/2023 12:26

If your workplace says you're important enough and it won't cause issues if you work to 60%,70%, 80% effectiveness and is happy for that then great but you can't argue that you're too sick to get to work and sit at a desk but as productive as you would be if you weren't

RollerGirl7 · 02/11/2023 12:24

Brefugee · 02/11/2023 09:19

If you're so sick that you can't work in the office then you can't work as effectively as needed from home imo.

even though several of us have explained exactly why and how we don't go to the office when we are too sick to travel or have other needs (IBS was one) and working from home is a better alternative (for the company: they don't have someone off sick, the work is still being done)

It's not rocket surgery ;)

Thats exactly my point, if you've got IBS and are going to spend hours back and forth to be toilet (I do know a little about this having crohns) then you're not putting in a full shift, you're working less, not because you're at home but because you're sick.

If you're sick then take a sick day, don't take a day at home doing less than you would if you were fully well.

There's a real significant different in sickness rates between job roles that are fully office based and ones that are WFH and it's masking how sick ppl are, which isn't right. We should have decent sickness policies and if sick take the time off

Brefugee · 02/11/2023 09:19

If you're so sick that you can't work in the office then you can't work as effectively as needed from home imo.

even though several of us have explained exactly why and how we don't go to the office when we are too sick to travel or have other needs (IBS was one) and working from home is a better alternative (for the company: they don't have someone off sick, the work is still being done)

It's not rocket surgery ;)

Swipe left for the next trending thread