Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you prefer Halloween or Bonfire Night?

88 replies

LilyAB · 02/11/2023 02:19

YABU - Halloween 🎃
YANBU - Bonfire Night💥

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Floralnomad · 03/11/2023 20:00

I don’t do either although we did do bonfire night when the kids were small . Christmas is really the only thing I do with any relish and I’m already looking forward to having the tree up .

CanIPetThatDawg · 03/11/2023 19:58

My mother is 81 and went trick or treating as a child in Ireland. Admittedly the term 'trick or treat' wasn't used back then but they dressed up in costumes and went door to door collecting sweets (I think a lot of apples and nuts featured too) in exchange for a joke or a song.

Beezknees · 03/11/2023 19:39

Trick or treat is not a new thing. I'm 33 and we did it as kids, so I don't know why people are suddenly annoyed by it.

Needmorelego · 03/11/2023 17:28

I was reading up on the first "American" style Halloween celebrations - apparently they actually started in Canada.
So blame them.
🇨🇦
😂

BitofaStramash · 03/11/2023 17:11

I get annoyed about the Americanisation of Absolutely Everything, and that's one of my objections to Halloween

Its Scottish and its Irish and the Americans (and English) copied us.

Ididivfama · 03/11/2023 17:08

Hallowe’en. I’ve never been a big bonfire night person (don’t like the crowds and too many fireworks). And now I do Halloween a lot more I don’t have any energy by bonfire night anyway!

TheKeatingFive · 03/11/2023 17:07

I get annoyed about the Americanisation of Absolutely Everything, and that's one of my objections to Halloween

As an Irish person, pretty much everything we do at Halloween nowadays goes back generations, in some form or another.

This idea of 'Americanisation' seems vastly overstated to me. The Irish and Scot's took their customs over to the US as immigrants. They've been continuing them in their own countries ever since.

CoffeeCantata · 03/11/2023 16:38

@MummyJ12

Yes - I agree about Bonfire Night. I get annoyed about the Americanisation of Absolutely Everything, and that's one of my objections to Halloween, but really, I can't say I'd keen on the idea of burning a human effigy or celebrating either a massive explosion (which didn't happen) or the hanging, drawing and quartering of the conspirators either! And Bonfire Night is my sister's birthday, so I do have happy memories of fab bonfire parties with treacle toffee/baked potatoes/gingerbread etc when I was a child (lived on a farm).

But a lovely harvest and food-themed celebration would be wonderful - basically, Halloween minus the zombies and bloody make-up etc and with a bonfire added in if possible.

MummyJ12 · 03/11/2023 15:46

CoffeeCantata · 03/11/2023 14:04

To me, Halloween is super-naff and American and Bonfire Night (if you think about the historical origin) is very gruesome. Don't mind a pumpkin lantern but could do without the celebration of all things ghoulish. I'm not religious, so that's not my objection - but I hate seeing blood and gore as a fun element!

So - not crazy about either, but I think we need a festival of some sort at this time of the year - as light gives way to the months of darkness. Long ago the festival of Samhain was celebrated at this time and many other cultures have festivals at this time. In my ideal world it would be a harvest festival of food, light, pumpkins, apples, mulled cider etc - and you could have a bonfire too!

I think fireworks could wither away though, except for massive public displays.

It’s my understanding that Samhain was the start/origins of Halloween. The Celtic festival signaled the end of the harvest and the beginning of winter, which they associated with death. They’d light bonfires and wear costumes to ward off ghosts and evil spirits.

My dad’s family are Northern Irish, we had turnips instead of pumpkins and always celebrated.

We don’t do much for Bonfire Night, it seemed more of a thing when I was younger, my DD goes to the same school as Guy Fawkes did in York. It’s part of the history of this country but I think celebrating it has had its day.

AllesAusLiebe · 03/11/2023 15:32

Halloween. I love decorating the house, love horror films and DS really enjoys the dressing up!

When I first moved to the UK, I found bonfire night to be quite a puzzling, but quirky tradition. I remember thinking there's nothing more British than celebrating somebody who fucked up setting fire to a building.

Nowadays, however, I hate it. We often have idiots nearby setting them off on other random days (I don't understand why this isn't policed properly?!), disturbing our sleep and I do think that people with pets have a hard time, which to me seems unneccessary. To add to my killjoy credentials, I also don't think the environmental impact of fireworks can be justified anymore.

Oganesson118 · 03/11/2023 14:59

Bonfire Night.

Probably stems back to when I was a kid, we never did anything for Halloween, I didn't care for trick or treating and there was less emphasis on dressing up, "picking" pumpkins that are randomly strewn around a field, decorating the house. Whereas we always went to a local bonfire/firework display, had sparklers and fountain (ie non bangy) fireworks at home.

I do get the concern for animals (we have pets) and wish people would stick to the one weekend but I really don't get the hype around Halloween - I don't think it's that fun - so it's still about Bonfire Night for me. Besides given the active drug running gangs and wedding venues around us, fireworks are going off every two minutes anyway.

Pootles34 · 03/11/2023 14:55

Love both, but bonfire just wins for me - less commercial, I guess as it's just the UK who celebrate?

Have to have a proper bonfire, not as bothered about fireworks, also definitely need parkin. We also always have a guy, normally with the face of our most hated politician - apologies to the squeamish!

PrincessHoneysuckle · 03/11/2023 14:53

Halloween.me and dh love horror films and ds loves sweets.Win Win.

Gingerbee · 03/11/2023 14:27

I like both.

I like festivals that are celebrated in the autumn and winter.
All of them beat weekend telly.

It brings light and warmth.

I might do Saturnalia this year too😊

CoffeeCantata · 03/11/2023 14:04

To me, Halloween is super-naff and American and Bonfire Night (if you think about the historical origin) is very gruesome. Don't mind a pumpkin lantern but could do without the celebration of all things ghoulish. I'm not religious, so that's not my objection - but I hate seeing blood and gore as a fun element!

So - not crazy about either, but I think we need a festival of some sort at this time of the year - as light gives way to the months of darkness. Long ago the festival of Samhain was celebrated at this time and many other cultures have festivals at this time. In my ideal world it would be a harvest festival of food, light, pumpkins, apples, mulled cider etc - and you could have a bonfire too!

I think fireworks could wither away though, except for massive public displays.

PlinkyPlonk176 · 03/11/2023 13:02

Halloween for sure. I hate fireworks, there’s always some tit around here who sets them off for days before and after, usually just after I’ve fallen asleep.

BakedBeansforabrain · 02/11/2023 15:27

And it’s my birthday too on bonfire night

Tisfortired · 02/11/2023 15:25

I loved both as a child but as an adult, bonfire night. We get a packet of ‘low noise’ fireworks, sparklers, toast marshmallows and have tater ash (hash?) for tea. This year I have seen a slow cooker hot chocolate recipe which keeps it lovely and warm so you can keep topped up! My sister and nieces are coming round this year too so that will be fun.

luckylavender · 02/11/2023 15:22

Dislike like both

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 02/11/2023 15:20

RightOnTheEdge · 02/11/2023 15:17

Halloween.

There doesn't seem to be much to bonfire night anymore. No one has an actual bonfire and our town doesn't have a fireworks display since Covid because of the cost. My kids have been asking for fireworks this year but I'm a bit scared of lighting them and next door on both sides have pets and one has a baby.

What happened to penny for the Guy? I haven't seen anyone do that since I was a kid.

I was guessing maybe parents don’t let their children sit with a guy in the street (usually outside a shop) to get money or go door to door, probably due to safety, so no more penny for the guy.

RightOnTheEdge · 02/11/2023 15:17

Halloween.

There doesn't seem to be much to bonfire night anymore. No one has an actual bonfire and our town doesn't have a fireworks display since Covid because of the cost. My kids have been asking for fireworks this year but I'm a bit scared of lighting them and next door on both sides have pets and one has a baby.

What happened to penny for the Guy? I haven't seen anyone do that since I was a kid.

Enderunicorn · 02/11/2023 15:12

Bonfire night, I miss living in Sussex so much around this time of year.

WITFITTO · 02/11/2023 15:06

Halloween is my favourite.
I love Halloween. I wasn’t allowed to celebrate it when I was a child and I remember feeling sad watching all of the kids in my street dressed up and having fun outside while we did nothing. I over-compensate for it now.

BertieBotts · 02/11/2023 14:59

BirthdayFlower · 02/11/2023 10:06

Bonfire Night. Not fussed about fireworks but have many happy memories of having a bonfire as a child, eating sausages, tomato soup from a mug and parkin outside in the dark. Did it use to be a lot colder though?- I remember always being wrapped up in hats and gloves which seems crazy now.

It's definitely cold enough for hats and gloves once the sun has gone down!

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 02/11/2023 12:01

Coffeerum · 02/11/2023 10:46

@CanIPetThatDawg Would quite like to see that parade they have in Lewes (I think) where they burn an effigy of the Pope!

You can see loads of those in Belfast sure 😂

I’ve been there once, with a Catholic friend included. From what I recall it’s quite pagan and has lighted torches and barrel rolling but it’s good fun.

There are lots of parades of the societies and I found it crowded.