Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Punishment for DS12

65 replies

Str3bor · 01/11/2023 14:52

DS is 12 and in year 7 high school, I have recently discovered that he has been burning stuff in his room, he has been using a lighter and deodorant can to and burning various things such as toys, teddy's socks etc. He has also ruined the carpet in the room which he shares with DSS, there are burn marks and parts of it is singed.

I didn't realise he was doing it as the house just smelt of deodorant, I did notice that my socks were sticking to the carpet when I walked in the room but thought they must have spilt something so it was sticky.

Anyway he has been royally shouted at, told that he could have killed us all etc, ruined things we have paid for without a care and just what has gone through his mind that he thinks that that is acceptable behaviour. I've confiscated all of things including his phone and have told him he is not allowed out for a month, he is allowed to watch TV and that's it. It has been a week and he keeps asking when he can have his phone back, I don't want to give it back too soon as he needs to understand that the punishment is serious to reflect what he has done but he also needs it for homework and I am also finding it inconvenient not being able to contact him when picking him up from school, WWYD? Partner thinks he should be banned for a month but I was thinking maybe 2 weeks but don't want to be too lenient. If I was to give the phone back he would still remain banned off everything else still for the month and he would need to give it to me at 8pm every evening.

AIBU making him go without his phone for a month?

OP posts:
BeadedBubbles · 01/11/2023 17:00

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 01/11/2023 15:22

You do realise your behaviour and reaction has probably made the situation worse. Inital anger yes but i'd want to get to the bottom of why he was burning stuff and if something else was going on. Punishments like this just damage the connection and make him opening up to you about the why more difficult.

I think you need to try apologising to him for your reaction and discussing the situation. Deodorant cans worry me since a friend found their 13 year old dead in their room after inhaling. If something is going on anger and punishment isnt going to help! If its a case of youthful boredom then education is key. A fitting consequence would be replacing items damaged and some education (look up fire education videos etc for something fitting to bore him.with).

Find out the why then work on amends and learning.

Totally agree with this.

MidnightOnceMore · 01/11/2023 16:57

LaurieStrode · 01/11/2023 16:51

Potentially burning down the house is "really harmful," too.

The family's safety must take priority over a child's "private space" for the forseeable future.

Yes, which is why making a kid who starts fires angrier might not be the most sensible course of action.

Punishment is for the punisher's benefit. What matters here is changing the child's behaviour.

Pezdeoro41 · 01/11/2023 16:55

I personally don’t think you need to apologise for your reaction! If there was ever a time to shout this would be it…. This could have killed neighbours too, as well as your family. Of course you also need to connect and get him to understand, but I don’t think anyone could blame you for initial horror/anger….

Yalta · 01/11/2023 16:55

illbeinthegarden

I have a relative who would take apart his mums brand new toaster to see how it worked then couldn’t put it back together. He was 4 years old. Nothing was safe from him. He had to be monitored 24/7. His mum was upstairs putting clothes away one day and she came down to find he was taking her electric oven apart .

He did grow up and become an electrician and has done incredibly well for himself.

LaurieStrode · 01/11/2023 16:51

Potentially burning down the house is "really harmful," too.

The family's safety must take priority over a child's "private space" for the forseeable future.

Yalta · 01/11/2023 16:47

*cestlavielife · Today 15:31

Punishment of phone does not teach him anything
His dad the fireman should show him round fire station and show him videos of housefires
You need to address the cause not just "punish"*

Its not just the fire it’s what happens if he has burnt something that smoulders and starts to smoke when you are all asleep
Its not usually the fire that kills people it’s the smoke that gets people before the fire even starts.

I think his phone needs to be monitored and other friendships fostered so that this other boy is naturally filtered out of his life and he gets role models in his life that he can model his behaviour on

Str3bor · 01/11/2023 16:44

illbeinthegarden · 01/11/2023 16:21

My teen ds has done this in the past... I used to find bits of burnt paper outside his window. He likes fire and flames! It used to worry me sick and he was banned from having anything like lighters etc in his room and I hid them in the house. He's 16 now and has candles in his room and a lighter. He loves a scented candle. He is very responsible now thankfully.

We also had to ban scissors at one point as he used to cut up random stuff like socks and bedsheets. He has autism though and when younger used to do all sorts of bizarre stuff. I'm surprised our house is still standing!

He is really compulsive and can be obsessive about things, he likes to, what I deem as break stuff but whenever I have asked him why he has done that he has answered in the past that he just wanted to see what was inside and how it worked. i will try and talk to him on his own at some point to make him understand the danger and also why he has done it. he just brushes me off whenever I try and talk to him.

OP posts:
MidnightOnceMore · 01/11/2023 16:41

LaurieStrode · 01/11/2023 16:14

I'd take the bedroom door off, for starters. And no TV either. He can read books or do chores if he's bored.

This is dreadful advice.

This sort of ongoing random punishment makes kids more angry and more bored.

Those who start fires tend to be both bored and angry.

What needs to happen is for the parent to make things better, not worse.

tattygrl · 01/11/2023 16:37

LaurieStrode · 01/11/2023 16:14

I'd take the bedroom door off, for starters. And no TV either. He can read books or do chores if he's bored.

This is a really nasty thing to do and can leave kids with long lasting issues around privacy. Sounds ridiculous I know, but genuinely removing kids' bedroom doors and revoking the option to have a private safe space to retreat to/relax in is really harmful, more than you'd think.

illbeinthegarden · 01/11/2023 16:21

My teen ds has done this in the past... I used to find bits of burnt paper outside his window. He likes fire and flames! It used to worry me sick and he was banned from having anything like lighters etc in his room and I hid them in the house. He's 16 now and has candles in his room and a lighter. He loves a scented candle. He is very responsible now thankfully.

We also had to ban scissors at one point as he used to cut up random stuff like socks and bedsheets. He has autism though and when younger used to do all sorts of bizarre stuff. I'm surprised our house is still standing!

HellonHeels · 01/11/2023 16:21

For the aerosol misuse, stop buying aerosol cans of deodorant or anything else. Remove the source of danger alongside educating him about risks.

LaurieStrode · 01/11/2023 16:14

I'd take the bedroom door off, for starters. And no TV either. He can read books or do chores if he's bored.

HellonHeels · 01/11/2023 16:13

I'd take the phone away until he's older. He could do homework on a family pc or laptop, in a common area of your home where you can monitor his online activity.

Thelittleweasel · 01/11/2023 16:13

@Str3bor Please see @Antsinmypantsneedtodance about inhaling. The other thing is that many of aerosol cans can be used as a flame thrower!

Spectacular and utterly terrifying ...

Hillarious · 01/11/2023 16:13

Sounds like you need to talk, not shout.

HellonHeels · 01/11/2023 16:10

Was there a thought that setting a fire might bring his dad and firecrew round to save him?

Some people who set fires do it so they can swoop in to be a saviour. I'm wondering if his thinking is along those lines, but getting his dad to swoop in.

Ohnoooooooo · 01/11/2023 16:07

When my daughter filled on her adhd assessment form one of the questions was whether she lights fires.

MidnightOnceMore · 01/11/2023 16:06

tattygrl · 01/11/2023 15:55

From the post and your updates, this sounds serious. Focus less on punishment and more on communicating effectively with him on this. The thing about finding videos of his friend setting himself on fire and also that he used deodorant cans not just lighters/matches. Make this a real watershed moment on connecting with him, not causing a gap between you with harsh punishment.

(just to add I do think punishment is absolutely appropriate, ideally in the form of something connected to what he's done - just that the actual issues here clearly need addressing thoroughly and in a way that's more long-standing and in depth)

Just want to amplify what has been said here, this is the key and clearly put: Make this a real watershed moment on connecting with him, not causing a gap between you with harsh punishment

AbbeyGailsParty · 01/11/2023 16:04

Str3bor · 01/11/2023 15:28

Sorry for the dripfeed! He has a friend from his primary school who I don't particularly like and who is quite naughty (bullies kids, says he wants to be a drug dealer when he older etc) my son is now in a different school to this kid which was part of the reason I chose a different school but he still sees him occasionally when he stays in his dads (we don't live near enough). anyway after I took his phone I seen videos where he was in this kids house filming the kid doing the same thing but setting fire to himself. Needless to say he has been banned from ever seeing this kid again. BUT my son has his own mind and needs to understand how wrong it was what he has done.

There’s the root of the problem, and the danger.
Cutting him off from the friend and grounding him for a month would be sufficient punishment. I’d rather tackle the dangerous behaviour to prevent it happening again. Surely his dad, as a fire officer, is the best person to do this? You need to be united on this to help him make better choices in the future.

tattygrl · 01/11/2023 15:59

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 01/11/2023 15:22

You do realise your behaviour and reaction has probably made the situation worse. Inital anger yes but i'd want to get to the bottom of why he was burning stuff and if something else was going on. Punishments like this just damage the connection and make him opening up to you about the why more difficult.

I think you need to try apologising to him for your reaction and discussing the situation. Deodorant cans worry me since a friend found their 13 year old dead in their room after inhaling. If something is going on anger and punishment isnt going to help! If its a case of youthful boredom then education is key. A fitting consequence would be replacing items damaged and some education (look up fire education videos etc for something fitting to bore him.with).

Find out the why then work on amends and learning.

This is utterly harrowing, how horrendous for your friend (and you, what a traumatic event to hear of).

tattygrl · 01/11/2023 15:57

cestlavielife · 01/11/2023 15:31

Punishment of phone does not teach him anything
His dad the fireman should show him round fire station and show him videos of housefires
You need to address the cause not just "punish"

This is a good idea - I'm sure (if time and resources allow) his dad and his colleagues would be interested in being able to intervene in this and teaching the seriousness of fire safety. Getting the fire station staff involved would be impactful and informative, giving him an experience that could set him up for life in terms of his impulse control and sense of danger.

Fionaville · 01/11/2023 15:57

Personally I would give him his phone back, but keep him grounded. I would also monitor his Internet/phone usage a lot more. It's vital that he stays away from the other kid. Also try to remember that his brain is still very much developing. The reasoning part of the brain still has a long way to go in a 12 year old boy. There are a few good books about this. One is called 'Blame my brain' I'd read up as much about it as you can, the teenage years don't need to be as turbulent as lots of people say.

tattygrl · 01/11/2023 15:55

From the post and your updates, this sounds serious. Focus less on punishment and more on communicating effectively with him on this. The thing about finding videos of his friend setting himself on fire and also that he used deodorant cans not just lighters/matches. Make this a real watershed moment on connecting with him, not causing a gap between you with harsh punishment.

(just to add I do think punishment is absolutely appropriate, ideally in the form of something connected to what he's done - just that the actual issues here clearly need addressing thoroughly and in a way that's more long-standing and in depth)

MidnightOnceMore · 01/11/2023 15:48

Str3bor · 01/11/2023 15:21

His dad is a fireman - you think he would know better! I did tell his dad and said he would speak to him.

He was upset at the time but most likely about being caught out, he has apologised and said he knows it was wrong but other than that I think he is just bored (he being assessed for ADHD so he generally cant keep still anyway!). I told him he was grounded for a month but didn't specify a time on the phone, I just said I'll see how he is and decide. He doesn't get pocket money but I've taken his birthday money off him to contribute towards the damage. I just don't want to give it back too soon as I need him to understand the seriousness of it.

I think you need to focus more on WHY and also future prevention, rather than just bollocking/punishing.

Punishment doesn't really work that well, it makes parents feel like they are 'doing something' but it doesn't change behaviour.

-Proper consequences - so financial contribution to replacing damaged items
-Education - on fire safety
-Listening to why
all work better than punishment.

Interesting his dad is a fire officer. This may be significant. Does he see his dad as much as he would want?

Also poor impulse control is a feature of ADHD so prevention of risk will need to be ramped up in your house.

Swipe left for the next trending thread