Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know what difference a female perspective would have made?

209 replies

icewoman · 01/11/2023 13:15

Covid enquiry.

Helen McNamara, deputy cabinet secretary says women were being ignored and disregarded and the female point of view was missing from most decision making

I have no difficulty believing that our revered leaders behaved like a bunch or ignorant arrogant chauvinistic pigs but I do wonder what, if anything, a female point of view would have changed about the decision making?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SisterMichaelsHabit · 01/11/2023 17:26

icewoman · 01/11/2023 17:14

what an odd post. I started this thread feeling that surely there must be a huge advantage to having women involved in the decision making, although unable to articulate why. I have read this thread very carefully, and come to the conclusion that no one else can coherently articulate why either, so far from not reading, and digging in, I have read everything, and changed my opinion completely.

Lots of people from this thread have coherently articulated the answer to your query. Over 50 people, in fact.

icewoman · 01/11/2023 17:14

SisterMichaelsHabit · 01/11/2023 17:05

If you read the entirety of this here thread that you've started instead of just digging into your position with no real justification for your opinion, you might find the answers are staring you in the face. 🧐

what an odd post. I started this thread feeling that surely there must be a huge advantage to having women involved in the decision making, although unable to articulate why. I have read this thread very carefully, and come to the conclusion that no one else can coherently articulate why either, so far from not reading, and digging in, I have read everything, and changed my opinion completely.

OP posts:
SisterMichaelsHabit · 01/11/2023 17:05

icewoman · 01/11/2023 15:00

In what way?

If you read the entirety of this here thread that you've started instead of just digging into your position with no real justification for your opinion, you might find the answers are staring you in the face. 🧐

Ladyaelic · 01/11/2023 16:55

Nothing. The Little Boys' Trublu club doesn't pay any attention to things that can actually help women (although any second now the Billy Goats Gruff's mates will undoubtedly be along to bleat that it's only the Tories who know what a woman is).

MidnightOnceMore · 01/11/2023 16:53

FFS.

It would have meant women's views were included.

So when they heard that PPE didn't fit women they might not have just shrugged and ignored it.

Diversity is a strength. Group think is shit - Johnson's government was an echo chamber full of muppets.

ToBeOrNotToBee · 01/11/2023 16:52

Remember how men could go to the barbers but women's beauty salons remained shut.

Yeah. That.

PinkArt · 01/11/2023 16:49

There were times it was glaringly obvious no woman had been involved in decision making. The supermarkets that hazard taped off the tampons aisle as non essential, when barbers were planned to reopen before beauty salons, despite involving similar levels of closeness...

And as above all of the decisions that showed no-one in the room had to worry about their safety being out after dark, or how much more important leaving the house is when it's a tiny flat with no outside space or you live with a violent person, or how the fuck to educate your kids and keep your job.

Women were definitely missing in a lot of those conversations but so were a lot of other groups.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/11/2023 16:28

MarilynBoo · 01/11/2023 13:26

How policies would impact on children, carers, women experiencing domestic abuse in lockdown etc. Things I doubt the men in the room gave a second thought to.

Yes all of this.

Not being able to exercise with someone outside your household -not so much of an issue during the first lockdown when there was plenty of daylight, but not so great during the January 2021 lockdown, especially with the restrictive rules in Wales and Scotland.

The lockdown did have a greater negative impact on women.

Ponoka7 · 01/11/2023 16:26

"it’d all very class-inflected too - ‘I have a cleaner so the gendered division of labour is no longer a thing "

Absolutely, crap DH? Pay a woman to do what he can't be bothered doing.

Ponoka7 · 01/11/2023 16:24

Nothanksthanksanyway · 01/11/2023 15:36

The majority of women in these positions get there by behaving like men anyway. SO they aren't giving a female perspective at all. They are giving a male, middle class, arrogant perspective.

I don't like Suella Braverman, but she had a difficult time fighting for maternity leave and was public about it. Women had to attend maternity appointments, give birth and struggle on alone. It was women getting jobs in the police and fire service that made the misogyny public. It's rare that we don't bring a different perspective, or at least add a voice to a topic which is in danger of being ignored.

WinterDeWinter · 01/11/2023 16:15

Reading some of the replies here, it’s really striking how women have been disadvantaged by the kind of liberal feminism that is purely about economic opportunity and which thinks everything’s fixed because more girls than boys go to uni or whatever - ignoring the fact that the vast majority of women are still expected to do most of the unpaid -shitwork- domestic labour in society.

they ignore women’s biology too, as if it’s a weakness or failing that we need to pretend doesn’t exist, rather than something which must be factored in to how we organise society and the economy if we’re to have true equality.

it’d all very class-inflected too - ‘I have a cleaner so the gendered division of labour is no longer a thing .’

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 01/11/2023 16:11

It's very well documented that diverse groups make better decisions. Surely you're aware of this, OP?

The wider range of perspectives around the table, the better, surely?

Lottapianos · 01/11/2023 16:06

'I think if the country was run by people like her & Louise Casey as the policy makers, it would be a better place'

Couldn't agree more. Helen MacNamara's thoughtful, empathetic approach couldn't be more different to Cummings, Johnson, Hancock etc. The only tool they had in their box was to butch it out and hope for the best. Referring to employees like her as 'cunts' - people who were trying hard to figure out the right thing and to show some proper leadership. What a disgraceful shower

And women shouldnt be excluded, talked over, intimidated or patronised because we are half the frigging population. That's why

Fionaville · 01/11/2023 16:05

The women in government? No difference whatsoever. All of the female, tory prime ministers have been abysmal. None of them have shown any particular care for other women or children. I don't think any of the tory women, in with a chance of decision making, would have made a difference.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/11/2023 16:04

Butlinsorbust · 01/11/2023 15:26

‘You can't understand why the input of a representative of half of the population on issues that affect all of the population would be valuable. Really?’

this with bells on…

Bells and flashing lights.

The misogyny believing that men are capable of making all decisions for us, without us! It's astounding.

Where's that meme with the dogs deciding cat medical policy?

Onethingatatime23 · 01/11/2023 16:04

I said all the time when these random shit decisions were being made at short notice, people having to cancel travel arrangements - we were meant to be going to see family the day after Nick Hancock announced on Twitter at 9pm, fucking 9pm the absolute shitclown, that you could not longer visit people in their homes in Greater Manchester - but hey, in the pub was ok - as it was now in Zone 3 instead of 4 or whatever the random shit system was - that none of these men had obviously ever had to book travel or make arrangements or run an household as they have wives or PAs doing it for them. I think that's what she means.

Newgirls · 01/11/2023 16:03

Watching her talk i thought she also meant the specific women in that room were ignored even though, like her, they were senior in their positions

that boris et al would only listen to ‘men like them’

MissyB1 · 01/11/2023 16:02

theresnolimits · 01/11/2023 15:58

Just read her testimony. She gives specific examples of how issues directly affecting women were ignored. She is clear and cogent.

It is utterly depressing to read and yet somehow totally unsurprising. There were many threads about this on here at the time.

I'm hoping that a lot will be learned and understood from the Covid inquiry and if it stops this 'exclusion' ever happening again, then something will have been gained.

And it's equally depressing to read a thread like this dismissing women's concerns on a predominately female forum.

Well precisely this. And it almost beggars belief that OP would even ask this question!

KatBurglar · 01/11/2023 15:59

I'd answer you but I'd expect a faux naïve "but how?" response like you've given others.

Instead, I suggest you read the outstanding analysis of just why it's essential women are involved in all fields (and the devastating outcomes when they aren't involved) Invisible Women by Calorline Criando Perez.

It's available in paperback, as a kindle book and in most libraries.

Quite simply, when women are part of the decision making, lives are saved in so many unexpected ways. Even snowplough use is gender-affected.

The more diverse a group, the better the decisions will be.

theresnolimits · 01/11/2023 15:58

Just read her testimony. She gives specific examples of how issues directly affecting women were ignored. She is clear and cogent.

It is utterly depressing to read and yet somehow totally unsurprising. There were many threads about this on here at the time.

I'm hoping that a lot will be learned and understood from the Covid inquiry and if it stops this 'exclusion' ever happening again, then something will have been gained.

And it's equally depressing to read a thread like this dismissing women's concerns on a predominately female forum.

AutumnCrow · 01/11/2023 15:53

Nothanksthanksanyway · 01/11/2023 15:36

The majority of women in these positions get there by behaving like men anyway. SO they aren't giving a female perspective at all. They are giving a male, middle class, arrogant perspective.

Not all of us, no - although I absolutely appreciate the point you are making and I have seen it in action.

(You sit there at the boardroom table wanting back-up for a point you've made about, say, social policy not being just a plaything for white, upper middle-class males, and the one other woman in the room decides to play the 'being female never held me back' game.)

beguilingeyes · 01/11/2023 15:49

It's not just that they were men either, it's that they were, by and large, rich men. She said that a lot of the cabinet couldn't conceive of having no outside space, or only one loo/bathroom.

ElaineMBenes · 01/11/2023 15:38

How policies would impact on children, carers, women experiencing domestic abuse in lockdown etc. Things I doubt the men in the room gave a second thought to.

This!! I lost count of the amount of times I said that you could tell polices were being made people who have never had to worry about childcare .

Nothanksthanksanyway · 01/11/2023 15:36

The majority of women in these positions get there by behaving like men anyway. SO they aren't giving a female perspective at all. They are giving a male, middle class, arrogant perspective.

hydriotaphia · 01/11/2023 15:34

Does it actually matter whether the female perspective would have 'added' anything. The women in the civil service/government were employed to do a job and entitled to be respected in the jobs they were doing. The fact that they were systematically talked over/ignored during covid means at the very least that a large number of qualified professionals were hindered in doing their job and decision-making was dominated by a self-selecting few. You don't have to think that men and women have their own unique viewpoints to think that this is likely to have been bad for decision making. And fwiw I think it is very likely correct that as many posters have pointed out women are more likely to have considered impact of lockdown on certain vulnerable groups.