Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know what difference a female perspective would have made?

209 replies

icewoman · 01/11/2023 13:15

Covid enquiry.

Helen McNamara, deputy cabinet secretary says women were being ignored and disregarded and the female point of view was missing from most decision making

I have no difficulty believing that our revered leaders behaved like a bunch or ignorant arrogant chauvinistic pigs but I do wonder what, if anything, a female point of view would have changed about the decision making?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
verdantverdure · 02/11/2023 12:42

Our local pub landlord employs lots of younger women too @Reugny.

As you say, it's not for their policy input.

verdantverdure · 02/11/2023 12:41

Never mind a female perspective.

It is becoming clear that just some fully functioning human empathy would have been a start.

I can't escape the impression that the Tories had some understanding of People Like Them and the rest of us were caricatures at best.

Reugny · 02/11/2023 12:38

Papyrophile · 02/11/2023 12:36

Apologies if this point has already been made, but for me it was notable that barbers were allowed to re-open before beauty salons. Businesses that are primarily female owned and operated seemed to suffer disproportionately, and many didn't qualify for the reliefs and support grants. So yes, I do think a greater female input would have helped.

But...but... Dominic Cummings claims he employed lots of younger women.

Women who wouldn't stand up to him and suggest stuff to him.

verdantverdure · 02/11/2023 12:37

beguilingeyes · 02/11/2023 12:23

The stuff coming out of the inquiry is chilling. Every awful thing we may have thought about what was going on at No.10 pales in comparison to what's coming out.
Matt Hancock deciding who lives or dies? Dear God.
Why are there no consequences for these people?

I have an extremely low opinion of our government's covid response but that even stopped me in my tracks.

Papyrophile · 02/11/2023 12:36

Apologies if this point has already been made, but for me it was notable that barbers were allowed to re-open before beauty salons. Businesses that are primarily female owned and operated seemed to suffer disproportionately, and many didn't qualify for the reliefs and support grants. So yes, I do think a greater female input would have helped.

beguilingeyes · 02/11/2023 12:23

The stuff coming out of the inquiry is chilling. Every awful thing we may have thought about what was going on at No.10 pales in comparison to what's coming out.
Matt Hancock deciding who lives or dies? Dear God.
Why are there no consequences for these people?

Brefugee · 02/11/2023 08:23

Not forgetting that the decision making was being advised on by people who have expertise. Hence the emails that are now coming out that were literally saying all the things we've been saying about how people live different lives.

I'm sure well-paid high grade civil servants don't all live in a 1 bed one toilet flat with no garden, and yet the emails that are coming out show that they were considering people who live in those conditions.

I hope that all of you with your right to a bank account, equal pay, a mortgage and not to have sex with your husband even if he wants it are even a tiny bit grateful that women of the past stuck their necks out for us. I know i am.

sashh · 02/11/2023 08:09

Maybe san pro would have started on the essentials list instead of being added later?Do you remember when you could only buy certain things?

Maybe allowing fathers at the birth of their child to support the mother? Or in an ultrasound scan where they may be bad news?

Maye PPE that actually fitted women and didn't leave gaps around the mouth making them useless. Particularly given the numbers of women working in health and care settings.

Maybe some thoughts about toilet breaks where women need to remove more clothing and PPE.

Some thoughts about childcare for single parents, who are usually women.

theresnolimits · 02/11/2023 08:07

Interesting someone mentioning how women fought for the vote.

Some of the replies on here remind me of the ‘men know best’ and ‘women are too emotional’ arguments that were put forward to stop women getting the vote. They were completely rejected then and it was accepted that women’s voices needed to be heard.

Yet here we are 100 years later discussing the exclusion of women’s views in the political debate. And some people arguing they have nothing to add and it makes no difference. How depressing .

PosterBoy · 02/11/2023 08:07

I still don't think people are getting the point. It was a Tory government in charge. Your choices in that room making decisions were from Tory politicians of two sexes. They all have the same background and life experiences of each other, and not of the average person. None of them, male or female, have to go through their house to their garden. They don't travel by train to watch the football on a weekend. None of them do the family Xmas shop at Tesco after working all day in a care home. The women as much as the men don't live in houses with one toilet or visit people who have houses with one toilet. The Conservative party could provide you with people of different faiths, colour and gender in that room but it couldn't provide you with people from the working or lower middle classes, male or female.

Lottapianos · 02/11/2023 07:59

'Blokes all so well off they Just.Did.Not.Think

Oh and also, that not all back gardens had a back gate. So what do you do if people have to go through your house to get to the garden...'

I read that she also had to explain that some households only have one toilet / bathroom and no access to outdoor space, and tried to get them to imagine what that would be like under lockdown for weeks on end. Their tiny minds were blown 🙄

Icefoot · 02/11/2023 07:52

It depends which women. I don't think over privileged, self obsessed, power hungry women would have been any better than their male counterparts. Women who were living the impact would have made a difference but so would those men.

Brefugee · 02/11/2023 07:45

All the "but the nurse..." "but Theresa May..." "but Liz Truss..." are missing the point. For sure at an individual level people can be absolute arses.

At the policy development level, it has been shown time and again that having minority / differing voices at the table brings better results for everyone, not just those who look like the decision makers. I am very sure that if minority voices were heard different faith groups, different cultural groups, women, disabled voices... the decision making wouldn't have been quite as skewed as it was.

Yes, men in power should consider women, minorities, children etc. But we know they don't. Which is one reason women fought so bloody hard for a voice.

And the fact that many (women especially) don't seem to grasp this is depressing. I'm another one who says: read Invisible Women. The snowplough thing is eye-opening and enraging.

Paperbagsaremine · 01/11/2023 22:27

Apparently she also had to explain to them that attending a football match didn't just involve watching it in the open air, but ALSO,

  • being crammed together on public transport
  • going through turnstiles and passages in crowds
  • going to the pub with your mates afterwards
All of which are rather more risky infection scenarios than the actual watching bit.

Blokes all so well off they Just.Did.Not.Think

Oh and also, that not all back gardens had a back gate. So what do you do if people have to go through your house to get to the garden...

verdantverdure · 01/11/2023 21:54

Maybe women wouldn't have been "laughing at the Italians"

I don't know anyone who saw the early covid footage coming out of Italy in early 2020 and found it funny.

But apparently Boris Johnson did.

Clariee45 · 01/11/2023 21:31

I would have kind of hoped a female perspective might have changed things and think yes it probably would have helped. However on the other hand I always remember an awful post with a tired nurse telling parents not to grumble about being at home with their kids. As someone who worked in healthcare and soon about to return from maternity leave. I saw the post shared by some colleagues/friends and was quite annoyed about it. Not everyone had children that coped well with lockdown and for many it was quite dire. I was not the only one who was actually glad to get back to work despite often caring for covid positive patients, wearing PPE etc, doing exactly the same job as those sharing the posts. I think it just illustrates that not everyone woman was in the same boat or can even imagine what it’s like for other women

MidnightOnceMore · 01/11/2023 21:19

Saschka · 01/11/2023 21:15

I’m sorry, but male politicians do not get a pass on not considering the impact of their actions on 75% of the population (old people, women and children) just because they aren’t women and can’t be expected to think how things might affect people who are not exactly like them and their donors.

The problem here is that not a single person in that government gave a flying fuck about “normal people”. The precise gender split is an irrelevance.

Of course they don't get a free pass, they deliberately excluded various voices.

But if you want women to be represented, they have to be there.

KarmenPQZ · 01/11/2023 21:18

Dotjones · 01/11/2023 13:18

Liz Truss did a remarkable job when she brought her female perspective to the top job. Plus people like Priti Patel or Dianne Abbot, they're almost universally respected for their opinions and decisions, their female perspective must have really helped.

I had to re-read this several times I was so wishful it was true. But coming to the inevitable conclusion 🤦‍♀️

Saschka · 01/11/2023 21:15

EqualityWhatequality · 01/11/2023 19:03

MarilynBoo · Today 13:26

How policies would impact on children, carers, women experiencing domestic abuse in lockdown etc. Things I doubt the men in the room gave a second thought to.

Exactly this. The right people weren’t at the table. There was expertise in these areas that was missing from the decision making.

I watched her testimony and she was brilliant. So depressing though.

I’m sorry, but male politicians do not get a pass on not considering the impact of their actions on 75% of the population (old people, women and children) just because they aren’t women and can’t be expected to think how things might affect people who are not exactly like them and their donors.

The problem here is that not a single person in that government gave a flying fuck about “normal people”. The precise gender split is an irrelevance.

verdantverdure · 01/11/2023 21:12

The Tories know what a woman is though so apparently that means they don't have to listen to any.

Brefugee · 01/11/2023 20:12

PosterBoy · 01/11/2023 19:51

No, we are asking how having Liz Truss, Priti Patel or Esther McVey would have changed policy. Although maybe we wouldn't have had lockdowns at all, to be fair, so it might have changed things a lot. Possibly not in the way meant today.

the fact that the names (of women politicians) crop up so often is that there were very very few of them, so we all know who they are. And sure, those ones were shit because they were too busy being politicians and ignoring the actual problems that competent and experienced civil servants were trying to raise.

One of the things that was completely ignored until it was way too late was the issue of abortion and the urgent needs that many women had

AutumnCrow · 01/11/2023 20:10

Give me an answer to this question.

Here is an answer to your question.

Not THAT answer. I don't want that answer to my question.

Well, here are two more excellent answers to your questions.

Fuck off they're wrong too

Okay. How about we decide on our terms of reference here?

That's wrong too.

Brefugee · 01/11/2023 20:05

icewoman · 01/11/2023 17:14

what an odd post. I started this thread feeling that surely there must be a huge advantage to having women involved in the decision making, although unable to articulate why. I have read this thread very carefully, and come to the conclusion that no one else can coherently articulate why either, so far from not reading, and digging in, I have read everything, and changed my opinion completely.

then you need to read it again. Properly read and understand because several posters have pointed out exact scenarios where women's voices might have resulted in fewer women ending up dead.

PosterBoy · 01/11/2023 19:51

itsgettingweird · 01/11/2023 19:19

Are we actually asking how having the opinion of woman who are working woman, know the role of woman, understand the vulnerabilities of woman in DV relationships, understand the woman's role in a home to name a few ......

Would have differed from the view of middle to upper class working men who likely had nannys, SAH partners, partners at home managing the household.

Seriously????

I'm surprised it needed an inquiry to even work out it matters.

But I'm glad the inquiry has highlighted the POV was missing.

No, we are asking how having Liz Truss, Priti Patel or Esther McVey would have changed policy. Although maybe we wouldn't have had lockdowns at all, to be fair, so it might have changed things a lot. Possibly not in the way meant today.

Ozgirl75 · 01/11/2023 19:50

“Can you tell me why there should be women involved in decision making?”

dozens of women giving sensible well articulated answers that answer the question

”those answers are sexist because women understand women’s business”

🙄