Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know what difference a female perspective would have made?

209 replies

icewoman · 01/11/2023 13:15

Covid enquiry.

Helen McNamara, deputy cabinet secretary says women were being ignored and disregarded and the female point of view was missing from most decision making

I have no difficulty believing that our revered leaders behaved like a bunch or ignorant arrogant chauvinistic pigs but I do wonder what, if anything, a female point of view would have changed about the decision making?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
verdantverdure · 04/11/2023 12:25

Thank you @RobinStrike

AdamRyan · 04/11/2023 10:59

Eleganz · 03/11/2023 16:20

Perhaps if women like Helen McNamara had spent less time popping along to parties in number 10 and more time acting like the senior civil servant she was paid to be we'd have had women's issues thought about more in the pandemic response.

Her evidence at the inquiry was as if she was having some kind of out of body experience. She was there in the middle of it as a senior person! She was totally ineffective, the copy of her email asking the head of the NHS about PPE for women was as if she was writing to a senior manager not the deputy cabinet secretary asking a serious question.

What a load of balls.
Its really very clear none of the men were interested in what the women in the room had to say. Blaming women for that by saying they weren't communicating effectively is classic sexism.

Eleganz · 03/11/2023 16:20

Perhaps if women like Helen McNamara had spent less time popping along to parties in number 10 and more time acting like the senior civil servant she was paid to be we'd have had women's issues thought about more in the pandemic response.

Her evidence at the inquiry was as if she was having some kind of out of body experience. She was there in the middle of it as a senior person! She was totally ineffective, the copy of her email asking the head of the NHS about PPE for women was as if she was writing to a senior manager not the deputy cabinet secretary asking a serious question.

RobinStrike · 03/11/2023 16:08

Brilliant article by Caroline Criado Perez of "Invisible Women"

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/nov/03/covid-inquiry-women-ill-fitting-ppe-pandemic-unisex-healthcare?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

Papyrophile · 02/11/2023 20:41

I may be an outlier, because I was 65 and in 2020, my primary concern was my DMIL. Her dementia was beginning to accelerate when Covid kicked off. The carefully picked care team supporting her independent life fell apart in January 2020; DSIL was booked in for a long awaited knee surgery, so she went into respite care a week before the big first lockdown. For months, noone could visit; then we were allowed to sit outdoors/ indoors to talk. For us it was either Facetime or a 13 hour round trip. After five months, DMIL had to choose between selling her house for care or living unsupported with random carers. As we had PoA, we sold her house to fund the care home she needed, because otherwise she would have been sat in her own excrement waiting for any random bod the council could hire to arrive to clean her. It was not enjoyable for any of us. And it cost DMIL a flippin fortune. Under two years of care absorbed two thirds of her estate's value, plus her army widow's pension.

Clariee45 · 02/11/2023 20:35

Yes

mambojambodothetango · 02/11/2023 20:30

Going back to the OP, the example i heard was that female scientists were ignored.

EasternStandard · 02/11/2023 19:59

Imo Sweden did better for women and children

EasternStandard · 02/11/2023 19:55

Challengemonica · 02/11/2023 19:52

EasternStandard - yeah, that's why I mentioned NZ and Denmark. Sturgeon's presentation during the pandemic was spot on and as much as she tried to differentiate from England, policy was virtually identical. Being a woman doesn't make one a better leader any more than a man does, but it can give a broader/ different perspective and priorities.

Idk I think those in Auckland probably suffered their prolonged lockdown as much as we did.

Harder still as it gave the rest of the country freedoms they didn’t have.

Challengemonica · 02/11/2023 19:52

EasternStandard - yeah, that's why I mentioned NZ and Denmark. Sturgeon's presentation during the pandemic was spot on and as much as she tried to differentiate from England, policy was virtually identical. Being a woman doesn't make one a better leader any more than a man does, but it can give a broader/ different perspective and priorities.

pikkumyy77 · 02/11/2023 19:01

hopeishere · 01/11/2023 13:28

Loads of women wouldn't think about those either though.

Not really, no.

verdantverdure · 02/11/2023 19:00

And there's this:

to not know what difference a female perspective would have made?
verdantverdure · 02/11/2023 18:58

Simon Stevens says that "certainly by the beginning of March it could be seen that if action was not taken to reduce the growth of COVID then the NHS would be overwhelmed"

Wasn't it at the beginning of March that Boris Johnson said "Take it on the chin" on This Morning?

And the middle of March when Cheltenham went ahead? And some football matches?

And March was most likely when the people who died in April caught covid.

It honestly beggars belief.

EasternStandard · 02/11/2023 18:32

And closing borders was still not realistic at all

EasternStandard · 02/11/2023 18:17

Reugny · 02/11/2023 18:11

The best thing New Zealand and Denmark did was shut their borders.

The government made up excuses why we couldn't. Heathrow was a clusterfuck bringing in the virus. Priti Patel was very quiet about that.

Not the borders thing again.

Think about food and goods getting into the U.K. on lorries

It’s not just flights.

Reugny · 02/11/2023 18:11

Challengemonica · 02/11/2023 15:55

But it did make a difference, didn't it, in countries like Denmark and New Zealand? Who knows if it's because they were led by women but I suspect they were able to take a broader view. As for the UK, absolutely disgusting - you wouldn't let them take charge of a school disco ffs

The best thing New Zealand and Denmark did was shut their borders.

The government made up excuses why we couldn't. Heathrow was a clusterfuck bringing in the virus. Priti Patel was very quiet about that.

CruCru · 02/11/2023 17:46

I remember MN at the time. There were some threads called the “Anti Dementors” which were set up by people who thought the lockdowns were a pretty bad idea. They were often lighthearted and contained pictures of wonky vegetables that people had grown. Quite often posters would come onto the the threads and try to pick fights with the ADs (who would often ignore them). It was as though any opinion which diverged in any way from “Lockdown as much as possible” was unacceptable.

There was a teacher who put up really long posts about how unsafe schools were and that all schools should be redesigned to include better ventilation / be more safe. Many people were not sure how this would happen but they were shouted down.

SalmonWellington · 02/11/2023 17:11

They issued guidance about nannies months earlier than guidance about after school clubs. Whole class/gender/selfishness clusterfuck going on there.

MidnightOnceMore · 02/11/2023 17:05

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 02/11/2023 16:58

Yes it was obvious it would cause harm.

What I don't understand is why you feel you were special in spotting it.

I think because - on MN at least - loads of posters flat-out denied that there would be any harm. And said that, if there was, it was just the fault of the parents for not providing a satisfactory homeschooling/home childcare environment because ‘SCHOOLS AREN’T CHILDCARE.’ It wasn’t just that these people thought there would be harm, but it was justified. It was a complete denial. The mere suggestion that measures could have negative effects was heresy and murder.

As I’ve said upthread, I think it’s possibly because people who were furloughed were overrepresented on Mumsnet, and also a certain kind of SAHP who felt their choice had finally been justified and enjoyed the advantage they felt their children were getting. But overall, the public wanted lockdowns. Which is unsurprising because lots of them were getting paid not to work.

If you read your post, it is full of negative interpretations of other people. It reminds me a lot of the tone of debate in 2020/21.

This projection of bad motivation onto fellow citizens is negative.

I could just as well say those who didn't support school closures hated old people and didn't care if people with disabilities died. Those things were said too.

I think people were generally really stressed during COVID. It was stressful and chaotic. We had no clear leadership and it was obvious there was no plan.

It was a shit time.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 02/11/2023 16:58

Yes it was obvious it would cause harm.

What I don't understand is why you feel you were special in spotting it.

I think because - on MN at least - loads of posters flat-out denied that there would be any harm. And said that, if there was, it was just the fault of the parents for not providing a satisfactory homeschooling/home childcare environment because ‘SCHOOLS AREN’T CHILDCARE.’ It wasn’t just that these people thought there would be harm, but it was justified. It was a complete denial. The mere suggestion that measures could have negative effects was heresy and murder.

As I’ve said upthread, I think it’s possibly because people who were furloughed were overrepresented on Mumsnet, and also a certain kind of SAHP who felt their choice had finally been justified and enjoyed the advantage they felt their children were getting. But overall, the public wanted lockdowns. Which is unsurprising because lots of them were getting paid not to work.

EasternStandard · 02/11/2023 16:40

I would be far less ragey if they said 'you know what, I supported that at the time and I wish I hadn't.' That would be productive.

I wonder if any poster who spent the pandemic hurling abuse at anyone pointing out harms to women and children would be this productive.

BallaiLuimni · 02/11/2023 16:33

MidnightOnceMore · 02/11/2023 16:03

I think trying to understand people will be more productive for me than calling my neighbours arseholes and idiots, so I agree we differ in that regard!

Have a good rest of the day @BallaiLuimni

I agree that trying to understand is important, but I don't see many people actually examining their thinking. I've seen a few people admit that they regret their pro-lockdown stance, but they don't seem to have much insight into why they thought that way. With the inquiry I'm just seeing people use the Tories as an easy target to deflect from the fact that they were totally in favour of all the policies they're now criticising. That's why I'm taking the immature approach of calling them idiots - I would be far less ragey if they said 'you know what, I supported that at the time and I wish I hadn't.' That would be productive.

MidnightOnceMore · 02/11/2023 16:03

BallaiLuimni · 02/11/2023 15:52

I don't think anyone who called for schools to be closed in January 2021 is caring. I think they're a shortsighted idiot. So I suppose that's where we differ.

I think trying to understand people will be more productive for me than calling my neighbours arseholes and idiots, so I agree we differ in that regard!

Have a good rest of the day @BallaiLuimni

EasternStandard · 02/11/2023 15:58

Challengemonica · 02/11/2023 15:55

But it did make a difference, didn't it, in countries like Denmark and New Zealand? Who knows if it's because they were led by women but I suspect they were able to take a broader view. As for the UK, absolutely disgusting - you wouldn't let them take charge of a school disco ffs

Why don’t you try closer to home with Sturgeon?

Who shut private nurseries causing huge stress to working women and impacting dc