Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’m not lazy or taking the “easy way out” for having a c section!

137 replies

Younghearts · 01/11/2023 12:41

I’m sure she didn’t mean too, but friend upset me earlier by her throw away comment. I had a c section 8 months ago, a couple of days into my induction because babies heart rate sky rocketed and I got extremely anxious and asked for an elective. It was a hard recovery but I do not regret it and loved my experience. I could have maybe continued with the vaginal route - but the nurses were constantly putting me on drips and monitors and I’d had enough and no sleep.

Anyway, having a light hearted convo with a friend and told her I’d probably have an elective c section if I was to have another DC and she said “Oh no you’re missing out, don’t take the easy way out and be lazy! It’s amazing pushing”

I said “I don’t feel like I’m missing out I had a great c section experience” and left it as that.

It’s been a couple of days and the comment is sitting there in my mind. Shall I say something or let it go?

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 01/11/2023 13:32

Younghearts · 01/11/2023 12:50

@herewegoroundthebastardbush I know I felt the same when I read that. I didn’t even know what to say back. I couldn’t skip the birth - I was there 🤣

The only way to respond to idiotic comments like that is to brush them off.

In real life, you could say something without making a huge deal, but to be honest it’s better to do it at the time. I used to pause and say - there was nothing easy about being told a section was necessary due to (whatever the issue). They then backed down, possibly annoyed, but if I prevented it being said to someone less tough than me it was worth it. I’m not sure how easily you can try to pick that conversation up at a later date though.

FrostBeDonePls · 01/11/2023 13:32

Well she is nuts and insensitive.

I don't understand the need to say this at all. Unless my kids's brains benefit from vaginal birth so much that they are guaranteed a oxbridge degree i cant see why i will do it 😂 kids remain the same lol

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 01/11/2023 13:30

Saveusernameforonce · 01/11/2023 13:22

^ I had two (difficult, ventouse 'natural') births and the powers that be made the decision for me that number 3 would be a c section. In the days when mothers weren't really given the choice.

This is the most important thing of all, choice/autonomy. The difference between my first birth and my second is that for birth 1, I swallowed the idea that a woman left to herself will by and large birth naturally and that was the only possibility I really considered. The second time, I knew it doesn't always go that way, so I informed myself and had a chance to do a lot of thought experiments - if this, then that - so when events started to diverge from my preferred pathway, instead of feeling panicky and distraught I was pre-armed with a plan B, C, and D, and worked my way to the eventual end point - by far my least preferred option - via a series of choices I could live with and feel in control of.

Someone just referenced 'fed is best' with a putative 'born is best' - actually, in both cases and always, 'informed is best', and the best possible chance of getting the best possible outcome all round for you and your baby who are a DYAD and whose needs HAVE to be considered as a single package, not one versus the other.

StoneWashJeansWithAMatchingJacket · 01/11/2023 13:30

You did the right thing for you and your baby and in no way is major abdominal surgery “lazy” or “easy”. Nor did you “skip the birth” (wtf-how?!)

Your friend is a thoughtless moron and in my experience there’s a fair few of them around. Honestly, no matter what we choose (vaginal vs C-section, breast vs bottle etc) someone, somewhere has something to say about it.

Peablockfeathers · 01/11/2023 13:25

Of course a C section isn't the easy option, it's a major operation with risk of serious complications- they literally handle your bowels and then place them back in ffs, anyone who thinks it's an easy route is dreaming. There's also the extra stress of the bed shortages and lack of anaesthetic staff which means often those who opt for electives are left waiting around as they keep getting bumped down the list. I suspect she said it to cover her own insecurities to try and make herself feel better, but it's a load of poo.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 01/11/2023 13:25

therealcookiemonster · 01/11/2023 13:22

absolutely amazing pushing ???

I dare her to go and say this to women who are actively labouring lol. the oxytocin released after/during birth makes you forget how bad it was

Apparently while my mother was birthing me my father exhorted her to relish "the joy you are experiencing". She could swear like an anatomically-informed sailor at the best of times, but I believe she surpassed herself on that occasion 😂

shivawn · 01/11/2023 13:24

I wouldn't dwell on it. We all make choices to best suit ourselves where possible.

My friend and I are both due in the next few weeks and we both had our first babies the same week in 2021 too. She's already booked in for an elective induction same as she did the last time. I, on the other hand had a terrible induction experience during my first pregnancy so I'll be hoping to avoid one and go naturally if at all possible. Just different choices based on different experiences.

BitofaStramash · 01/11/2023 13:23

@FetchezLaVache

In which case you are still the only one

Saveusernameforonce · 01/11/2023 13:22

^ I had two (difficult, ventouse 'natural') births and the powers that be made the decision for me that number 3 would be a c section. In the days when mothers weren't really given the choice.

therealcookiemonster · 01/11/2023 13:22

absolutely amazing pushing ???

I dare her to go and say this to women who are actively labouring lol. the oxytocin released after/during birth makes you forget how bad it was

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 01/11/2023 13:21

IncomingTraffic · 01/11/2023 13:13

There's a perception that women use it to avoid the pain of child birth vaginally. It's utter tosh because (a) medicine has rarely given a stuff about women's pain anyway and (b) the aftermath of a c-section can cause new mothers all sorts of practical difficulties.

And it really hurts. Recovering from major abdominal surgery is painful. Very painful. Even without a newborn involved.

Having a section doesn’t somehow produce a nice, tidy, pain free experiences. There are catheters and stitches and struggling to move at all, and all sorts of indignities involved.

Well quite. It's no fun having your vag in tatters either I imagine, but not being able to stand up, laugh or cough for several days without going "oooooow!" is not my idea of an 'easy' option, nor is being unable to drive for 6 weeks, or pick up your baby without being very bloody careful. I remember after baby 1 I was in the postnatal ward sleeping, baby started crying in the bassinet next to me and I sprang up half asleep and had her in my arms before I knew what I was doing - and then OOOOOOOHMYGOD the agonising pain. Got told off so badly by the nurse when I called her over to check that my insides were still actually in.

FetchezLaVache · 01/11/2023 13:21

BitofaStramash · 01/11/2023 13:09

@FetchezLaVache

You seem to be the only person this thread that found that one to be humorous

Didn't say I found it humorous, just that it clearly wasn't to be taken literally.

Saveusernameforonce · 01/11/2023 13:20

How about 'born is best'?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2023 13:17

The good thing about vaginal births for me - if anyone ever asked - was that I was up and feeling fine pretty much straight away (especially after the first aged 29). Until the sleep deprivation of having newborn care straight afterwards with no chance to sleep or rest hit. But that plus point isn’t the same for everyone either.

stayflufft · 01/11/2023 13:16

Your friend is pretty thoughtless. I’ve done birth both ways and would choose c section over vaginal birth any day. I didn’t push either of my children out as I just couldn’t. It’s so bizarre how competitive women get over what way they birthed their children - not to mention how some women seem determined that other women should suffer bringing a child into the world! Mad!

dontforgetme · 01/11/2023 13:14

Pushing my babies out were the 2 worst experiences of my life. She is nuts Grin

CandyLeBonBon · 01/11/2023 13:13

I was due to have my second section due to my ds being both breech and low in amniotic fluid and the anaesthetist joked that I was too posh to push. I absolutely tore him off a strip and told him not to be so fucking rude.

It's not the easy way out at all. It fucking hurts, like most people's experience of childbirth.

This attitude really grinds my gears!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2023 13:13

There’s no way that @BitofaStramash ‘s comment was “tongue in cheek”, @FetchezLaVache

Tongue in cheek doesn’t mean saying something insulting then pretending “it was a joke”

IncomingTraffic · 01/11/2023 13:13

There's a perception that women use it to avoid the pain of child birth vaginally. It's utter tosh because (a) medicine has rarely given a stuff about women's pain anyway and (b) the aftermath of a c-section can cause new mothers all sorts of practical difficulties.

And it really hurts. Recovering from major abdominal surgery is painful. Very painful. Even without a newborn involved.

Having a section doesn’t somehow produce a nice, tidy, pain free experiences. There are catheters and stitches and struggling to move at all, and all sorts of indignities involved.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/11/2023 13:12

"I'd rather miss out on the natural birth experience than have a dead baby" would probably have been my response, but I'm a bit brutal

Indeed this.

There are only two ways of getting a baby out, and neither is pleasant or easy!

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 01/11/2023 13:11

Younghearts · 01/11/2023 12:56

@FrostBeDonePls The “weird” part about it is, she says pushing was amazing but didn’t have a good birth experience.

I don't actually think that's contradictory! Pregnancy, labour and birth is incredibly primal and the feelings that go with it are probably not easily compartmentalised.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2023 13:10

In no way is a c section easy, lazy or in any way “skipping the birth”

It’s major abdominal surgery and a hard recovery, but is often safer for the baby in particular. In your circumstances it sounds like totally the right decision from every point of view.

This woman’s comments sound very ignorant. You just need to ignore.

(Not got any axe to grind here as I was lucky enough to have relatively “easy” vaginal births. But having been on the ward with many mums who’d had c sections, I could see that their experience was not the easier one! Not that I think “easy” should be said in the context of births at all)

BitofaStramash · 01/11/2023 13:09

@FetchezLaVache

You seem to be the only person this thread that found that one to be humorous

mindutopia · 01/11/2023 13:09

She's being quite silly and thoughtless. I had two very natural home births and I don't really think it's 'amazing' pushing. But a c-section is not the easy way out. It's major surgery and not something anyone would choose just because it's 'easier'. I certainly wouldn't have wanted to have one, if I had other options. You made the absolute best choice for you though and your friend is being really insensitive.

I have a friend who has hang ups like this about breastfeeding. She found breastfeeding really difficult and it really affected her mental health, but she is militant about it and anyone who doesn't breastfeed deserves to lose their children to care because it's neglect, blah, blah, blah. (Yes, really). I breastfed one of mine and formula fed the other one, both for good, well thought out reasons each time. She's just bonkers.

Some times though people struggle with their own experiences and how they feel about them, and the easiest thing to do is to project that experience onto someone else's choices to make them feel a bit better.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 01/11/2023 13:08

Younghearts · 01/11/2023 12:50

@herewegoroundthebastardbush I know I felt the same when I read that. I didn’t even know what to say back. I couldn’t skip the birth - I was there 🤣

As you've had a section, the medical professionals by and large would push you in the direction of an elective for your second child anyway - and the flip side of the wanker coin from people like your twatty mate scolding you for not 'trying' are the people who scolded me for 'risking my baby's life' by making my own risk assessment and trying for a VBAC. The fact of the matter is it is anyone passing judgments on an individual woman's birth choices in conversation is a monumental bellend and just plain rude so fuck them.

I was SO desperate for a 'natural birth' with my first baby, I went two weeks overdue waiting, eventually agreed to be induced, laboured agonisingly for days with contractions every three minutes almost from the off, and eventually ended up with an elective section as I was exhausted and my partner was close to a nervous breakdown from watching me struggle for so long and neither of us having any sleep (went to be induced Saturday morning, baby didn't appear until Tuesday night - bloody horrible and quite traumatic). For ages I blamed myself for 'giving in' to the section, and even for 'giving in' to the induction, as all the 'natural birth' advocates sucked their teeth at that and said that if I hadn't had an induction baby would have come 'naturally' in their own time.

Fr second baby I was a lot more relaxed about things but still wanted to try for a natural birth, so booked myself for a VBAC at home; I had to make the case for myself against some opposition, whilst avoiding building it up into a big deal in my mind, because I knew my MH couldn't take another 'failure'. What will be will be was very much my mantra. This time I went into labour naturally, and it turns out I apparently just have very rapid onset, very powerful, very painful contractions pretty much from the get go even 'naturally' (had blamed this on the induction previously, and was looking forward to experiencing gradually increasing 'waves' with baby 2 - no such luck!).

Meconium in waters nixed my homebirth, and not too long into labour baby's heart rate started struggling, and despite all my powerful frequent contracting I wasn't dilating much at all. As I was moving around so much, staff were struggling to monitor baby and wanted to give me an epidural to keep me still. I looked at the way things were going for me, considered the likelihood that the ordeal I was about to go through had any likelihood of 'healing' my previous experience or giving me a healthy, vaginally delivered baby, and decided to go for another elective. Baby arrived screaming and well (and massive like her sister, both over 9lbs!) and I was home within 24 hours).

Looking back, I'm glad I tried again for a natural birth, but I'm gladder still that I knew when to stop and saved myself a lot of pain and upset. Taking control of things for myself, even when it didn't give me the experience I had wanted, was far more healing of my previous rather traumatic experience and far more empowering than pursuing a natural birth could have been for me under the circumstances. And most important of all , my baby was well and safe.