Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’m not lazy or taking the “easy way out” for having a c section!

137 replies

Younghearts · 01/11/2023 12:41

I’m sure she didn’t mean too, but friend upset me earlier by her throw away comment. I had a c section 8 months ago, a couple of days into my induction because babies heart rate sky rocketed and I got extremely anxious and asked for an elective. It was a hard recovery but I do not regret it and loved my experience. I could have maybe continued with the vaginal route - but the nurses were constantly putting me on drips and monitors and I’d had enough and no sleep.

Anyway, having a light hearted convo with a friend and told her I’d probably have an elective c section if I was to have another DC and she said “Oh no you’re missing out, don’t take the easy way out and be lazy! It’s amazing pushing”

I said “I don’t feel like I’m missing out I had a great c section experience” and left it as that.

It’s been a couple of days and the comment is sitting there in my mind. Shall I say something or let it go?

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 01/11/2023 14:11

Hang on hang on hold up ... Skipping the birth is an option? Why the fuck did nobody ever tell me that? I'd have had my husband deal with it the second time round and gone to the pictures or something.

arecklessmanor · 01/11/2023 14:10

I gave birth by elective c-section, I felt it was the best choice for me, signed off and date agreed before my 20 week scan.

It didn’t feel easy (in fact the postnatal care was really bad) but I would do it again.
it no one else’s business really.

IncompleteSenten · 01/11/2023 14:06

The easy way out?
Is she having a fucking laugh?
My sister had a CS and she was in agony! For weeks. Got an infection, couldn't do anything for ages. The scar tissue still causes her pain at times and her daughter's 25!

I had my 2nd son (vaginally) on the same day a friend had hers by cs. Next morning I was walking down the corridor in search of coffee with my newborn tucked under my arm when I heard a soft "bitch". I looked over and there was my friend looking like death warmed over. In her bed.

Easy option indeed.

Major abdominal surgery is not what I'd call the easy option. And my first got stuck (shoulder dystocia) and has erbs palsy as a result and I still think that in terms of my body, it was 'easier' than recovering from having your belly sliced wide open!

coolkatt · 01/11/2023 14:05

tell her to shut the fk up that c sections actually save lives and is defo not the easy way out. her ignorance stinks.
as long as the section was right for you that is all that matters. what u do on the future is completely
your choice.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 01/11/2023 14:00

Saveusernameforonce · 01/11/2023 13:44

That's interesting, and a very well argued point. I also posted the born is best comment, not expecting several more posts between the two. The 'putative' comment was meant as a come back to the friend, really. I followed it up with an explanation of my experiences.

I agree that informed is best, and no doubt things have changed a great deal since I gave birth. However having to be armed with all the information, and being expected to make all the choices, is a big ask I think. I've dealt with similar with other medical issues recently. The medics, one would hope and trust, are the experts on these things. So very well worth being guided by them.

Yes and no really. Being guided by medical evidence is a good idea of course; but individual medics are just people, and I'm sorry to say that in the field of maternal care there is a lot of traditionalism, a lack of staying up to date with current evidence, a risk aversion that fails to account for the specificities of the individual woman/pregnancy, and culture plays a huge (unwonted) part in the advice you receive and the treatment you get.

Just trustingly doing as you're told is a bad shout in my view because a lot of the time you are seen as "expectant mother #444456, seen one you've seen them all", and if you do not make it very clear you are informed and ready to advocate for yourself a lot of staff will gently bully you into thinking you don't have a say or a right to one in terms of what happens to you during pregnancy, labour or birth.

With the best intentions of course - they don't want anything bad to happen to you or your baby.

But 'bad', to them, means something that will show up on an incident report. Not birth trauma, not PND, not failure to bond, not breastfeeding failure, not a whole bunch of other things that can wreck your life and your experience of parenthood because you weren't listened to and treated as an individual having an individual experience that falls into, but doesn't necessarily follow, the population-level statistics.

For evidence of this you only have to look at the variation in rates of c-section from country to country, and from trust to trust. The section rate in Cyprus is not nearly 60% (outnumbering vaginal births) because women in Cyprus are built different to women in the Nordic countries, where rates are below 20%; there will be culture and politics and pressures at play that have made this the case, and you can be pretty damn sure that not every woman in that 60% needed it, and of the ones who had it but didn't need it that they all wanted it. Likewise there might be women in the 80% of vaginal births in the Nordic countries who would have preferred and/or benefitted from a section, who were denied it or persuaded out of it because of prevailing culture.

The only person who is all that interested in your specific needs and risks and weighing them up is you; so you need to be very well informed, so that when a midwife or doctor attempts to jam you and your baby and body down the path of least resistance, you are armed to make the case that while this may be the best for the majority of people, it may not be for YOU because of XYZ, and that you would like to discuss the possibility of [other option]. It doesn't make you popular that's for sure; even less popular when you point out something you have been told is actually factually incorrect, which happens more often than give one any kind of confidence.

But I think it's pretty essential to having a non-traumatic experience in which you either feel ignored and like a piece of meat, or abnegate yourself entirely because only the baby matters. No. The mother is the patient. She matters. And it goes without saying in the vast majority of cases, she cares about the baby's wellbeing a damn sight more than even the medical professionals and will not be making choices selfishly.

MorningHood · 01/11/2023 14:00

Some people are simply tedious and cuntish and think their way is the best way.

Some people like to shame women any which way possible. Internet loses misogyny exists and is especially prevalent around any topics relating to motherhood.

Your friend is ‘some people’..

Younghearts · 01/11/2023 13:59

@BeingATwatItsABingThing My recovery was actually quite a bit of a blur as baby was in SBCU for a couple of weeks so I had no choice but to be up walking around visiting him multiple times a day in and out the car walking around the hospital. No rest for me and they didn’t have any beds for me to stay at the hospital so we had to leave him there every night! xx

OP posts:
Sparklesocks · 01/11/2023 13:57

I had an elective. I had GD and there were some concerns with DD’s size (too small) and about my placenta, so I decided I wanted to take away some of the uncertainty of the birth by having an elective. It wasn’t something I went into lightly, but I’m glad I did it - I had a great experience and the team were amazing. And DD was fine, bar some issues with her sugars which were resolved.

One of my relatives said I was ‘posh’ for it. I rolled my eyes and brushed it off. I had enough to worry about with a newborn anyway!

you’re always going to get people who make silly comments unfortunately, but I think most people understand there is no ‘easy’ way to have a baby - as many mothers will tell you.

Mariposista · 01/11/2023 13:56

These comments have been made by ignorant people since the dawn of time. You know, and anyone sensible knows, that they are not founded. Any birth is difficult and the best decisions are made Bla Bla Bla. What is the point in wasting time getting 'upset' and oversensitive about it. Just roll your eyes and change the subject.

AngeloMysterioso · 01/11/2023 13:55

Anyone who characterises major abdominal surgery where they literally slice and tear through layers of flesh, before sewing you back up again and handing you a newborn, as taking the “easy way out” is an eejit.

Torganer · 01/11/2023 13:47

I had a section and it was the most amazing experience. I was very lucky and had a quick recovery, discharged in under 20hrs and had no problems lifting or walking (was pushing the baby round the park on day 3). I would definitely choose the same option again.

I had more pain having my appendix out. Appreciate it’s not the same for everyone. I just don’t know why people insist on negatively commenting on women’s birth or feeding choices. They don’t do this for any other medical procedure.

Betty407 · 01/11/2023 13:46

The hardest part for me about becoming a mother has has nothing to do with my children and everything to do with other people's judgement. I have no idea what it is but once you become pregnant people seem to think its a free for all to make comments on your body and your choices, and your parenting.

It is absolute madness. People should keep their opinions to themselves!

Saveusernameforonce · 01/11/2023 13:44

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 01/11/2023 13:30

This is the most important thing of all, choice/autonomy. The difference between my first birth and my second is that for birth 1, I swallowed the idea that a woman left to herself will by and large birth naturally and that was the only possibility I really considered. The second time, I knew it doesn't always go that way, so I informed myself and had a chance to do a lot of thought experiments - if this, then that - so when events started to diverge from my preferred pathway, instead of feeling panicky and distraught I was pre-armed with a plan B, C, and D, and worked my way to the eventual end point - by far my least preferred option - via a series of choices I could live with and feel in control of.

Someone just referenced 'fed is best' with a putative 'born is best' - actually, in both cases and always, 'informed is best', and the best possible chance of getting the best possible outcome all round for you and your baby who are a DYAD and whose needs HAVE to be considered as a single package, not one versus the other.

That's interesting, and a very well argued point. I also posted the born is best comment, not expecting several more posts between the two. The 'putative' comment was meant as a come back to the friend, really. I followed it up with an explanation of my experiences.

I agree that informed is best, and no doubt things have changed a great deal since I gave birth. However having to be armed with all the information, and being expected to make all the choices, is a big ask I think. I've dealt with similar with other medical issues recently. The medics, one would hope and trust, are the experts on these things. So very well worth being guided by them.

SpareHeirOverThere · 01/11/2023 13:42

Your friend is a twat. Who for some reason wants to feel better about herself by making you feel bad. Don't be friends with someone who makes themselves feel big by making others feel small. It's a huge vharacter flaw.

TiptoeThroughTheToadstools · 01/11/2023 13:41

I've heard this before, a couple section is in no way easy. My first was VB and my twins were CS, it take VB over CS any day of the week! It's an ignorant and untrue turn of phrase.

Wishingawaymylife · 01/11/2023 13:39

I can’t stand these stupid women who have opinions over other peoples choices.
Ive had it all myself and usually end up upsetting them by saying something really cutting back.
I don’t dwell on it though because I’m not attached to that part of life.
I had apparently perfect, easy pregnancies- hated every second of it , zero photos exist of me up the duff, I refused to acknowledge it and avoided socialising because I felt disgusting and fat and was pissed off about the wine and shellfish and cheese situation 🤣 I literally sulked for 9 months both times. Had an easy birth, 3 hrs pushed for 10 mins , no stitches no damage- again, hated it. No photos until I was thin again and the baby looked less like boiled bacon. Second baby was a fatty, had a section because I was terrified of damaging my privates. Complication free , home the next day- still hated it 🤣 cried cos it hurt when I was trying to clean the house and make bottles, didn’t want anyone around to help because I was hormonal and could not deal with people so sent DH on pointless errands with baby just to get some peace. Again, perfect recovery but still complained. I love my kids they are amazing ! but everything about pregnancy and the bit after makes me want to vomit. When my SIL decided to invite herself over with her newborn and lecture me on the virtues of natural births and breastfeeding she was lucky I sent her away with just a flea in her ear tbh. All power to the earth mothers with the magical tits and the babies they never put down for the first year ( their poor backs?) some of us just want kids that arrive in one piece and to survive the early days without getting sectioned thanks.

SuperGreens · 01/11/2023 13:39

Fools who think birth is an 'experience' annoy me. The one and only goal is healthy mum and healthy baby, and sometimes the best way to achieve that is major abdominal surgery aka c section. It is not lazy, and it is certainly not easy. I wouldnt say anything to her now (probably would have at the time though). But I would put her into the idiot bucket from now on, and distance myself.

Vinrouge4 · 01/11/2023 13:38

I would let it go. She’s entitled to her opinion. I think when you have children you need to develop a tough skin as there will always be someone with a different view to you. Just have confidence in what you decide is best for you.

ThisIsntThe80sPat · 01/11/2023 13:37

I don't understand how a woman births her child has anything to do with anyone else. Yanbu, op.

Fwiw pushing is fucking awful. Two vaginal births here and I found the pushing horrible and much more difficult to deal with than the contractions.

FrustatedAgain · 01/11/2023 13:37

Unfortunately there will always be women out there who think that successfully pushing their baby out of their vagina after a few hours pushing makes them superior to those of us who laboured for days and then had emergency surgery to save them and the baby.
Ignore the comments from these people who only have a straight forward birth experience and have no idea what you went through previously. I'm not trying to devalue their experience either, however they are in not position to advise you. Hopefully you'll have an excellent midwife to have that discussion with.

Thehumiliatedfish · 01/11/2023 13:35

No one who has had a csection thinks its the easy way out. Ignore your friend. She is talking from a place of ignorance.

I once had a man tell me I had been too posh to push. He didn't have an answer for when I asked him how many babies he had pushed out his own vagina.

almondseagull · 01/11/2023 13:35

It’s amazing pushing

Fuck off is it! Its a means to an end, as is any way you end up giving birth

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 01/11/2023 13:34

The thought of recovering from a c-section felt worse than a vaginal birth. I was up and walking about after DD2 within hours and it was very little recovery time afterwards. I wouldn’t have had that with abdominal surgery.

You have definitely not had an easy way out. You didn’t have the pain of pushing but you did have the pain of recovering after.

ConflictofInterest · 01/11/2023 13:34

I think each birth experience is just so different for each person that they can't really be compared at all. I found my emergency c-section such a horrible ordeal (and I still have nerve damage 10 years later) that I opted for a VBAC the next time. Well that turned out to be a horrible ordeal too. Agony and lasting damage in both scenarios. A woman at work said she didn't know what all the fuss was about as when she gave birth to her son there was no pain at all, it was "just like doing a large poo." I can't even imagine how she could have had that experience and she couldn't imagine mine.

Maray1967 · 01/11/2023 13:33

I’ve done it both ways so it’s women like me who can speak with authority that it makes no difference how they arrive in the world!!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread