Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A friend of mine has not used soap for half his life!!

110 replies

WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 11:44

changed name for obvious reasons
He's a long time friend of mine.

How I found out.
He does work on buildings ranging from plastering to laying patios. He's qualified for many things but all are manual jobs.
He was round doing a job for me in the garden which made him get rather dirty. I noticed when he washed his hands, when I made him a hot drink, he would just swill his hands in the kitchen sink with water.. But I didn't think much in it but I noticed as the hand wash is obviously there.

Well, once he finished I asked if he could look at a job that wasn't done properly previously in my bathroom.

Once he removed his trainers (no footwear in my home as a rule) both myself and he noticed his feet stunk from the garden job. So he asked if he could wash them to put some fresh socks with a change of footwear, that carries around with him in his van (his trainers were now soaking)
I pointed out to him where the shower gels were... And he said "no I don't use those" .. So I pointed out the baby friendly soap I've got for my youngest (thinking it was more about the type of gels)

He continued to say "no.. I don't use those.. I just use water. Water is good enough".

I'm stunned to silence as he just swills his feet in water.

After a few hours.. As he's still had the left over of the garden job to finish.. Just putting things back etc... I ask him... "are you winding me up about the soap?" (he's a bit of a wind up merchant tbh)... But he sticks with it... "No.. Waters fine.
You don't need to use all those chemicals on your body, it's not good for your skin, I don't use deodorant either cos they put aluminum in them
"

I am shocked cos he then said he's not any of them for 20+ years now!!! He's a grown man!!
Trust me... He absolutely stinks of BO but I just put it to the fact he's doing the jobs he does...

I'M ABSOLUTELY MORTIFIED!!!

Am I out of touch here? Is this normal? Do others do this?
AIBU to think this is disgusting!!??
I can't help but put my mind to his lower areas... I mean... Ewwww. He doesn't use soap on his ASS!!
For half his life he's not used soap!!!

OP posts:
WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 13:23

Woollyjumpersandtomatosoupweather · 01/11/2023 13:21

Does he have a partner? I cant imagine any partner putting up with that (or having sex with a dirty penis) unless they have anosmia!

No.. We were looking at beginning more than friends.. But now I can't with knowing this.

OP posts:
Woollyjumpersandtomatosoupweather · 01/11/2023 13:21

Does he have a partner? I cant imagine any partner putting up with that (or having sex with a dirty penis) unless they have anosmia!

WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 13:20

BettyBallerina · 01/11/2023 13:11

It’s absolutely none of your business. Some people are allergic to it. You are ignorant.

He's not got eczema, he's not allergic. He doesn't want chemicals on his body.
But I'm sure Holland and Barretts might have something suitable.
We are a family of eczema, so I recommended one of those products.

Either way, he's a friend that we were both thinking of being more than friends and now I've no idea how to go from here.
I don't want to offend him. He stinks of BO badly, but now it's obviously NOT his job that's creating the smell as such. It's just him. I can't be more than friends with him without soap or some cleaning products involved.
Now I've gotta pull back, which is gonna be obviously from the recent knowledge he's given me.

OP posts:
Appleofmyeye2023 · 01/11/2023 13:18

Guesswho88 · 01/11/2023 12:27

I would kindly advise him to use one of them simple soaps or is it Pears soap - one of them has as little chemicals as possible.

soap is still soap - the ones you mention just have additional chemicals removed that are additives used as stabilisers, preservatives (parabens), surfactants (eg sulphites which are added to increase bonding with dirt and as foaming agent ) and perfumes etc.

soap itself always requires 3 basic chemicals; alkaline (used to be lye, sodium hydroxide, but it’s this that is the major irritant whatever alkaline is used, yep you can use weaker alkalines, like Lauric acid, but if people are irritated by them it will make sod all difference becuase it’s the change in pH of skin that’s the issue), Triglycerides (fatty acids: like lard, olive oil, even lanolin and again some of these,like lanolin, can be irritants) and finally water

Without that “saponification reaction” it’s not soap🤷🏼‍♀️.

soap works by binding it’s hydrophobic/lipophilic end of its molecule (water hating /lipid loving end) with dirt particles and it’s hydrophilic end of its molecule (water loving)) that then bonds to water being used. It’s why washing with running water is best as you’re constantly providing clean water for more of these hydrophilic ends of the molecule to bind with. And like most chemical reactions heat also speeds it up, so warmer water works best.

Damn smart but very simple chemistry. Hats off to the (woman I’m sure) 5000years ago that accidentally tipped the lye onto her greasy oily hands and found they stopped being greasy 🤷🏼‍♀️😉

Cleansers for many people with allergies work better and are essentially surfactants. These are again molecules with hydrophilic and hydrophobic/lipophilic ends . They’re not made using alkaline or fatty acid. They’re synthetically produced mainly from petroleum chemicals. So, kinder to skin but not exactly environmentally friendly 🤦‍♀️

Anonymouslyposting · 01/11/2023 13:17

I use hand soap and shampoo but very rarely use soap anywhere else unless I’m particularly sweaty or visibly dirty. Water works just fine and I’m sure I don’t smell (I have plenty of friends and family who wouldn’t hold back if I did!). Too much soap/shower gel dries out your skin and can be bad for the environment.

GreyWednesday · 01/11/2023 13:17

19lottie82 · 01/11/2023 12:02

They did yes. But disease was rampant and most people didn’t live past 35.

Isn’t that a common misconception about life expectancy? That life expectancy might have been around 30 (depending on which era you’re talking about) but it’s an average which is skewed by the very high infant and child mortality. Obviously that would have been in part due to poor hygiene, but not solely.

We should all be washing our hands with soap though!

BettyBallerina · 01/11/2023 13:11

It’s absolutely none of your business. Some people are allergic to it. You are ignorant.

jlpth · 01/11/2023 13:08

To some extent, he’s right. A lot of the stuff that we wash ourselves in and slather onto ourselves is very bad for us. We just do it because society has a clean obsession and it’s what we are accustomed to.

Deodorant is rank for example. All that shite vaporised and breathed in - never mind what it’s actually doing to your skin/body under your arms.

Gentle soap is ok.

and don’t get me started on the fragrances that people add to their laundry. They think they smell “clean” but actually smell like a chemical factory. Smelling clean means smelling either of nothing or mildly like a person.

uhOhOP · 01/11/2023 13:06

It'll not be the lack of soap that's his problem. His problem is obviously that he doesn't wash properly, if at all. And standing under the shower with warm water running down his body for two minutes wouldn't count as "properly".

newnamethanks · 01/11/2023 13:00

He's right, chemical filth and unnecessary. Wash properly with water and you'll be fine, wear clean clothes every day.

MumblesParty · 01/11/2023 12:56

People who don't wash properly are rank. I'll never understand why so many people are happy to stink. Yuk.

AbbeyGailsParty · 01/11/2023 12:53

Basic soap is made from oil , water and lye. Lye can be made from ash so no artificial chemicals involved.
Aluminium free deodorants are the norm now I think.

If he wants to stink that’s his choice but he’d not be coming into my house.

PennyNotWise · 01/11/2023 12:51

If he’s lovely in other ways, maybe read around a bit.
We use salt rock deodorant such as “pit rok” as it’s not got dangerous chemicals in it, and as others say there are plenty of gentle soaps. But then maybe there is no need for soap, could look at the research. People who don’t use chemicals on their hair and hardly wash it have the loveliest hair!

Also he might just not care, and he might think if you judge him on that you’re not for him

therealcookiemonster · 01/11/2023 12:50

yes people are disgusting. this is why when I come home, I change my clothes and have a good wash and why most things from outside get disinfected on entry to the house.

and I have seen what happens when people don't clean properly. look up necrotising fascitis if you have the stomach for it....

Good thing you actually didn't sleep with him....

Appleofmyeye2023 · 01/11/2023 12:48

19lottie82 · 01/11/2023 12:02

They did yes. But disease was rampant and most people didn’t live past 35.

Well actually the first soap remains found date for 2800 Bc, so humans found ways to make it 5000 years ago. Prior to that, and in cultures where soap was not made, herb/plant infusions were and are still used commonly. Humans have found ways to make washing more efficient since they learnt how to figure stuff out.

but hey, my adult son avoids soap, just like many do with eczema , it literally turns his skin on fire and cracks it. He never uses soap, and finds deodorants that he can work with just. He doesn’t use shampoo either. Hasn’t since he was a child. He uses eczema cleansers where he’s dealing with biological contamination (ie after using loo) , and on his hair after exercise or being on public transport, but even that he avoids as much as possible. To be frank he avoids anything that touches, rubs or agitates his skin. 😢

the guy is right that soaps are not good for the skin. But he’s unreasonable to not use something that chelates with dirt particles and helps remove them from his skin. There are plenty of options for him.

tattygrl · 01/11/2023 12:39

At risk of being a nobhead, "mortified" doesn't mean similar to horrified or shocked, it means to feel extremely embarrassed or ashamed at ones' own behaviour or actions. Nothing to do with being shocked or upset by something someone else has done.

I'm only risking being a dickhead here because this is a much mis-used word and one of my pet peeves!! In this context, you'd be mortified if you realised you hadn't been using soap for years and that you stank of BO.

WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 12:37

betterangels · 01/11/2023 12:30

Agree. Mortified? And coming to the Internet to have strangers drag him. Well done, OP.

Read my 3rd post please

OP posts:
Bloomingmagnolia · 01/11/2023 12:31

WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 12:28

Read my 3rd post on this thread.

Yes, apologies. I agree that shagging him would be grim, but I would respect his right to be a filthy bastard nonetheless. It wouldn’t affect my friendship with a person.

betterangels · 01/11/2023 12:30

RubyBoozeDay · 01/11/2023 11:54

His personal hygiene is his business, not yours. You're a friend, not a partner so his pits and bits being smelly shouldn't cause you any concern.

Agree. Mortified? And coming to the Internet to have strangers drag him. Well done, OP.

Superbroom · 01/11/2023 12:29

I had a client that explained the scientific reasons behind just using hot water. Don’t recall her smelling. Don’t know if what she was saying his true.
Her choice and had zero impact on me. Why does it bother you so much op?

WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 12:28

Bloomingmagnolia · 01/11/2023 12:22

Total overreaction on your part. I couldn’t imagine giving a flying fuck about this. My guess is nobody died from him not using soap. He has his own philosophy on this issue and it’s not your place to judge him (unless you are secretly shagging him - that would be grim, I agree).

Read my 3rd post on this thread.

OP posts:
Guesswho88 · 01/11/2023 12:27

I would kindly advise him to use one of them simple soaps or is it Pears soap - one of them has as little chemicals as possible.

WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 12:26

Iliedwheniwas17 · 01/11/2023 12:24

Again op- why are you mortified? Why would you be embarrassed and ashamed when you are not the one who smells?

Because I've added on another post that says "we were looking at being more than friends and years ago we came close to having sex".

OP posts:
skgnome · 01/11/2023 12:26

Mortified is a bit strong
maybe he just has a bad skin condition and doesn’t wants to divulge it
if he has bad BO and you were thinking on taking this out of a friendship zone I get BO being a put off, and fair enough
but this l(for me) falls on the live and let others live

Iliedwheniwas17 · 01/11/2023 12:24

Again op- why are you mortified? Why would you be embarrassed and ashamed when you are not the one who smells?