Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A friend of mine has not used soap for half his life!!

110 replies

WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 11:44

changed name for obvious reasons
He's a long time friend of mine.

How I found out.
He does work on buildings ranging from plastering to laying patios. He's qualified for many things but all are manual jobs.
He was round doing a job for me in the garden which made him get rather dirty. I noticed when he washed his hands, when I made him a hot drink, he would just swill his hands in the kitchen sink with water.. But I didn't think much in it but I noticed as the hand wash is obviously there.

Well, once he finished I asked if he could look at a job that wasn't done properly previously in my bathroom.

Once he removed his trainers (no footwear in my home as a rule) both myself and he noticed his feet stunk from the garden job. So he asked if he could wash them to put some fresh socks with a change of footwear, that carries around with him in his van (his trainers were now soaking)
I pointed out to him where the shower gels were... And he said "no I don't use those" .. So I pointed out the baby friendly soap I've got for my youngest (thinking it was more about the type of gels)

He continued to say "no.. I don't use those.. I just use water. Water is good enough".

I'm stunned to silence as he just swills his feet in water.

After a few hours.. As he's still had the left over of the garden job to finish.. Just putting things back etc... I ask him... "are you winding me up about the soap?" (he's a bit of a wind up merchant tbh)... But he sticks with it... "No.. Waters fine.
You don't need to use all those chemicals on your body, it's not good for your skin, I don't use deodorant either cos they put aluminum in them
"

I am shocked cos he then said he's not any of them for 20+ years now!!! He's a grown man!!
Trust me... He absolutely stinks of BO but I just put it to the fact he's doing the jobs he does...

I'M ABSOLUTELY MORTIFIED!!!

Am I out of touch here? Is this normal? Do others do this?
AIBU to think this is disgusting!!??
I can't help but put my mind to his lower areas... I mean... Ewwww. He doesn't use soap on his ASS!!
For half his life he's not used soap!!!

OP posts:
ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 01/11/2023 19:32

I saw a top dermatologist on TV just last week who said that there is no need to use soap, water is perfectly adequate for cleaning. She herself used a simple soap for anything which might be particularly smelly or dirty, but the use of a lot of soap and too hot water damages the skin.

Iheartpizza · 01/11/2023 19:08

No of course YANBU! He sounds repulsive and I can't imagine the state of his nether regions. Dodged a bullet there didn't you?!

Ivegone · 01/11/2023 19:07

My wife doesn’t use soap except for her hands and shampoo for her hair. She has eczema, extreme allergies and a very painful skin condition so basically everything hurts her.

She doesn’t smell.

WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 18:50

Cosyblankets · 01/11/2023 18:24

On the verge of having sex. So kissing and stuff..... yet you didn't notice?

You thought it was his job? There are plenty of people out there doing messy manual jobs, my husband is one of them. He smells lovely! He washes properly.

We were at the end of an all day bender (was a wedding we attended of a mutual friend) ... Drunk is putting it mildly. Yes we kissed but I'd say more smashed teeth... Then when he started getting undressed he tripped up getting his leg out his trousers... Hence we laughed about it. Kinda put it to.. "the signs are pointing to we are just not meant to do this".
It was an absolute scream at the time and does still make us laugh even now about it.
Yes, he smelt of BO.. Not as extreme as his work days, but he was wearing loads of aftershave and obviously he was sweating (like we all were) from dancing. I just put it to that then.

So, I never got close enough to find out.

OP posts:
Cosyblankets · 01/11/2023 18:24

WTAFSHOCKEDANDMORTIFIED · 01/11/2023 12:11

He had made it clear he wants something more than friends but I'm a "get to know first" Person.
He's ticks all the boxes and I was on the verge of going ahead...
But now... I just can't.
It's gave me the ick beyond measure.
He's really lovely but he is very smelly... But as I've said... I put it to his type of work that he does.
I only normal see him after work occasionally.
I just can't get it out my head now.
About 8 years back we very close when drunk to having sex, but then thought it was weird and just laughed about it.
Just imagine!!!

On the verge of having sex. So kissing and stuff..... yet you didn't notice?

You thought it was his job? There are plenty of people out there doing messy manual jobs, my husband is one of them. He smells lovely! He washes properly.

Maireas · 01/11/2023 18:19

"doesn't want chemicals on his body"
how ignorant, and selfish

Poppyseed14 · 01/11/2023 18:18

Oh OP. What are the odds he's one of those that can't wipe his arse right either? MN is full of women who have one of them at home. Don't be one of them OP! Save yourself while you can!

2jacqi · 01/11/2023 18:10

I take it he is still single!!!!😷

Monsterjam · 01/11/2023 18:07

I don’t use anything on my body either just water. I do wash my hair with 2 rounds of conditioner. It’s more of a horrible sensitive skin things but I’m sure I don’t smell

Maireas · 01/11/2023 18:01

Justinian, like all Romans, had good personal hygiene.

Manadou · 01/11/2023 17:57

GreyWednesday · 01/11/2023 13:17

Isn’t that a common misconception about life expectancy? That life expectancy might have been around 30 (depending on which era you’re talking about) but it’s an average which is skewed by the very high infant and child mortality. Obviously that would have been in part due to poor hygiene, but not solely.

We should all be washing our hands with soap though!

Yes, the average was skewed by the amount of infant and child mortality, but even so in medieval England, life expectancy at birth for boys born to families that owned land was a mere 31.3 years. However, life expectancy at age 25 for landowners in medieval England was 25.7. So people who got to 25 could expect to live until they were 50.7, on average, that is 25 more years. While 50 might not seem old by today’s standards this is an average, many people would have lived much longer, into their 70s, 80s and even older. The Roman emperor Justinian I lived to be 83 in the 6th century.

Allooetta · 01/11/2023 17:49

That would freak me out. I get freaked out by my mum
as she never washes her hands with soap in the kitchen! It’s so gross. I asked her once to wash her hands and she got upset so I try and block it out. My sister is the same 🤮

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/11/2023 17:44

Manadou · 01/11/2023 12:08

Yes but doctors say just water is equally good. I am not that brave personally!

I'd like to see that fly when scrubbing up for surgery.

Manadou · 01/11/2023 17:38

tattygrl · 01/11/2023 12:39

At risk of being a nobhead, "mortified" doesn't mean similar to horrified or shocked, it means to feel extremely embarrassed or ashamed at ones' own behaviour or actions. Nothing to do with being shocked or upset by something someone else has done.

I'm only risking being a dickhead here because this is a much mis-used word and one of my pet peeves!! In this context, you'd be mortified if you realised you hadn't been using soap for years and that you stank of BO.

I can quite easily see that 'mortified' is exactly the right word here. Many people, myself included, would feel terribly embarrassed and (kind of) ashamed at the thought of having to tell someone that they smell bad. I have heard of whole workplaces being in turmoil because nobody wanted to tell someone, including the manager. One place I heard of they put a deodorant on her desk, and she walked out and never came back. At a place I worked at we had a girl who rode her horse before coming to work and people complained, and the manager, an old battleaxe, said 'Go home and have a shower!'.

19lottie82 · 01/11/2023 17:28

Manadou · 01/11/2023 12:19

Covid viruses are not everyday things and soap or substitutes break down a virus's fatty coat.

No, but plenty of other bugs and viruses transmitted by germs are. And salmonella…..

Alloveragain3 · 01/11/2023 15:03

We do use way too many chemicals on us without giving it a second thought.

Soap, shower gel, shampoo, moisturise, make up, nail varnish, sun cream, cleanser, toner...

It wouldn't surprise me if in 100 years some of the things we use daily are banned.

I wash with soap as I'd feel grim if I didn't but I only use deodorant sparingly, for example, before a work out or on a hot summer day.

He can't seriously not wash hands with soap? That's a recipe for parasites and food poisoning!

Crunchymum · 01/11/2023 14:58

About 8 years back we very close when drunk to having sex

How did he smell then?

Changednamesforthis22 · 01/11/2023 14:58

I've heard of people not using deodorant before as it's believed to be unhealthy, even carcinogenic? but I'm not sure how true that is. No soap is very extreme.

Jewelspun · 01/11/2023 14:57

If you don't intend to have close relations with him why are you banging on about his lifestyle choice.

From how you have worded it you have tried to embarrass or belittle him and thankfully he was having nine of your nonsense.

Octavia64 · 01/11/2023 14:53

I mean I don't use soap, a lot of people don't mostly for skin related reasons but he is unreasonable not to use something that cleans his skin.

The ancient Greeks used oil

PawsisShady · 01/11/2023 14:52

newnamethanks · 01/11/2023 13:00

He's right, chemical filth and unnecessary. Wash properly with water and you'll be fine, wear clean clothes every day.

Water isn't going to wash off poo, ingrained dirt and smegma Envy though is it
You don't get shit on your hands or go gardening or touch raw chicken then rinse them and think yeah that'll do, I'll get some food prepped

PawsisShady · 01/11/2023 14:50

Not a chance I would date him
To put it bluntly nobody is going to being wanting to put their mouth near his bits when he hasn't washed them or his arse
You can use a shower oil, emollient cream, soap, whatever but you need to wash

CalistoNoSolo · 01/11/2023 14:09

newnamethanks · 01/11/2023 13:00

He's right, chemical filth and unnecessary. Wash properly with water and you'll be fine, wear clean clothes every day.

Presumably some form of detergent is used to wash all of those changes of clothes though?

Appleofmyeye2023 · 01/11/2023 13:39

AbbeyGailsParty · 01/11/2023 12:53

Basic soap is made from oil , water and lye. Lye can be made from ash so no artificial chemicals involved.
Aluminium free deodorants are the norm now I think.

If he wants to stink that’s his choice but he’d not be coming into my house.

🤨😂
you do know that lye is sodium hydroxide?

Your idea of that there are “artificial” chemicals, that are “bad” is hilarious. I’m a chemist so not talking out of my arse.

Everything is simply chemical. We’re made of atoms, that bind into compounds and make all the molecules in the world, solar system and universe. Whether it’s long chain molecules like fatty acids, or simple 2 atom water compound. All atoms, molecules are natural, in that the earth and atmosphere and universe was created with them all. Just because you extract a certain chemical molecules from plants, even ones you’ve burnt to a cinder to create ash, doesn’t make it in any way different to one coming out of a test tube- the molecular structure, the bonds, the atoms it contains are exactly the same.

The idea that using soap made from ash and olive oil, contains more “natural” chemicals than any other soap is complete bollocks. When it comes to it, it’s still the same old atoms reacting in same way during the saponification reaction. Lye is actually worse than most other soaps because sodium hydroxide is actually a stronger alkaline than something like lauric acid or the myriad of other acids used these days. But all those asides are just chemicals as well..no “artificial” or “natural” ..just plain old chemicals

And don’t get me started on the idea of “organic” soap being better fgs…more snake oil selling ….

WhatsTheEffingPoint · 01/11/2023 13:32

If he's not using soap on his skin, it makes me wonder what is he washing his clothes with? If he's smelling of BO that will transfer to his clothes. If they are not being washed properly then it begins a nasty cycle!

For everyone saying it's not a problem etc, thats fine when you only see a person for short amount of time, but personally I'm with the op, I couldn't stomach cuddling up of an evening with someone who smells so bad, let alone doing anything else.

Even with allergies/eczema etc there are enough products in the world now to find something that suits everyone. There's no need to smell.