Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a HOT chocolate?

163 replies

AlwaysTheBabysitter · 01/11/2023 09:08

I know it's me and that I'm an uncultured swine with an asbestos mouth, but I'm starting to feel disappointed whenever I try out a lovely, independent shop which prides themselves on doing a spectacular hot chocolate, only to be given a cup of (admittedly delicious) lukewarm chocolate instead. Which is no good when I want to sit and savour it, and do the whole 'two hands around the mug, jumper sleeves dangling to my fingers' thing. Instead I end up having to gulp it down before it actually goes cold.

I did mention it at my local coffee shop when they started doing the same with their coffees, only to be told that it's the optimum temperature for the beans, and I've heard that the Hotel Chocolat Velvetiser produces lukewarm chocolate too. So I suppose the experts have spoken!

Looks like I'll have to stick to tea.

OP posts:
greenhydrangea · 01/11/2023 13:38

Burnoutwhat · 01/11/2023 12:46

I think I have a different definition of lukewarm to many. You do as you like op it's your money after all.

But honestly (and this is definitely because of my fanny of a dad) I find the type of person who has to have food and drink a certain temp a pain in the arse. It's as if none of us have made any compromise ever on the temp of or food and drink. Or I don't know something about not being able to tolerate any variation from their idea of perfect. And I suppose that many cultures do have room temp food. But that's absolutely a projection based on him and that being his personality.

I'm sure there are people wjo insist of piping hot who aren't like this, I've just found there is definitely a correlation, and the sample isn't just my dad!! 😂

The clue is in the name. It's Hot Chocolate.

I can make it hot at home, without this precious "burning" of the milk. I used to be able to buy it in cafes some years ago. Modern cafes can't seem to do it, even when expressly asked to. It's not a treat when it is an expensive disappointment, served barely warm.

MyOtherNameToday · 01/11/2023 13:37

AlwaysTheBabysitter · 01/11/2023 09:22

@ShirleyPhallus YES vulnerable sleeves!! That's exactly it! I didn't know it had a word! Bonus points for my pensive expression as I look out onto a rainy street, of course. There might even be a cat.

I love this thread 😂

I'm with you OP I hate tepid drinks even if they're technically at the 'correct' temperature.

UdderlyPumpkin · 01/11/2023 13:35

AlwaysTheBabysitter · 01/11/2023 09:12

Now that's an idea! Travelling around Europe sampling their hot chocolate offerings. That's my December sorted 😊☕

Please can I come too? I will bring us some cosy books to read.

queenofthewild · 01/11/2023 13:32

I am not alone!

Every hot chocolate I've had recently away from home has been served in a cold cup and is 75% foam with a tiny dribble of warm chocolate at the bottom.

I want a full cup of hot chocolate, no foam, maybe a bit of squirty cream. Like hot chocolate used to be.

mokjkjjo · 01/11/2023 13:20

I agree. In many places it’s barely warm, and I don’t enjoy lukewarm drinks.

Starbucks here make it lukewarm however I’ve always found it’s hot when made at the Starbucks service stations I’ve been to.

I have a Velvetiser and the first cup from mine is ok for me - hotter than lukewarm - but the second cup is much hotter. I make the first cup for the DC as it’s just right for them.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/11/2023 13:20

But honestly (and this is definitely because of my fanny of a dad) I find the type of person who has to have food and drink a certain temp a pain in the arse. It's as if none of us have made any compromise ever on the temp of or food and drink. Or I don't know something about not being able to tolerate any variation from their idea of perfect. And I suppose that many cultures do have room temp food. But that's absolutely a projection based on him and that being his personality.

I take the point but I'd never be fussy in say, someone else's house.

But if I'm going to a coffee shop, buying a drink as a treat, that's costing me the most part of €5, yes, I'll be specific about my preference.

There's also a time & place - if I'm not happy I'll politely ask for my drink to be remade. But if there's a long queue, they are short staffed or whatever, I won't (tho will be internally disappointed)

Pinkpinkpink15 · 01/11/2023 13:13

mylittleponyrainbow · 01/11/2023 10:53

On a side note I'm a trained barista and yes the milk has an optimum temp.. we have thermometer on the side of the jug.. if people asked for a hot latte I would just do it to boiling point if that's what they wished but I always wondered if it tasted different!

@mylittleponyrainbow

yes it does. Unfortunately.

i like my drinks HOT, I was under the illusion that if I had a decent machine I could make a HOT latte.

but sadly if I heat the milk over 65° It tastes horrible.

at least at home I can make the cup hot and not faff about making it. It's still not AS hot as I'd like, but better than cafes!!

RaraRachael · 01/11/2023 13:04

The only place I can get a decent on is Costa if I ask for extra hot. When I previously complained I was told that they only serve them at X degrees and if you want it to be anything like actually hot you have to ask for extra hot.

Side note - I had the most disgusting not even remotely lukewarm one in a coffee shop round the corner from the Mousetrap theatre on Saturday night. We were in desperation for somewhere to get out of the rain until the doors opened,

LegendsBeyond · 01/11/2023 12:50

I agree. I feel like it’s a waste of money when I can drink it in 30 seconds. My velvetiser hot chocolate goes in the microwave after making so it’s hot enough for me.

Burnoutwhat · 01/11/2023 12:46

I think I have a different definition of lukewarm to many. You do as you like op it's your money after all.

But honestly (and this is definitely because of my fanny of a dad) I find the type of person who has to have food and drink a certain temp a pain in the arse. It's as if none of us have made any compromise ever on the temp of or food and drink. Or I don't know something about not being able to tolerate any variation from their idea of perfect. And I suppose that many cultures do have room temp food. But that's absolutely a projection based on him and that being his personality.

I'm sure there are people wjo insist of piping hot who aren't like this, I've just found there is definitely a correlation, and the sample isn't just my dad!! 😂

EarringsandLipstick · 01/11/2023 12:42

shivawn · 01/11/2023 12:38

Totally agree OP. I want my hot chocolate super hot, the marshmallows should melt into a lovely frothy sweet layer on top not just sit there bopping sadly in a lukewarm mug.

My husband makes me a lovely hot chocolate from his coffee machine but I have to nuke it for 30 seconds in the microwave after because the machine doesn't get it hot.

Marshmallows?!

No no no. You can't be in my HC club 😂

(I am always faced with baffled faces when I refuse cream + marshmallows. No. I just want the chocolate. But hot)

shivawn · 01/11/2023 12:38

Totally agree OP. I want my hot chocolate super hot, the marshmallows should melt into a lovely frothy sweet layer on top not just sit there bopping sadly in a lukewarm mug.

My husband makes me a lovely hot chocolate from his coffee machine but I have to nuke it for 30 seconds in the microwave after because the machine doesn't get it hot.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/11/2023 12:32

AtomicBlondeRose · 01/11/2023 12:16

Of course the way round this is to intend the drink for a small child, in which case it will be both the temperature and consistency of lava.

😂😂😂

warriorofhopelessness · 01/11/2023 12:30

It’s the same with coffee. By the time they have faffed around tapping down the froth and wiping spouts and often chatting to their colleagues the coffee is lukewarm. If you ask them to heat it up they hand you back a scalding cup.

TheBunnyLover · 01/11/2023 12:30

I'm like you OP. Asbestos mouth. Love hot chocolate, not 'warm-ish' chocolate. I do make my own but it'd be nice to be able to order one while out and not have to gulp it down straight away before it goes cold.

I feel the same about coffee machines which is why I've never owned one. I drink it more or less straight from the kettle otherwise It's just not worth having.

greenhydrangea · 01/11/2023 12:30

Burnoutwhat · 01/11/2023 09:11

Having worked in a coffee shop, you can only get milk so hot before it burns.

In my experience people who refer to things like this as lukewarm are being a bit dramatic it's just not boiling hot. Iuke warm is a hot cup of teas after 30 min or so I'd be surprised if it's actually this cold.

If you can stick your entire finger into the cup and it is... lukewarm, then it is lukewarm. It isn't being dramatic.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 01/11/2023 12:26

stepfordwifey · 01/11/2023 12:05

Yogi Christmas tea. Like mulled wine, a real mix of spices. Holland & Barrett do it nearer Xmas.

Rooibos, hibiscus / rosehips infusions, the world of "Indian style" chais...

I have a really nice wild apple and rosemary tea blend.

And I personally really like green teas. But suggesting that feels a bit like opening pandora´s box, tbh... There are just so many types, quality differences etc.

Oolong however isn´t my cup of tea (horrible pun, I know)😂Blush

AtomicBlondeRose · 01/11/2023 12:16

Of course the way round this is to intend the drink for a small child, in which case it will be both the temperature and consistency of lava.

elephantblock · 01/11/2023 12:07

'two hands around the mug, jumper sleeves dangling to my fingers'

Cringing in millennial vibes babe

stepfordwifey · 01/11/2023 12:05

Lougle · 01/11/2023 09:31

While we're on the subject of hot drinks, I've expanded my tea repertoire to earl grey, mint, and camomile. Matcha is a work in progress. Any tea I'm missing? I don't like lady grey, too flowery.

Yogi Christmas tea. Like mulled wine, a real mix of spices. Holland & Barrett do it nearer Xmas.

Manicule · 01/11/2023 11:18

Yes, the McDonalds case was actually horrific and they turned it into a big joke. The poor woman.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 01/11/2023 11:14

LylaLee · 01/11/2023 11:02

Just in case anyone is not familiar with the McDonalds case.

McDonalds had been superheating hot drinks so that people would not complain that they were not hot enough. They had been told to stop doing this because of several reported injuries. They kept doing it.

Stella Liebeck was a 79 year old woman (Originally from Norwich, England), who was in the passenger seat of a car. They ordered at the drive through and the coffee spilled in her lap when she tried to add sugar.

It was so hot her labia melted and fused together.

She asked McDonalds for $20,000 for medical costs only (no NHS in USA). They refused and said $800 max. She took them to court. The judge awarded punitive damages, because they had been warned several times. The amount was 2 days of coffee sales. $2.7 million but McDonalds argued for this to be reduced to $640,000.

McDonalds started a campaign to paint her as a frivolous lawsuit chaser. (It worked)

Thank you for the comment!

People complaining about the McDonalds coffee lawsuit are usually unaware about the backstory.

the drink was unreasonably hot, it caused major injuries and McDonalds had been warned repeatedly ...

ladeluge · 01/11/2023 11:05

Oh yes, they can keep their lukewarm mugs of coffee and hot choc. To me, it is such a waste of good money to sit down to savour a hot drink and get a lukewarm undrinkable (to me) one instead. Then I have to neck it down or it will be COLD before I finish it. Ugh.

For this reason, I don't get hot choc anymore, but like a pp said, an extra hot mocha will do if I'm gasping for a hot drink when out and about.

I suppose we are expected to be sophisticated and drink stuff at the temperature of a baby's bottle, or we will be considered philistines!

At home I have the perfect solution to hot drinks at the temperature I like. I got a kitchen master hot water dispenser that sits behind my workstation/computer zone on the kitchen counter. It boils the water in a few seconds, so I make my coffee and halfway through when it is cooling down I stick the cup under the spout again and top it up with boiling water. Perfect, perfection, I love it! No filling the kettle ten times a day either.

I am obviously a heathen.

LylaLee · 01/11/2023 11:02

CranfordScones · 01/11/2023 10:02

I'm with you.

I suspect it's a combination of reasons: They'd get just as many complaints about it being too hot. They think tables will turn round quicker because people aren't waiting for drinks to cool. Lower risk of being sued by people who burn themselves (anyone remember that McDonalds case in the US years ago?).

On a similar theme: restaurants that serve hot food on barely warm (or cold) plates is a personal bugbear.

Just in case anyone is not familiar with the McDonalds case.

McDonalds had been superheating hot drinks so that people would not complain that they were not hot enough. They had been told to stop doing this because of several reported injuries. They kept doing it.

Stella Liebeck was a 79 year old woman (Originally from Norwich, England), who was in the passenger seat of a car. They ordered at the drive through and the coffee spilled in her lap when she tried to add sugar.

It was so hot her labia melted and fused together.

She asked McDonalds for $20,000 for medical costs only (no NHS in USA). They refused and said $800 max. She took them to court. The judge awarded punitive damages, because they had been warned several times. The amount was 2 days of coffee sales. $2.7 million but McDonalds argued for this to be reduced to $640,000.

McDonalds started a campaign to paint her as a frivolous lawsuit chaser. (It worked)

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 01/11/2023 10:59

AlwaysTheBabysitter · 01/11/2023 09:12

Now that's an idea! Travelling around Europe sampling their hot chocolate offerings. That's my December sorted 😊☕

www.caffegilli.com/en

The best place ever 😋