Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - sister and brother in law seemingly excluding me

190 replies

MarleneH · 31/10/2023 23:23

Good evening all,
please advise me if I’m being unreasonable being annoyed?

my husbands sister (SIL) brought hubby a gift for his birthday last year to go to a concert in December. I found out last week that It’s not just hubby and sister in law going, it’s sister in law and her partner, and my brother in law and his partner - so couples night excluding me. My hubby is basically third wheeling.

do I have the right to feel annoyed? I feel excluded and disrespected tbh. I feel like I should have been asked.

it’s annoyed me because it’s basically hubby and his siblings plus their partners, but no one thought to ask me. I do not expect anyone to pay for me, but it would’ve been nice to have been asked and I could have sent over my money or booked my ticket. All sold out now so too late.

what would you do? Is it even worth me speaking to hubby?

Thanks
M x

OP posts:
andweallsingalong · 02/11/2023 16:26

Cumbrianlife · 31/10/2023 23:54

Is it because they'll all be travelling in one car?

This is a good point, if they're all travelling together in a typical 5 seater car then there wouldn't be room for you without breaking up into separate parties and having 2 drivers.

Proudbitch · 02/11/2023 15:55

@labamba007 Well to be fair it was a very low key gathering at one of their homes. They arranged a date to get together for 2 of DP’s relatives (one being a child) as well as my DP’s birthdays. They checked dates with everyone, DP told them the dates I could and couldn’t do and they picked a date that I had said I couldn’t do rather than trying to find a date we all could do in the end 😂

We’d had a bigger party for DP on his actual birthday and that the parents and sister came to as well but none of the others made the effort to come to, so I assume they thought it didn’t matter if I was there or not..

I think they are all very socially awkward and can only handle small cliquey gatherings amongst their own family who everyone has known for years and years! I came along much later than the other partners! I’d be curious to know if that’s the same for OP actually.

Twazique · 02/11/2023 15:53

I don't think it was a good birthday gift as it has lead to OP feeling rejected. It would be a great trip for all three couples to go on and to celebrate together, but excluding the OP is bound to lead to hard feelings. OP, I would feel bad about this too.

Greenpolkadot · 02/11/2023 15:38

His ticket was a birthday gift...right..?
So why would they buy you a ticket..? It's not your birthday.
Plus, I can't believe you haven't chatted to your hubby about it ,

Jellytot1234 · 02/11/2023 15:31

Mari9999 · 01/11/2023 10:59

@MarleneH
It seems that as a birthday gift , his siblings are taking him to a concert. Usually a gift is given to the celebrant. In this case the celebrant is your husband. There is no real reason why the gift should have included a ticket for you. This is a one time event, does it really matter that he goes alone? Why create an unnecessary issue between the siblings? There is a lot to lose by creating unnecessary friction and nothing to be gained from doing so. What would be your purpose?

Have you even read the original post. The OP isn’t saying she’s upset that they didn’t buy her a ticket or that all siblings are going- she’s upset that her partners siblings… are taking their partners and she wasn’t even given a thought. That’s excluding and really nasty.

labamba007 · 02/11/2023 15:20

Proudbitch · 02/11/2023 10:28

I’m sorry to hear this OP. Definitely YANBU.

They could easily have contacted you and said ‘we are all going to xx event and were planning on clubbing together to get DH a ticket as a surprise. Appreciate you may already have sorted out a gift, but are you interested in joining in too?’

I can imagine this exact scenario happening on my partner’s side (they actually excluded me from a party for his birthday 😂) so I can easily imagine that they would do the same. We haven’t fallen out, we just don’t have much in common.

However there’s no way I’d book a ticket for my brother without at least asking his wife first if she wants to join and giving her the opportunity to say no! I know if I ever did mistakenly do that, my brother would also straight away say to me ‘what about SIL?’

Hope you are ok. You should definitely plan something really lovely for yourself on that particular day is you may find you’re feeling quite upset.

They excluded you at his birthday party!? How did they even explain their reasoning behind that!

PloddingAlong21 · 02/11/2023 14:31

@Rosscameasdoody

hmm, not really. Think how it played out at Christmas as he opens it

”love this band”

“me too will be so much fun”

“can’t wait”

the OP and DH assume it’s the two of them.

months roll by and here they are planning it and realisation hits. They’ve probably not really discussed it as it was gifted 11 months ago. DH realises he too isn’t just going with one sibling. Too late to get more tickets.

Rosscameasdoody · 02/11/2023 14:23

PloddingAlong21 · 02/11/2023 13:59

They’re selfish and inconsiderate. Also not your husbands problem or fault so shouldn’t be penalised for it. He should maybe ask then why they didn’t think to invite you and make them aware.

Methinks it’s very much the husband’s problem and fault. How else have they managed to keep it quiet for this long ?

PloddingAlong21 · 02/11/2023 13:59

They’re selfish and inconsiderate. Also not your husbands problem or fault so shouldn’t be penalised for it. He should maybe ask then why they didn’t think to invite you and make them aware.

Proudbitch · 02/11/2023 10:28

I’m sorry to hear this OP. Definitely YANBU.

They could easily have contacted you and said ‘we are all going to xx event and were planning on clubbing together to get DH a ticket as a surprise. Appreciate you may already have sorted out a gift, but are you interested in joining in too?’

I can imagine this exact scenario happening on my partner’s side (they actually excluded me from a party for his birthday 😂) so I can easily imagine that they would do the same. We haven’t fallen out, we just don’t have much in common.

However there’s no way I’d book a ticket for my brother without at least asking his wife first if she wants to join and giving her the opportunity to say no! I know if I ever did mistakenly do that, my brother would also straight away say to me ‘what about SIL?’

Hope you are ok. You should definitely plan something really lovely for yourself on that particular day is you may find you’re feeling quite upset.

WhoNeedsEnemiesWithFriendsLikeThese · 02/11/2023 09:11

My MIL and SIL used to exclude me all the time, and let me know to my face they were doing it. My MIL used to tell me that I wasn't her DD and she didn't want to do things with me, that you do with a DD. I am talking, go for a coffee, or shopping, not anything particularly intimate. My SIL used to throw her toys out of her pram if I did anything with my MIL. I was told I'm not family.

It hurt me for a long time, then I got over it.

Years later, my DC are their only DGC, and they get very upset when they are not included in the things we do. I don't facilitate any meet ups or anything with them, because as they told me.........I'm not their DD, I don't want to do things with them that you do with a DD, I'm not family.

MyMiniMetro · 02/11/2023 08:14

The OP should just ask the SIL (in person preferably or by telephone, but NOT via a message) why a ticket was purchased for everyone's partner except for her. It's a reasonable question. Unless they get the apologetic response 'we were gifted/won an odd number of tickets and you got the short straw, sorry' her husband should definitely not go.

Aside from a competition win, there's no excuse for this. Even if tickets are for a band OP openly hated, the SIL should have checked-in with 'we're all getting tickets for X, we assume you don't want to come?' And if it a money issue then an offer like 'I'm getting Y & Z tickets for X as a present, partners are invited too of course, but you guys will need to pay for your own ticket, if that's okay?'

I'll say again; the husband should not go. If I can be blunt, he should probably 'grow a pair' and have already asked his family why his wife was excluded. He should be telling his wife without prompting that he is not going to go to an event that so hurtfully excluded her.

Sounds like he's staying quiet because he actually wants to go to this gig and he's hopeful OP will overlook the slight and say 'oh but you should still go.' Don't say that. Make clear that going to events with siblings is one thing, but when all partners are invited except her someone is making a point, and not a very nice one. OP and her husband need to make a point too by husband not going and both of them calling out SIL on her behaviour and asking for an explanation. If you don't stand firm as a couple now, expect this kind of shite to continue.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 02/11/2023 07:17

backtowinter · 01/11/2023 16:15

@DuplicateUserName Well luckily I don't give a fuck what you think 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP's use of that infantile word was the written equivalent of the verbal "y'know" that punctuates some people's conversations

I'll continue to judge, thanks all the same pet

Before you accuse anyone else of being ‘infantile’ you might want to look back at your last few posts. What have you actually brought to the discussion?

Hilly7 · 02/11/2023 06:25

DotAndCarryOne2 · 01/11/2023 12:37

Don’t understand this. DH’s brother and sister have arranged a birthday event for him, included their own partners, and left the OP out of her own DH’s birthday celebrations. How could you not see this as a snub ? And the fact that they’ve kept it quiet since last year implies that DH has known all along that the other partners were invited, but said nothing. And I don’t think it’s that the OP didn’t care enough to purchase tickets - she was under the impression that it was just DH and his siblings going, so it would have been inappropriate.

The fact that it’s actually a couples’ event and she has been left out, puts a totally different complexion on it and In the grand scheme of things it absolutely does matter. She’s been snubbed and her DH is complicit, so the ‘good relationship’ with his family clearly isn’t. I would want it brought out in the open, and frankly, no matter what the explanation, it would leave me with a very bad taste in my mouth and I would be rethinking my relationship with all of them. DH included.

This 100%

Mothership4two · 02/11/2023 01:18

I'd be a bit surprised that DH isn't raising this issue himself. Definitely warrants a discussion with you OP and one with his siblings. Why isn't he querying why you are being left out?

Findinganewme · 01/11/2023 22:28

Unless there is animosity in your relationship with your in laws, it’s just plain mean to exclude you.

its fair that they’re paying for his ticket as it’s his birthday, maybe. I bought my brother a dinner voucher for a restaurant he likes, for his birthday and said that I hope that he and his wife enjoy it. To not ask you if you’d like to join, (albeit at your own cost) doesn’t make sense.

I think that the real issue is that your partner is not saying anything. Why is he not asking his own sister, why you are not included? How can he be OK to just crack on without you. I mean, if it were just a siblings thing, or a boys thing, that would make sense. Unless there is more to it, this does not make sense.

sandyhappypeople · 01/11/2023 21:02

MarleneH · 31/10/2023 23:23

Good evening all,
please advise me if I’m being unreasonable being annoyed?

my husbands sister (SIL) brought hubby a gift for his birthday last year to go to a concert in December. I found out last week that It’s not just hubby and sister in law going, it’s sister in law and her partner, and my brother in law and his partner - so couples night excluding me. My hubby is basically third wheeling.

do I have the right to feel annoyed? I feel excluded and disrespected tbh. I feel like I should have been asked.

it’s annoyed me because it’s basically hubby and his siblings plus their partners, but no one thought to ask me. I do not expect anyone to pay for me, but it would’ve been nice to have been asked and I could have sent over my money or booked my ticket. All sold out now so too late.

what would you do? Is it even worth me speaking to hubby?

Thanks
M x

I wouldn't feel annoyed at this point but I would be confused.

And I'd ask why you've not been asked? there could be a few different reasons as to why things have been done this way, but none really stack up tbf, if they knew it was a couples outing from the get go they should have let you know early on so you could get a ticket too? or if it became a couples outing later on they should have asked you then?

Just ask the SIL who arranged it, in person / on the phone would be better though, text messages can easily be misconstrued!

suchandsuchandsuchandsuch · 01/11/2023 20:18

Talk to your partner that’s sounds way out of order, maybe it started off as just siblings then it ended up the partners saying that wanted to go but even so they should have then have included you, I would not be happy and I would definitely be talking to my hubby about it, to be fair I know he’d have flagged it up pretty much straight away and he wouldn’t feel comfortable going. Even if your husband still goes it needs to be addressed to stop it happening again in future.

readingrocks · 01/11/2023 19:51

I'd be fuming. I speak as someone who has had a lot of experience in weird inlaw behaviour on these lines. The only excuse would be if you are known not to be interested in whatever the ticket is for. But I think this is a real case of copying Michelle Obama (when they go low, we go high) and waving your husband off and wishing him a great evening. Easier said than done.

pam290358 · 01/11/2023 17:08

Mari9999 · 01/11/2023 15:31

@pam290358
The OP is assuming that she was excluded. There is no evidence of that. What she knows with certainty is that her husband received a birthday gift . She does not know any of the circumstances surrounding the selection of or even the purchase of the gift She has made several assumptions without knowing the details, and in truth who really gives any significant details with a gift. A gift usually comes, gift wrapped with a card and good wishes.

I am still having difficulty understanding how you immediately assign negative intentions from people with whom you have always gotten along. Is the OP thinking that this group suddenly all awoke up one morning thinking "let's find a way to exclude OP."

What would be the reason , and why would her thoughts immediately turn to exclusion? That is so offensive to people who have seemingly treated her well in the past.

No answers to any of the questions you pose. So the best course of action is for the OP to ask. AS several posters have said previously there may be a simple explanation. But on the face of it the tickets were bought, all other in laws are going, and the OP didn’t know this until recently - she assumed it was just the siblings, which would be perfectly acceptable. But a couples night from which she has been excluded is not. And her DH seemingly knew she’d been excluded. It needs an honest conversation to sort it out.

easylikeasundaymorn · 01/11/2023 17:04

Drinagh · 01/11/2023 13:03

Any reason why you can't buy yourself a ticket and go too, if it's an act you like and tickets are still available?

maybe because, as she literally said in the opening post, tickets have all sold out now?

Rosscameasdoody · 01/11/2023 17:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Er - she’s using these words in their correct context. And it’s you who’s derailing the thread with this nonsense. You don’t like the use of the word “hubby’ as a term of endearment. But your use of ‘poppet’ is derisory. Try sticking to the question the OP actually asked, and then we’ll all get along just fine ‘poppet’!!

AliceOlive · 01/11/2023 17:01

Half term still going there?

Notamum12345577 · 01/11/2023 16:58

DuplicateUserName · 01/11/2023 11:30

People need to get off the OP's back about using the word 'hubby'.

It's not my favourite word either but she's entitled to use it if she wants to Hmm

Yeah, surely it is better than ‘DH’

backtowinter · 01/11/2023 16:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread