Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister wants to sell our jointly owned property aboard but I don't ??

155 replies

iwanttoholdyourhand · 31/10/2023 18:56

I need some advice. I jointly own a property abroad with my sister. We are both in our late 40s. She does not work and is on benefits.

She now wants to sell her share of said property and I don't . This property was gifted to us by our mother. It is currently rented out.

The country the property is located in the economy is really bad at the moment and it's already lost £10k of its value. The total value is now around only £50k. I want to wait it out and have plans to eventually semi retire in the country the property is in. I also have very fond memories of spending summers at this place. I really don't want to sell.

However, she wants out now and would like the money. I cannot afford to pay her in excess of £25k. I have suggested given her a small lump sum of £5k and then monthly payments of £500 per month over 3 years. She is angry and is not happy with this suggestion. She would like the money in one lump sum.

AIBU. I work full time and also have a young family. The money I give her will be tax free for her and also I don't think she will declare it to her benefits office.

I really don't want to upset her but think she's being a little unfair.

OP posts:
YireosDodeAver · 01/11/2023 01:53

Sirzy · 31/10/2023 19:02

If you can afford £500 per month could you not get a mortgage or loan to buy her out?

ultimatly even if you both pay out to go through courts etc chances are you would still have to sell

This. You could easily get an appropriate loan to buy her out. If she is unwaged then owning this property is a massive barrier to her recieving support which you are generally ineligible for if you have more than £6000ish assets.that means your nice little retirement plan is causing your sister immediate financial hardship. Yabu.

ninjasnap · 01/11/2023 01:43

So she is fraudulently claiming UC whilst wanting you to sell this asset for fun spends?? How on earth is anyone defending the sister in this??

iwanttoholdyourhand · 01/11/2023 00:14

Mum5net · 31/10/2023 23:56

Could you raid from your pension pot to help raise cash , OP. Not ideal but it is for retirement.

No I would never do that I have a good pension it's better to just try and get a loan

OP posts:
Mum5net · 31/10/2023 23:56

Could you raid from your pension pot to help raise cash , OP. Not ideal but it is for retirement.

iwanttoholdyourhand · 31/10/2023 23:38

nibblessquibbles · 31/10/2023 21:04

OP be careful on this. As part of my divorce I got the abroad property and I had to pay a substantial cost to transfer into my name, this was just the paperwork but I had to pay the full equivalent of stamp duty even though my ex didn't on the UK property.
There was also capital gains for him on disposal of our rental flat and I made sure that it was clear in our paperwork that he was liable for any taxes etc on his side. I'm fairly sure he didn't pay CGT which I did pay and was a fair whack!
You should make sure it's clear that each party is responsible for their own tax bills and declarations to the relevant authorities.

Be careful also that you have a fair valuation on the property including all costs before you pay your sister with the loan. She doesn't get half the valuation but the valuation less all the costs as that is what would happen if you sold it and divvied the proceeds.

That's a good point at the moment she wants half the value of the property I will also deduct taxes and costs first too.

OP posts:
iwanttoholdyourhand · 31/10/2023 23:35

Zilla1 · 31/10/2023 20:52

Good luck. HNRTT but perhaps try to view the temporary reduction in the value of the property due to the state of the market as beneficial in saving you half of the reduction in the £10k in the purchase price you'd need to pay. Make sure you get an independent valuation at a suitable time to ensure your DSis doesn't make herself feel she has been hard done by. Also, make sure half the legal fees for the sale-side are charged against her share as they would be if you sold it entirely now. Again, might be helpful to put in writing the obvious like she'll stop receiving half the rental income from the point of sale and she won't be entitled to stay there for free if it can be rented out. Sometimes difficult people have a habit of feeling aggrieved when the can't have their cake and eat it.

.

Yes I do plan to put everything clearly in writing .

OP posts:
iwanttoholdyourhand · 31/10/2023 23:16

Feraldogmum · 31/10/2023 23:10

The issue of benefits is irrelevant to anyone but the sister ,and that's for her to navigate.She owns half the property and wants to sell, that's her right. To actually suggest blackmailing and threatening the sister just so OP can get her way, is morally repugnant and bordering on illegal,plus it would cause a rift in the family.

I would never ever blackmail my sister or try and take anything from her that she is owed.

I will do everything legally and above board. As I said previously her issues with UC are hers. I have chosen to turn a blind eye for years.

OP posts:
venusandmars · 31/10/2023 23:16

PP are focusing on OP’s sister’s UC circumstances, but unless she declared the proceeds herself, was subject to a spot check or was reported to DWP by someone she knew, she’s not going to get suddenly “found out” purely because of this sale. It’s a risk she’s obviously willing to take, and that’s her responsibility.

There is a risk difference between having an undeclared property of 'unknown' value abroad, and having X amount of cash hit your UK bank account.

iwanttoholdyourhand · 31/10/2023 23:13

Sureaseggs44 · 31/10/2023 23:03

I would buy her out as long as you do everything properly it’s up to her to declare it and as much as I hate benefit cheats I would just leave that bit and hope Karma gets her eventually . Then you will have the benefit of rising prices and the income . Tough luck on her .

I know the property will double in valise over the next 5 years and then even more so. I have explained this to my sister but she doesn't care and wants the money now. She has made no provision for her retirement at all.

I have worked since I was 18. I want to retire in the next 5 years. It's a no brainer to keep hold of it.

OP posts:
Feraldogmum · 31/10/2023 23:10

The issue of benefits is irrelevant to anyone but the sister ,and that's for her to navigate.She owns half the property and wants to sell, that's her right. To actually suggest blackmailing and threatening the sister just so OP can get her way, is morally repugnant and bordering on illegal,plus it would cause a rift in the family.

iwanttoholdyourhand · 31/10/2023 23:09

Mum5net · 31/10/2023 23:07

Has the probate process to be gone through in England? We lost two parents in the last year and our experience has been that this process is very slow. Then when you factor in rules of the country where the property is, and any rules pertaining to the family who are renting, this could be a lengthy period.

My mother signed over the property to us over 10 years ago

OP posts:
iwanttoholdyourhand · 31/10/2023 23:08

Coughingdodger · 31/10/2023 22:59

Her half of the property is her business. She’s entitled to cash it in if she needs the income. Why should she be deprived of her own money just because you fancy a holiday home in the future?

You drip-feeding her money isn’t appropriate for either of you. If you buy her out it has to be done legally, for both your sakes.

As pp said, you can get a loan and buy her out. Let her do the legwork if you trust her to get a good price for it - do you? - but you both need to pay any legal and professional costs and you shouldn’t put obstacles in her way.

My sister is not very savvy when it comes to money at all. If I every did want to sell I would do all the negotiating as she just would not be able to do it.

OP posts:
Mum5net · 31/10/2023 23:07

Has the probate process to be gone through in England? We lost two parents in the last year and our experience has been that this process is very slow. Then when you factor in rules of the country where the property is, and any rules pertaining to the family who are renting, this could be a lengthy period.

iwanttoholdyourhand · 31/10/2023 23:04

AnotherEmma · 31/10/2023 22:53

It will be difficult to raise the £25k but I think you should buy her out as it's better not to jointly own with someone like this. You say she has been fraudulently claiming UC for years and is irresponsible with money. So buy her out and draw a line under it. Hopefully once it's sorted you won't have to talk to her about money again and can just disengage / grey rock if she raises the subject.

Do you have a mortgage on your home? I wonder if you could increase it?

Do make sure you are getting an accurate valuation of the property abroad, get several valuations if you can.

Oh and you'll get lots of people telling you to report her for benefit fraud. Morally it might be the right thing to do but I think you need to be pragmatic. If she found out or had any suspicion it was you, it would utterly destroy your relationship. She will probably get found out eventually one way or another. But it doesn't have to be your fault.

Edited

Yes my plan is to buy her out. I really don't want to sell. I won't be able to remortgage my coproperty as have only recently paid a large sum for renovations.

I will raise the money some how I have things I could sell/ and also take out a personal loan.

I would never not give her what she is entitled to.

OP posts:
Sureaseggs44 · 31/10/2023 23:03

I would buy her out as long as you do everything properly it’s up to her to declare it and as much as I hate benefit cheats I would just leave that bit and hope Karma gets her eventually . Then you will have the benefit of rising prices and the income . Tough luck on her .

puffylovett · 31/10/2023 23:02

Please don’t allow your sisters irrational and irresponsible behaviour To ruin your dreams for your future retirement.
personally I would report her or as above, force her hand and make her do all the legwork, finding solicitors etc.

Coughingdodger · 31/10/2023 23:00

Sorry, I meant if you trust her to get a good price if you decide to sell to a third party.
If you decide to buy her out yourself then you can let her set it up but don’t block her.

Coughingdodger · 31/10/2023 22:59

Her half of the property is her business. She’s entitled to cash it in if she needs the income. Why should she be deprived of her own money just because you fancy a holiday home in the future?

You drip-feeding her money isn’t appropriate for either of you. If you buy her out it has to be done legally, for both your sakes.

As pp said, you can get a loan and buy her out. Let her do the legwork if you trust her to get a good price for it - do you? - but you both need to pay any legal and professional costs and you shouldn’t put obstacles in her way.

AnotherEmma · 31/10/2023 22:53

It will be difficult to raise the £25k but I think you should buy her out as it's better not to jointly own with someone like this. You say she has been fraudulently claiming UC for years and is irresponsible with money. So buy her out and draw a line under it. Hopefully once it's sorted you won't have to talk to her about money again and can just disengage / grey rock if she raises the subject.

Do you have a mortgage on your home? I wonder if you could increase it?

Do make sure you are getting an accurate valuation of the property abroad, get several valuations if you can.

Oh and you'll get lots of people telling you to report her for benefit fraud. Morally it might be the right thing to do but I think you need to be pragmatic. If she found out or had any suspicion it was you, it would utterly destroy your relationship. She will probably get found out eventually one way or another. But it doesn't have to be your fault.

iwanttoholdyourhand · 31/10/2023 22:52

FirstFallopians · 31/10/2023 22:16

PP are focusing on OP’s sister’s UC circumstances, but unless she declared the proceeds herself, was subject to a spot check or was reported to DWP by someone she knew, she’s not going to get suddenly “found out” purely because of this sale.

It’s a risk she’s obviously willing to take, and that’s her responsibility.

I’d sell up if I was you, OP. If she’s already fraudulently claiming UC I’d worry about what other risks she was taking, and I wouldn’t want any financial ties to that person.

I am tempted to just sell and break financial ties with her. My family and friends have advised me that it is too much,

It is always complicated when dealing with property and family members.

My sister is the kind of person who will blow through the money in a year or so and then be angry at me for having an asset that's increasing in value. She has no other property or pension and sees me as the rich sister.

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 31/10/2023 22:51

I think if you can't afford to buy her out now, you should sell. It doesn't matter what she plans to spend the money on, and I don't think she is unreasonable to want to sell a property overseas that is of limited use to her.

MariaLuna · 31/10/2023 22:49

Find it quite weird people thinking they know how it works in other countries who all have different inherenterence laws.

You cannot disinherit kids here unless a junkie. (It happened).

Get thee to a lawyer!
,

Soontobe60 · 31/10/2023 22:48

Sealady19 · 31/10/2023 19:19

You are being totally sensible and understanding in a wise and considerate way with your sister. You have the right vision, do not change your stance, you are on the right track, she would waste the money gained pretty soon any any way and then she'd be deprived of this last resource.

How do you know she would waste the money? What she does with her money is totally up to her!

widowtwankywashroom · 31/10/2023 22:47

I'll buy her out OP. I'd love a little place abroad xx ❤️

Swipe left for the next trending thread