Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my friend will lose her job

159 replies

MollyMindy · 31/10/2023 18:53

Posting for advice as a close friend of mine is in a bind

She started a new job 2 months ago, a promotion, all good.

4 weeks ago her husband walked out, no kids, but she is devastated. Can't function at work, been doing the bare minimum, and what she is doing I gather is pretty poor quality.

Performance is now being monitored, informally for last few weeks, more support given etc. She thinks it is going to get more formal soon, so has got herself signed off for a month with stress.

She is under the impression that although she is on probation she now can't be touched, I think she is wrong but not sure what advice if any to give her.

OP posts:
nibblessquibbles · 01/11/2023 08:33

It really depends on the probation policy at work but typically you can fail soneone's probation if they've been off sick for a long period as they haven't been able to demonstrate they've met the criteria to pass probation. She's also already flagged up as not performing so there would be sufficient evidence to cause doubt that she can perform.
Her best bet is as PP said to come clean, explain that she is aware she's not been at her best and that she just needs a month to get herself sorted and then she'll come back and perform and that she would be happy for probation to be extended to cover the gap. If she proactively offers this and recognises the issues they may look more kindly on this.

MrsPinkCock · 01/11/2023 08:32

I’m an employment lawyer and if the employer was my client I’d probably be telling them it’s fine to dismiss. Some more wary employers might see “stress” and go down a formal capability route first though just in case it’s linked to a long term MH condition which could be a disability.

However either way she is clearly incapable of performing the role both due to incapability when she is there and persistent absences. I’ve terminated people whilst covered by a fit note many times over the years.

Your friend has had a rough time and it sounds like she needs help and support to try and get back to some normality. Maybe losing her job will shock her into taking some action for herself?

Beautiful3 · 01/11/2023 08:28

She's not protected because she's still on probation. They're going to get rid of her for sure. You cannot have lots of time off, when your partner leaves you! Maybe one day would be okay, but not if she's already had many days off.

Startrekkeruniverse · 01/11/2023 08:28

Passepartoute · 01/11/2023 08:12

Might your friend be receptive to the notion that actually getting her head down and doing her job properly would help her dealing with her relationship issues? I've often found that, no matter how bad things were - including lose bereavements - , once I was back at work it helped me to put whatever the problem was into separate mental "box" and concentrate on work where I could function more or less normally.

100%.

The fact she’s intending to potentially get another 4 week sick note (taking two months off after a marriage breakdown is pretty OTT) plus the fact she’s taken sick days off for having a cold and toothache would make me want to get rid of her to be honest.

Katrinawaves · 01/11/2023 08:23

pam290358 · 01/11/2023 08:12

Probation doesn’t mean anything when it comes to employment law and doesn’t allow an employer to sack an employee any quicker. They still have to honour notice periods etc.

Probation is usually though a contractual construct and during the probation period the contractual notice period is much shorter than it would be once probation has been passed.

So for a senior role, notice during the probation period could be as short as one week but once probation is passed, it goes up to 3 or even 6 months

user1471538283 · 01/11/2023 08:22

She needs to hang onto the job if she can. Will she meet or speak to the employer to ask if they could extend her probation and then go back to work?

If she takes another month off sick on top of the rest without engaging with the employer they will let her go. They might anyway but at least by engaging she has done all she can to keep the job.

Rosscameasdoody · 01/11/2023 08:21

Canonlythinkofthisone · 31/10/2023 19:47

She's partly right.
It's highly unlikely that she'll be let go whilst she's signed off.

But

As PP have said, all that will happen is that it will delay the inevitable. She needs to reach out to her line manager/HR/EAP and be open and honest.

It may still result in a failed probation period but she'll have more chance of some leniency if she is honest. Most workplaces these days have people trained in mental health and almost all can refer to occupational health services. Rather than burying her head in the sand, she needs to speak up pronto.

There is nothing in law to stop the employer firing her while she is signed off, provided they observe notice periods.

Neriah · 01/11/2023 08:16

She's partly right.
It's highly unlikely that she'll be let go whilst she's signed off.

She certainly isn't partly right. She has worked there for 2 months, has had time off for a cold and toothache, and now a month at least for stress. Even the most sympathetic employer is going to be considering dismissal in those circumstances and they can DEFINITELY and easily dismiss whilst she is signed off sick.

Passepartoute · 01/11/2023 08:12

Might your friend be receptive to the notion that actually getting her head down and doing her job properly would help her dealing with her relationship issues? I've often found that, no matter how bad things were - including lose bereavements - , once I was back at work it helped me to put whatever the problem was into separate mental "box" and concentrate on work where I could function more or less normally.

pam290358 · 01/11/2023 08:12

booksandbeans · 01/11/2023 07:52

She will lose the job - probation is a quick get out of jail card for both parties if the fit is not good. I am not sure if performance management is even an option in probation - it would take an open minded employer to do this.

Probation doesn’t mean anything when it comes to employment law and doesn’t allow an employer to sack an employee any quicker. They still have to honour notice periods etc.

Rosscameasdoody · 01/11/2023 08:08

MollyMindy · 31/10/2023 19:05

I think the issue is that she has been told by someone online that if its stress related illness her employer can't fail her probation, not sure that is the case.
She is unlikely to go back in 4 weeks and is likely to be signed off again.

They absolutely can fail her probation for stress related illness, regardless of whether or not the stress is related to the job. There is also nothing to stop them terminating her employment while she is off sick, observing any notice period requirements. Probation has no meaning in employment law and is a matter between employer and employee - the conditions depend on what is stated in the employee’s contract. A probation period doesn’t mean an employer can get rid of an unsuitable employee any sooner - they still have to honour any relevant notice period.

What it comes down to is whether the length of time off sick can be considered reasonable. If she’s signed off for four weeks and is unlikely to be fit for work after that period, then I would think termination is likely. I would suggest she meet with her employer and explain what’s happening, and they may be flexible as a result. But if they’re not aware, they can’t help, so she needs to be honest.

Vinrouge4 · 01/11/2023 08:06

Sitting at home moping for a month is not going to do her any favours. Especially if she is well enough to go out to the pub. She needs to get back to work and put her energy into doing her job. Frankly the way she is now she doesn’t deserve to keep the job.

booksandbeans · 01/11/2023 07:52

She will lose the job - probation is a quick get out of jail card for both parties if the fit is not good. I am not sure if performance management is even an option in probation - it would take an open minded employer to do this.

Citrusandginger · 01/11/2023 07:52

I have sympathy for your friend, but practically, how does she think this situation can be resolved? Not by avoiding work, and building up to a stressful return and probable failure.

Previous advice to be honest about her situation is wise. If I were her manager I would be willing to offer support, but I would expect her to take responsibility for working to resolve her difficulties and to ask for support when required. I would also likely look to extend her probation.

anyolddinosaur · 01/11/2023 07:47

Yes, the only question is when. She needs to find a job she can still do while upset, maybe see if her previous post has been filled / they would have her back.

wildwestpioneer · 01/11/2023 07:43

Depends what company she works for, if she's on probation and hasn't been there very long she's not got a huge amount of security, even if she's signed off sick.

If she works for a large company with a good hr department they might be more inclined to help.

She can only sign herself off sick for a week, anything longer will require a doctors note

androidnotapple · 01/11/2023 07:30

She's going to lose her job. Sick notes with 'stress' are a massive red flag - if she does get signed off again then ideally the note needs a proper diagnosis on it.

But it would be better if she just goes back to work. Staying at home will make things worse. If I were her GP then unless I felt there was clinical depression, I'd be having a hard discussion and issuing at most one more week.

femfemlicious · 01/11/2023 07:29

MollyMindy · 31/10/2023 20:10

Thanks for all the replies, at the moment she is planning to get signed off again as she is worried that if she goes back in a few weeks she will face performance issues, but I don't know what happens if she gets another 4 week Dr note.
I don't think she is thinking too clearly, she does need the job, but hasn't engaged at all, just emailed them her Dr note.

WOW...she really needs to dig deep and go to work. Everyone goes through hard times but we still have to do what we have to do.

icelollycraving · 01/11/2023 07:16

I think she needs to accept that unless they are a really unusual company, her contract will be terminated. She is unlikely to be getting any sick pay.
Two months in and several times off sick. I’d terminate her contract.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 01/11/2023 07:15

If she is open about the issue, I would extend probation by the period of absence to give her a fair go.
However, if she has had odd days here and there plus a block of sickness I would dismiss more likely than not.

Rewis · 01/11/2023 07:12

Safe workers uk says "One of the most common reasons to fail probation is excessive sick days. Studies suggest that around 50% of workers who were fired during probation had taken too much time off."

If she wants any chance to keep her job she needs to be honest with her situation and have a an improvement plan she presents to them.

But also, if she is employable it might be good to take some time off.from working and getting herself back together. But doing it in cooperation with the employer even if she is dismissed.

GuinnessBird · 01/11/2023 07:07

Your friend is going about this completely the wrong way and I expect she'll be sacked ASAP.

RosesAndHellebores · 01/11/2023 06:53

She will lose her job.
She needs to be honest with the company and with herself.
She needs to sort out some therapy and hold tight to a pair of grips.
She probably does need a month off and a small gap can be absorbed into a CV.
Please explain to her that the contract of employment is an agreement that works both ways. The Company gives the employee money for the competent services rendered.

Aprilx · 01/11/2023 06:47

MollyMindy · 31/10/2023 20:10

Thanks for all the replies, at the moment she is planning to get signed off again as she is worried that if she goes back in a few weeks she will face performance issues, but I don't know what happens if she gets another 4 week Dr note.
I don't think she is thinking too clearly, she does need the job, but hasn't engaged at all, just emailed them her Dr note.

Your friend needs to understand that being signed off sick for two months, when only two months into a new job, is in itself a performance / capability issue.

With this track record, I absolutely would terminate her whilst she is off sick. She would be better off talking to her manager about her situation and going in and doing her best. I am not sure how being at home helps her anyway, I’d rather be keeping busy if I were going through this!

Viviennemary · 01/11/2023 06:36

A few days off here and there and she has only been there 2 months. If her attendance had been perfect up till now she would have a chance but it doesn't sound good.