Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my friend will lose her job

159 replies

MollyMindy · 31/10/2023 18:53

Posting for advice as a close friend of mine is in a bind

She started a new job 2 months ago, a promotion, all good.

4 weeks ago her husband walked out, no kids, but she is devastated. Can't function at work, been doing the bare minimum, and what she is doing I gather is pretty poor quality.

Performance is now being monitored, informally for last few weeks, more support given etc. She thinks it is going to get more formal soon, so has got herself signed off for a month with stress.

She is under the impression that although she is on probation she now can't be touched, I think she is wrong but not sure what advice if any to give her.

OP posts:
GuinnessBird · 02/11/2023 22:34

I'm sorry but your friend is an idiot and I'm beginning to understand why her husband walked out.

MollyMindy · 02/11/2023 22:30

Hi, large business, I think she is just hoping to be paid as long as possible whilst signed off

OP posts:
Treesandsheepeverywhere · 02/11/2023 22:26

This is how small businesses struggle to survive. Is she seeking help ?
I've been through similar but kept going to work which helped keep my mind off the break-up.
If she's just sitting at home expecting to be paid for nothing, it's unfair on the business.

MollyMindy · 02/11/2023 22:22

She has been advised on another forum that if she is signed off with stress she is untouchable....and won't listen to any one disagreeing . She has been told employer cannot contact her etc

OP posts:
HundredMilesAnHour · 02/11/2023 22:17

She's being very foolish. At a minimum, she needs to check her contract/employee handbook as it will most likely state how often she needs to contact them while off sick. She can't just disappear off the face of the earth and expect them to keep paying her.

MollyMindy · 02/11/2023 22:12

Thanks everyone

She said her employer has asked if she is up to a chat about cause and what they can do to help and likely return date , they sent this by email, she has not replied as she is adamant when she talks to me that she has been advised that they cannot do anything whilst she is signed off.

I don't want to upset her so now just trying to be there and not advising on job anymore , she refuses to engage with them and will get another doc note if she can in 3 weeks

OP posts:
Littlemisscatlover · 02/11/2023 21:53

As someone who has always suffered with mental health problems this is what happened to me. I had just finished my probation and I went off sick with mental health issues. I sent in a sick note for a month. The second sick note they said they hadn’t received (via post) and therefore couldn't pay me sick pay. I then had a text from my immediate boss asking when I was likely to return to work. I asked him not to put pressure on me as this would exacerbate my condition.
The next step they sent me a formal letter asking me to attend a meeting where they could discuss my return to work and if there were anything they could do to assist me in my job to allow my return to be easier.
I said I wasn’t well enough to attend the meeting and this is how it went on. Eventually they were pushing for a return date and so I handed in my resignation rather than them letting me go.
From research at the time the company did follow the correct procedure.
i think your friend is required to keep them informed and give a possible date she expects to return. But if I remember correctly they can terminate her probation at any time if they have valid reasons.

InvestingMimi · 02/11/2023 21:44

My relationship of 11 years broke down 3 months into a new job it knocked me for 6 my confidence went I doubted my ability and it was rough. I was open with my line manager he wasn’t particularly helpful but I weathered the storm with the help of therapy through the employee assistance program. It took me about a year to start feeling like my old self I still have dips but feel stronger. I think OPs mate will have to be open with her employers and hope for the best.

Escapefromhell · 02/11/2023 19:00

In the UK an employee with less than two years service can be let go for absolutely any reason that isn’t related to a protected characteristic. Unless a person has been employed for two years they are in a very precarious position.

Guttedme · 02/11/2023 18:48

I would really discourage friend from getting further/extended fit notes, it is painting 'target' on their back.

I think your friend needs to come clean 100% about the personal situation behind this - when I returned to work on an extended fit note (even with Occ Health involved) for a physical condition I was threatened on return with disciplinary action which was very frightening and if I'd been off with depression I might have found that even more worse.

Recently I have made some mistakes at work in temp job prior to resigning and actually to my surprise been told I could go back if the new job doesn't work out, I seriously think it was my attendance ethics which has got that, so mistakes and further leaning needed seems to be something which can be got past.

Some companies/organisations do write in the contract, that they reserve the right not to apply their full capability and disciplinary procedures during the probation period.

Girlswillbetwirls · 02/11/2023 07:22

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 01/11/2023 13:15

When I had a bad break up a few years ago (needed counselling and Prozac) I think I took 2-3 days of annual leave or leave at the discretion of my manager. I’d been there 4-5 years at that point and my attendance had been great but I just couldn’t stop crying, it was emotional abuse from him.

There’s no way I’d have taken off a month with stress though signed off by my doctor. I was just encouraged by friends and family to go into work. I did take a week’s annual leave after a month but this was booked, approved and I had the annual leave to take.

That’s great you did what works for you. But honestly some people could really do with a month or even more, off work due to mental health issues - and that’s OK. Often they go back to work feeling much stronger and don’t take any further extended periods off sick.

For some the alternative is they push through, then feel so burned out and low that they don’t even want to work at all. I’d say this is more of a problem.

I know people who have been signed off on long term disability due to mental health. My school friend hasn’t worked since 2018. I don’t think it’s in her interest at all to be out of the workforce for this long. I think these prolonged absences from work are far more of a problem.

I don’t think the friend is acting very wisely in this instance but that’s another matter.

Girlswillbetwirls · 02/11/2023 07:12

To be fair, I’ve heard toothache is awful. I’ve never had it but had some friends say it was one of the worst pains ever. If you just have a cold though perhaps best to just work from home if possible rather than take time off in your first few months. Not everyone wants your cold germs flying around the office.

Itsallok · 02/11/2023 04:44

Frankly, if she hadn't been so slack prior to the breakup she would be in a better position and that's assuming she was upfront about the problem

Sick leave in the first 2 months for a cold and toothache. Pathetic. People like this make it hard for others with actual need for leave.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 01/11/2023 18:55

Donkeyseason · 01/11/2023 10:03

At the risk of sounding harsh, surely if she wants/needs this job then she has to step up and make an effort. In my many decades of working I have known numerous people who have suffered marriage breakdowns, including myself, and other than a day or two off work everyone has just carried on working as before. For someone in a new job she isn't making a good impresssion, and while her employers may be supportive this can't continue indefinitely

Well no, when I had a former colleague whose normally excellent work performance slipped, our boss asked her about it and she told him she found out her H had been having an affair. He told her to take as much time off as she needed. Because he was a great boss.
But that's different from OP's friend whose employers don't know her from Eve but only know she does not turn up to work.

That's all very well - but was your friend on probabion?

Honestly, I get that these things have an impact - but imagine how many people have marriage break-ups, find out about affairs, etc. every day, and think how it would be if every one of those people took extended time off work. There would be a shortage of workers in every field - accompanied by complaints from customers/clients. Sitting around moping is absolutely the worst thing anyone can do. When I separated from my exh my boss was also having marital issues - we talked about it together, but neither of us took time off work.

Neriah · 01/11/2023 17:43

HunterHearstHelmsley · 01/11/2023 16:25

I had 2 months off sick last year due to an operation. I've worked for the same place for 12 years. When I changed my role internally I had to meet with Occupational Health. My only other period of sickness had been 2 weeks about 8 years and ago and another 2 weeks with Covid. This is a very understanding and compassionate employer. I can't imagine that even we would keep someone on who had spent most of their short time with us off sick.

I agree. I had 10 weeks off after major surgery during which time, for 8 of those weeks, I was not allowed to place one foot on the ground ever. I actually worked a bit during that time, from home - just a few hours here and there - with no pressure to do so, but because I needed to keep an overview of a new programme. When I went back I was in stage 1 of the sickness absence process. I totally got it - it wasn't a lack of support or sympathy, it was the process and the policy could not allow for emotions or variance. That was after 10 years with the employer and 1 previous sickness (1 week with swine flu). I wouldn't complain about my employer at all in terms of sickness etc - but there are lines that must be drawn, and at 2 months that line wouldn't be far in the future.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 01/11/2023 16:25

Neriah · 01/11/2023 13:49

Yeah, public sector here too and whilst I might be sympathetic to some leave to deal with a break up like this, I am afraid that two periods of sickness in the first two months followed by at least a month (and she seems to be planning more from what the OP says) - my sympathy would have run out around the second week and termination would be served by week 3. And if I didn't think that my employer definitely would. We are talking about more than 1/3rd of her employment on sick.

Two+ months of sick leave is looked at askance by our HR for employees with two decades of service, never mind two months. with us she'd now already be in the first stage of dismissal (assuming we used the whole process, which we don't within the probationary period) for absence, which begins at 3 occasions (which she has hit) within 12 months or 9+ days within 12 months. She's being delusioal if she thinks any employer is going to sit back, take this amount of absence, and continue to employer her.

I had 2 months off sick last year due to an operation. I've worked for the same place for 12 years. When I changed my role internally I had to meet with Occupational Health. My only other period of sickness had been 2 weeks about 8 years and ago and another 2 weeks with Covid. This is a very understanding and compassionate employer. I can't imagine that even we would keep someone on who had spent most of their short time with us off sick.

Neriah · 01/11/2023 13:49

Donkeyseason · 01/11/2023 09:50

My public sector employer terminate the employment of a new young colleague after she went off ill - can't remember what it was, glandular fever or something. I thought it was really shit of them, she was so excited about her new job and really keen and committed. HR said she could be off for ages but our HR were so slow and shit at recruitment that she would almost certainly have got better before they had someone new in post.

Your friend is deluding herself. If she can't do the job or does it poorly they will get rid of her. She needs to get back to work and back to speed as soon as she can.

Yeah, public sector here too and whilst I might be sympathetic to some leave to deal with a break up like this, I am afraid that two periods of sickness in the first two months followed by at least a month (and she seems to be planning more from what the OP says) - my sympathy would have run out around the second week and termination would be served by week 3. And if I didn't think that my employer definitely would. We are talking about more than 1/3rd of her employment on sick.

Two+ months of sick leave is looked at askance by our HR for employees with two decades of service, never mind two months. with us she'd now already be in the first stage of dismissal (assuming we used the whole process, which we don't within the probationary period) for absence, which begins at 3 occasions (which she has hit) within 12 months or 9+ days within 12 months. She's being delusioal if she thinks any employer is going to sit back, take this amount of absence, and continue to employer her.

lanthanum · 01/11/2023 13:20

I think the company need to know that her personal circumstances are responsible for the stress, her poor performance and being signed off. In the absence of that, they'll assume they've got a new employee who can't manage the work and has got herself signed off as a result of that.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 01/11/2023 13:15

When I had a bad break up a few years ago (needed counselling and Prozac) I think I took 2-3 days of annual leave or leave at the discretion of my manager. I’d been there 4-5 years at that point and my attendance had been great but I just couldn’t stop crying, it was emotional abuse from him.

There’s no way I’d have taken off a month with stress though signed off by my doctor. I was just encouraged by friends and family to go into work. I did take a week’s annual leave after a month but this was booked, approved and I had the annual leave to take.

Girlswillbetwirls · 01/11/2023 13:07

A former friend worked for the NHS. Believe it or not she took over a month off after her boyfriend left her /moved out their house.
She was definitely threatened with formal disciplinary action.

It wasn’t her first time taking long term sick for stress in that role, so she was on her last warning . She did eventually go back to work but I’m no longer in contact with her so I’m not sure if she took off any more time from work/ was fired.

The difference I guess was she wasn’t on probation. I can imagine if she was they’d have sacked her without continual warnings .

OP, please ask your friend to give ACAS a call. She’s digging her head in the sand, they’ll hopefully set her straight on the fact she can be fired on sick pay. And extended sick leave during probation isn’t a long term strategy. If she comes back she will need to show them how well she can do the job and it’s likely they’ll extend her probation period.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 01/11/2023 12:52

Your friend has been given (or is choosing to believe) some very poor advice. She definitely can be let go, they won't fire her while she is off (unless this is over a very long period of time) but if she has not told them what the problem is, they are probably already planning to fail her probation.

Movinghouseatlast · 01/11/2023 10:20

Has she told her boss/HR what the problem is. That is absolutely crucial to this.

I used to train managers and one of the key things is to know what's going on with your employees.

As others have said stress is not a disability and therefore not a protected characteristic unless its linked to a long term mental health issue. I think she may think it's a disability and give her some protection.

hjytrjulykuyh · 01/11/2023 10:18

She needs to get back to work asap, be honest with her employer, and she may have a tiny chance of saving her job.

It sucks, went through the same when I was in my twenties, it's not easy to show up to work and get through the day when you're heartbroken, but it's unfortunately part of life and no employer is going to say 'oh, you've had a breakup, fair enough, don't worry about the probation period, you can keep your job'. She's probably already wrecked her chances of keeping the job but if she's honest and gets back asap she might have a tiny chance.

Donkeyseason · 01/11/2023 10:03

At the risk of sounding harsh, surely if she wants/needs this job then she has to step up and make an effort. In my many decades of working I have known numerous people who have suffered marriage breakdowns, including myself, and other than a day or two off work everyone has just carried on working as before. For someone in a new job she isn't making a good impresssion, and while her employers may be supportive this can't continue indefinitely

Well no, when I had a former colleague whose normally excellent work performance slipped, our boss asked her about it and she told him she found out her H had been having an affair. He told her to take as much time off as she needed. Because he was a great boss.
But that's different from OP's friend whose employers don't know her from Eve but only know she does not turn up to work.

SamW98 · 01/11/2023 10:02

She’s been given incorrect information. The whole point of a probation period is to see if it’s a good fit for both and either party can terminate the contract, usually with a weeks notice.

She really needs a conversation with her line manager and HR very quickly as her contract can be terminated at any point in her probation, not just at the end.