Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are lonely, do you ever feel even worse when trying to get out and do things with people? Volunteering, classes, etc?

186 replies

Manycupsofteaforme · 31/10/2023 18:26

I'm probably not explaining well, but it's like everyone has their own real, main people in the form of their close family and friends, so even though it is nice and interesting to chat to people I meet out and about, it compounds the isolation in a way.

I do a small bit of volunteering in my local community and it is enjoyable but people naturally chat about their parents, kids etc and I feel myself taking a step back and mentally removing myself into a different category because they are 'normal' with rich tapestries of family and friend connections.

I have my lovely DP but my parents are dead and I can't have kids and I feel so awkward at best, and in a constant state of bereavement at worst. It will soon be Christmas, and I feel so isolated. I moved countries and really like where I live but I haven't made friends here, and over the years drifted from friends I had from uni etc.

Does anyone else find similar, that being around people who are lovely but who you are not close to actually makes you feel more lonely?

Don't get me wrong, I think the lowkey social activity I have when out and about is important because it meets a need to interact with other human beings, but I miss more meaningful friendships and connections.

Can anyone relate at all?

OP posts:
CantChatNow · 03/11/2023 16:14

This thread struck a chord with me. I have struggled on and off with loneliness since I had my first child very young. It is not that I can't make small talk, or that I don't have anyone, but more that I struggle to be close to people, and find a level of easy intimacy where I am comfortable asking to do things together. I have a lovely husband, and 3 children, but socially they do not serve all my needs and I think my husband (who has a lot of friends and is very good at maintaining old friendships) finds me needing him to be my girlie bestie draining sometimes.

I have tried everything, honestly, all the different baby and toddler groups, different hobbies, volunteering, evening classes, book groups. I have had some limited success with some but it falls apart after a time, or I just spend it all feeling like the weirdo outsider whilst everyone else already came with a friend.

I finally felt like I was making some progress about 2 years ago - I left a job I hated, made some connections in my new job, a mum friend at school sort of adopted me, together we forged a group with the wife of my husbands friend. It finally felt a bit like I had a proper adult friendship group and I was so happy. But I fell out with one of them over the summer and now I feel back to square one.

Basically it mostly feels like I am fundamentally a bit broken, that I can't make friends like a proper person, and that even when I had something close I messed it up. It is comforting (if similarly sad) to read about other people who have similar difficulties.

TheBunnyLover · 03/11/2023 15:49

Thank you @MaggieBroonofGlebeSt . I am in my forties and in a relationship that isn’t giving me what I need. I am scared that I may have to start all over again. I also was a model until my mid-thirties! I know I’m not bad looking, I also know I am a good person, I’m fun, kind, loving. It doesn’t feel that I deserve to be alone. Not saying that anyone who is none of those things does of course! But looks aside, I just feel I’ve given my relationships my all, given a lot of love and not ever got it back.

Yes, very kind reply @allaloneandlost Smile

I have a bit of a positive tale to share. Regarding making friends. When my ex left me a few years ago I was at rock bottom. Felt like I was just waiting to die. Her children went from my life too obviously, missed them so much (eldest one and me are close now).

Anyway after some time I began taking my dog to the local beer garden of an eve and having a couple of glasses of wine in the sun. I do see that the dog is a plus point here as they sort of 'make' people come and talk to you, they comment on the dog rather than the weather! I'm in my late thirties and an early fifties guy asks if he can have a look at my dog, sits with me and we have a really nice chat for a couple of hours. Then he offers to buy me a drink and I said 'Sorry no because I can't buy you one back!'I only ever took £10 out with me in my pocket. He bought me one anyway as said he had enjoyed my company. I'm gay and he was married with children, nothing untoward.

Fast forward to now, some 8 years later and we're firm friends. It probably took a couple of years for us to get to that stage. We have some excellent chats, we text throughout the week, share jokes, share daft things that have happened, also confide in one another about our difficulties (his marriage is not a happy one unfortunately) if one of us goes in the pub they always text the other a 'no obligation but I'm going to (pub) if you fancy coming'.
He walks me home, often comes in for a drink if we're not up early and we listen to music and have a chat-I trust him with my dark thoughts and he does me with his. We're not 'in one another pockets' sorts of friends, we don't put any pressure on one another but we're definitely more than 'someone you talk to down the pub'. He's my rock and he often says I keep him sane-real mutual respect and openness.

The only downside for me is, if we meet up and have a good time, I know he's going home to his wife and child (elders are at university). Which is a bit bittersweet at times, while I'll then go to bed alone. But I am a lot happier to have him in my life than if I didn't, I made a good friend albeit purely by accident! In my late thirties.

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 15:29

Strawberriesandpears · 03/11/2023 14:25

@WrongSwanson That's encouraging to hear. Glad it has helped you. Would you mind sharing the types of volunteering and activities you have been involved with, please?

I'm a trustee of a local charity and I also used to go to dance classes before I got ill. Maybe I would have made friends eventually but I hadn't before I got ill, but dancing still made me smile

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 15:28

Yumyi · 03/11/2023 14:43

Yes I think if you join something solely with the purpose of making friends then it is sole destroying. And you find yourself thinking after a few meetings that it’s not really working yet should I persevere as it’s taking up my time and money. So the best thing to do it find something you actually want to do or have to do. I used to enjoy running but I can’t do this any more. I wish I could as it’s a really good way of exercising and chatting too. If you enjoy running then you are also doing something you love so you don’t feel you are so much wasting your time partaking the activity and it doesn’t matter so much if you make a friend. I just need to find a similar activity now for people like myself who can’t run !

Yes I agree. And I think that's the nuance that's missing from advice when people say they are lonely

Yumyi · 03/11/2023 14:43

*soul destroying

Yumyi · 03/11/2023 14:43

Yes I think if you join something solely with the purpose of making friends then it is sole destroying. And you find yourself thinking after a few meetings that it’s not really working yet should I persevere as it’s taking up my time and money. So the best thing to do it find something you actually want to do or have to do. I used to enjoy running but I can’t do this any more. I wish I could as it’s a really good way of exercising and chatting too. If you enjoy running then you are also doing something you love so you don’t feel you are so much wasting your time partaking the activity and it doesn’t matter so much if you make a friend. I just need to find a similar activity now for people like myself who can’t run !

Strawberriesandpears · 03/11/2023 14:39

WhatNoRaisins · 03/11/2023 14:30

I suspect a better approach for a lonely person is to just do the activities that bring them some joy and that can include volunteering and "social" things like a group or lessons as well as more solitary activities.

Just telling someone to get out there and join things and I'm sure you will make friends isn't helpful.

@WhatNoRaisins I agree with that. I also suspect that the more 'focused' the group or activity is on a subject / topic, the more chance you are to find people who you 'click' with. For example, an exercise group is quite general. Volunteering with your local heritage railway / joining a bat spotting group is a lot more 'niche' and specific.

(Those are just random examples to illustrate a point!).

WhatNoRaisins · 03/11/2023 14:30

I suspect a better approach for a lonely person is to just do the activities that bring them some joy and that can include volunteering and "social" things like a group or lessons as well as more solitary activities.

Just telling someone to get out there and join things and I'm sure you will make friends isn't helpful.

Strawberriesandpears · 03/11/2023 14:25

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 14:14

I don't know, I think volunteering/doing activities has still improved my life. I wouldnt discourage people from it

@WrongSwanson That's encouraging to hear. Glad it has helped you. Would you mind sharing the types of volunteering and activities you have been involved with, please?

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 14:14

Strawberriesandpears · 03/11/2023 14:03

I am so sorry to everyone feeling so lonely. This thread is so sad and depressing. I don't have many people in my life and thought that if I made the effort to get myself out there and find some good friends, I could be OK, but I am now doubtful. So worried about my future. I live with constant anxiety about it and find it hard to concentrate on anything else.

I don't know, I think volunteering/doing activities has still improved my life. I wouldnt discourage people from it

WhatNoRaisins · 03/11/2023 14:07

I suspect a lot of society doesn't want to admit that this level of loneliness can happen. I've read a lot of articles in my time, admittedly not so much now things are better, and they almost always seem to conclud that the solution is to join groups and volunteer.

It's like no one wants to admit that it's often simply not a solution for lack of friendship unless you get very lucky. I'd have loved to have seen more advice on how to try and live with the loneliness rather than solutions that only offered false hope.

Strawberriesandpears · 03/11/2023 14:03

I am so sorry to everyone feeling so lonely. This thread is so sad and depressing. I don't have many people in my life and thought that if I made the effort to get myself out there and find some good friends, I could be OK, but I am now doubtful. So worried about my future. I live with constant anxiety about it and find it hard to concentrate on anything else.

IceAndLemonPlease · 03/11/2023 13:43

My friend feels like this a lot as she’s 38, no kids and single. Even when she goes to groups to meet people she often feels lonelier as their lives are so different to hers. I know how tough she finds it and it makes me feel sad

WhatNoRaisins · 03/11/2023 13:19

Chalkdowns · 03/11/2023 12:28

I do hear what you are saying but if you keep meeting the same people (repeated exposure to them through activities and volunteering) you will build up histories with them. And then you’ll begin to talk about your shared life rather than their life.. but you need to keep on keeping on. Persevere!

I think people can be very thoughtless with their chat about their children / grandchildren to others though.

I personally don't think I believe that anymore. Especially not with monthly meetings or something where different people seem to come each week or where the people you meet don't even seem interested in new friends. How long should you persevere at something that doesn't seem to be going anywhere, a year? 5 years? 10 years?

Right now I've got my group but if we drift or I have to relocate I'm not sure I even want to try this sort of thing again.

blackheartsgirl · 03/11/2023 13:15

I relate.

I have no partner, no siblings in this country, no aunts uncles cousins and my dad is dead and my mum very poorly.

yes I have friends but they all have their partners, parents, etc, my dc are older so now do their own thing.

I feel worse when I’m with people, it’s so lonely.

BansheeofInisherin · 03/11/2023 12:43

Thanks @Motti and @WrongSwanson . I do make it a point to never talk much about my DC, because honestly it's often boring to other people. There are many other things to talk about.
I should say that my book club offers me the most connection these days. A really good way to bypass small talk and go straight to talking about meaningful things.

Chalkdowns · 03/11/2023 12:28

I do hear what you are saying but if you keep meeting the same people (repeated exposure to them through activities and volunteering) you will build up histories with them. And then you’ll begin to talk about your shared life rather than their life.. but you need to keep on keeping on. Persevere!

I think people can be very thoughtless with their chat about their children / grandchildren to others though.

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 12:25

Gosh don't apologise @BansheeofInisherin

You've articulated what I feel (and I only moved from one end of country to the other!).

This thread has been helping me so much, have been busy with work but just reading it made me feel less "odd" and more like it's a societal issue.

I have great friends at work but I feel deeply uncomfortable about being reliant on those, but because I have prioritised juggling a career and caring for children there hasn't been much time to make connections other ways.

As others say, my monthly trustee meeting and weekly exercise class doesn't seem to turn into anything deeper, and perhaps that is just because it's not enough regular quality time to allow connections to evolve.

And I do have individual friends but they all have local family and /or "mum groups" that I never really formed because my son was quite ill as a baby/toddler, and mainly they work long hours too so we rarely meet more than a couple of times a year

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 12:25

Gosh don't apologise @BansheeofInisherin

You've articulated what I feel (and I only moved from one end of country to the other!).

This thread has been helping me so much, have been busy with work but just reading it made me feel less "odd" and more like it's a societal issue.

I have great friends at work but I feel deeply uncomfortable about being reliant on those, but because I have prioritised juggling a career and caring for children there hasn't been much time to make connections other ways.

As others say, my monthly trustee meeting and weekly exercise class doesn't seem to turn into anything deeper, and perhaps that is just because it's not enough regular quality time to allow connections to evolve.

And I do have individual friends but they all have local family and /or "mum groups" that I never really formed because my son was quite ill as a baby/toddler, and mainly they work long hours too so we rarely meet more than a couple of times a year

Motti · 03/11/2023 12:20

Please don’t feel like you shouldn’t post because others have it worse. No matter our situation we can all feel lonely hence the saying lonely in a crowd. I think it’s part of the human experience to be honest- we are all alone at the end of the day even though we can find connections with others. Some just feel it more than others.

BansheeofInisherin · 03/11/2023 12:06

Actually, I am sorry for posting. Many of you have it far worse. I need to count my blessings and will try to do that. The menopause is not helping me either.

I hope everyone on this thread finds a solution.

theleafandnotthetree · 03/11/2023 11:52

It's funny how different seasons can be harder than others - it's the summer barbecue one that I find really rough for some reason. You can actually hear and smell people's festivities and gatherings in summer in a way you don't so much in winter. I could count on one hand the amount of barbecues I've been invited to in my life and yes, I have hosted a few but as a single mum, I find them a very tricky one to manage solo.

TheBunnyLover · 03/11/2023 11:50

Yes you didn't kill the thread SmileI'm staying with a friend this weekend, which will distract me from not seeing my partner for another three weeks but it is hard. I don't suit this life. Staying with a friend won't fulfil my need for affection and connection it will just distract me temporarily, which is what it feels like every other 'activity' I do to connect with people does. I would love a 'normal' life, a family and someone to get into bed with each night.

All2Well · 03/11/2023 11:42

You didn't kill the thread @BansheeofInisherin !

I think a lot of us will agree with you, the festivities are hard and the darker colder nights and days don't help much with the feelings of isolation.

I have to distract myself a lot over the Christmas/New Year period as I get very lonely and low. I've come to accept I will cry and need a hug that won't come at some point over Christmas and try as be as kind to myself as I can. Though it gets boring keeping myself company!

BansheeofInisherin · 03/11/2023 11:15

Sorry, I killed the thread!