Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you saw this parent on a train?

191 replies

rocknrollaa · 31/10/2023 18:12

On the train today, I saw a mother with 3 kids was really losing her temper with them. The kids were just being kids - talking quite loudly, getting out of their seats sometimes - nothing bad, just a bit excitable.

But mum was really telling them off - for the whole journey of about half an hour, all you could hear from her were loud angry commands to sit down, shut up, threats that they are not going to go trick or treating, etc. She didn't say a single thing to them that wasn't a command or telling them off, and her voice was loud and angry.

At one point the eldest, probably about 8/9, got very upset with her mum who told her she couldn't go trick or treating.

The child was crying, she said ' I was just starting to feel happy again and then you told me off again'. Mum replied loudly 'Stop being naughty then. Why the bloody hell are you only happy when you're bad?! I SWEAR DOWN you're not going trick or treating tonight', then the kid started crying.

We didn't intervene but we felt really sorry for these kids. It was serious shouting and they really weren't misbehaving much at all.

It got me thinking what I would do if I actually saw her hit one of the kids (because I felt like she was on the verge of it, but didn't).

Would you intervene? If so how?

YABU - No I wouldn't intervene - it's her business how she parents her kids.
YANBU - Yes I would intervene (please comment what you'd do)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Fionaville · 01/11/2023 00:25

I wouldn't intervene for a smack on the leg (even though I strongly disagree with smacking) Anything more than that, I'd be over there giving her a piece of my mind. I was once in an hour long fair ride queue with my kids, behind a dad who was telling his kids off the entire time. So, I told him to give it a rest, because his voice was annoying everyone and that his kids were just being kids!

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 00:10

Although I think it may not always be the case that the mother is struggling. Some people are just antisocial, quick to anger, and deal with things via confrontation/aggression. Go to a few rough pubs in a dodgy part of town and you'll defo meet some women that'd headbutt you rather than talk if you pissed them off after they'd had a few.

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 00:03

Challengemonica · 31/10/2023 23:43

LadythatLaunches - I'm interested to see those figures. Given women undertake the vast majority of childcare, they shouldn't surprise us. Perhaps if figures such as these were more widely known, we might address some of the issues they raise. Monstering women allows members of society to feel good about themselves while taking no responsibility. Actually addressing the fundamental issues takes effort. Being a mother is a difficult and lonely job, when the pressure gets too much, it's the children that suffer because the mum can't just walk away. Remember children's centres? They were supposed to address some of these fundamental problems, all gone now as far as I know 😔

I've posted the figures above. I agree with you. It's not about blame, it's about understanding the reality and dealing with it. Sadly it's almost always male violence we hear about on here and never this stuff.

Obv men commit the majority of general violence (mostly against other men) but it's been done to death so many times already. Until searching for some links requested by ChiefWiggum earlier tonight I wasn't even aware that women kill the most children (only that they abuse more).

Maddy70 · 31/10/2023 23:57

rocknrollaa · 31/10/2023 18:23

What kind of help do you think she might need that I could offer her?

I dint know. Thats why I would have asked ? Maybe offer to sit one of the kids by you. Or simply just chat to the mum sj she he's a bit of a break. She doesn't look like she's coping

Challengemonica · 31/10/2023 23:51

AuntieDear - some charities have a history of behaving very poorly with regard to safeguarding in their own organisations let alone anywhere else. The NSPCC were implicated in failures in the Victoria Climbie case. The public tend to put these charities on a pedestal they don't necessarily deserve. I don't have the answers but blind trust in charities and public services is the way individuals absolve themselves of responsibility. They can't do the job of community (but they will take your money and they will collate figures on the number of reports they get about stressed mums on trains and will present them to government and the public as justification for increased resources) meanwhile children go on being abused and mumsnetters go on feeling smug that they've grassed up a stressed mum. What a world!

AbbeyGailsParty · 31/10/2023 23:49

Most of me thinks I’d have distracted the kids with a whisper game, a sitting version of sleeping lions, join in ISpy, read them/ tell them a story etc..
But I’m not this mum who might have been taking the kids home after seeing a sick relative , she might have mega money worries, health worries, housing worries, lost her job, can’t get a job., not had a decent nights sleep in a week. Any one of a million things where she just needed them to sit still and quiet until they got off the train. Shit days happen.

porridgeisbae · 31/10/2023 23:48

I saw what looked like a gran verbally threaten some girls with being hit for getting food round their mouths. Another time I saw a family and can't remember the details but the dad was being very controlling and aggressive. It seemed like that was their life. Think he said that their picnic was going in the bin. I wish I'd asked the mum if they were ok; I mean, she would've had to say yes in front of him probably. Maybe I could've taken her to one side.

VeridicalVagabond · 31/10/2023 23:45

Poor kids.

I doubt I'd have done anything or said anything, to be honest. Lots of people are heroes on their keyboards a million miles away from the situation, few people actually do anything in the moment. I'd worry I'd make it worse for them somehow.

I might try and catch the eye of one of the nippers and give them a smile, try and project all the "it won't always be like this" I can into their little brain. Coward's way out probably, but as the child of a relentlessly shouty and critical and nit-picky mum, I'd just want to tell them without words that it's not forever. It gets easier as you get older and she gets better at it. Hang in there.

Poor kids.

Challengemonica · 31/10/2023 23:43

LadythatLaunches - I'm interested to see those figures. Given women undertake the vast majority of childcare, they shouldn't surprise us. Perhaps if figures such as these were more widely known, we might address some of the issues they raise. Monstering women allows members of society to feel good about themselves while taking no responsibility. Actually addressing the fundamental issues takes effort. Being a mother is a difficult and lonely job, when the pressure gets too much, it's the children that suffer because the mum can't just walk away. Remember children's centres? They were supposed to address some of these fundamental problems, all gone now as far as I know 😔

Auntiedear · 31/10/2023 23:40

Challengemonica · 31/10/2023 22:15

DdraigGoch not sure you meant me. I didn't say anything about pride. There are charities out there who persistently encourage grassing, tale telling, reporting - I'm not sure the terminology is important here - the point is, it creates an atmosphere of mistrust. My 'appalling attitude' is neighbours supporting each other - a cup of tea and a friendly chat goes a long way. As we've seen in many cases recently, this sort of reporting has done nothing to help children who are being abused, and people grassing up harassed mums on trains take precious resources away from those who need it. Those working in social services will tell you the bar for a 'good enough' parent is pretty low.

As per your post, the point of much of this reporting is a sense of superiority which is often misplaced - but you'd know that if you cared to offer a helping hand. If you look a bit deeper, this is what many find distasteful.

The charities are encouraging safe-guarding children. If you equate that with 'grassing' or 'tale telling' then there is something seriously wrong with your priorities.

Children need adults to advocate and speak up for them so yes, it is 100% better to be safe rather than sorry.

Screamingabdabz · 31/10/2023 23:34

Challengemonica · 31/10/2023 23:29

Screamingabdabz - and you are extremely rude. Absolutely foul manners on a public forum, and yes, abusive language. Take a good look at yourself. I can't engage with that sort of rhetoric but I think it's clear how well formed your opinions are.

🤣

Ladyj84 · 31/10/2023 23:32

You can not judge the scene you saw. You have no idea what that mum has or hasn't been thru the rest of the day or week. Sorry we all get to the end of our tether occasionally also

Challengemonica · 31/10/2023 23:29

Screamingabdabz - and you are extremely rude. Absolutely foul manners on a public forum, and yes, abusive language. Take a good look at yourself. I can't engage with that sort of rhetoric but I think it's clear how well formed your opinions are.

LadyThatLaunches · 31/10/2023 23:20

The gov stats from 2001-2006 and 2009 both show the mother as being over twice as likely to kill or abuse a child. I didn't know the discrepancy was that big tbf.

It does show how selective people are with what data they prioritise as I've literally never heard this discussed once on mumsnet despite it being a significant statistic. In future, I'll defo have to give serious thought to reporting if I see a woman who gives me the impression she could become violent towards her kids or if I have a bad feeling.

LadyThatLaunches · 31/10/2023 23:10

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 31/10/2023 22:23

Are they? Have you got any stats to back that up coz google isn't giving me anything about perpetrators just victims.

See attached (as pic) table from Statista, showing that in 2021 more females than males perpetrated abuse - Statista is one of the most trusted sources of stats and subscribed to by many businesses and orgs worldwide. Source is below.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/418470/number-of-perpetrators-in-child-abuse-cases-in-the-us-by-sex/

The gov stats also show that the mother was main perpetrator of abuse in studies conducted between 2001-2005, in 2009, and in 2021 - tables attached.

Also, the data from article below. This was just first page of Google so not read it all in detail. I've just read several times previously that men commit the most sexual abuse but women the most overall abuse.

TV shows and movies likewise hardly ever tell stories of abusive mothers or mothers who kill their children, leaving the viewing public with the misimpression that fathers are a far greater danger to their children than mothers. TV shows and movies are also far more likely to portray girls as victims of maltreatment than boys.

However data from the U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Services (DHHS) tells a completely opposite story regarding who abuses children. The DHHS publishes an annual report called "Child Maltreatment", and each year's report contains a table detailing the parental status of the perpetrator(s).

Shown below is an analysis of data drawn from the "Child abuse and neglect" and the "Child fatality" tables from each of the DHHS' "Child Maltreatment" reports between 2001 and 2006.

The DHHS calculates the percentages of perpetrators in various categories such as Mother, Father, Foster Parent, Daycare Staff, Friend or Neighbor, etc. The percentages are often used to argue whether, on average, it is fathers or mothers that pose a greater risk of harm to their children. But when trying to determine which parent, on average poses the greater danger, categories like Foster Parent, Daycare Staff, Friend or Neighbor, etc. are entirely irrelevant. The calculations below factor out those categories to produce a more accurate picture. The resulting calculations show the percentage of child abuse and deaths caused by one parent acting either alone or in concert with someone other than the child's other parent.

The DHHS data shows that of children abused by one parent between 2001 and 2006, 70.6% were abused by their mothers, whereas only 29.4% were abused by their fathers.

And of children who died at the hands of one parent between 2001 and 2006, 70.8% were killed by their mothers, whereas only 29.2% were killed by their fathers.

Furthermore, contrary to media portrayals that leave the viewer with the impression that only girls are ever harmed, boys constituted fully 60% of child fatalities. (Table 4-3, p. 71, Child Maltreatment 2006, http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/pubs/cm06/cm06.pdf, reports that 675 boys died in 2006 as compared to 454 girls).

https://www.breakingthescience.org/SimplifiedDataFromDHHS.php#data

If you saw this parent on a train?
If you saw this parent on a train?
If you saw this parent on a train?
Screamingabdabz · 31/10/2023 23:03

Challengemonica · 31/10/2023 22:57

Screamingabdabz - I happen to think it's shameful that no-one steps in to offer help to a woman who's struggling. One woman and three kids - everyone else looks on tutting - utterly shameful. Individuals - usually women - are expected to carry the shame for a society that has failed them. It's an old story.

Society’s ‘shame’ didn’t make her treat her kids like that - she feels no shame and did it all by herself in a very public place. I’m a feminist and very sympathetic to the plight of women in this world but you’re talking shit. 🙄

Challengemonica · 31/10/2023 22:57

Screamingabdabz - I happen to think it's shameful that no-one steps in to offer help to a woman who's struggling. One woman and three kids - everyone else looks on tutting - utterly shameful. Individuals - usually women - are expected to carry the shame for a society that has failed them. It's an old story.

Teder · 31/10/2023 22:54

greenhydrangea · 31/10/2023 22:26

She chose to come on Mumsnet to chastise another mother who can't defend herself. You can bet I'm judging.

She came on MN as she was unsure whether or not she should have intervened - that is, said something to the woman about her abusive behaviour towards her children. Nothing was said about alerting authorities.

The ones who can't defend themselves in this situation are the young children.

I'm judging too - the 80% plus posters who seem to think child abuse is okay.

This one-off incident is unlikely to be viewed as child abuse. It might be a sign of child abuse. It certainly is not healthy, good parenting. Those poor kids.

I have to say, if one genuinely believes they have witnessed child abuse, they should go out of their way to find some method to report it. (I’m not referring to the OP but generally.)

Teder · 31/10/2023 22:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The majority of child abusers are not women.

Child abuse is in categories so which one is it that women are the majority?

Notalldogs23 · 31/10/2023 22:50

She sounds like a controlling bully, I'm amazed how many posters are saying she probably had a bad day, her behaviour was unacceptable, but I don't know what I woukd have done as she didn't actually hit them.

Poor kids.

Screamingabdabz · 31/10/2023 22:45

Challengemonica · 31/10/2023 22:23

Screamingabdabz - you weren't there, not was I so we really don't know. But interesting you say she should be 'ashamed' that's a very strong word. A very long history of women who should be ashamed and shaming women of course is what this often comes down to. What if we didn't shame? What if we offered a hand of friendship? I'd better shut up, me and my appalling attitude again. Best go off and be ashamed of myself, quietly.

PS if the woman is committing a crime or endangering the children, OP should call the police. She chose to come on Mumsnet to chastise another mother who can't defend herself. You can bet I'm judging.

I was quite a shouty impatient mum with my kids. I should’ve been ‘ashamed’ (and I am) for all the times I was less than patient. My kids were good kids and it was not their fault that I was frazzled and fucked off.

Why should women be let off for talking to their kids like shit and manhandling them roughly like this train arsehole did? It is shameful and there is no excuse.

MidnightOnceMore · 31/10/2023 22:36

I'm judging too - the 80% plus posters who seem to think child abuse is okay.

There's a lot of rather aggressive replies on this thread, I'm surprised by the number of people supporting the behaviour described.

But mum was really telling them off - for the whole journey of about half an hour, all you could hear from her were loud angry commands to sit down, shut up, threats that they are not going to go trick or treating, etc. She didn't say a single thing to them that wasn't a command or telling them off, and her voice was loud and angry. This is not ok.

pumpkinpie25 · 31/10/2023 22:31

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 31/10/2023 22:25

You know what? I get really ticked off with these faux-I-was-so-upset-with-this-mother post.

You didn't say anything, you didn't care enough about either the mother or the children to do so in the moment. If you did, maybe the mum would have burst into tears. I know I've been short with my own kids when I'm barely holding it together - and like a sixth sense that's when their behaviour is at its worst. Maybe she would have jumped up and shouted at you, let's be real here, you didn't trust your judgement enough that this chavvy mum wouldn't clock you one, you weren't prepared to risk insult or injury to 'save' those children. Even though you were with your husband.

Of course, maybe she is abusive. There's always that possibility. So now you've done nothing to challenge an abusive mother either. I'm really not sure what you want from here other than a pat on the back for identifying an upset mum and her upset children.

Absolutely this.

Basically what you want is recognition for noticing how badly someone else was parenting. By default a humble brag about how your parenting is so much better.

Well done you.

crew2022 · 31/10/2023 22:30

I'd think frazzled mum at the end of her tether with possibly relationship problems or financial worries in the background. I've been there and a supportive comment would go along way.

Singleandproud · 31/10/2023 22:28

I have a neighbour that shouts and tells her children off all the time, often in a very aggressive way, screaming and shouting and swearing at them it's emotional neglect at best and has the potential to get worse on both accounts as the children get older as they retaliate. When it's extreme I report to NSPCC and the children's school on one occasion to the police, occasionally people with clipboards turn up. I suspect she has MH and send needs and her children attend a specialist school so I know it's not easy but she is the adult and MH and SEND is no excuse for being abusive.

She needs help, support and some respite and unfortunately the only way for her to get that is to let other agency's know.

If I saw a stranger behaving as you did there is very little you can do unless they are wearing something identifiable