Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you saw this parent on a train?

191 replies

rocknrollaa · 31/10/2023 18:12

On the train today, I saw a mother with 3 kids was really losing her temper with them. The kids were just being kids - talking quite loudly, getting out of their seats sometimes - nothing bad, just a bit excitable.

But mum was really telling them off - for the whole journey of about half an hour, all you could hear from her were loud angry commands to sit down, shut up, threats that they are not going to go trick or treating, etc. She didn't say a single thing to them that wasn't a command or telling them off, and her voice was loud and angry.

At one point the eldest, probably about 8/9, got very upset with her mum who told her she couldn't go trick or treating.

The child was crying, she said ' I was just starting to feel happy again and then you told me off again'. Mum replied loudly 'Stop being naughty then. Why the bloody hell are you only happy when you're bad?! I SWEAR DOWN you're not going trick or treating tonight', then the kid started crying.

We didn't intervene but we felt really sorry for these kids. It was serious shouting and they really weren't misbehaving much at all.

It got me thinking what I would do if I actually saw her hit one of the kids (because I felt like she was on the verge of it, but didn't).

Would you intervene? If so how?

YABU - No I wouldn't intervene - it's her business how she parents her kids.
YANBU - Yes I would intervene (please comment what you'd do)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Littlelucas · 01/11/2023 20:09

The gov stats from 2001-2006 and 2009 both show the mother as being over twice as likely to kill

Id like to see the proof for this - I seriously doubt this is correct.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 01/11/2023 19:55

LadyThatLaunches · 31/10/2023 23:20

The gov stats from 2001-2006 and 2009 both show the mother as being over twice as likely to kill or abuse a child. I didn't know the discrepancy was that big tbf.

It does show how selective people are with what data they prioritise as I've literally never heard this discussed once on mumsnet despite it being a significant statistic. In future, I'll defo have to give serious thought to reporting if I see a woman who gives me the impression she could become violent towards her kids or if I have a bad feeling.

Edited

Interesting.

I'd be interested to see this overlaid with with family unit types, as I suspect the results would be massively influenced by the fact that women are overwhelmingly the majority of single parent families. The fact it's not there strikes me as disingenuous manipulation of the stats if I'm honest.

CatMadam · 01/11/2023 19:20

Babochan88 · 01/11/2023 17:24

They do at times. Not all kids but some and nothing crazy either

Edited

Hitting a child is always ‘crazy.’ Luckily, it’s seen as the abuse it is in Scotland and is, in fact, illegal.

Chichz · 01/11/2023 19:09

This is really making me picture a family from the school I used to work in... Knowing what I know about them, I'd report it but you don't know the situation at all! It's very hard.

(Please just say you weren't in NW England 🫣)

Abbimae · 01/11/2023 18:34

Kid sounds like a little brat? I just started to feel happy again? What a spoiled thing

Whyohwhywyoming · 01/11/2023 18:32

BogRollBOGOF · 31/10/2023 19:19

I often wonder what people think of me hissing at my two in public. DS1 is very sensory (ND), gets overwhelmed and his idea of a coping strategy is constant niggling at DS2. Added to that, his spatial awareness isn't great so I'm coping with directing him around, and him bouncing off me because he doesn't walk in a straight line and sending my stress levels up. So I probably look like I'm overreacting to very trivial things, but it may well have been grinding for a while and I'm trying to stop the trivial from escalating into full-scale sibling bickering or howling meltdowns.
It's much easier to be a nice, fun parent at home when he's unwound and he's back in his comfort zone. For many families, out and about is not their best angle, and they're not necessarily worse behind closed doors.

Unrelated threats of cancelling trick or treating are not ideal strategies, but no one's perfect and one snap shot is not enough to judge whether it's an isolated stressful moment, or more problematic, damaging relationship. DS2 can often make dramatic, hyperbolic statements; it doesn't mean it's the truth if he declares things like he's dying, or it's the worst day ever.

If it's a parent that I see regularly being overbearing and damagingly critical at my youth groups, that's a different matter and there are safeguarding pathways to go through. TBH even with knowing who and referring on to trained specialists, it's still a pretty tricky concern for investigation and follow-up.

I agree - my children are teens now but when little they always found being out and about really difficult especially anything that was new and different. I was always a much better parent at home. Also I was a single parent so they went everywhere I went. Everywhere. And that was difficult in itself!

funinthesun19 · 01/11/2023 18:26

The kids were just being kids - talking quite loudly, getting out of their seats sometimes - nothing bad, just a bit excitable.

Parents can’t do anything right! You could easily have been one of those passengers who complain about hearing children talking and getting out of their seats. Maybe she didn’t want any arseholes kicking off with her because it would have been really upsetting, and this was the only way she felt she could prevent that from happening?

Babochan88 · 01/11/2023 18:18

It’s legal millions do and will continue to do so

ManateeFair · 01/11/2023 17:58

Babochan88 · 01/11/2023 17:24

They do at times. Not all kids but some and nothing crazy either

Edited

Don't hit kids, ffs

ManateeFair · 01/11/2023 17:57

I think people saying 'Poor woman, I'd have offered her some help' are being incredibly naive and don't really understand the type of situation the OP is describing.

If a parent is struggling with a four-year-old whining for sweets while their toddler is announcing they've just wet themselves and a baby is screaming its head off, and the parent has reached the end of their tether and yelled at them all to shut the hell up, that would be a situation when it might be appropriate to offer the mother some help or sympathy. But that would be a very different situation. What the OP is describing is an hour of sustained anger and shouting over trivial things at children who are behaving perfectly normally and are old enough to have a conversation with.

I guarantee you that if the OP had 'offered her some help' she would have told the OP to fuck off and then shouted at the kids some more because they'd embarrassed her.

OP, I know exactly the kind of thing you mean and I've witnessed it myself years ago with a mother and father who were waiting for the same bus as me. They had two kids, a boy and a girl maybe around the six to eight age range, something like that. The kids were not being badly behaved, just a bit fidgety (which had no impact on anyone else, they weren't in anyone's way, as it was a bus stop; they were causing no hassle by standing up rather than sitting down). The mother just started shouting at them and barking orders over every, tiny, inconsequential thing while the father said absolutely nothing. The two things I particularly remember were that the little boy putting his hand out to touch a sticker someone had put on the bus stop pole and the mother snatching his hand away and snarling 'DON'T TOUCH THAT, IT'S DIRTY, YOU STUPID LITTLE BOY' right into his face and also at one point the little girl said 'How long until the bus comes?' and the boy said 'A hundred million years' and the girl laughed and said 'No, a thousand million billion' and they were both giggling and trying to think of massive numbers, and the mother suddenly shouted 'For god's sake, SHUT UP about the bloody bus times, I'm sick of hearing your stupid voices'.

At the time I lived in a pretty rough inner city area (and also one that was multicultural and with a lot of different norms for disciplining kids) but I found the whole thing chilling and the whole vibe really bothered me. At one point an elderly lady who was also waiting caught my eye and I could tell she was worried about it too but I don't think either of knew what on earth we could actually do - shouting at a kid isn't a police matter and if people are random strangers it's not like you can report them to social services - what would you say, 'Hello I saw someone being awful to their children but I don't know who they were or where they live, I just them getting on the 96 bus'? And there was no way any comment from me to the mother at the time was going to make things better for those kids, quite the contrary.

Littlelucas · 01/11/2023 17:29

I get it OP - I hate seeing kids getting really told off/shouted at by aggressive adults, especially when they're doing nothing wrong. She sounds a bit unhinged.

I always think if they're like that in public what are they like in private?

I very rarely shout at my dc's and would never shout in public.

Babochan88 · 01/11/2023 17:24

CatMadam · 31/10/2023 20:35

@Babochan88 Kids never ‘need a smack’, wtf?

They do at times. Not all kids but some and nothing crazy either

rocknrollaa · 01/11/2023 16:48

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 31/10/2023 21:45

There it is! I knew there was a reason OP had capitalised “swear down” and this is it.

Let’s be honest OP, you saw a working class mum, decided her parenting style wasn’t as flowery or stereotypically “middle class” as MN tells you perfect parenting is, and came here to round up the troops with you.

I stopped reading the thread after @LadyThatLaunches’ insightful comment above, but I’m glad to see this was the first (and hopefully only) one that took the bait.

I capitalised 'swear down' because she shouted it.

I am from a working class background myself.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 01/11/2023 15:39

crew2022 · 31/10/2023 22:30

I'd think frazzled mum at the end of her tether with possibly relationship problems or financial worries in the background. I've been there and a supportive comment would go along way.

What would you say though? What would your supportive comment be?

PrincessesRUs · 01/11/2023 13:23

Op - I think you're getting a hard time here. Even when I'm cross with my children I still make it clear that they are loved and I would never be mean to them. I tell them off but NEVER for a solid hour. I was in the supermarket at the weekend and some mum yelled at her kid in such a horrid tone I actually felt tears in my eyes thinking about how that poor kid felt. Some people are shit parents. I just hope those kids get lots of love from somewhere.

stayflufft · 01/11/2023 13:19

Montaguez · 01/11/2023 01:47

Think about what you would do if you saw an adult hit another adult. You’d call the police wouldn’t you

Not always, would depend on the situation.

Really? Care to give an example?

toddlermom9 · 01/11/2023 09:31

I'd mind my own bloody business, that's what I'd do.

This poor mom is probably at the end of her tether. You're only seeing the train journey. How do you know how the kids have acted all day? You have been a tiny snapshot of the day and judging based on that.

ohme · 01/11/2023 07:29

This is how my neighbours speak to their children every single day. I have never heard them have a conversation with the kids, only ever bark orders at them. SS are not interested, this is life for many children across the UK. So long as they are clothed, fed and have a bed there is no consideration given to the emotional neglect these children suffer.

Bellsandthistle · 01/11/2023 07:23

Cadenza12 · 31/10/2023 18:44

Once saw a mum slap a child around the face in a pub. Followed them home, reported to SS. Never heard back.

Why would you expect to ‘hear back’?

Isittimeformynapyet · 01/11/2023 07:18

SingleMum11 · 01/11/2023 00:48

Not the same as OP, but one of them was violently smacking a 3yr old (?) boy I get it’s scary to intervene but I’d have phoned the police for that. Or if she wasn’t as scary, told her to stop and told a security or someone.

This was in the street, before mobile phones, but yes, I often wonder if I should have done something. I have more confidence these days too.

Montaguez · 01/11/2023 01:47

Think about what you would do if you saw an adult hit another adult. You’d call the police wouldn’t you

Not always, would depend on the situation.

stayflufft · 01/11/2023 00:58

Think about what you would do if you saw an adult hit another adult. You’d call the police wouldn’t you? Amazes me that people wouldn’t automatically know to contact police if they saw an adult hitting a child. It’s assault.

However - she didn’t hit anyone, so what’s the point in speculating?

You have no idea what is going on for this woman. She could be under huge stress and her children have just pushed her buttons all day.

SingleMum11 · 01/11/2023 00:48

Not the same as OP, but one of them was violently smacking a 3yr old (?) boy I get it’s scary to intervene but I’d have phoned the police for that. Or if she wasn’t as scary, told her to stop and told a security or someone.

SingleMum11 · 01/11/2023 00:46

This is quite difficult - I think I would have tried to engage a little, even if it was just about the weather or ‘it’s so busy today’ or something stupid. Just to bring the mother out of it - it’s hard to keep being angry with someone engages. It can break the relentlessness.

But I do see sometimes just some horrible heartbreaking things, like gangs of kids wandering around with younger ones, not of the age you could call SS but you just know that this isn’t great for them. Or seeing like I did yesterday a kid just not looking great with a Dad who totally ignored him. It’s just a snapshot, but sometimes a really sad one.

Having said that I have a child with SN and often people have probably assumed all sorts, he screams sometimes so loud it’s like an emergency! And shouts and cries, tantrums go on for an hour sometimes. Sometimes in public. It might be because I said ‘let’s go home now’… but it might really look differently to a passer by!

Isittimeformynapyet · 01/11/2023 00:40

AbbeyGailsParty · 31/10/2023 23:49

Most of me thinks I’d have distracted the kids with a whisper game, a sitting version of sleeping lions, join in ISpy, read them/ tell them a story etc..
But I’m not this mum who might have been taking the kids home after seeing a sick relative , she might have mega money worries, health worries, housing worries, lost her job, can’t get a job., not had a decent nights sleep in a week. Any one of a million things where she just needed them to sit still and quiet until they got off the train. Shit days happen.

Or she might be an abusive bully.

Would you really need to rule out a million excuses before considering that possibility.

I've seen many, many stressed out Mum's being harsh with their children, and given them a sympathetic smile. But I've also witnessed three women being awful in a very different way that really concerned me.
All were strangers in public places and nothing I could do.

Not the same as OP, but one of them was violently smacking a 3yr old (?) boy while holding him off the ground by his arm with her other hand. I just stood staring, wondering what to do, hoping other passersby might help. She had a 5yr old (?) daughter who stood dispassionately by - she saw me looking aghast at her mother and said, "what the fuck are you staring at?"

This was 30 odd years ago in Shepherds Bush. The woman looked like she'd have punched my lights out if I'd intervened.