Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Halloween is just another massive marketing ploy we've all fallen for.

239 replies

Blwean · 31/10/2023 17:00

Reading this article today https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/oct/30/halloween-boo-basket-useless-clutter?CMP=fb_gu&utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Facebook&fbclid=IwAR1HhG1J-mqf1zU7ss8lxMCkNwsMJVTKudjgEt4auGVFrS8qwKuIUUUBmQc#Echobox=1698686636

Apparently Halloween spending is set to surpass £1bn in the UK this year for the first time and shops have been making a concerted effort since 00s to introduce more products and use social media influencers to push them.

Then there's pumpkin patches. Basically fields where people place pumpkins as there's none actually growing there and people pay silly prices to go and take pictures for Instagram. A friend of mine paid £50 to take her and DCs to one of these places then she's shelled out £20 on each of them for costumes and over £30 on decorations. It's her business what she spends on but just last month she was complaining about cost of living.

I'm all for celebrating Halloween but it's just about spending more and more money each year. The Instagramisation of it has ruined it and everyone just blindly spends loads on costumes they'll use once and other meaningless tat. Its the shops cashing in and we're all just like sheep who follow the marketing and influencers so we spend more

I was all for Halloween mania in the UK. Then I heard about ‘boo baskets’ | Amelia Tait

These hampers full of useless clutter have nothing to do with the true spirit of the season, says freelance writer Amelia Tait

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/oct/30/halloween-boo-basket-useless-clutter?CMP=fb_gu&fbclid=IwAR1HhG1J-mqf1zU7ss8lxMCkNwsMJVTKudjgEt4auGVFrS8qwKuIUUUBmQc#Echobox=1698686636

OP posts:
Lessstressedhemum · 31/10/2023 19:27

Samhain is thousands of years old. Guiding (disguising yourself to scare off malevolent spirits) is an ancient and venerable tradition. It's not American.

Ilovecleaning · 31/10/2023 19:23

Of course it is. What else did you think it was?

CraftyGin · 31/10/2023 19:21

I grew up in Scotland. For us, Hallowe'en was something you did at Brownies - apple dunking, treacle scones, etc, with a re-enactment of Tam O'Shanter. It didn't exist outside of this in our community.

I know some kids would come around to earn some money, but they would have to do some kind of turn to earn their 10p. There was definitely no tricking. My mother didn't allow us to go out on Hallowe'en (except to Brownies). There was a bit a class divide, I think.

The main celebration at this time was Guy Fawkes, which I always though Guising to refer to. Kids would come around the doors with a Guy in a pram, and would get their 10p. Again, this is not something we were allowed to do.

museumum · 31/10/2023 19:13

It’s Celtic not American. I’ve had some form of Halloween celebration every year that I lived in Scotland since I was tiny in the 70s.
kids here still do a party piece at the door (usually a joke) and although most kids call it trick or treat now, adults still call it guising.
It’s a bit of fun and a nice way to distract ourselves from the fact it was dark by 5 today.

IHeartGeneHunt · 31/10/2023 19:08

I spent £1.50 on a costume from Vinted that she'll wear as a onesie in the house until she grows out of it, and we went round the estate and got a few sweets. That's it, apart from a £2 Asda pumpkin that's going to be curry tomorrow. I don't do decorations. We've had fun tonight. We knocked on doors that have decorations and pumpkins and they'd got sweets ready, so it's hardly begging.

VanityDiesHard · 31/10/2023 19:07

What a miserable, moany thread. People are entitled to a little fun. I do agree that the 'boo boxes' are a bit OTT, but the rest is just fun! I adore the period of time between the equniox and the winter solstice, it is the most magical time of the year. I also love Christmas. I get very tired of all the grinches, if you don't like it don't celebrate it, but leave the rest of us in peace!

GrimGrinningGhosts · 31/10/2023 19:06

Can picture them Celts sat around their bonfire on Samhain discussing how they could make a bob or two off the back of it cant you? 😂

Meanwhile, some people exisit just to suck the joy out of everything. Don't like it? Don't participate. It's not difficult.

Celia24 · 31/10/2023 19:05

YANBU

For those of us with a bit of resourcefulness and imagination costumes and fun dont have to cost a fortune.

notahappybunny7 · 31/10/2023 19:01

Badbadbunny · 31/10/2023 17:06

Yep, just commercialism to persuade the gullible to buy loads of plastic tat from China and loads of sweets/chocolates.

I’ll take being “gullible” over being a joyless, miserable twat anytime.

Polis · 31/10/2023 18:56

Another who hasn’t fallen for it. I have spent nothing at all on anything Halloween related, nor have I done anything Halloween related.

I haven’t got a problem with anyone else enjoying it, although the orange plastic tat should be banned from sale.

ohtowinthelottery · 31/10/2023 18:50

When I was a child (late 60's to 70's) we 'celebrated' Halloween with a washing up bowl containing water and apples or with apples hung on string by their stalks. The object of the game was to take a bite out of the apples with your hands behind your back - in the comfort of your own home. No one knocked on doors to get sweets.
My youngest is now 27 and I took him trick or treating but it certainly wasn't as popular as it is now. We've probably had around 50 children knock here tonight and they certainly don't all live on our estate - some of them have come in cars.

bellamountain · 31/10/2023 18:40

It's been great up my road this evening, all kids have been lovely and polite. Some brilliant costumes, my little one has loved handing out the sweets.

We are getting excited for bonfire night this weekend and the lead up to Christmas.

QuestionableMouse · 31/10/2023 18:33

There's plenty of farms where the pumpkins are grown on the land. We visited this one recently and they definitely hadn't be "plonked in a field".

https://www.spilmans.co.uk/pyo-pumpkins/

PUMPKIN FEST 2023 - Spilmans

https://www.spilmans.co.uk/pyo-pumpkins

DwightDFlysenhower · 31/10/2023 18:33

Bigcoatweather · 31/10/2023 18:25

You do know that you can reuse all the decorations, yes?
It’s been a delight here - happy, giggling children and meeting lots of local parents.

I've just hung up some rubber bats that my DM bought for a Hallowe'en party when I was a baby! 30+ years of use and they still look fine (although the original elastic to hang them up with perished long ago, we just replaced it with cotton). They're only used for one night after all!

BackAgainstWall · 31/10/2023 18:28

Yes, fu*k the kids - don’t let them have any fun.

Meanie.

JamSandle · 31/10/2023 18:27

Traditionally it isn't. You can mark the traditional holiday or not.

Bigcoatweather · 31/10/2023 18:25

You do know that you can reuse all the decorations, yes?
It’s been a delight here - happy, giggling children and meeting lots of local parents.

RubyRubyRubyRubay · 31/10/2023 18:22

Bobbing for apples, the sheet/torch/wet sponge game and scary sardines cost nothing.

Just turn the light down in the house and play spooky games. You don't have to buy any plastic tat at all. We get the same stuff out every year - a homemade broomstick (twigs obvs), homemade decs out of card and old material, bones and skulls we've found on the beach, a 'dead toe' I made out of wax and some of my hair.

The old homemade stuff is loads more scary. We've even got a brain in a jar that horrifies the kids (just a bit of cheap mince moulded into a ball)

Stroopwaffels · 31/10/2023 18:21

There is too much plastic tat but I hope that it's reused the following year and costumes recycled to younger kids

If that's the case, who is buying it new each year? There wouldn't be aisles of it in shops if it didn't sell. And things like those godawful fake webs cannot be reused.

SkankingWombat · 31/10/2023 18:19

I can't get too worked up about it. People spend their money on all kinds of non-essentials I would consider a waste, and I'm sure many would disagree with a good number of my purchases too. The important points for me are that it isn't forcing someone into debt, it is bringing them joy, and it isn't going to end up in landfill shortly after.

We spend around £20-25 per year on Hallowe'en. I usually buy costumes second hand in a size up for £5-ish, so DD1 can get 2 years out of it before passing it down to her sister, but this year spent £11 on a pair of skeleton PJs (still sized up!) instead as she needed some more and can use them for their intended purpose after tonight. I spent approx £7 on sweets this year, and usually spend £5-10 after Hallowe'en on discounted decorations to add to the collection for coming years. Some years DH might buy a pumpkin at the supermarket to carve, but this year he grew them. All in all, it definitely brings more than £25 of joy, so I'm happy to spend the money.
Easter is a similar cost FWIW: £8-10 egg x 2 DCs plus about £5 on tiny eggs to hide in the garden. If DH has been good (😬), I might get him a smaller token egg for under £5.

BoohooWoohoo · 31/10/2023 18:19

I have no problem with people like farmers profiting from Halloween. There is too much plastic tat but I hope that it's reused the following year and costumes recycled to younger kids. I think ToT developed into a nice community activity- I'm at the stage of doling out sweets rather than going out with young trick or treaters and I've been lucky to only had polite kids knock.

jays · 31/10/2023 18:09

My granny was buying me a Halloween cake (had little trinkets wrapped up inside it like a button/bell) and we had doockin for apples and pretending to fly on the kitchen brush (I’m laughing remembering it now) and that was 46/47 years ago. It’s just ended up more commercial because there’s more disposable tat to buy now but it’s always been a big thing for me since I was a kid, I love it!

IncompleteSenten · 31/10/2023 18:03

People spend money which is good for the economy and it's a bit of fun when it's started to get cold, miserable and dark.

Stroopwaffels · 31/10/2023 18:03

The pumpkin patches don't offend me. It's a good way of farmers to make extra cash, pumpkins are biodegradable, you can eat them, the pictures on Insta are harmless.

What DOES offend me is the acres of plastic tat in the supermarkets and places like Home Bargains, and the idiots who put that fake cobweb on bushes despite warnings about how bad it is for birds. And they don't care because it's about "making memories with the famalam".

Elphame · 31/10/2023 18:01

EtiennePalmiere · 31/10/2023 17:50

I'd like to try but don't want to risk losing a finger 😥

Use one of those potato peelers that don't swivel. You can dig out chunks with the pointy end and then use the blade to shave out the inside. Much safer and easier.