Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas Dilemma- WWYD?

784 replies

christmasstollen · 31/10/2023 16:39

I am one of 4 children, all in our 60s. For the last 10 years my brother and I had arranged alternating hosting my widowed mother for Christmas (other 2 'children' stay on their own and have refused to host for the last 40 years). Except that my brother always makes an excuse and so we (DH, DCs and I) have hosted my mum every year.

After the last couple of Christmases with no thanks afterwards I put my foot down and told my brother we aren't having mum this Christmas its his turn. He agreed but has just phoned to say he's going abroad with his girlfriend so obviously can't host. I didn't want to be manipulated into having her so I said that was fine and mum would have to be on her own. Phoned mum who knew the new plans, said it was fine and she would have lunch with exDIL (Brother's ExWife) and just have a plate of vegetables (was very woe is me). Brother is the Golden Child so no blame on him wanting to go somewhere sunny, all the unsaid blame on me for not offering to host that instant.

I'm in a real quandary of what to do. On the one hand brother is getting what he wants and I'm the 'bad child' for letting mum be on her own, on the other hand he always gets away with it and the last few years I've not received any thanks for the immense amount of laundry/cooking/cleaning over 4 days.

Complicating things is that mum up until this year has been in exceptional health and is very spritely for a 90 year old. This year she's had some serious health scares and family are whispering 'what if it's her last Christmas?'

An option is to pay for her to stay in a local hotel and do pick ups/drop offs as well as pay for a taxi to bring her and take her back either side of Christmas but this would all cost £500ish which neither of us have. Any opinions welcome.

For voting:
YABU- Host your mum for what could be her last Christmas
YANBU- Don't host her as this is your brother's responsibility

OP posts:
MarryingMrDarcy · 31/10/2023 18:31

porridgeisbae · 31/10/2023 18:23

Being with non-bio family isn't usually seen as the same if the person has living family members.

Edited

I disagree. In any case, you said ‘alone’ not ‘spending Christmas with a less desirable/biologically close relative’ - which is untrue.

SingleMum11 · 31/10/2023 18:31

If you didn’t have any siblings, what would you do?

Do that…

PortalooSunset · 31/10/2023 18:27

Have you/she spoken with the other siblings? Maybe one of them could step up this year?

Blanketpolicy · 31/10/2023 18:26

You just need to decide how much you like your mum and if making a point to your brother (who doesn't care anyway) is more important to you than your mum being lonely at Christmas.

I would invite my mum and never invite my brother again!

AndromacheAstyanax · 31/10/2023 18:26

I’m very sorry to read this, OP. You’ve been badly let down by your siblings, both the brother who has made promises and then reneged on them, and the others who haven’t offered at all. My view, for what its worth, is that you should host your mum this time, that you should make it very clear to your siblings that it must be their turn next. You probably aren’t thinking as far as Christmas 2024 yet, but if there is another occasion when you tend to get together as a family (maybe Easter or birthdays) book yourself a holiday at that time and let the others know well in advance.

I have an elderly parent and have no siblings living so it is non-negotiable that Parent comes to me every Christmas. I enjoy it, especially as I know there won’t be many years left, but I can’t deny it’s hard work in some ways. We do find it easier with other guests too - adult children, etc, who can help share the hosting. I don’t know if that is a possibility for you.

Of course, if she is very close to her ExDiL (is this lady a vegetarian? Does she not serve meat to guests?) and you think she’d be very happy with that arrangement, maybe go with that. But it doesn’t sound from what you said that she would be happy with that. As she is the more vulnerable one, I would say that the rule of thumb is that mum comes first.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 31/10/2023 18:25

porridgeisbae · 31/10/2023 18:23

Being with non-bio family isn't usually seen as the same if the person has living family members.

Edited

Depends whether you like your friends better than your relatives, I suppose.

TheBeef · 31/10/2023 18:24

YANBU

If you dB is going away, why is it ok to push responsibility back on you? Why doesn't he talk to your siblings and ask them to step up?

Whe was his holiday booked? Why didn't he think of your dmum?

NumberTheory · 31/10/2023 18:24

Do you like Christmas with your mum? Is she nice to have as a guest? Do you all enjoy Christmas while she’s there? If you’ve been hosting for the last 10 years (notwithstanding the “agreement” to alternate with your DB) aren’t most of your traditions and wrapped up in your mum being there?

If it’s just that it’s hard work hosting over Christmas, could you scale back a bit? Having one guest for a few days doesn’t normally have to be an immense amount of extra work and effort. Keep the fun bits, scale back the hard bits and enjoy being with her for the years you have left.

But, reading between the lines, it sounds like you do a lot for your mum, including the hosting at Christmas, your mum doesn’t seem to acknowledge that. She possibly makes the household difficult while she stays? And is ungrateful? And you’re pissed off that your DB puts no effort in but your mum thinks the sun shines out of his backside?

If that’s the case I don’t think there’s any point hosting her unless you’re going to feel guilty and awful about it if she does die this year. These things are supposed to be fun for everyone. Someone who is ungrateful and treats you unfairly doesn’t have to be indulged because they might die this year. You can prioritise the rest of your family, including yourself, and ensure you have a Christmas you enjoy. Your mum can find companionship in people she is prepared to be nice to.

If it’s at neither extreme, I would tend to veer towards hosting, but scaled right back. And maybe announce plans next August to be away next Christmas (even if you don’t actually go anywhere).

rookiemere · 31/10/2023 18:24

Why is it 4 days ?
Can you strip it back - even if it means a fair bit of driving- to Christmas day only?

redskyanight · 31/10/2023 18:23

The crucial point here is how your relationship is. You describe your brother as Golden child and 2 other siblings won't have your mum over. And, unlike all the posters on this thread who presumably have loving mothers, you are not immediately thinking "of course I can't leave mum on her own".

I suspect that it's not the physical effort but the emotional effort of having her over that's the issue. Do you only have a relationship out of obligation? If that's the case, then I'd leave her to ex-DIL. If you have a close relationship then I'd perhaps have her over for a shorter time.

porridgeisbae · 31/10/2023 18:23

Being with non-bio family isn't usually seen as the same if the person has living family members.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 31/10/2023 18:22

I am an only child and my parents split up.

Because I am married and have in-laws I could not always spend Christmas with my mum. Sometimes I spent it with my dad, sometimes I spent it with the in-laws. Fortunately my dad could go to my aunt and my DH is one of 4 children so the parents in law weren't on their own. But my mum was, although I think she did get invited to Christmas dinner by friends a couple of times.

So can people stop going on as if being on your own for Christmas is the worst thing that can ever happen. Sometimes/often it is unavoidable.

And the OP's mum was invited by the ex-DIL so it's not like she would be on her own. The guilt tripping on here is ridiculous.

Mirabai · 31/10/2023 18:22

I’d have my mum, don’t really care what DB does. But 4 days is a lot, why not 2 or 3 - how long is her journey?

Gnomegnomegnome · 31/10/2023 18:22

Unless you are going to drip feed that your mum is vile and abusive them yabu

Someoneonlyyouknow · 31/10/2023 18:21

Another idea - bro takes mum on holiday with him and gf!! OP gives foreign currency as Christmas present (it's always difficult to buy for older people who have everything they want)

SammyScrounge · 31/10/2023 18:21

It is only natural to feel resentment at the unfairness of this broken Christmas agreement. You are definitely much put upon. It's hardly your mother's fault though. And as others have pointed out, your mother is a great age and getting frailer.
Go on, retrieve your Xmas spirit and have your mother round to yours. You will be glad you did. I will be really outrageous and suggest you bring the ex daughter-in-law as well. I take it she is on her own if she is prepared to spend Christmas with the old lady rather than leave her by herself. That was nice of her.
Don't let your brother's selfishness sour your own good will. You will have good memories of the family together. He will have a faded sun tan and be the outsider.

Nicole1111 · 31/10/2023 18:21

Host her and send a bill to your brother for anything involved in doing so

MarryingMrDarcy · 31/10/2023 18:20

porridgeisbae · 31/10/2023 18:19

Eh? The only option is the hive mind of MN guilt tripping this poor woman into hosting her Mum at Christmas?

It's generally considered bad form to leave a relative on their own on Xmas day. A lot of us put up with that annoying uncle etc for that reason.

Her mum isn’t going to be alone though, is she? Read the original post.

SomethingIsThere · 31/10/2023 18:20

I am you, but 5 years away from this.
I hate Christmas, love my mum. But every year.

One year we would like not to have to drive, to do what we want.

One year that will come, but we would like our siblings ( mine ) to host her, just to give us a break.

Highlights12 · 31/10/2023 18:20

I'd host her. If you don't & it was her last Christmas you will probably feel awful afterwards. Can understand how annoying it is though

porridgeisbae · 31/10/2023 18:19

Eh? The only option is the hive mind of MN guilt tripping this poor woman into hosting her Mum at Christmas?

It's generally considered bad form to leave a relative on their own on Xmas day. A lot of us put up with that annoying uncle etc for that reason.

MarryingMrDarcy · 31/10/2023 18:19

Also PP’s need to properly read OP’s post - her Mum won’t be alone at Christmas if OP doesn’t host her, she’s said she can spend it with another relative

DiscoBeat · 31/10/2023 18:18

I wouldn't turn my back on her just to prove a point. I do understand - I do all the running with my own mum, but I just want her to feel loved wanted so I do it. She will be feeling hurt about the other 3 I expect, so don't add to it.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 31/10/2023 18:17

As you are a household of at least 4, surely one 90 year old is not a lot of extra cooking, cleaning or laundry. Is your mother really a difficult/ungrateful guest? Maybe that's because she's an awful person, maybe that's because only one of her four children ever invites her (grudgingly) for Christmas. Will you regret not inviting her? Your siblings won't care.

Your DSiL sounds lovely (even if vegetarian)

MarryingMrDarcy · 31/10/2023 18:14

SecondUsername4me · 31/10/2023 17:48

Well, yes. Because ideally we could all collectively force her siblings to take their fair turn

But we can't. So realistically, what other option is there?

Eh? The only option is the hive mind of MN guilt tripping this poor woman into hosting her Mum at Christmas? How did you come to that conclusion?

Swipe left for the next trending thread