Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas Dilemma- WWYD?

784 replies

christmasstollen · 31/10/2023 16:39

I am one of 4 children, all in our 60s. For the last 10 years my brother and I had arranged alternating hosting my widowed mother for Christmas (other 2 'children' stay on their own and have refused to host for the last 40 years). Except that my brother always makes an excuse and so we (DH, DCs and I) have hosted my mum every year.

After the last couple of Christmases with no thanks afterwards I put my foot down and told my brother we aren't having mum this Christmas its his turn. He agreed but has just phoned to say he's going abroad with his girlfriend so obviously can't host. I didn't want to be manipulated into having her so I said that was fine and mum would have to be on her own. Phoned mum who knew the new plans, said it was fine and she would have lunch with exDIL (Brother's ExWife) and just have a plate of vegetables (was very woe is me). Brother is the Golden Child so no blame on him wanting to go somewhere sunny, all the unsaid blame on me for not offering to host that instant.

I'm in a real quandary of what to do. On the one hand brother is getting what he wants and I'm the 'bad child' for letting mum be on her own, on the other hand he always gets away with it and the last few years I've not received any thanks for the immense amount of laundry/cooking/cleaning over 4 days.

Complicating things is that mum up until this year has been in exceptional health and is very spritely for a 90 year old. This year she's had some serious health scares and family are whispering 'what if it's her last Christmas?'

An option is to pay for her to stay in a local hotel and do pick ups/drop offs as well as pay for a taxi to bring her and take her back either side of Christmas but this would all cost £500ish which neither of us have. Any opinions welcome.

For voting:
YABU- Host your mum for what could be her last Christmas
YANBU- Don't host her as this is your brother's responsibility

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DeeLusional · 27/12/2023 20:10

Martyrs are never appreciated.

Mumof2NDers · 22/12/2023 18:51

Rainraingoaway21 · 31/10/2023 17:53

How sad that nobody seems to want their 90 year old mother for Christmas and would rather leave her on her own. Could you truly enjoy xmas day knowing she was on her own?

How much of a burden is she? 1 more mouth to feed isn't much.

And as for putting her in a hotel 😱she is 90!!!

On the surface of it, it does seem extremely sad but there might be very good reason. I feel, like a lot of other posters there may be a backstory here. My FIL was a vile narcissistic bully who bullied my kids and tried to split me and DH up because I stood up to him. When his partner died we got the woe is me I’m going to be alone at Christmas. He had 6 kids and not one of them bothered with him. Not a fucking chance was he getting in my house! No one wanted him for very good reason.

Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 22/12/2023 18:33

Mummyratbag · 31/10/2023 16:46

What would I do? I'd host my Mum, but I don't know what your relationship is like and what is involved in hosting her. I couldn't let someone I love be on their own at Christmas just because my siblings were rubbish.

This🖕.I would love to have my mum for one last Christmas. I had a lovely mum though.
If she isn't/wasn't a great mother, then you do what you feel is right. If she is/was great, then you move heaven and earth to spend some time with her, regardless of what siblings are doing!!

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 09/11/2023 08:20

redskyanight · 08/11/2023 07:22

The ignorance about abuse and the responses of victims to it on this thread is really shocking.

If a friend confided in you that her husband was emotionally abusive and she was thinking of leaving him, would your response be that she'd been married to him for 20 years and what makes this year any different when he's always been like that?

Absolutely this, also that a 'no, not this year' is an acceptable answer.

Rottweilermummy · 09/11/2023 08:10

The ops reasons seem to change people's opinions The person who said she's known about her mum and done every other year, so why should this one be different doesn't get fact that op has been lumbered into doing xmas again this year, when brother supposed to be doing it and has let her down yet again and the fact no one appreciates op doing Xmas and her mum siding with brother op appears to have reached the end of her tether and I don't blame her. But if this is possible last Xmas with mum least OP will be there for mum if she entertains her. OP if you can shorten the time mum with you save expense and hassle, maybe she could stay 1 night. All the best 🍀

redskyanight · 08/11/2023 07:22

Ramalangadingdong · 07/11/2023 23:29

The op has hosted her mum for several years. If she was willing to do that what suddenly made this year different? Given
that she has always known these things about her mother. It doesn’t make any sense To suddenly decide that a 90 year old woman should be cancelled. Weird.

But you know what is a waste of time? For me to argue with you at this time of night so I will not be responding to any more of your outrage. Save it for the OP’s mum.

The ignorance about abuse and the responses of victims to it on this thread is really shocking.

If a friend confided in you that her husband was emotionally abusive and she was thinking of leaving him, would your response be that she'd been married to him for 20 years and what makes this year any different when he's always been like that?

Ramalangadingdong · 07/11/2023 23:29

namechangnancy · 07/11/2023 23:24

@Ramalangadingdong I feel as though I was tricked into giving my initial answer

Are you joking. It's not like there isn't a requirement from MNHQ for a op to put every single what maybe considered relevant detail into their first post. Some people haven't changed their answer and have read all ops updates which well (I can't relate but fair)

However I find it really quite off that instead of going oh ok well that info changes my mind. My bad. You feel someone's tricked you because you weren't able to read ops updates which weren't many.Which is literally the structure of MN forum.

And if you can't grasp those very basics it doesn't matter how busy you are it's a bit of a waste of everyones time don't you think.

Because op didn't gain anything out of 100 people calling her really nasty names.

The op has hosted her mum for several years. If she was willing to do that what suddenly made this year different? Given
that she has always known these things about her mother. It doesn’t make any sense To suddenly decide that a 90 year old woman should be cancelled. Weird.

But you know what is a waste of time? For me to argue with you at this time of night so I will not be responding to any more of your outrage. Save it for the OP’s mum.

namechangnancy · 07/11/2023 23:24

@Ramalangadingdong I feel as though I was tricked into giving my initial answer

Are you joking. It's not like there isn't a requirement from MNHQ for a op to put every single what maybe considered relevant detail into their first post. Some people haven't changed their answer and have read all ops updates which well (I can't relate but fair)

However I find it really quite off that instead of going oh ok well that info changes my mind. My bad. You feel someone's tricked you because you weren't able to read ops updates which weren't many.Which is literally the structure of MN forum.

And if you can't grasp those very basics it doesn't matter how busy you are it's a bit of a waste of everyones time don't you think.

Because op didn't gain anything out of 100 people calling her really nasty names.

Burnoutwhat · 07/11/2023 23:22

MellyMel0865 · 06/11/2023 17:35

Hi
I'm afraid it's down to the children to look after their aging parents.
All I can say is your lucky to still have at least one of your parents.
There are lots of people out there, including me, who don't have there parents anymore.
So your going to have to make your preparations, and invite your Mum for dinner. Enjoy. xx

Have you read all pp's updates?

Ramalangadingdong · 07/11/2023 23:17

crumblingschools · 05/11/2023 23:58

@ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming but then what happens if someone asks a question or asks for clarification? Not much of a discussion if the OP can only post something in their opening post

But that was such an important piece of information. I feel as though I was tricked into giving my initial answer and then reprimanded when she revealed the rest of the story which I could not possibly know. One poster even implied that I should have been able to guess from the op but as much as I come on MN a lot I do actually have a life.

MellyMel0865 · 06/11/2023 17:35

Hi
I'm afraid it's down to the children to look after their aging parents.
All I can say is your lucky to still have at least one of your parents.
There are lots of people out there, including me, who don't have there parents anymore.
So your going to have to make your preparations, and invite your Mum for dinner. Enjoy. xx

Luddite26 · 06/11/2023 13:28

Dogs that is not parents ^.

Luddite26 · 06/11/2023 13:27

Well obviously! They can't make their own lunch and don't gaslight.

redskyanight · 06/11/2023 09:49

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 06/11/2023 09:06

We shouldn't have to filter just the OP's posts - honestly, how hard is it to give the whole story in the first post!! If they can't be bothered to give the whole story why should I bother to filter their posts? They ask for opinions, the onus is on them to give the whole story at the start. It's not rocket science.

I don't think it's rocket science either to assume if a person doesn't want to host their elderly mother for Christmas it's either

  1. Because they are monumentally selfish
  2. There is a very good reason why not

In the lack of any information either way in the OP, both are equally likely. So why have so many posters assumed (1) must be the case? A person posting on MN can't pre-judge what assumptions their readers might make.

Skyscrapers921 · 06/11/2023 09:23

I wouldn't leave a dog on its own.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 06/11/2023 09:06

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 06/11/2023 07:54

Yes @ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming - because filtering to just the op's posts is SOOO hard that it's far too much to ask for a busy MNer... 🙄

We shouldn't have to filter just the OP's posts - honestly, how hard is it to give the whole story in the first post!! If they can't be bothered to give the whole story why should I bother to filter their posts? They ask for opinions, the onus is on them to give the whole story at the start. It's not rocket science.

Rottweilermummy · 06/11/2023 08:02

I can't say either way whether u are or not unreasonable , as I get how fed up you are with your brother. Is it your brother or mum who doesn't thankyou? If your not getting thanks from your mum I'd be pretty fed up having to host too, but she's your mum.
I lost mine last week and moved to be with her in her last few years so if its possibly her last Christmas, just have her you'll regret it if you don't, even if your brother or other siblings don't care. You were there for her, that's what matters, You'll have plenty years when she's gone to do what you want

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 06/11/2023 07:54

Yes @ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming - because filtering to just the op's posts is SOOO hard that it's far too much to ask for a busy MNer... 🙄

Otter1971 · 06/11/2023 07:17

My mum will be alone this Xmas but I tried. She lives 250 miles from me and my brother. She is still making me feel guilty. My brother is golden boy but goes to partners parents each year who are local to us. Somehow thats OK despite me suggesting alternating or something. Me and my young adult offspring are all working Xmas day and that's generally how at least alternate years go (care and catering roles). I can't host Xmas and work 13 hours as a nurse. But somehow I should. This sounds so similar to OP being made guilty too. OP you have done your share and it's someone else's turn. What about the other 2 siblings?

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 06/11/2023 06:52

crumblingschools · 05/11/2023 23:58

@ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming but then what happens if someone asks a question or asks for clarification? Not much of a discussion if the OP can only post something in their opening post

People can always ask questions, but OPs who only give the basic info in their first posts are frankly a pain. I never said they can only post in their opening post, but they should give the whole story, not give a sanitised version and then bring in the reasons for their decisions later. Too many posters are doing it, and as I said, it makes me think that sometimes they are making the story up as they go along. How on earth do they expect others to give the advice they've asked for when they don't bother telling the whole story?

Bobtheamazinggingerdog · 06/11/2023 06:49

Mandy90d · 06/11/2023 05:55

How would you feel if your children were having the same argument because none of them wanted to have you over for Christmas. I have my mother and mother in law every Christmas, there's no discussion, all other siblings go aboard or do their own thing, or join us. I'd rather be around family.

763 posts over many days and you don't think to check the OP's posts to see if you've missed something before weighing in with your pointless take?

Learn how to mumsnet people. If a thread is busy and long then there is guaranteed more to it than the OP. Read their posts at the very least before posting!

Mandy90d · 06/11/2023 05:55

How would you feel if your children were having the same argument because none of them wanted to have you over for Christmas. I have my mother and mother in law every Christmas, there's no discussion, all other siblings go aboard or do their own thing, or join us. I'd rather be around family.

crumblingschools · 05/11/2023 23:58

@ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming but then what happens if someone asks a question or asks for clarification? Not much of a discussion if the OP can only post something in their opening post

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 05/11/2023 23:48

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 05/11/2023 23:29

Why don't you actually read all of the op's posts before replying with this inane nonsense?

If people write a post and only give a segment of the information in their opening one then they deserve the answers they get. The constant drip feeding is beyond irritating, and to be honest I sometimes wonder if they embroider the truth in their subsequent posts to get the answers they want.

We shouldn't have to read all of an OP's posts to get the information. If they ask for an opinion they need to give the facts at the start.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 05/11/2023 23:29

DD1963 · 05/11/2023 23:16

Four children and not one of you want her for Christmas, this is beyond sad. Please trust me it could well be her last Christmas and how would you feel if it was? However you think you might feel the reality will be a million times worse and when she is sadly no longer around you will miss her.

Why don't you actually read all of the op's posts before replying with this inane nonsense?

Swipe left for the next trending thread