Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School asking me to buy a £30 costume

221 replies

Tedn · 31/10/2023 12:33

I’ll start with, this is a state school, in south east London, relatively nice area but like most London schools, some kids live in houses worth well over a million others in council houses. The school prides its self both on being inclusive and environmentally conscious.

DD is 4 and in reception, yesterday I got an email, giving all the children their nativity roles (yes I know very early but school say it’s to give parents a chance to buy the costumes) and with it links to the costume you should buy.
DD has been given the role of Angel Gabriel, the costume linked £30!!! The other angels costumes are only £15. DDs costume is the most expensive by £10 (the animals and the star are £20), and from a different place.
The teacher noted in the email that the PTA has some funds available to help those who may not be able to buy them and if that’s the case you should reach out to the class PTA rep on WhatsApp. However it’s not that I can’t afford it, it’s more just what’s the point on a £30 costume for one day? Why so much more expensive than the others?
The way the school does nativity is that the reception children have no real lines, instead all the Y1 and Y2 children narrate and the reception kids just act it out on stage. So it’s worse to me that I’d be paying £30 for a costume to wear for two afternoons to not even hear DD saying anything.
I spoke to the teacher briefly at drop off today and she said that they picked that costume as it stands out from the other angels and as she is Angel Gabriel they thought it would look better and make it easier to follow. She reminded me that I can speak to the PTA rep if I need any help buying it.
Now I’m also thinking that it’s just wasteful? What will I do with it when the nativity is over?
I will probably just buy the damned costume to save any headaches but AIBU to think this is a ridiculous, tone deaf (considering COL) and wasteful request from the school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
redskyanight · 31/10/2023 13:05

Can you find out who was Angel Gabriel last year and see if they have their costume still? actually surprised there isn't already a parents' costume swapping market in place-

SiousieSoo · 31/10/2023 13:04

GunboatDiplomacy · 31/10/2023 12:48

Not inevitably surely.

If I'd shelled out for a camel costume for an eight year old and the PTA rep said "we'd be very grateful if you donated it to the school for next year" then I'd happily hand it over to get rid of it and stop it going to waste.

You might but what about people with siblings, cousins in the school or those who want to re-sell. This is far from fool proof.

Goldbar · 31/10/2023 13:04

Our school has a set of nativity costumes. You send them in plain underclothes of a specified colour.

I'd find out who played the Angel Gabriel last year and offer the parents a tenner for the costume if they still have it.

More generally, email the head about how unacceptably wasteful this is.

RunningUpThatBuilding · 31/10/2023 13:02

SiousieSoo · 31/10/2023 12:41

But they would be reliant on all the costumes being returned in a complete and suitable manner for re-use and this is not at all guaranteed. This proposal would cost the PTA an absolute fortune and I don't think it is workable.

Costumes were never allowed to go home. Stayed in school and children got changed in class before performances.

I worked in a triple stream school (so around 75 children per infant year group) and we managed to fund it through various events. Costumes reused for years without issue. Washed every year. Also managed to fundraise to buy a professional backdrop (featuring the star!) which was again reused year in year our. Made for great photos!

Gettingbysomehow · 31/10/2023 13:02

Bloody hell that is just so absurd - £30 for a 4 year old for one day. I'd have said outright no.

redskyanight · 31/10/2023 13:01

Agree with others that this is rubbish, but I guess parents don't actually complain so they consider it ok?

My DC's school said something like "wear light coloured clothing" and they made haloes in school with tinsel for the angels. Similar requests for other characters - nothing other than normal things the children would have at home anyway with odd bits of costume kept by school from year to year. Yes, I'm sure it didn't look as flashy as OP's nativity will, but do parents really expect that at infants school?

Riverlee · 31/10/2023 13:00

I thought you were going to say it was for a senior school play, not infant school.

Schools should provide them.

PrudeyTwoShoes · 31/10/2023 12:58

Speaking as a teacher, I'd be annoyed, too. In the school I work at, we store nativity costumes in the school loft (along with all other xmas decs) and have an evening where staff get everything down. It's actually a big palaver but much easier than requesting that parents buy the costumes, for the reasons you've already listed.

Tedn · 31/10/2023 12:57

It’s even more frustrating now I realise some schools don’t even expect the parents to buy any costumes!!
I don’t think I’d have minded if it wasn’t so expensive (though I’d have grumbled at a school who prides themselves on being environmentally conscious being so wasteful).

OP posts:
Isobel201 · 31/10/2023 12:57

what's happened to making a foil star out of cardboard and foil and using a white sheet or overlarge white T-shirt with white tights or leggings?

Spinet · 31/10/2023 12:55

I would say they've given the PTA plenty of time to raise funds for everyone's costumes. Much better environmentally as well as cost-wise. Are you a member of it OP? You could suggest a cake sale/ teatowels/ calendar or something.

chocolatefiends · 31/10/2023 12:55

This is crazy and beyond wasteful.

My kids' school has a set of nativity costumes they reuse every year (and presumably replace the odd that's worn every now and again). They never leave the school, so there's no danger of them not being returned. There's a washing machine in the reception classroom so I presume they wash them there.

Namechangedagain20 · 31/10/2023 12:53

At our school the kids only wear the costumes in school, they don’t go home with them. Then they’re reused every year.

AhBiscuits · 31/10/2023 12:53

Costumes at our school are always left to the parent to choose, with suggestions on how the costume can be made or put together very cheaply. There's no way I'd buy one the school told me I had to buy.

MumblesParty · 31/10/2023 12:53

This is bonkers OP.

At my kids schools we'd get a note saying something like "please can your child wear a white T-shirt and leggings" and then the school would add the tinsel or whatever. Surely that's normal?

MabelMaybe · 31/10/2023 12:53

What happened to the white sheet and wire coat hanger angel costumes of old? Dressing gown and ttea towel for wish men. They don't need purchased costumes.

Tedn · 31/10/2023 12:52

Having spoke to some friends about it who have older children in the school, they’ve said it never ends. The older kids do a panto every Christmas and they’ve been sent their costume list and it’s much the same!!
My friend also seems to think from a quick look down the list that they have given the roles with expensive costumes to families who they think will have the money vs the ones with less expensive to costumes to the others. Obviously I can’t confirm that but if that’s the case that’s even more outrageous!!

OP posts:
rwalker · 31/10/2023 12:51

BoohooWoohoo · 31/10/2023 12:44

My kids went to school where the costumes were reused every year. My son was an Angel and he wore an adult man's T-shirt with a halo made from Tinsel by a teacher or TA. Angel Gabriel had a yellow T-shirt and a different halo to the other angels. I supplied the T-shirt.

Nativities look best when the costumes are clearly "wrong" My son the shepherd had a plain dressing gown and tea towel on his head. He was the only shepherd who said no to face paints (beard and moist ache) so was a young shepherd on the programme 😂

I agree let’s be honest school plays can be a bit shit
the best part at our was the homemade costumes pillow cases,bin bags, dressing gowns and bridesmaids dresses nothing matched absolutely brilliant kids looked fantastic

WhateverMate · 31/10/2023 12:50

SiousieSoo · 31/10/2023 12:41

But they would be reliant on all the costumes being returned in a complete and suitable manner for re-use and this is not at all guaranteed. This proposal would cost the PTA an absolute fortune and I don't think it is workable.

The kids would leave them in school and someone from the PTA would wash them.

It's what happens in schools that provide costumes.

budgiegirl · 31/10/2023 12:49

That's such a waste of money. If the school expects children to wear a particular costume, then they should provide it, and keep it for future years.
Or accept home made costumes.
At our childrens nativity/school plays, all costumes were hand made - either at school, or provided by parents. Or bought at charity shops. Angels were kids in white t shirts with a tinsel halo and cardboard wings. And they looked lovely, it was part of the charm.
When my DS was the caterpillar from Alice in Wonderland for the summer play, he wore a blue sleeping bag, blue faceprint, and deely boppers. Not expensive at all, and worked perfectly well.

Ellie56 · 31/10/2023 12:48

Allmarbleslost · 31/10/2023 12:37

Surely it would make more sense for the PTA to fund the costumes then the school can use them year after year? What's the point in the next set of reception parents buying exactly the same costumes?

Yes I agree. Why don't you suggest this?

DrCoconut · 31/10/2023 12:48

Angel costume used to be a pillow case with holes cut in (a white bin bag would work too) and tinsel. Maybe cardboard wings if you were from a particularly creative family! £30 is absurd, they'd be far better having a bank of costumes to reuse.

MimiSunshine · 31/10/2023 12:48

that’s ludicrous. Surely they do this every year, why doesn’t the school already have costumes?

also I highly doubt that the PTA would fund it. That’s not what a PTA does, they have clear remits to support all children’s education at the school. Not buy expensive costumes for one or two kids.

Personally I’d be buying a large pillow case and some tinsel, making the former into a smock, using the tinsel for wrapping around a headband and buying some cheap Angel wings and telling the school to keep it afterwards.

GunboatDiplomacy · 31/10/2023 12:48

Tedn · 31/10/2023 12:44

I also doubt the PTA will have enough to cover costumes for 30, I reckon they will be expecting to cover less than 10 and the parents who pay for the other 20 will inevitably want them back.

Not inevitably surely.

If I'd shelled out for a camel costume for an eight year old and the PTA rep said "we'd be very grateful if you donated it to the school for next year" then I'd happily hand it over to get rid of it and stop it going to waste.

jadey1991 · 31/10/2023 12:47

Omg that is taking the piss on so many different levels...

They school should provide things like this.
To be honest my daughters school is like this. I refuse to buy things that they will only wear once(not that I can't afford it because I can) but it's the principle.

With the cost of living I'm sure they should take that into consideration... op I would refuse to pay for it and make them pay for it seeing as they have the funds to do so