Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School asking me to buy a £30 costume

221 replies

Tedn · 31/10/2023 12:33

I’ll start with, this is a state school, in south east London, relatively nice area but like most London schools, some kids live in houses worth well over a million others in council houses. The school prides its self both on being inclusive and environmentally conscious.

DD is 4 and in reception, yesterday I got an email, giving all the children their nativity roles (yes I know very early but school say it’s to give parents a chance to buy the costumes) and with it links to the costume you should buy.
DD has been given the role of Angel Gabriel, the costume linked £30!!! The other angels costumes are only £15. DDs costume is the most expensive by £10 (the animals and the star are £20), and from a different place.
The teacher noted in the email that the PTA has some funds available to help those who may not be able to buy them and if that’s the case you should reach out to the class PTA rep on WhatsApp. However it’s not that I can’t afford it, it’s more just what’s the point on a £30 costume for one day? Why so much more expensive than the others?
The way the school does nativity is that the reception children have no real lines, instead all the Y1 and Y2 children narrate and the reception kids just act it out on stage. So it’s worse to me that I’d be paying £30 for a costume to wear for two afternoons to not even hear DD saying anything.
I spoke to the teacher briefly at drop off today and she said that they picked that costume as it stands out from the other angels and as she is Angel Gabriel they thought it would look better and make it easier to follow. She reminded me that I can speak to the PTA rep if I need any help buying it.
Now I’m also thinking that it’s just wasteful? What will I do with it when the nativity is over?
I will probably just buy the damned costume to save any headaches but AIBU to think this is a ridiculous, tone deaf (considering COL) and wasteful request from the school?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ReadingSoManyThreads · 31/10/2023 15:02

Are the days of homemade costumes over then?

In all the years I was at school, we never ever purchased a costume.

YANBU, out of principal, I'd be refusing and would make an outfit for a fraction of the cost instead.

I fear this will just be the start of your venting of random school costs if your child is only 4yrs old. I home educate my children and thankfully don't have any of this nonsense to contend with!

Araminta1003 · 31/10/2023 15:01

In our London school the costumes get handed down/shared from older years. The school just does not want to store all of them, although they do keep donkeys and the 3 Kings! Have you tried asking people on the WhatsApp groups for Year 1 or 2 whether they still have an Angel Gabriel costume to borrow/purchase 2nd hand?

Kaibashira · 31/10/2023 14:56

This is absolute madness.
I'm a trustee of our PTA and I would be fucking raging to discover PTA funds spent on anything other than reusable costumes for the school to retain - and even then only if there was a surplus after we'd paid for all the actually important things were constantly trying to raise money for.
Tinsel round the head, big white T-shirt, job done.
100% raise this with head and governors. Madness.

Topsyturvy78 · 31/10/2023 14:55

That's rubbish when I was Mary in my school play and school provided all costumes. But they were all handmade I remember having to get measured up for my costume. Because I was tall and the costume they had was too small.

Same with my kids school they would never expect us to provide costumes. Unless it was something we had anyway

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 31/10/2023 14:52

Or withdraw your child from that role and let them play another angel or less prominent part. Let a family who wants it go for it.

Ah, yes - society is always much fairer when poorer people are excluded from opportunities for no reason whatsoever...

ChateauMargaux · 31/10/2023 14:43

I would consider approaching it from a sustainability angle.. it makes no sense to require the whole class to purchase costumes made from poor quality materials for single use.

Suggest instead that guidelines are given for homemade costumes, encourage second hand purchases and suggest that the school seriously consider having a set of costumes that parents contribute to each year. Yes, this is more work on staff.. but perhaps they could ask for parent volunteers to help, with the option to do so at a weekend.

Pineapple23 · 31/10/2023 14:40

You can donate it so another parent doesn't have to buy it next year. Or withdraw your child from that role and let them play another angel or less prominent part. Let a family who wants it go for it.

PrudeyTwoShoes · 31/10/2023 14:40

Angel costume used to be a pillow case with holes cut in (a white bin bag would work too) and tinsel. Maybe cardboard wings if you were from a particularly creative family! £30 is absurd, they'd be far better having a bank of costumes to reuse.

This brings back memories for me... As an Angel, I definitely wore a pillowcase with silver tinsel one year. And I've also been put in black bin bag before, too. Although that was on Halloween when I was dressed a wicked witch.

Spacecowboys · 31/10/2023 14:38

I’d buy it and give it
to the school afterwards for them to use next time.

ACynicalDad · 31/10/2023 14:34

Pillowcase and tinsel all the way. How old is the class teacher, I'm guessing young. I'd write to the head, more about the waste than the cost, do they have any of the environmental badges in the footer of their homepage? If so flag them.

Wolvesart · 31/10/2023 14:33

That’s awful, what are you supposed to do with the costume next year? We were only ever asked to provide elements of costumes or specified what kind of home clothes were recommended for narrators to wear. School should provide costumes and if they need funding then ask for donated sum of money equal for all parents involved and opt out if parents can’t afford it.

AliceMcK · 31/10/2023 14:33

3 DCs and never paid for a nativity costume, the school make them and they are reused, parents just supply basics (white tights or leggings and a T-shirt for angels etc..) The Angel Gabriel wears the same dress as the other angels except she or he has good tinsel instead of silver. Costumes never come home with the children so the school can keep control.

Also a mix of families, some absolutely would not be able to afford £10 let alone £30 for a costume. We could stretch to £30 but I wouldn’t pay it on principal, I don’t even spent that on clothes for myself.

BridasShieldWall · 31/10/2023 14:33

My kids primary school reused costumes from one year to the next and asked they wear a particular colour tights and top. Any plays in later years they asked for clothes that were readily available and something you either had or could reuse. This is lucky as I had twins - I wouldn’t pay £30 for one costume let alone £50-£60 for two. I think it is appalling that parts are being given to children whose parents can afford the costumes, let alone speaking to another parent to ask for help paying for it. It sounds like inclusion at this school is not considered especially as it seems to continue through the years, I would be questioning the ethos and values of the school.

TheFireflies · 31/10/2023 14:29

My mum cut up her wedding dress to make my angel costume for the nativity 😳

I agree though, they’re going to do this play every year so they should have a cupboard of costumes they can wash and reuse, rather than expecting people to buy specific costumes every year. What a waste.

OopsaDazy · 31/10/2023 14:28

*Angels

OopsaDazy · 31/10/2023 14:28

Angles used to be dressed in an old white sheet, or some other article of clothing that was no longer in use.

The whole 'fun' of the nativity play was the make shift costumes- the tea towels for head coverings etc.

You need to complain to the Head.

Flippingflamingo · 31/10/2023 14:27

I’m lucky enough that I could spend £30 on a costume, but I absolutely wouldn’t as it’s so wasteful!

Our school expect parents to provide costumes, but they don’t specific which ones to buy.

DD4 is a star, the guidance said wear silver. I’ve brought her a silver party dress she can wear all Christmas and a headband with a big star on it.

sollenwir · 31/10/2023 14:27

SiousieSoo · 31/10/2023 12:41

But they would be reliant on all the costumes being returned in a complete and suitable manner for re-use and this is not at all guaranteed. This proposal would cost the PTA an absolute fortune and I don't think it is workable.

Costumes don't go home, kids come in own clothes and get ready at school, then change back into own clothes to go home. Someone on the PTA (or a few folk) wash them and they get stored at school. Works in lots of other places.

@Tedn look on e-bay etc for a similar one, second hand, or if you decide to get this one then sell it on after use.

Mariposista · 31/10/2023 14:26

agree that most schools buy the costumes that they use each year - or the parents can provide their own if they want/can. After all, the story doesn't change.

Whatever happen though, don't risk your daughter losing her part. Heartbreaking....

ChatBFP · 31/10/2023 14:26

My kids go to a private school and they don't tell you to buy a £30 costume. They tell you to wear a certain colour top (and sometimes bottom) and then they give the kids something homemade or recycled to wear with it (donkey ears, tinsel/cardboard star etc). So much of the time it's just the cost of a t shirt if you don't currently have that colour.

It is crazy that anyone would be told what to buy and that they would choose according to family wealth.

Sgtmajormummy · 31/10/2023 14:24

From the age of 8 to 11, I got to play angels in school, Sunday School and Brownies Nativity Plays enough times that DM just made me my own costume to take around to the different venues.

A cut-up white bedsheet with kimono sleeves, golden ribbons crossed over the chest to hold on the cardboard wings and a tinsel headband.
I still begrudge not having a levitating halo, though…

Wrongsideofpennines · 31/10/2023 14:23

My children aren't in school yet but this is absurd. Its such an unbelievable waste of money. And it is horrendous for the environment. Even if your child fits in the costume next year they won't be given the same part so it will literally be worn for a few hours. I cannot understand how they don't have these costumes already. It's not like a new play they choose each year, the nativity literally has the same parts every year.

I think I would have to tell them that you won't be buying some plasticky tat for £30 to be worn for 4 hours and then disposed of.

Tempnamechng · 31/10/2023 14:23

I could afford it, but I would still be annoyed at the waste. What happened to arts and crafts in schools, encouraging kids to make their own costumes? A white nightie, or as pp said pillow case (brilliant) with a tinsel wasteband, big cardboard wings painted white and edged in tinsel.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 31/10/2023 14:21

I'm always curious as to why schools cast girls as Gabriel when it was actually a male angel!

Probably because there no female roles except an almost mute Mary.

True, but why not one of the non-sex-specific parts instead? Even if they likely wouldn't have done 2,000 years ago (they wouldn't have spoken English either), shepherds or innkeepers could be female - the innkeeper is one of the few speaking roles. The narrator can be either sex, and is the biggest speaking part of all. Many of the (obviously) non-speaking parts are also animals, which can of course be girls or boys.

This is so silly, though. Part of the attraction of school Nativity plays is the fact that they're amateurish: home-cobbled-together costumes, kids fluffing and forgetting their lines and singing out of tune. There's a reason why they don't sell tickets to all-comers and that the only people who actually want to see the plays are the kids' own parents and grandparents.

It's also very loaded, suggesting that either you buy the expensive prescribed costumes or otherwise you must be too poor to do so - and thus need to ask for 'charity'. You don't have to be on your uppers to be careful with money and object to making wasteful, bad-value purchases.

C152 · 31/10/2023 14:20

I don't understand why the school are telling parents they HAVE to buy a costume (and asking the PTA to pay for it is the same thing; someone is still having to buy a bit of tat that will get used once or twice and then binned). Why aren't they making the costumes as part of art or design and technology? It's not that hard to make some angel wings out of cardboard and paint them. It's not a hollywood production!

Swipe left for the next trending thread