Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He hit me but said I deserved it

139 replies

alco · 31/10/2023 10:05

Firstly I am an alcoholic. I have been mostly sober for 4 years. I had nearly 6 months this time but I slipped yesterday. I was never a violent drunk, I have seen found out I have a MH issue which I was using alcohol to cover.

DH was really really annoyed about it and hit me. I told him never raise a hand to me again but he said I needed it. He also got into a huge 'anger' himself and went to leave with our son but then handed me our son and stormed off

Did I need to be hit?

OP posts:
FSTraining · 31/10/2023 12:57

alco · 31/10/2023 10:05

Firstly I am an alcoholic. I have been mostly sober for 4 years. I had nearly 6 months this time but I slipped yesterday. I was never a violent drunk, I have seen found out I have a MH issue which I was using alcohol to cover.

DH was really really annoyed about it and hit me. I told him never raise a hand to me again but he said I needed it. He also got into a huge 'anger' himself and went to leave with our son but then handed me our son and stormed off

Did I need to be hit?

No. Being hit is not a therapy for alcohol addiction that I'm aware of. Whilst some forms of battery may be acceptable to an alcoholic (e.g. grabbing them and pulling them away from danger they are about to get themselves into), hitting is definitely not one of them.

People saying call the police are therefore probably right although I suspect you are worried about how this would play out for you if social services got involved? You need help but I would start with Women's Aid rather than the police first.

Cosywintertime · 31/10/2023 12:57

WhateverMate · 31/10/2023 12:56

Because all of that information is there in the relatively small OP that you couldn't be bothered to read.

Not one answer to those questions is in the op. What on earth are you talking about?

Ollifer · 31/10/2023 12:56

If I were you op I'd contact social services for support with this. It will look far better should you ever have to go through a custody case If you can shown you are seeking help, being open and trying to better yourself for your child. I think you're at risk here of spiralling and then if you want to split he can manipulate the situation to make it look like you're mentally unstable (trust me, I've been there with this).

You need to report the physical abuse to the police so it's on record and keep note of any last and future incidents.

Reach out to your GP for help with the alcohol, reach out to SS.

Lochness1975 · 31/10/2023 12:56

OP you did not ‘deserve’ to be hit. No one has the right to hurt another person. I grew up with a mother who was an alcoholic and there was a lot of violence between both my parents. Unfortunately It still affects me now- MH diagnosis, anxiety etc.

You are an alcoholic. That’s not going to change. But you can change your story. You child deserves so much more than this. You may kid yourself into thinking they don’t know, but they will
do. They’ll know that feeling of unease, that change in atmosphere, the tensions raising.

Seek help now and change the outcome of your child’s future.

WhateverMate · 31/10/2023 12:56

Cosywintertime · 31/10/2023 12:55

Yes, seriously? Why have you taken issue with this?

Because all of that information is there in the relatively small OP that you couldn't be bothered to read.

Cosywintertime · 31/10/2023 12:55

WhateverMate · 31/10/2023 12:53

are you sober now, when is the last time you had a drink? And was your child there yesterday when you were drinking, were you alone with them?

Seriously?? Hmm

Yes, seriously? Why have you taken issue with this?

Irridescantshimmmer · 31/10/2023 12:54

You did not deserve to be hit, under no circumstances should he hit you regardless if the circumstances.

I suggest you get your self to place of safety because once they start hitting a woman once, they do it again and again. Its why laws have been tightened because too many women end up dead.

So you have a few choices. Repert him to the police, leave him or both.

JFT · 31/10/2023 12:53

OK there's two issues here.

  1. You're an alcoholic and your alcoholism needs urgent treatment, regardless of whether you're actively drinking or 'sober' today or not - it's a lifelong issue;

  2. Your partner is violence and he is justifying / rationalising violent criminal abuse of you and you are buying into to his excuses.

These are separate issues.

Living with an alcoholic / untreated 'white-knuckling' sober alcoholic is a nightmare, being one is a nightmare.

Living with a violent person who punches you is living in a violent situation.

Please find your nearest local AA meetings, in person, on zoom, you can speak to their helpline.

https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/contact

There are also other alcohol recovery projects such as SMART recovery and your local council will have lots of guidance and advice for alcohol recovery projects and support groups in your community.

As for the violence, then there are also people who can work with you - your local council will have details and your local mental health team. I would suggest that since you're battling alcoholism and you have mental health problems, you ring the crisis team and ask them.

Contact us - Get in touch with AA today!

There are a variety of ways to contact AA. Contact us using the details below. Get in touch with AA today!

https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/contact

WhateverMate · 31/10/2023 12:53

Cosywintertime · 31/10/2023 12:47

I’m sorry about your abusive up bringing and no of course hitting you isn’t the answer nor did you deserve it, I think you know this.

are you sober now, when is the last time you had a drink? And was your child there yesterday when you were drinking, were you alone with them?

are you sober now, when is the last time you had a drink? And was your child there yesterday when you were drinking, were you alone with them?

Seriously?? Hmm

sandyhappypeople · 31/10/2023 12:49

alco · 31/10/2023 10:40

@Sp1ke3 thanks, I probably do need more help. I wanted to go back to the MH hospital when I was suicidal after DS was born but DH didn't want me to. Said He'd miss me. I wanted to go back there recently too but he said I don't need too. I am sober far far more than I am drunk. I was sober for 2 years that was my best stint, altho I was pregnant for a good chunk of that.

There’s a lot of blame being flung around for your apparent lack of treatment, you make your own decision when it comes to having a drink so why can’t you make your own decisions when it comes to your treatment? stop putting excuses in the way why you can’t and just get on with it, you both should be thoroughly ashamed of your actions and behaving that way in front of your son.

when you say your ‘known’ for having MH issues and as an alcoholic do you mean your known to the police? Is that why you say they would take your son away?

I grew up with an semi-alcoholic mother, she wasn’t a ‘violent drunk’ either, but the mental torture that she was blissfully unaware of the next day leaves a lasting impact that you can never fully get over, you should know better than anyone after growing up the way you did.

Get treatment for your mental health issues and get treatment for you alcoholism and stop subjecting your child to this abuse.

babyproblems · 31/10/2023 12:49

No one deserves go be hit.
No one deserves to live with an alcoholic; it destroys lives, yours and everyone’s around you. It will be a horrible burden for your son to bear to see you live life as an alcoholic. Don’t model that as a normal lifestyle. Please seek help for yourself. Xxx

Mrsttcno1 · 31/10/2023 12:48

WhateverMate · 31/10/2023 12:39

I don't think anyone here should be deciding the OP's mental health disorder is bollocks and that she might not even be an alcoholic.

That crosses a line massively.

I think (I hope) that possibly what the poster who said this meant is that BPD is one of the most commonly misdiagnosed mental health conditions and this is largely because it is really quite difficult to diagnose accurately due to the fact many of the symptoms overlap with other mental health conditions such as anxiety, depression, bipolar, even substance abuse and yes, PTSD. Many are almost reluctant to make a BPD diagnosis because it can be really difficult to say for sure that it’s accurate due to all of the overlapping symptoms.

I hope that what the poster was intending to point out is that perhaps if the OP is able to open up and seek help not just for alcoholism but also to deal with a lot of the trauma that has been described throughout the posts, they may find that things start to change for them in terms of their mental health in general and relationship with alcohol as well as other things such as self esteem. Unresolved trauma and PTSD can present itself in many different ways and could potentially lead to a misdiagnosis, I hope this is all the previous poster intended to say

Cosywintertime · 31/10/2023 12:47

I’m sorry about your abusive up bringing and no of course hitting you isn’t the answer nor did you deserve it, I think you know this.

are you sober now, when is the last time you had a drink? And was your child there yesterday when you were drinking, were you alone with them?

Hooplahooping · 31/10/2023 12:44

Where are you based? Are you working a program? Going to meetings?

Of course you don’t deserve to be hit. it sounds like you and your son need more support. How old is he?

Neriah · 31/10/2023 12:43

alco · 31/10/2023 10:12

@DailyMailHater tbh I think I have gotten all the help I can with alcoholism. I know wht I am. He isn't normally angry

Hitting someone is never right, but that isn't quite the same thing as not being understandable.

There is no such thing as "mostly sober". You either are, or you aren't. You drank yesterday, so you aren't.

It sounds to me like you both need help - this is not a good environment to be raising child.

sollenwir · 31/10/2023 12:39

There is no justification for hitting someone (with the caveat of self defence perhaps), so please don't tell yourself you 'deserve' it, because you didn't.

That said, you do need some help/support with your addiction issues, for the sake of you and everyone around you.

WhateverMate · 31/10/2023 12:39

porridgeisbae · 31/10/2023 12:35

I get what Pam is saying but treatment for the less-than-ideal behavioural/psychological effects someone can develop as a response to trauma can be beneficial.

When I did the Freedom Programme, the leaders had this 'drop the disorder' outlook, but a lot of women there had many, probably pre-existing issues which would've benefited from more therapy and treatment.

I don't think anyone here should be deciding the OP's mental health disorder is bollocks and that she might not even be an alcoholic.

That crosses a line massively.

porridgeisbae · 31/10/2023 12:35

I get what Pam is saying but treatment for the less-than-ideal behavioural/psychological effects someone can develop as a response to trauma can be beneficial.

When I did the Freedom Programme, the leaders had this 'drop the disorder' outlook, but a lot of women there had many, probably pre-existing issues which would've benefited from more therapy and treatment.

crumblingschools · 31/10/2023 12:30

@kitsuneghost the son shouldn't be with the dad

YabbaDabbaDooooo · 31/10/2023 12:29

PamFritters · 31/10/2023 12:21

Hot take but in what way are you an alcoholic?

You say you have been sober more than drinking in the last four years. You have one slip in 6 months and your husband hits you for it.

He’s been violent to you for years.

You have had an abusive traumatic life.

BPD is bollocks, recognised less and less. It’s a cop out diagnosis they give women because they are lazy. It’s more likely c-PTSD. A very normal response to trauma.

Alcohol abuse is common in trauma. It doesn’t actually mean you are an alcoholic.

I speak from personal experience. I no longer drink but I didn’t need AA or rehab or detox. I just needed to address my trauma. I’ve shaken off a BPD diagnosis and have stable mental health.

Theres a high chance that if you left the abuse you’d lose the MH issues and alcohol crutches.

BPD is bollocks, recognised less and less. It’s a cop out diagnosis they give women because they are lazy. It’s more likely c-PTSD. A very normal response to trauma.

Do you have a link about it being 'bollocks' please?

porridgeisbae · 31/10/2023 12:29

It's usually seen as good to treat any trauma/MH issues and substance abuse issues alongside each other. Any treatment OP can access to help her stay sober, can't hurt. Same goes for any treatment for her mental health, as long as it's a type of help that makes her feel better, rather than worse. Decent professionals can treat 'BPD' (aka a response to trauma in childhood) without being stigmatising/nasty about it.

For sure leaving her abuser is bound to help too.

kitsuneghost · 31/10/2023 12:27

He shouldn't have hit you and he shouldn't have left your son with you.
He should have just left quietly with your son

Duckingella · 31/10/2023 12:25

He'll hit you again,then again,then it'll be a punch,a kick,bruises,a black eye,a broken bone...........

There is NO excuse to hit someone.

Please call women's aid if you're not prepared to go to the police.

Gnomegnomegnome · 31/10/2023 12:24

It’s never okay to hit anyone and blaming it on you being an alcoholic is awful. No ‘but’ or ‘however’.

I grew up with an alcoholic parent, no one would ever have hit them no matter what hell we were going through because we knew that they were struggling. They weren’t drinking for fun!

Are you currently receiving support for your addiction and/or BPD?

PamFritters · 31/10/2023 12:21

Hot take but in what way are you an alcoholic?

You say you have been sober more than drinking in the last four years. You have one slip in 6 months and your husband hits you for it.

He’s been violent to you for years.

You have had an abusive traumatic life.

BPD is bollocks, recognised less and less. It’s a cop out diagnosis they give women because they are lazy. It’s more likely c-PTSD. A very normal response to trauma.

Alcohol abuse is common in trauma. It doesn’t actually mean you are an alcoholic.

I speak from personal experience. I no longer drink but I didn’t need AA or rehab or detox. I just needed to address my trauma. I’ve shaken off a BPD diagnosis and have stable mental health.

Theres a high chance that if you left the abuse you’d lose the MH issues and alcohol crutches.