Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Your parents generation - gifts/money

40 replies

Lwrenagain · 31/10/2023 09:16

Not aibu more a general question, however I never find anyone very chatty in chat. Or I'm just a massively boring bellend. Anyway.

Myself and DP just had a chat about our parents and friends around our age parents and we aren't sure if this is a generational thing or just a poor area thing. So I'd like your opinions.

We find our parents are generous, providing they're choosing what to buy, as where grandparents are happy to gift some money. I'm not talking huge for MN circles amounts, tops £50 which for our circles is extremely generous and very gratefully received.

So say one of our parents has a bit of financial gain, maybe a refunded bill, bit of a bonus at work etc, they'd not say, "here you are lass, £20 quid buy the kids something", but instead would buy £20 worth of things for the kids, usually sweets etc or for Christmas would never ask what we wanted, instead just choose bits and pieces, even though we could heavily hint what we'd like. (Eg a nice bathbomb from lush or a book from waterstones, nothing that can't be picked up locally or delivered, certainly nothing excessive. Although if my mam does ever read this, I cannae stress this enough to you mam, EDIBLE GIFTS PLEASE 😂)
But instead our parents and pals parents also seem to love the little shopping buzz of buying us things that often won't get used due to allergies or something, or when it comes to grandchildrens gifts just aren't things that they're interested in.

My friends DC are still being bought paw patrol things despite being year 7. They've repeatedly mentioned, kindly, to their DGP that they're getting older now, DGP aren't older GPs etc, they just don't want to gift other things and there is only so much "thanks nan, haven't had a new paw patrol lunchbox for a few months now" kids can do without seeming to be rude.

My mum smelt amazing last time I saw her, I told her I loved her perfume, "thanks, nana gave me some cash to treat myself!" So I strongly hinted I'd love to choose a perfume for my birthday, emphasis on choose, so she bought me a few box sets of body spray which cost more than the perfume she had on and triggered my eczema. But she loves buying things and I couldn't ever upset her to be arsey over it, even though she knows I can't use body sprays or certain bath stuff.

I suspect that they enjoy choosing gifts to make the gift it's self seem bigger than receiving a single item, such as a bottle of Britneys finest or the latest Marian Keyes is one gift as opposed to the 3 boxes of gift sets.

Now grandparents, they're the real prezzie heroes, you get either vouchers or cash from them, they're like, "go ham, here's 30 quid to spoil the kids with, buy them a fuckload of E numbers and playdoh, have a riot girl".

So is it a growing up being skint thing, is it consumerism and enjoying the spending?
They're the same with the kids as I say, one of my kids is autistic so has very specific interests. Both DGP will say, "what shall I get the neuro spicy one?" To which I'll send an a few links, they all use amazon or ebay, again and I can't stress enough, they're not being tight because they spend more on their choices, but I'll send a link of something he'd enjoy and appreciate massively, even if it's under a fiver, and they'll just ignore it and buy him something he won't even remotely acknowledge (he's quite severe asd, not a rude little shit), but they just can't cope with not choosing.

Anyone else's parents like this? Are my pals and partner and I just alone on our island of unusable gifts that do admittedly, come wrapped lovely.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Justdontask · 31/10/2023 16:01

Lwrenagain · 31/10/2023 14:05

We have very similar issues here 🙈

Its good to know it's not just my family but I'm afraid I don't have any solutions! I did try being really specific but where they might still have a bit of choice a few birthdays back but it didn't get listened to

It's a shame because birthdays and Christmases just end up feeling stressful, and about managing feelings of others rather than appreciating the love everyone is giving by wanting to give you something.

electriclight · 31/10/2023 15:42

TheBabylonian · 31/10/2023 14:12

Imho people who give non-money gifts tend to do it as they get a dopamine hit out of the shopping. It’s about making themself feel good, not the person on the receiving end.

People who gift money are far more concerned about the recipient than themself.

I hate receiving money. It doesn't make me think that the giver cares about me, but that they couldn't be bothered thinking about what I would like. It is so generic and impersonal.

TheBabylonian · 31/10/2023 14:12

Imho people who give non-money gifts tend to do it as they get a dopamine hit out of the shopping. It’s about making themself feel good, not the person on the receiving end.

People who gift money are far more concerned about the recipient than themself.

Pooooochi · 31/10/2023 14:07

My in laws are like this. They've openly said before, they give the gift they want to buy.

They rarely if ever ask if there's anything the DC would like for christmas, as a result they have simply wasted tons of money over the years buying duplicates, things that arent age appropriate, poor quality versions of things the DC already have, clothes that don't fit etc.

I always assumed it was because they are and always have been, very well off and don't seem to mind or acknowledge wasted money. Whereas my parents, and my grandparents generation watched every penny and couldn't stand waste.

Lwrenagain · 31/10/2023 14:05

Justdontask · 31/10/2023 13:09

My mum seems to have got worse with presents as they've got older. I used to be able to write a list of specific suggestions and they'd chose some surprises from it, but now its definitely about quantity and having things to open rather than what will be appreciated. They don't have much spare money so have a set small budget per child/grandchild, but she buys things throughout the year from charity shops, usually with no one in mind and then just decides come Christmas who it's for (regardless of how appropriate it is).

She sometimes asks for ideas (presumably it the gift cupboard is empty) but definitely doesn't like to gift vouchers or be given specific requests (e.g my brother dared ask for a specific model of a dish rack last Christmas - presumably as he needed one and it fit their space and aesthetic and I heard no end of grumbles that they could have got him one for a fiver and bought some other stuff). It makes you feel very unappreciative, but genuinely I don't want them to spend money they don't have on things I don't want, but don't know how to get that through to them without looking ungrateful.

I almost always end up with something I can't use/eat as it's not vegan (have been for over 10 years so it's not new!), but if I mention it contains milk or whatever to avoid a repeat again, it's met with a bad reaction (and I'm always polite about it!)

We have very similar issues here 🙈

OP posts:
GoonieGang · 31/10/2023 13:10

Another one whose parents felt cash and vouchers were impersonal. Very much the thought rather than the value.

Justdontask · 31/10/2023 13:09

My mum seems to have got worse with presents as they've got older. I used to be able to write a list of specific suggestions and they'd chose some surprises from it, but now its definitely about quantity and having things to open rather than what will be appreciated. They don't have much spare money so have a set small budget per child/grandchild, but she buys things throughout the year from charity shops, usually with no one in mind and then just decides come Christmas who it's for (regardless of how appropriate it is).

She sometimes asks for ideas (presumably it the gift cupboard is empty) but definitely doesn't like to gift vouchers or be given specific requests (e.g my brother dared ask for a specific model of a dish rack last Christmas - presumably as he needed one and it fit their space and aesthetic and I heard no end of grumbles that they could have got him one for a fiver and bought some other stuff). It makes you feel very unappreciative, but genuinely I don't want them to spend money they don't have on things I don't want, but don't know how to get that through to them without looking ungrateful.

I almost always end up with something I can't use/eat as it's not vegan (have been for over 10 years so it's not new!), but if I mention it contains milk or whatever to avoid a repeat again, it's met with a bad reaction (and I'm always polite about it!)

Lwrenagain · 31/10/2023 12:41

MidnightOnceMore · 31/10/2023 12:18

Gifts can be a tool through which to show love or, sadly, toxicity.

I have experience of being repeatedly gifted things containing a known and obviously labelled (in big letters on the front) allergen - it's deliberate.

If you have a local post office or collection point or somewhere you'd be comfortable sharing an address, I'll send you a gift x

OP posts:
Lwrenagain · 31/10/2023 12:39

electriclight · 31/10/2023 11:45

Your grandparents give cash.

Your parents hated receiving cash and thought it was impersonal, thoughtless and lazy. They vowed never to do that to their own children and that they would instead spend time choosing and wrapping thoughtful gifts.

If you want cash you'll have to spell it out and convince them that you really mean it and are not just suggesting it because you think it'll be easier for them.

I'd never just ask purely because if it's something they enjoy doing, choosing things, then I'd not deny that.
Weirdly I can remember a massive argument between my DM and DGM when I was about 9 because DM (very much loved, but an absolute spoilt horror she can be) had a massive row because DGM bought her a new kettle and set of saucepans. Ironically I'd be made up with new pans. Mine are so old they remember Andy Pandy on the telly.
Anyway DM kicked off royally.
That one occasion absolutely traumatised me so I'd never in a million years cause conflict.
Despite being allergic to almost everything I'm given 🙈

OP posts:
ny20005 · 31/10/2023 12:33

My mil is like this & I don't understand it at all. It's purely about gift buying for her & not the recipient.

We just smile, say thanks & flog stuff on eBay or Vinted.

I've got older teens now & 2 years ago she bought loads of clothes that were wrong sizes & refused to give gift receipts. Youngest didn't want to upset her so said nothing when she asked. Older one asked if he could return them as they didn't fit. She took him in January & traipsed round the sales returning each item as didn't have his size.

Last year, she gave them oodie type hoodie & cash Grin I'd like to think she learned but we'll see lol

MereDintofPandiculation · 31/10/2023 12:28

Hate giving cash - so transactional. Would also like to think the cash went to something that the recipient wouldn't have normally bought rather than straight into the housekeeping money. Don't like receiving cash either. I want to be able to look at something in my daily life and think "so-and-so gave me that".

Even worse at Christmas, I give them £50, they give me £50. What's the point? We avoid the tat by circulating lists beforehand, lots of suggestions, so it's still a surprise, but you stray from the list at your peril! I can stray for DH, but I wouldn't stray for adult DC.

MidnightOnceMore · 31/10/2023 12:18

Gifts can be a tool through which to show love or, sadly, toxicity.

I have experience of being repeatedly gifted things containing a known and obviously labelled (in big letters on the front) allergen - it's deliberate.

Itwasamemo3 · 31/10/2023 12:14

My mum usually gave me cash to choose presents for the children. She really hated shopping and would get in a tizz so her approach was great.
I ask daughter what to get granddaughter and then I add a couple of small extra presents ie jigsaw,colouring books etc .

BodegaSushi · 31/10/2023 12:05

Acheyknees · 31/10/2023 11:00

We have one set of GP's who give money (great!) and one set who buy random reduced stuff throughout the year and divvy it up amongst the grandchildren. So each child gets random crap, not gifts that are personal/special to them. Or one of those shit gift cards that you have to register, check the balance and use in an obscure shop 30 miles away.

I know a lot of people think this attitude is ungrateful and grabby, but your example demonstrates that 'gift giving' in this instance is more about the giver than the receiver. So it's selfish and thoughtless, and what's the point in that?

I look after lots of children, I ask them what they want. If they can't decide I get them a voucher for Amazon or a shop I know they frequent.

I also appreciate when people ask me what I'd like (and listen), I'd much rather nothing than something I won't use.

electriclight · 31/10/2023 11:45

Your grandparents give cash.

Your parents hated receiving cash and thought it was impersonal, thoughtless and lazy. They vowed never to do that to their own children and that they would instead spend time choosing and wrapping thoughtful gifts.

If you want cash you'll have to spell it out and convince them that you really mean it and are not just suggesting it because you think it'll be easier for them.

LoreleiG · 31/10/2023 11:44

I don’t think about what people buy/don’t buy or wish it were money. It’s up to the giver what they give. If it makes them happy to do so, that’s a valid reason. A very fussy relative of mine sent back a present to another relative saying their child didn’t like it which I personally think is far worse than a thoughtless gift (which it wasn’t anyway, anyone else would have been pleased to receive it).

LadyDanburysHat · 31/10/2023 11:40

My Mum has an odd obsession with not giving money or gift cards, to the end that she used to turn herself inside out trying to find something for my teenage cousins years back. Weirdly now she will happily give my DC cash. But she buys me some random stuff considering she knows me well enough to know what I like.

RudsyFarmer · 31/10/2023 11:31

My MIL bought every toy known to man. Must of spent upwards of 5k I reckon by the time she reigned it in. My partner couldn’t and wouldn’t stop her and I figured out in the end that it was giving her pleasure. So I’m going to guess it’s the same with your family. They are enjoying having the ability to treat you/your kids but part of the treat for them is choosing abd buying the items.

RB68 · 31/10/2023 11:26

I sometimes think this is they get the dopamine hit of spending and can "see " something for the money and feel like they are doing a good thing for you. I know my parents when they were alive preferred to gift things rather than straight cash - same for similar generation rellies.

So would far rather pay for say a cheapish dishwasher than give me the cash and let me add to it to get one that will last better. I was starting to get through to them - or at least learning how to approach this - so when Dad would ask if there was anything I needed etc I would say well I am putting a bit of money aside for x, I want to get one to last so not the basic model etc. But I should be good to get it in a couple of months etc. And he would come back and say if I give you x towards it will that help you get it now? And thats how we got round it - but I would have to prep him to do that it didn't just happen etc, so they get the thrill of helping you look for best deal and choose etc even though they may only be paying half say.

Mum was the same - she would always buy her taste (actually quite modern, often more so than me and my house) unless I was very specific.

Both gone now and I miss em just for the little things.

Joonio · 31/10/2023 11:21

As a gran I usually send money but my daughter spends mad amounts buying me presents I will never use. For example designer bags and clothes that don't fit, expensive make up and scent which I don't wear and various kitchen equipment which at my advanced age I don't need .

Lwrenagain · 31/10/2023 11:17

Wazzzzzuuuuuuup · 31/10/2023 11:10

Haha. My mum buys me a bottle of prosecco and a box of after eights every Christmas. I only drink red wine and have never liked after eights. She also offers my brother a chicken dinner every time she sees him despite the fact he's been a vegan since he was 15.

She puts money in for the kids now, although she used to buy them really high end clothes for Christmas and birthdays when they were small. Not gifts chosen in terms of how much they would enjoy them, but in terms of how much she enjoyed buying them. She did try buying athleisure for all the GDs a few years ago and bought really nice pieces all in the wrong sizes and not to the wearers tastes.

I'm not sure this is a generational thing or a class thing, I think she's just a bit weird.

It amazes me no matter how long a child from a meat eating family stops eating meat, that the family behave like its a fad. Like after 20 years they're still asking do they want a bacon butty 🙈

OP posts:
Lwrenagain · 31/10/2023 11:14

Cryingbutstilltrying · 31/10/2023 11:06

My GPs are long gone now, my mum prefers to give a gift plus some money if it’s under her spending limit and the gift bit is almost always no use to me or the kids. I’ve told her not to worry before now but I think she just likes to shop. My MIL is happy to give money as she lives in a care home and can’t get out, and tells me to get something and let her know what it was. This is much more useful!
I always put money in cards or bank transfer for my nieces and nephews. They live in different places and their interests change all the time, so it’s much easier and we’re all happy!
Plus I’m basically lazy.
So it’s probably more a person thing than a generation thing, I guess.

Your username 🥺💐♥️

Your MiL sounds lovely. We're NC with mine sadly, but one year she sent us half a tub of celebrations and had, no lie, taken out the maltesers and galaxy's.
That isn't why we're NC but I'm still salty.
They're the best ones!
My FiL and wife send us booze and we're a teetotal household. They know this 😂
But it's never half of bottle so I'd not grumble!

OP posts:
Wazzzzzuuuuuuup · 31/10/2023 11:10

Haha. My mum buys me a bottle of prosecco and a box of after eights every Christmas. I only drink red wine and have never liked after eights. She also offers my brother a chicken dinner every time she sees him despite the fact he's been a vegan since he was 15.

She puts money in for the kids now, although she used to buy them really high end clothes for Christmas and birthdays when they were small. Not gifts chosen in terms of how much they would enjoy them, but in terms of how much she enjoyed buying them. She did try buying athleisure for all the GDs a few years ago and bought really nice pieces all in the wrong sizes and not to the wearers tastes.

I'm not sure this is a generational thing or a class thing, I think she's just a bit weird.

Lwrenagain · 31/10/2023 11:09

shivawn · 31/10/2023 10:48

My mum (60) loves nosing around charity shops and buys my son loads of second hand toys, books and clothes. She also set up an investment account for him not long after his birth and puts €100 a month into it although I tried hard to talk her out of it. I won't accept money from her so she's stopped trying and my son is only 2 so too young to receive money directly. She buys me Estee Lauder makeup for every occasion because she knows that's what I wear and I'm hard to buy for. I'm always begging her not to spend money on us, we're very comfortable whereas her and my father are living on fairly small pensions. She's very frugal and sensible with money and loves finding bargains but very generous.

I love the charity shops and bargains! All our clothes are from vinted etc except for my eldest who's really into a certain fashion style (he isn't, but think gymhead drug dealer 😂) so he has to use birthday/Christmas for his North face clad arse.

Hes asked for Christmas for a £300 bottle of aftershave, which I've said he can have £150 towards and he can ask his DF for the rest because £300 for a bottle of creed i think its called, isn't possible for us.

But I'd rather listen to what it is he does want than give him ten cans of lynx, which is what my mam would do 😂

OP posts:
Cryingbutstilltrying · 31/10/2023 11:06

My GPs are long gone now, my mum prefers to give a gift plus some money if it’s under her spending limit and the gift bit is almost always no use to me or the kids. I’ve told her not to worry before now but I think she just likes to shop. My MIL is happy to give money as she lives in a care home and can’t get out, and tells me to get something and let her know what it was. This is much more useful!
I always put money in cards or bank transfer for my nieces and nephews. They live in different places and their interests change all the time, so it’s much easier and we’re all happy!
Plus I’m basically lazy.
So it’s probably more a person thing than a generation thing, I guess.