Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think living in a city is too much for DC?

63 replies

AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 07:34

DC1 is applying for university. They want a job that will most likely mean they’ll need to live in a city, as there won’t be many opportunities for it. It’s a niche, arty specialism and tbh wouldn’t transfer to other jobs much, so they need to be absolutely sure that they want to do this before starting to pay for the course.

The pay is hard to find an average of, as most things say you can expect between £35000 and £85000 per year, so quite varied and I imagine will depend on experience.

Round our little town, £35000 sounds a decent wage. Houses are around £12000 for a nice semi 2 bedroomed with a drive. So DC thinks this is a good wage. However, if moving to a city such as London or Manchester, I doubt this will translate as well. I’m not sure how much accommodation would be in London, or where the areas people live in to be able to travel in to the main area. Does anyone know how much it would cost roughly for one person to rent and travel in London? Plus then there will be council tax, bills etc.

I don’t want to put them off a career they are passionate about, but I also don’t want them to have a degree that is unusable around here and not be able to afford to use it elsewhere.

YABU - let them figure it out as they go and it will all work out
YANBU - City life is too expensive for a single person to start off in a career

OP posts:
Pinkdelight3 · 31/10/2023 09:48

They're bound to be naive about these things at their age, that's what uni is for, to transition into being less naive and seeing how things work. Which will be different for them than it was for you. But there's no point totting up rent and bills equations per location at this stage and making overly cautious decisions so that the end result is an affordable local house. The best thing about your post is that DC knows what they enjoy and want to pursue. That's a huge thing and more than a lot of kids their age have, so let them explore it for themselves, learn their craft and how the industry works, then make their way. This -

If they were to stay local, they could get an apprenticeship or work in a different field.

is irrelevant as it's not what they want to do and feels like something from a past generation where people had to do jobs their parents insisted upon instead of what they're interested in and what will have more chance of making them fulfilled. Also there are permanent jobs on the tech/production design side of theatre/film/tv/touring but who knows where he'll end up at this point. One step at the time and all the best to 'them'!

MojoMoon · 31/10/2023 09:27

I can see why you are concerned but would suggest that the cost of living in a city in a few years time should not really be the main one right now.

I agree with a PP that set design is a challenging, insecure career and requires working as part of a team under tight time and budget pressures. It requires excellent social skills, flexibility and resilience.

It sounds like your teenager has a dream but I think it would be a challenging career for an autistic person who you say doesn't really like socializing so I will assume isn't great with people.

They should apply for this work experience placement - deadline is 4 Dec so get cracking. There are online workshops if they can't get to Manchester, London or Nottingham
https://www.nationaltheatre.org.uk/learn-explore/young-people/young-technicians/

There are also apprenticeship schemes that would be cheaper than doing a degree

https://www.roh.org.uk/learning/young-people/apprenticeships/the-scheme

https://www.rsc.org.uk/jobs/where-do-i-fit-in/apprenticeships

Young Technicians | National Theatre

Ever thought about how to make what happens onstage actually happen? The National Theatre's free Young Technicians programme shows you how. Open to ages 13-19.

https://www.nationaltheatre.org.uk/learn-explore/young-people/young-technicians

Twentypastfour · 31/10/2023 09:21

Also the OP needs to consider that where her child moves at 21 to start their career is just where they are living at 21. Plenty of people start their careers in a city, get great experience, connections and a good CV (and have a blast while they’re at it) and then go and get jobs elsewhere when they’re ready to settle down.

Twentypastfour · 31/10/2023 09:19

HerMammy · 31/10/2023 08:15

Have you considered Glasgow or Edinburgh, brilliant vibrant cities, London isn't the only city!

But it’s not for the OP to consider at all though is it?

If I was half way through university and applying for graduate jobs and trying to imagine my future life and my Mum said to me “I’ve actually been considering X and Y cities for you” that wouldn’t be ok.

It’s up to the OP’s child to plan a future.

Like many others on this thread I was also from a cheap / deprived town and I was desperate to leave. My parents didn’t need to opine or decide for me.

Nevermind31 · 31/10/2023 09:19

i doubt that 35K is the starting salary for a graduate, if the top bracket is 85k. They have to be prepared to start on less. But they’ll work it out - plenty of people work in fields unrelated to their degree.

Wiffleontoomuch · 31/10/2023 09:18

Omg let them live their own life

NoSquirrels · 31/10/2023 09:18

Sorry, you said ‘like set design’? Lighting design? I’d think there’s actually a decent career there even if not West End because every performance needs lighting, even one-person performances like comedy or singers, even when they’re on a black drapes studio set. Regional theatre employs a lot of people.

fixies · 31/10/2023 09:16

You are getting ahead of yourself. I don't know what the degree is but a huge percentage of people don't go on to do what they studied for. Even if it is arty, you can do other things or a masters if you want to switch.

£35-85 k is more than enough to live on in London! I live on that and I have two kids (albeit with a partner earning the same), but this is years away. One thing at a time.

Staying in your small town and doing and apprenticeship sounds a bit smothering to me. Clip their wings! I'm sure the autism element is worrying for you and I can understand why you are concerned.

NoSquirrels · 31/10/2023 09:14

Set design will be a freelance career, not a steady wage. It very well may be hard for them as an autistic person - it’s not conducive to routine, for example. And they will need to build a network and spend a lot of time doing things for free and working another job on the side, at least to begin with. West End shows are the top of the tree, obviously - you won’t start out there.

They absolutely need experience with am-dram, work placement at the local theatres etc.

It’s fine to have it as an ambition but lots can change if they’re not even at uni or on a course somewhere yet. Don’t put the cart before the horse worrying about money.

BoohooWoohoo · 31/10/2023 09:13

Why wouldn't you encourage your son to go to uni in a city so that he gets a realistic taste of city life and expenses ?

City life is exciting for someone just starting out. It's expensive but being young is the perfect time live very centrally in a flatshare.

3WildOnes · 31/10/2023 09:09

I think 35k is a bit of an optimistic starting salary for set design. They are very unlikely to start off in the west end, much more likely as an assistant in a smaller theatre. However, I think they will be fine. Lots of the juniors in my work earn much less than 35k. They live I cheap flatshares in not the nicest areas and cycle in or get the bus to work. They socialise cheaply.

nahliom · 31/10/2023 09:07

I live in London as an autistic adult and I find the lifestyle is brilliant for my needs. Less need for interaction as so much is automated. But having less money can be limiting, and accommodation is expensive and hard to find. I had a council flat a young adult due to my needs and that helped a lot as I wouldn't have coped with living with flatmates, and it meant my money could go further. But your DC wouldn't be eligible. I also get PIP and a Freedom Pass as well so don't pay for public transport. Your DC could eventually get those but it's not guaranteed as they are functioning well enough to be in HE. And I think having grown up here, I know the cheaper places to go to shop and ways of getting cheap tickets etc so I can live more cheaply than a newcomer. Personally I think I'd struggle on a wage of £35k and having to live in house shares and having to pay for travel and not getting PIP. Being autistic does mean that some of the things that young grads have to endure are more of a struggle compared to NTs.

ManateeFair · 31/10/2023 09:04

First of all, everyone I know started their career in a city, because that's where the jobs mostly are, there are more house-shares, better transport and more social opportunities. It's totally normal to start your adult life in a city, regardless of salary.

Secondly, London and Manchester are two massively different places in terms of living expenses - I've lived in both places and the price I paid for my three-bed house in Manchester wouldn't buy me a studio flat in London. You're not comparing like with like. 'A city' could mean Birmingham, Newcastle, Nottingham, Liverpool, Glasgow, Cardiff, Leeds... all these places are a great deal cheaper than London.

Either way, stop trying to engineer your adult child's life. It's not up to you to decide what degree they do or where they live. You're overthinking this and projecting your anxieties and life choices on to your child. It's not a good look.

AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 09:00

PonteMinchi · 31/10/2023 08:44

More information would help, OP. What is the degree? There may well be someone on here who works in the field.

Thank you. It’s theatre work, like set design. They want to do big shows like the west end etc. They haven’t yet had a go at it, so I’m encouraging them to join the local amateur groups to see if they do enjoy it, but they’re anxious at the prospect of applying.

OP posts:
Coffeerum · 31/10/2023 08:58

You're way too over invested. Regardless of what career they pursue they might want to live in a city anyway. It's not your choice.

TheYear2000 · 31/10/2023 08:57

It's much better for your child to pursue their interest and have a career they enjoy. If it doesn't work out, they can rethink. It's not the end of the world. Hopefully it will work out. Also, if they pursue this specialism and the salary can increase, what's to say they don't end up being extremely successful in their field and at the higher end of the wage spectrum?

If it's an art related course/career, have they done an Art foundation year or any relevant work experience?

AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 08:56

dicedicebaby · 31/10/2023 08:15

I have no idea why you are concerning yourself with this.

It's your dc's life, it's entirely their decision where they go to uni and what they do afterwards - you should be encouraging them to spread their wings.

Also, they can go to uni in one city and apply for jobs anywhere, they don't have to stay put.

I can’t imagine a why someone wouldn’t want to help out their child or show concern, whether they’re autistic or not.

Of course it’s their decision, I’m not planning on stopping them. I’d like them to be fully aware of what it all entails before they make a big decision though.

They’re not planning on going to uni in London, just living there afterwards.

OP posts:
sipsqueak · 31/10/2023 08:49

I would absolutely be encouraging my DC to pursue their subject of interest and to work towards living independently away from their small home town.

bryceQ · 31/10/2023 08:48

My brother has just moved to London (I've lived here 15 years) I would just say I've been shocked at the rental market. It's absolutely cut throat, he had to pay 6 months up front and they had to put deposits before doing viewings. He was on the phone to every estate agent he could and the free market sites, they pay £2700 for a three bed in a nice area. I doubt they would be able to afford to live alone. Council tax, water, electricity, gas, travel, food are very expensive.

PonteMinchi · 31/10/2023 08:44

More information would help, OP. What is the degree? There may well be someone on here who works in the field.

AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 08:40

MojoMoon · 31/10/2023 07:53

London, Manchester, etc are full of young single people starting out on their careers and living in often fairly rubbish rental flats so clearly it is completely do-able.

It is completely normal for recent graduates to live in large cities. They will live in houseshares. Flatshare somewhere is probably starting around 800quid per month in London.

Some of the flats they live in will probably be quite grotty. They'll go out lots. They'll work lots. There will be adventures. There will be rubbish bits.

It won't be a 2 bed semi with a drive but maybe that isn't the life they want to have?

Thank you for the info. £800 is a lot less than I’d have thought, so that makes me feel better. They’re quite naive and think that they’ll be in a house on their own, so I’m having to make sure they’re prepared for a flat share and the idea it may be grotty! They also hear £35000 and think that will all go in their pocket, so I need to explain rent, bills, tax, student loans etc.

My goal isn’t to keep them in our town and have a job they’re unhappy at. I want them to be happy and enjoy their job, I’d rather a happy job than a well paid job. But I also need to make sure they’re prepared. This passion has only came about in the last few months, so I’m also afraid of them changing their mind, but I have to accept that’s a possibility with any degree/apprenticeship they do. My goal of the post is to find out if that’s a lovable wage in a city.

OP posts:
Goodornot · 31/10/2023 08:38

I'd worry that as an autistic "person" (can't say he or she as you won't say) they'd never be able to move out of their comfort zone living in the same small town.

My partner is autistic spectrum and he does struggle in crowds , noise, etc. He has a job in London and nice friends.

Your DC will be OK.

Bearbookagainandagain · 31/10/2023 08:24

And also based on what you describe, I think realistically the wage isn't 35k at a new starter, that would be a very high wage for a graduate. Art fields in particular usually comes with loads of unpaid or poorly paid internships first to get experience, and first jobs are not very well paid.

35k is fine to live in London, but I don't think that what he'll get. I'm in a scientific industry and that's what we pay for juniors with a couple of years of experience.

longestlurkerever · 31/10/2023 08:23

Agree with everyone else. It's much much better for people starting out a career to be in a city. It's where the opportunities are. Once they've found their feet career wise there's more scope to negotiate terms , live further out etc if that's what they want. Though it may not be. The start of your career is not the time to worry about house prices and limit your horizons based on that.

Almondmum · 31/10/2023 08:21

Are those the only 2 cities they could work in then?

Is it the type of job that could involve hybrid work because that would enable him to live further out where it's likely to be cheaper.