Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think living in a city is too much for DC?

63 replies

AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 07:34

DC1 is applying for university. They want a job that will most likely mean they’ll need to live in a city, as there won’t be many opportunities for it. It’s a niche, arty specialism and tbh wouldn’t transfer to other jobs much, so they need to be absolutely sure that they want to do this before starting to pay for the course.

The pay is hard to find an average of, as most things say you can expect between £35000 and £85000 per year, so quite varied and I imagine will depend on experience.

Round our little town, £35000 sounds a decent wage. Houses are around £12000 for a nice semi 2 bedroomed with a drive. So DC thinks this is a good wage. However, if moving to a city such as London or Manchester, I doubt this will translate as well. I’m not sure how much accommodation would be in London, or where the areas people live in to be able to travel in to the main area. Does anyone know how much it would cost roughly for one person to rent and travel in London? Plus then there will be council tax, bills etc.

I don’t want to put them off a career they are passionate about, but I also don’t want them to have a degree that is unusable around here and not be able to afford to use it elsewhere.

YABU - let them figure it out as they go and it will all work out
YANBU - City life is too expensive for a single person to start off in a career

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pimlicopubber · 02/11/2023 07:35

I'm being vague on purpose, but while my first job out of uni looked great on paper, it was mostly about making powerpoints, meetings and negotiation skills. I hated it, so I quit and changed careers. I definitely wouldn't have done my master's in my original field had I know what the job marked would be like.

smilesup · 02/11/2023 07:29

AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 08:40

Thank you for the info. £800 is a lot less than I’d have thought, so that makes me feel better. They’re quite naive and think that they’ll be in a house on their own, so I’m having to make sure they’re prepared for a flat share and the idea it may be grotty! They also hear £35000 and think that will all go in their pocket, so I need to explain rent, bills, tax, student loans etc.

My goal isn’t to keep them in our town and have a job they’re unhappy at. I want them to be happy and enjoy their job, I’d rather a happy job than a well paid job. But I also need to make sure they’re prepared. This passion has only came about in the last few months, so I’m also afraid of them changing their mind, but I have to accept that’s a possibility with any degree/apprenticeship they do. My goal of the post is to find out if that’s a lovable wage in a city.

Honestly let them discover this all by themselves. They may strike lucky, they may not but they are adults and don't need their Mum butting in. They won't thank you for it!

pumpykins · 02/11/2023 07:28

Back off and allow them to make their own mistakes

Unlikely they will graduate snd then move back to their home town regardless of the degree

pimlicopubber · 02/11/2023 07:23

Based on what you are saying, my main concern for the job would not even be salary, but employability.
How many of the graduates actually go on to have the specific career and how many get a generic graduate job because they can't find a job in the field or just realise it's a bad career?
As a young person before university, they'll know very little of how they'll feel once they start their working life. Many people don't realise that even a career in a field you like can be 90% things you don't like (ie: making lots of phone calls and having to negotiate if you're an introvert, creating neat slides when you have ADHD or doing Excel and emails as an artistic person).

Your DC should ignore.marketing. prospects and talk to actual graduates (forums, LinkedIn, social media).
I work in tech, so I'm in a very different bubble, but have many friends with STEM degrees such as chemistry, bioengineering etc who just couldn't get work in the field - there's very few jobs. They retrained as software engineers, one is just doing an additional masters in CS. They are doing well, but say they should have just studied it from the start.
I also used to work at a retail bank and half of the credit risk team were physics PhDs who used to work at prestigious institutions such as CERN or academia and quickly realised they hate the lifestyle (super long hours, low pay, hierarchy, it's very hard to move) and went for the corporate life.
I'd personally also have done a different degree if I had known how few people actually go on to have the specific career.
I did gain transferrable skills, but I could have gained skills that would be directly applicable at my work on top of that.

AllstarFacilier · 01/11/2023 20:05

Bean83ts · 31/10/2023 21:27

So I studied costume/set and props I actually live in a small village, earning 50k plus. There’s a lot of opportunity all over the country in set/prop design, you’ll be surprised. You can work anywhere and it’s not just for theatre! Ive commissioned set and prop works for parades, leisure farms, outdoor events….all sorts and then there’s all the different types of jobs you can also do i.e teaching others, Doing carnival, doing outdoor arts which travels all over….you really do not have to work in a big city

Edited

This is really interesting, thank you! Are there any instagrams/pages they could follow that you know if in this field?

OP posts:
Bean83ts · 31/10/2023 21:27

So I studied costume/set and props I actually live in a small village, earning 50k plus. There’s a lot of opportunity all over the country in set/prop design, you’ll be surprised. You can work anywhere and it’s not just for theatre! Ive commissioned set and prop works for parades, leisure farms, outdoor events….all sorts and then there’s all the different types of jobs you can also do i.e teaching others, Doing carnival, doing outdoor arts which travels all over….you really do not have to work in a big city

mangotree6 · 31/10/2023 19:06

Step away

itsmyp4rty · 31/10/2023 19:03

OP a lot of people on here how no idea how an autistic person thinks. Cut the apron strings is just not how it works with an autistic 17 year old whose emotional maturity may be three years behind their actual age.

There's a good chance I'd guess that your YP hasn't really thought about all the long term consequences of the decisions they're going to make and are entirely focussed on the niche course that they are currently fascinated by. My advice would be to talk about all the things they need to take into consideration, do the thinking ahead for them and discuss the possible consequences of their decisions with them. When they have all the information then they can make a more fully informed decision as to what is actually likely to work best for them in the long term.

gotomomo · 31/10/2023 19:02

There are options that are in the middle price wise eg Leicester & Chichester are 2 that have good commissioning theatres who will employ people in that field.

Jcf1977 · 31/10/2023 19:02

But that’s growing up. You have to budget your finances. I was actually worse off when I started work in London because of the cost of everything but … I adjusted. Went out occasionally, take outs occasionally, and still had a blast. Your first flat sounds awful but that doesn’t mean it had to be. My first house share was with a complete knob but then I found a fab house and we had a blast. We stayed in and played cards, had bbqs, watched tv together. All starting out, all in the same boat. Amazing times. Autism is a struggle but I think living a solitary life in a small town could be more limiting overall

Goodornot · 31/10/2023 19:00

This is helicopter parenting in the extreme. They're only applying to university and OP has decided where they should live and not attempt a city.

Just let them live and make their own choices and mistakes.

MidnightOnceMore · 31/10/2023 18:51

Cities are far better for opportunities and social life. Also higher earnings.

Jcf1977 · 31/10/2023 18:49

If they can start off at 35k and work up to 85k they will be fine. Rent for a one bed flat is about 1500pcm in London travel depends but could be about 800 pcm. Much less in ManChester. On 35k that would be v manageable or he can share for less. If he lives out of a city he would have a nice first home and be able to afford a car. Choosing to live in a city it will take a few more years and he may need to carry on house sharing to start. As I did. It’s fine. Pretty fun actually, like an extension of your uni time. Everyone about his age will be in the same boat. Your earning potential in a city is much greater overall. Sounds like you maybe don’t want him to live or work in a city ? If he worked in Manchester he can commute from some of the cheapest properties in the country…?

MamaBear4ever · 31/10/2023 17:29

Manchester has a tram network and the Bee bus network you can easily live out of the city in cheaper accommodation and commute in. Lots of areas surrounding Manchester have low house prices.

Mrsttcno1 · 31/10/2023 12:27

I think budget depends on what kind of lifestyle they plan to have and how picky they are about their living situation. I ended up living in Manchester as part of my degree studies and initially was in a flat share which was £740 a month (probably will be more than this now with interest rates etc) and I absolutely hated it. Yes it was cheaper than renting alone but I couldn’t have stayed there for the full year it was awful, it was a small flat and I found sharing a small kitchen/bathroom/living area with someone I didn’t really know just didn’t work for me at all. I met a friend through work in a similar situation and we ended up finding a bigger flat and went into that just the 2 of us which was around £1750 a month (so about £875 each) which was more expensive but worth every penny for me personally because I hated my previous place. But if your DC is planning on renting alone, be prepared to be looking at probably a minimum of £1100 per month on rent.

The other thing to consider is that depending on lifestyle it can be expensive living in a city like Manchester, there’s always a bar/pub/cafe/restaurant open and 100 different takeaway options on Uber all hours of the day and night! Obviously this can be the case anywhere, but if DC has come from somewhere where this isn’t so much of a thing in a small town ( DH & I bought our house and now live up North somewhere similar) then they could easily end up spending a fortune when surrounded by all of these options, plus every night seems to be like a weekend in a lot of cities, the pubs are just as busy on a random Tuesday night as they are on a Friday!

fungibletoken · 31/10/2023 11:51

I'd be a bit dubious over the £35k-85k salary estimate. A former classmate of mine went into set design and I gather a lot of it is on a self employed basis with vary variable pay. She's been doing it for over a decade and is quite vocal on social media about it being a pursuit of passion, not a lucrative career. To give an idea, she's produced for shows in London but can't afford to live there - she lived with her family for a while and now rents close to home.

That's not to say it's won't work, but if your DC is looking for a job with steady pay and straightforward progression then it might not be the most suitable option.

InTheRainOnATrain · 31/10/2023 11:37

A relative of mine in his 20s builds sets, mostly TV and films rather than theatre. Doesn’t have a degree so no student debt but has just bought his own flat in an outer London borough which he’s modernising himself thanks to his DIY skills and will have a mate in the spare room to help with the mortgage. He got his kitchen for free after building it for a TV advert and just asking what they were doing with it afterwards! If he’s going through a quiet period, which hasn’t happened for a while, he takes on handyman/carpenter/decorating jobs mostly through word of mouth. It’s really not a bad career choice at all.

Razorcroft · 31/10/2023 11:23

AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 08:10

Sorry if I’ve confused, I must have muddled something up. If they were to stay local, they could get an apprenticeship or work in a different field. They wouldn’t be able to do the job that the degree leads to locally.

I also didn’t include my worry that they are autistic and struggle making conversation with people, and so I’m worried they’ll be very isolated elsewhere. But I also know they’d probably submerge themselves in the work and they don’t have friends at home so they wouldn’t necessarily miss out there. My concern is mostly the funding.

That was my mum’s concern- thank god I didn’t listen to her.

I feel really sorry for all of the bright working class kids who are told to think small and sensible and just focus on getting a ‘good 30k job’ and a little terraced 2 bed at aged 25. So many of those kids are in dull careers in dull towns when they could have been doing something incredible that their parents haven’t even heard of because their families couldn’t provide mental security and constantly worried about cash.

I didn’t even want to do anything arty- I am a teacher. But I moved to London straight after university. Brilliant social, educated social group in the arts and finance and politics, had an amazing social life and met my super interesting husband who would have never visited my beige little hometown. Even as ‘just a teacher’- I’ve had access to brilliant, dynamic professional development and gained so much experience from being in the capital.

Your child needs to be allowed to grow up and blossom and stretch their wings- if they are shy and quiet, all the more reason to move on to something more vibrant really.

Hbh17 · 31/10/2023 11:20

What have I just read?! A person will have SO many more opportunities in a city, and they're not all expensive places to live. Or maybe the young adult would like to live abroad?
The bottom line is that it's for the individual to decide, and absolutely nothing to do with their interfering parents!

AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 11:17

WorkingItOutAsIGo · 31/10/2023 10:16

OP it’s hard to let them grow up and make their own mistakes, and it must be even harder with a child who has autism or any other extra challenge. You’ve had helpful advice here, and the thing I most wanted to comment on is that you are focusing on I think the wrong question. This sounds like a fairly recent enthusiasm and one in which your child has no experience and isn’t prepared to apply for opportunities. I think your focus should not be on whether they will be able to afford to live in a city but on practical exposure to set design to ensure it is really what they want to apply for.

Thanks, yes this is also a concern, but I don’t want to discourage something that they’re enthusiastic about. We’ll try and get the ball rolling with some amateur experience to see if they really do enjoy it. Whilst it’s not the end of the world to study something and then not continue in it, university is so expensive and so I do think they need to have a good idea of whether it’s right before they have to pay for it.

OP posts:
AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 11:14

NotLactoseFree · 31/10/2023 10:12

Theatre work is work that can be done in cities and large towns all over the place, so that's actually quite good from that perspective. In terms of pay, I think it would vary massively and I suspect that to start, it would be pretty dire.

I also think a general course studying set design is not a bad thing - DH worked in theatre and while he was a performer, his friends from that time were less likely to be the other performers and more likely to be the backstage teams. I can tell you that within theatres, backstage teams are hugely varied and there are options to move around. Set design itself is often done elsewhere and a friend worked for a company that did set design - he was an engineer and was hired to help them with things like designing the way sets moved around the stage, or made things fly. He did a lot of work on sets for cruise ships in fact and at one point spent a few months in the far east overseeing the build of a set on a cruise ship there.

My point is that there's quite a lot of variety and it's not a bad thing to do. Most of DH's friends from those days are not still in theatre - the hours aren't particularly family friendly if you work in theatre itself, but there are related jobs and transferable skills.

This is really reassuring, thank you so much. The cruise information is particularly interesting, I think that’s something they’d be excited to know!

OP posts:
WorkingItOutAsIGo · 31/10/2023 10:16

OP it’s hard to let them grow up and make their own mistakes, and it must be even harder with a child who has autism or any other extra challenge. You’ve had helpful advice here, and the thing I most wanted to comment on is that you are focusing on I think the wrong question. This sounds like a fairly recent enthusiasm and one in which your child has no experience and isn’t prepared to apply for opportunities. I think your focus should not be on whether they will be able to afford to live in a city but on practical exposure to set design to ensure it is really what they want to apply for.

NotLactoseFree · 31/10/2023 10:12

Theatre work is work that can be done in cities and large towns all over the place, so that's actually quite good from that perspective. In terms of pay, I think it would vary massively and I suspect that to start, it would be pretty dire.

I also think a general course studying set design is not a bad thing - DH worked in theatre and while he was a performer, his friends from that time were less likely to be the other performers and more likely to be the backstage teams. I can tell you that within theatres, backstage teams are hugely varied and there are options to move around. Set design itself is often done elsewhere and a friend worked for a company that did set design - he was an engineer and was hired to help them with things like designing the way sets moved around the stage, or made things fly. He did a lot of work on sets for cruise ships in fact and at one point spent a few months in the far east overseeing the build of a set on a cruise ship there.

My point is that there's quite a lot of variety and it's not a bad thing to do. Most of DH's friends from those days are not still in theatre - the hours aren't particularly family friendly if you work in theatre itself, but there are related jobs and transferable skills.

AllstarFacilier · 31/10/2023 10:02

MojoMoon · 31/10/2023 09:27

I can see why you are concerned but would suggest that the cost of living in a city in a few years time should not really be the main one right now.

I agree with a PP that set design is a challenging, insecure career and requires working as part of a team under tight time and budget pressures. It requires excellent social skills, flexibility and resilience.

It sounds like your teenager has a dream but I think it would be a challenging career for an autistic person who you say doesn't really like socializing so I will assume isn't great with people.

They should apply for this work experience placement - deadline is 4 Dec so get cracking. There are online workshops if they can't get to Manchester, London or Nottingham
https://www.nationaltheatre.org.uk/learn-explore/young-people/young-technicians/

There are also apprenticeship schemes that would be cheaper than doing a degree

https://www.roh.org.uk/learning/young-people/apprenticeships/the-scheme

https://www.rsc.org.uk/jobs/where-do-i-fit-in/apprenticeships

Thanks so much for this, it’s really helpful and kind! I’ll pass the links on to DC.

I’m not going to respond to comments about cutting apron strings or it being none of my business as that’s not advice that is needed when people don’t know my child’s capabilities. I’d love for them to be more independent, and we’re working on skills in preparation for university such as transport. They’d be fine being told which number bus to go on if we trialled it a few times, but if the bus was ever cancelled then they’d need to learn to be resilient and of course I want to help them with that.

Someone mentioned other cities, and DC is angling towards London because of the West End, however we went to see a show in Manchester this year so that opened that possibility up. We could maybe do a few city visits in order for them to see what they like about each place.

OP posts:
PinkRoses1245 · 31/10/2023 10:01

YABU. They don't need to buy a house immediately. Encourage them to pursue their interests, and broaden their horizons. And it is none of your business, now they're an adult.