Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who actually benefits from changing the clocks?

593 replies

shockwaze · 31/10/2023 06:13

Kids up at 5:30. Pretty sure that the same thing has happened in many, many houses this morning.

It's just an hour, but so disruptive to children.

Who benefits? Winds me up every year.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
CreeperBoom · 31/10/2023 08:14

Everyone in the North of the country benefits, and it doesn't really harm anyone in the south apart from moaning about changing the clocks twice per year.

Even if the clocks didn't go back, it will be dark by evening rush hour for most of the country by December. But if they didn't go back, it would also be dark until after 9 in the North.

Lots of people wouldn't see daylight all week, and kids would arrive at school in the dark. There is evidence about the reduction in traffic accidents - it does save lives.

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/10/2023 08:12

AmandasFleckerl · 31/10/2023 06:41

Every year as my dad is changing the clock in the kitchen he complains claiming that it’s only done for the benefit of schoolchildren in Scotland.

Tell him it's the north too.

Icopewhenihope · 31/10/2023 08:12

Well it suits me just fine, I love it and guess what? The exact same thing will happen next year at the exact same time. Love the dark evenings, bring it on!

Ineedaholiday23 · 31/10/2023 08:11

2pm? 4 pm in northern Scotland!

GRex · 31/10/2023 08:11

Pooooochi · 31/10/2023 08:01

Please explain what exactly you think prevents a farmer from getting up at 5.30 in summer and 6.30 in winter, if they feel those are the best working hours for their farm.

Farm land tends to be in rural locations where there is next to no lighting whatsoever. No street lighting and no access to mains electricity to run any.

Imagine trying to check your crop for a deadly fungus in pitch black, or repair fences.

The point is to align the timing of the (limited) hours of light we have in mid winter, with the working day

Good lord, urea like pulling teeth. Nobody is preventing the farmer from leaving their own house an hour later.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/10/2023 08:11

Do you ever go on holiday somewhere with a different time zone?

it’s annoying for a couple of days but then they adjust and there have been studies/trials and for now it’s been decided that there is more benefits to changing the clocks than not. Maybe not for you personally but it’s about what’s best for society as a whole rather than one individual.

grottyb · 31/10/2023 08:11

@Stroopwaffels thats not my sisters experience, perhaps it’s different depending on location. And it’s common for secondaries to finish at 2pm?

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 31/10/2023 08:10

It benefits me! I love daylight saving and the long evenings in summer. As do many other people. At the end of summer I'm quite happy to have the clocks go back again. I'm not in the UK but surely you have just gone back to "normal" time?

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/10/2023 08:10

shockwaze · 31/10/2023 06:28

They'll be walking home in the dark anyway. Makes no difference

It does because kids are more alert if they haven't just got up.

The accident stats from the trial proved that.

curaçao · 31/10/2023 08:10

shockwaze · 31/10/2023 06:28

They'll be walking home in the dark anyway. Makes no difference

Schools tend to finish before the hump of tge rush hour, whereas most people startbwirk around tge sane time school starts.
The clocks goung back is lovely for most people as tgey get an extra hour in bed.

grottyb · 31/10/2023 08:09

It's funny seeing some "super mums" dishing out parenting advice on these sort of threads. Just goes to show some people have absolutely no idea how easy their children are in some respects compared to others and show no insight into the fact that's often down to luck rather than judgment.

One of my dc woke early regardless of the clocks changing!

Pooooochi · 31/10/2023 08:09

Spain a couple of weeks ago, which is geographically in the wrong time zone. It should be on the same as the UK, Portugal and Ireland but aligns with France and Germany etc. It was a bit weird that it was still dark while 8.30 am, but the big advantage was that it was light in the evening until about 8 pm, so much better for being out and about then, when more people have time to do so.

Spain is a much hotter country than the uk. This means they have a cultural practice of sleeping during the mid afternoon when its too hot to go, and staying up later in the cooler evenings. Its also further south, so they don't have the very short winter days we have in the north of the uk.

This pattern does not make sense in the uk where its cooler and we need to make use of the daytime weather.

Stroopwaffels · 31/10/2023 08:09

I think the Spanish school day ends much later & school bus services are more of a thing then here.

No - Spanish schools start earlier (8am - 8.30am) and finish around 2.

Willyoujustbequiet · 31/10/2023 08:08

instaready · 31/10/2023 06:27

Scotland benefits. Kids would be waking to school in the dark otherwise.

It's not just Scotland.

Parts of England are actually further north than parts of Scotland.

ShatteredPeace · 31/10/2023 08:08

Edinburgh is 100% not south west of Bristol. It is north west of Bristol.

fetchacloth · 31/10/2023 08:08

Energy companies gain massively. Lights have to go on earlier and so does the heating 😩

In these financially constrained times it's about time we resurrected the idea of BST all year round or even double BST.

Brumbies · 31/10/2023 08:07

People like you OP puss me off, it's all me me me

Itsbritneybitch22 · 31/10/2023 08:05

Why do people do posts like this asking a question then get the answer and are like no because of this or ‘fuck them’.

Its not people’s opinions OP it’s literally what people are answering for your question, the OP updates read like a teenage girl .. yea but 😅

grottyb · 31/10/2023 08:05

I was in Spain a couple of weeks ago, which is geographically in the wrong time zone. It should be on the same as the UK, Portugal and Ireland but aligns with France and Germany etc. It was a bit weird that it was still dark while 8.30 am, but the big advantage was that it was light in the evening until about 8 pm, so much better for being out and about then, when more people have time to do so.

I think the Spanish school day ends much later & school bus services are more of a thing then here.

ShatteredPeace · 31/10/2023 08:04

It's not to benefit school children or farmers or anyone else. It's now back on GMT. It's just the time. BST was brought in to allow people and extra hour of sunlight in the evening as the government of 1916 felt it would reduce the demand for coal.

Yes, the lack of daylight feels tough but the long light days we get in the north are the other side of the coin. And what a beautiful morning it is today.

Pooooochi · 31/10/2023 08:04

I see all these parents moan that their kid gets up at 6am....now 5am but why put them to bed so early? They need 12 hours sleep or if 8 years old between 10 and 12 hours so time their bedtime for when you want them to get up. If you want your kid to get up at 7am but them to bed 7pm. My kid always went to bed at 8pm and got up 8am. Never in my life did they get up early.

Many children (and adults) have stronger body clocks/circadian rhythms. I kept my DS up 2 hours late on clock change night, he still woke up at exactly the same (old) time that he always does. I did too.

I can go to bed very very late and still wake without an alarm at 6.30am. I did a couple of weeks ago - i only got in at 3, and woke with no alarm etc at 6.30am. Normally I'd go to bed at 10.30/11!

Maxus · 31/10/2023 08:04

shockwaze · 31/10/2023 07:56

Oh @saffy2

Hardly nonsensical, I'm yet to be convinced it helps anyone. No one here has the answer.

I'm posting between bathing my two cherubs as well. I do apologise.

In parts of the country it stops kids going to school in the dark, esp secondary kids who often get buses at 7.30 am. There, thats your answer right there .

BCCoach · 31/10/2023 08:02

Zanatdy · 31/10/2023 07:56

Farmers and school kids, if you didn’t return the clocks to GMT then kids in Scotland would be walking to school in the pitch black. I think it’s better to put them back and deal with the early dark evenings than kids going to school in the dark

So why put them forward in summer in the first place?

Whoknows101 · 31/10/2023 08:02

It's funny seeing some "super mums" dishing out parenting advice on these sort of threads. Just goes to show some people have absolutely no idea how easy their children are in some respects compared to others and show no insight into the fact that's often down to luck rather than judgment.

If we put out nr 4 y/o daughter to bed an hour "late" she'll wake up at the exact same time as normal, but be an over-tired mess by the evening. If we try the same again that night, she won't sleep properly because she's gone absolutely beserk with tiredness, and wake up even earlier than normal, not later!

It takes her about 2 weeks to adjust to each clock change in terms of being an over tired mess, and about 1-2 months to start waking up at the previous "normal time." And that's with using a sleep clock etc, incrementally later bedtimes etc and every other trick we can think of to get her to wake up a bit later. So it's 5:30 for us for the foreseeable future, 6am in a few weeks then finally (hopefully!) back to 6:30 in a month or so. Worse things have happened but it feels totally uncessary to be doing this every year.

I used to love these extra hours in bed pre children, but with young kids they are an absolutely enormous PITA!

gotomomo · 31/10/2023 08:01

Mine too @Luckyduc I don't get it, plus I'm sure many of the moaners go abroad.

My dc travelled long haul (work, it's complicated) and had to adjust to -8hrs 2-3 times a year which they managed, 1 hour is nothing

Swipe left for the next trending thread