Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“women and children” in war

166 replies

Diolchynfawr · 30/10/2023 15:00

Just catching up with Any Questions on R4. Much talk of ‘women and children’ being bombed in Gaza, and who were slaughtered on October 7th.

Laying aside one for one moment (if such a thing is possible) the appalling horror and tragedy of the current situation, I can’t quite pinpoint how I feel about this little snippet of rhetoric.

My first response is to feel as though I’ve been transported back to an era when women, like children, where kept and cared for by men. I hear echoes of the Titanic and cries of ‘save the women and children’. Sort of feels regressive in this day and age, why not speak of civilians, or of ‘children, the elderly and infirm’, if wanting to highlight the plight of the vulnerable?

In the next moment I’m reflecting on how it must feel to be a young man these days, to hear outcry at the death of women and children, but little said about fathers and brothers. I wonder if it is any coincidence that it is young men who are shooting and stabbing each other in our inner cities, and what the value our society places on their lives.

Not really an AIBU, but what do you think? Should ‘women and children’ still be a phrase we use today and why/why not?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Coffeerum · 31/10/2023 06:44

Of course women start and escalate wars.
Only recently there was a documentary of an IRA terrorist who was a woman.
No doubt the posters who spout this think female suicide bombers are pressured and don’t want to do it but don’t think the same applies to men.
It’s a really odd statement that it’s fine for all the men, who largely are very young, are caught up in war because a privileged few have the power to make decisions like war.
What does a conscripted 18 year old have to do with the person who orders a city to be bombed into oblivion?

JanglyBeads · 31/10/2023 05:32

99%of the posts here are missing the point: as @Rudderneck and one or two others have said, it means "groups who are definitely not soldiers".

Didn't click on the link recently posted but I imagine v few of Hamas fighters are female?

Pinkflamingopants · 31/10/2023 05:11

Men shouldn’t start wars if they want their lives to be considered valuable. After the images of raped women coming out of Israel I’m not surprised people are concerned about what’s happening to women and children.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 31/10/2023 04:43

Its recognition of the heinous female specific tortures. Did you not see that Irish guy celebrating when his 8 year old daughter was found dead rather than captured? He honestly believed it to be the kindest, safest option for his baby.

WandaWonder · 31/10/2023 04:07

Children yes absolutely is a separate thing but I am sick of this women are more precious than men thing

And yes I am a woman

Mouldyfoodhelp · 31/10/2023 03:38

So we should discount Thatcher and Co because they are the exception to the rule but not discount Putin and the like? Posters are essentially saying its fair for men to die because something like 0.000001% of men on the earth have the power to (and do) start wars in which other men are often forced to fight and die/risk their lives which posters don't like but also are disregarding the lives of those that don't fight because of the actions taken by 10s/ 100s of men in a population of billions.

And yes I know there'll be more that rape women and that's unacceptable but it doesn't make others lives forfeit

Fionaville · 31/10/2023 02:13

Considering we don't see many women on the streets fighting or at the forefront of terrorist groups, I think its a fair phrase to use.

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 00:43

I do think “women and children” is outdated. It should be switched to “civilians and children” to count deaths of non-combatants.

Both IDF and Hamas have female combatants and leaders. Our female physical limits are pretty much null and void when you’re using advanced weaponry. https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/defense-news/article-769134

Squad of female IDF combat troops eliminated nearly 100 Hamas terrorists

Lt.-Col. Or Ben Yehuda, Caracal Battalion, praises her troops' bravery against Hamas, silencing doubts about female combat soldiers with their training, heroism, and life-saving actions.

https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/defense-news/article-769134

Trulywonderful · 31/10/2023 00:23

That is am interesting question op

Firstly women fight in wars too these days (both Hamas and Israel have female fighters) definitely not as many as men. However why do we assume all women lost in conflict are helpless little housewives. It is a very old fashioned view because even in places where women cannot fight officially they may be near the war zone doing other work to help.

Secondly we in the west have a very different view of childhood compared to other places around the world. We view childhood as up to the age of 18. In some parts of the world children work fra very young age, though I would argue they are still children. However a working 17 year old with a wife and two kids is still classed as a child under western views and the UN children's rights act. I think some us us would argue that this 17 year old should be counted as a man. However it really is a grey area.

Totalblindnessofthesoul · 31/10/2023 00:15

I don't think it's sexism/1950s thinking so much as shorthand for innocent people. The vast majority of Hamas operatives will be adult men.

In saying that 70% are women and children, they mean at least 70% of those killed are innocents. Most men will be too, but any 'legitimate targets' that Israel is going after are likely to be within the adult male demographic.

Tempnamechng · 31/10/2023 00:09

Perhaps the term is old fashioned, but is old fashioned always bad?
I think the term is more of a catch all for the cared for, vulnerable, and their carers. Equality doesn't come into it, if there is a scramble for survival it'll be the strongest who survive, and 90% of the time this will mean the men. The "save the women and children" catch all tries to ensure that the less physically strong are also given a chance.
We also know that life for unprotected women and girls under Jihadist rule is pure hell.

Edinburghmusing · 30/10/2023 23:55

Women are more vulnerable in war. Denying that helps no one.

But that does not mean that therefore women should have less social, political or economic power in general. The problem is when less physical strength is equated with social, political and economic strength.

MariaLuna · 30/10/2023 23:51

Women and children never start or escalate these wars do they?

Children no, not, of course.

Women can and do. Heard of Margaret Thatcher? Falklands war.

Kind of feeds into the question, who owns which land where people live.

Brit empire fucked up Palestine too.

Don't see Rishi dealing with it. Of course, he comes from the very empire it spawned, he's just taking care of his gazillions...

DeeCee77 · 30/10/2023 23:29

Daffodilwoman · 30/10/2023 23:10

In a nutshell it’s always men who cause the wars. Always.
Personally I think it’s fine for women to join the military.
Doesn’t change the fact that almost all that is bad in the world is a result of nasty men.

As PM of Israel Golda Meir (that's a woman btw) rejected a peace agreement in 1971 that would have seen the pre 1967 borders reinstated.

"When the committee (formed by Meir) unanimously concluded that Israel's interests would be served by full withdrawal to the internationally recognized lines dividing Israel from Egypt and Syria, returning the Gaza Strip and, in a majority view, returning most of the West Bank and East Jerusalem, Meir was angered and shelved the document. The United States was infuriated by the cool Israeli response to Egypt's proposal, and Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs Joseph Sisco informed Israeli ambassador Yitzhak Rabin that "Israel would be regarded responsible for rejecting the best opportunity to reach peace since the establishment of the state."

No one individual is responsible for the conflict, but no question she is one of the prime reasons it has gone on this long.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/10/2023 23:20

HerculesMulligan · 30/10/2023 15:06

In some places, including Gaza, women and children have far fewer choices than their adult male relatives.

I think this is important.

I do generally say “civilians”, but it’s also important that women as a class don’t have much say in what happens in Gaza

VeniVidiWeeWee · 30/10/2023 23:16

Daffodilwoman · 30/10/2023 23:10

In a nutshell it’s always men who cause the wars. Always.
Personally I think it’s fine for women to join the military.
Doesn’t change the fact that almost all that is bad in the world is a result of nasty men.

Also wrong. Please educate yourself really recent studies.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 30/10/2023 23:15

whowhy · 30/10/2023 15:51

Women and children never start or escalate these wars do they? They are nearly always victims who get caught up in the midst of it all. If Netanyahu and his govt or Hamas were female, would all this be going on? No.

Wrong. Please educate yourself. Google will help.

alrighthen · 30/10/2023 23:11

It’s been bothering me too! Feels really 1950s. As though we women are weak and childlike and need special protection. I mean, it doesn’t matter if I’m 5’3 or 6’4 if my hospital is bombed or someone shoots at me.

And yes, the implication is that the loss of an 18 year old male’s life is somehow less sad than a 60 year old woman’s. It makes no sense to me and I find it a bit offensive.

Daffodilwoman · 30/10/2023 23:10

In a nutshell it’s always men who cause the wars. Always.
Personally I think it’s fine for women to join the military.
Doesn’t change the fact that almost all that is bad in the world is a result of nasty men.

Rudderneck · 30/10/2023 23:02

Spendonsend · 30/10/2023 16:47

To be fair my view is somewhat based on having two female ukrainians living with us, whilst the husband/dad is not living with us, but is in ukraine. And thinking its a bit shit for him. But i guess if they were also in ukraine it would be even shitter which is why they left.

Isn't part of the issue WHY the men are still there?

Why is it that they expect men to stay and fight for the country, but women and children are being sent to safety?

Sexism? Or something else?

HvalaALot · 30/10/2023 19:42

But ask yourself who is using the phrase “women and children” and why? It is not people who necessarily care about women and children but people who want to garner sympathy and using the phrase “women and children” is an internationally recognised sign meant to indicate innocent civilians.

If only men would admit their own vulnerability. There isn’t a definite point at which a vulnerable child turns into an invincible child. It is not women (or rather mothers) pushing this narrative because WE all know and love our sons for the vulnerable creatures they are.

Doingtheboxerbeat · 30/10/2023 19:30

I think of the impracticalities of having to change my pad + tampon every couple of hours because of my flawed physiology - this is just one of the challenges without having children .
I always see men in the streets of Gaza in most of the coverage, there's a reason for that.

PixiePirate · 30/10/2023 18:54

I do kind of agree, and have thought similar myself over the last few weeks. On the other hand, I am so sick of men starting wars and women and girls being raped and traumatised.

Memememestillme · 30/10/2023 18:10

These women are the exception not the rule, and seem to be held to a much higher standard than men in similar positions.

Jesus of course they're the exception. But then warmongering men like Putin are also the exception.

Weefreetiffany · 30/10/2023 18:05

DeeCee77 · 30/10/2023 17:56

Golda Meir rejected the best chance of peace that region has had since the modern state of Israel came in to being.

She also said Palestinians don't exist.

And Thatcher, she wasn't exactly shy when it came to what to do in the Falklands was she? (even though she was correct). She also allowed the US access to Royal Air Force bases when they bombed Libya, with The Sunday Times releasing a story by the Queen that she was an "uncaring" Prime Minister.

These women are the exception not the rule, and seem to be held to a much higher standard than men in similar positions.

the existence of Margaret thatcher means FA to the experience of a civilian woman in a war zone.

We know women are just as intelligent and capable as men. We can resist and fight. However each native population of women and men is socialised and politicised differently to think of sex, individual and group. For every gun toting Zapatista there is a woman who has been told she cannot say no to men. This is about physical domination and power situations where you are being attacked in a war zone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread