Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“women and children” in war

166 replies

Diolchynfawr · 30/10/2023 15:00

Just catching up with Any Questions on R4. Much talk of ‘women and children’ being bombed in Gaza, and who were slaughtered on October 7th.

Laying aside one for one moment (if such a thing is possible) the appalling horror and tragedy of the current situation, I can’t quite pinpoint how I feel about this little snippet of rhetoric.

My first response is to feel as though I’ve been transported back to an era when women, like children, where kept and cared for by men. I hear echoes of the Titanic and cries of ‘save the women and children’. Sort of feels regressive in this day and age, why not speak of civilians, or of ‘children, the elderly and infirm’, if wanting to highlight the plight of the vulnerable?

In the next moment I’m reflecting on how it must feel to be a young man these days, to hear outcry at the death of women and children, but little said about fathers and brothers. I wonder if it is any coincidence that it is young men who are shooting and stabbing each other in our inner cities, and what the value our society places on their lives.

Not really an AIBU, but what do you think? Should ‘women and children’ still be a phrase we use today and why/why not?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Bluesea123 · 01/11/2023 11:23

I’m sick of hearing women and children too. There are only some men who are choosing war, the rest are gravely impacted by it and will suffer trauma the rest of their lives.
and my goodness it annoys me about mothers of only daughters who somehow feel superior that they would not have to send their daughters to fight. It’s not 1914

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/11/2023 11:22

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 30/10/2023 15:15

I think it depends on how you choose to interpret it.

For me any loss of life is appalling. Regardless of age or sex .

I am also very aware of the fact they physically many women and pretty much all kids are highly vulnerable in conflict in a way men are not. Due to their sex and/or age.

Rape and trafficking is still a actual weapon of war.

Please read "The War on Women " if you still believe this narrative is sexist and outdated.

This.

Yabu OP not to acknowledge that it's women and children who suffer disproportionately in times such as this.

Women are 2nd class citizens to begin with in Gaza and their suffering is amplified now at the hands of men. Its always men.

vivainsomnia · 01/11/2023 11:21

I totally agree with you OP. If we want equality for women, it has to be for the better and say the worse.

There seems to be a vision that by virtue of their sex, men are supportive war and fighting when the majority are as distressed by it all as women.

Some also seem to forget that many women have joined the forces in Israel.

Sanguinello · 01/11/2023 11:20

YaWeeFurryBastard · 30/10/2023 15:40

In the next moment I’m reflecting on how it must feel to be a young man these days, to hear outcry at the death of women and children, but little said about fathers and brothers. I wonder if it is any coincidence that it is young men who are shooting and stabbing each other in our inner cities, and what the value our society places on their lives.

Men have been shooting and stabbing each other since the dawn of time and it’s precisely fuck all to do with how “valued” they feel, especially when for millennia men have been far more value to society than women.

Women are particularly vulnerable in times of war as they are almost always physically weaker and often caring for vulnerable children. They are also susceptible to sexually motivated war crimes in a way men are not. This is particularly true in areas of the Middle East where many women are controlled by the male members of their family and don’t have full access to money etc. Nobody is saying it’s not sad when men die, but very very clearly women and children are a more vulnerable group. I find it astounding anyone can think otherwise and I’m getting thoroughly sick of the “poor menz” attitude.

I agree with this

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 11:16

Iwasafool · 31/10/2023 22:33

UK went to war with Argentina when we had a female PM and a female head of state. We were attacked though.

The Falklands War would have been excluded by the study. I think though that the numerous invasions & colonisations under Queen Victoria would have been included.

EtiennePalmiere · 31/10/2023 22:40

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 22:37

I really do not understand the hyper focus on rape.

It is one of many forms of torture. Girls/boys, men/women are all vulnerable to torture by enemy soldiers. Combatants captured, whether male or female are also vulnerable to torture including rape (Abu Grahib?, Guantanamo?).

So the females can be raped argument doesn’t wash for me as to why casualties are listed as a total with this many women and children. The only guaranteed non-combatant innocents are children in my opinion. Adults should be split into civilian non-combatants and combatants (soldiers), not by male or female because that is based on traditional and outdated sex roles.

With apologies to @marmaladeandpeanutbutter, that's the dumbest thing I've ever heard in my life.

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 22:37

I really do not understand the hyper focus on rape.

It is one of many forms of torture. Girls/boys, men/women are all vulnerable to torture by enemy soldiers. Combatants captured, whether male or female are also vulnerable to torture including rape (Abu Grahib?, Guantanamo?).

So the females can be raped argument doesn’t wash for me as to why casualties are listed as a total with this many women and children. The only guaranteed non-combatant innocents are children in my opinion. Adults should be split into civilian non-combatants and combatants (soldiers), not by male or female because that is based on traditional and outdated sex roles.

Iwasafool · 31/10/2023 22:33

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 14:22

There was a study that concluded women rulers are just as likely as men rulers to start wars. They excluded wars where the woman ruler had been attacked by an aggressor. Of course it won’t be an even number because so few women have been rulers. But likelihood relates to the odds of whether your country will start a war is about the same whether you are ruled by a man or a woman.

UK went to war with Argentina when we had a female PM and a female head of state. We were attacked though.

Iwasafool · 31/10/2023 22:30

YaWeeFurryBastard · 30/10/2023 15:40

In the next moment I’m reflecting on how it must feel to be a young man these days, to hear outcry at the death of women and children, but little said about fathers and brothers. I wonder if it is any coincidence that it is young men who are shooting and stabbing each other in our inner cities, and what the value our society places on their lives.

Men have been shooting and stabbing each other since the dawn of time and it’s precisely fuck all to do with how “valued” they feel, especially when for millennia men have been far more value to society than women.

Women are particularly vulnerable in times of war as they are almost always physically weaker and often caring for vulnerable children. They are also susceptible to sexually motivated war crimes in a way men are not. This is particularly true in areas of the Middle East where many women are controlled by the male members of their family and don’t have full access to money etc. Nobody is saying it’s not sad when men die, but very very clearly women and children are a more vulnerable group. I find it astounding anyone can think otherwise and I’m getting thoroughly sick of the “poor menz” attitude.

And the men who were abducted by IDS soldiers, stripped and abused and one reported sexual assault. Possible that more were sexually assaulted but reluctant to admit it?
I'm not sure on the relevance of being physically weaker if you are blown up or shot.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 31/10/2023 22:24

EtiennePalmiere · 30/10/2023 15:35

Do you know how rape works ?

Do you know how good manners on social media works?

lljkk · 31/10/2023 21:47

It's short-hand for non-combatants, but more human way of saying it. Could also say "The Very young, disabled, very old and their carers" but that's more words.

EtiennePalmiere · 31/10/2023 21:42

gannett · 31/10/2023 15:34

I suggest you read up on war crimes in Bosnia and Rwanda, for starters, if you think men aren't susceptible to rape and sexual assault in war.

The key phrase here is "in a way that men are not." Men are certainly victims in war, most recently in Ukraine there have been men who are victims of rape, although I'm not sure about Israel/Hamas.

However, it cannot be compared to the sheer scale of rape that women are subjected to, everyone knows this.

gannett · 31/10/2023 15:38

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 14:22

There was a study that concluded women rulers are just as likely as men rulers to start wars. They excluded wars where the woman ruler had been attacked by an aggressor. Of course it won’t be an even number because so few women have been rulers. But likelihood relates to the odds of whether your country will start a war is about the same whether you are ruled by a man or a woman.

In my opinion it's power, and the kind of person who seeks power, that's correlated to warmongering. And as you say far fewer women have been in power throughout history so there's no substantial data set to compare to men who start wars.

I would note that most male warmongerers have had high-profile women backing them to the hilt. Would I feel more comfortable if Margarita Simonyan was the Russian president instead of Putin? Or if Lauren Boebert or Sarah Palin had been president instead of Trump? Or if, heaven forfend, Suella Braverman was our PM? Would I hell.

gannett · 31/10/2023 15:34

YaWeeFurryBastard · 30/10/2023 15:40

In the next moment I’m reflecting on how it must feel to be a young man these days, to hear outcry at the death of women and children, but little said about fathers and brothers. I wonder if it is any coincidence that it is young men who are shooting and stabbing each other in our inner cities, and what the value our society places on their lives.

Men have been shooting and stabbing each other since the dawn of time and it’s precisely fuck all to do with how “valued” they feel, especially when for millennia men have been far more value to society than women.

Women are particularly vulnerable in times of war as they are almost always physically weaker and often caring for vulnerable children. They are also susceptible to sexually motivated war crimes in a way men are not. This is particularly true in areas of the Middle East where many women are controlled by the male members of their family and don’t have full access to money etc. Nobody is saying it’s not sad when men die, but very very clearly women and children are a more vulnerable group. I find it astounding anyone can think otherwise and I’m getting thoroughly sick of the “poor menz” attitude.

I suggest you read up on war crimes in Bosnia and Rwanda, for starters, if you think men aren't susceptible to rape and sexual assault in war.

sollenwir · 31/10/2023 14:36

I'd honestly prefer they used the term adults and children (and in war situations children would definitely be up to 18 and not 16, and if in doubt of exact age then err toward them being children). I have also heard a lot of 'men are the ones who cause wars' sort of statements, but there have been a lot of evil women over the centuries too.

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 14:22

Daffodilwoman · 31/10/2023 07:39

For all those saying women have started as many wars as men, please name all the wars. Then we can tot up your scores against those atrocities started by men.

There was a study that concluded women rulers are just as likely as men rulers to start wars. They excluded wars where the woman ruler had been attacked by an aggressor. Of course it won’t be an even number because so few women have been rulers. But likelihood relates to the odds of whether your country will start a war is about the same whether you are ruled by a man or a woman.

Rudderneck · 31/10/2023 09:37

I think people are missing what is probably the most basic point here. I asked up-thread - why in the Ukrainian conflict, are women and children allowed to leave, but men aren't?

It's not just that women and children are more vulnerable. And it isn't just that men like fighting and are war-mongers, or that they aren't scared and even vulnerable. Being captured and tortured isn't really that much better for men, and it's not like systematic rape of male soldiers isn't a thing too.

The fact is that the reason Ukrainian men are not allowed to leave, is that this is seen as a dereliction of their duty to fight to protect their people. If they are a member of the state, claim its care and name and citizenship, they are considered to have a moral duty to protect it when the chips are down. Not duck out and run and leave others, some professional fighting force, to do the work for them.

We aren't so used to this thinking in the west, but the legal capacity to enforce this kind of thing where circumstances warrant exists here too. And historically when things get that bad, people have very strong feelings about people who try and get out of that kind of duty.

The role of women has never been seen as the same, and it's mainly because women are mothers. Without mothers, there is not a people to fight for, their is no future existence. So yes, we do see occasional women who directly fight, particularly ones without children. And along with caring for children, women often are the ones who keep the infrastructure going, which is in a way a similar role.

In a total war where people want to really wipe out the enemy, or subjugate them, they are not going to just want to kill soldiers. They want to subjugate the future as well, the women and kids. A conflict where that is going on is particularly nasty. It's not a "professional" war with neat political boundaries, the stakes are their existence as a people, as a nation state with an identity.

That's the kind of conflict going on in Israel and Palestine, and between Ukraine and Russia. It's not neat, and can't be, as far as those involved are concerned the stakes are too high. And under those circumstances you see a very basic division in the role of the sexes emerge. Neat professional wars are actually the exception.

RiderofRohan · 31/10/2023 08:25

It was largely men who attacked the concert and the homes of civilians. It was largely men who killed, tortured and kidnapped Israeli citizens.

And it's largely men who are ordering the bombardment of Gaza, the totalling of homes despite the catastrophic loss of human life and refusing a ceasefire.

The phrase 'women and children' stands for a reason.

TintinHadToBeMale · 31/10/2023 07:53

Men have been shooting and stabbing each other since the dawn of time and it’s precisely fuck all to do with how “valued” they feel, especially when for millennia men have been far more value to society than women.

This. In fact, my impression is that when men are more valued that’s when brutality increases. When brutality increases, men are more valued. Perhaps it’s the knowledge and experience of treating an entire population like dirt that enables and trains them to practice on their own. Men gain from a society with decent ethics

PurpleWisteria1 · 31/10/2023 07:45

Women and children are physically weaker. Most can’t fight off a man trying to rape, kill or kidnap them, even if they have a weapon.
That’s literally it. Women get out in the vulnerable category with children and elderly because we are.

Daffodilwoman · 31/10/2023 07:45

Hmmmm looking at those attacking the plane that landed yesterday, yes the baying crowds were all women weren’t they. Every single one was a woman wanting to kill Jews.
Oh sorry no, it’s the other way round I didn’t see one female, the baying mob was predominantly male. The females I saw were staff begging the mob to please stop.
Of course there are women terrorists/ freedom fights/military personnel, so what?
Again prove to me that the majority of wars and violent crimes are committed by women.

cushhhonhed · 31/10/2023 07:41

WandaWonder · 31/10/2023 04:07

Children yes absolutely is a separate thing but I am sick of this women are more precious than men thing

And yes I am a woman

You've missed the point completely. It's about vulnerability not importance.

Daffodilwoman · 31/10/2023 07:39

For all those saying women have started as many wars as men, please name all the wars. Then we can tot up your scores against those atrocities started by men.

notimagain · 31/10/2023 07:34

Not that I'm a fan of Thatcher but seeing as here name keeps popping up I suspect some don't have a scooby do about what led to the Falklands conflcit.

Ironically if the Thatcher administration had appeared more warmongering in late 81, early 82 it's highly possible the Argentine Junta wouldn't have made the decision to invade the Islands.

FinallyFinalGirl · 31/10/2023 07:06

Are people actually pointing to ONE woman - Thatcher - as some kind of evidence that women are as warmongering as men? We all know who causes almost all the violence in this world so why some women insist on pretending otherwise, is beyond me.

These are men's wars and women and children are ALWAYS the innocent victims. Always. You cannot say the same for men.

And if your first thought, when hearing about the torture and murder of women and children is to feel sorry for MEN, then I have nothing to say to you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread