Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“women and children” in war

166 replies

Diolchynfawr · 30/10/2023 15:00

Just catching up with Any Questions on R4. Much talk of ‘women and children’ being bombed in Gaza, and who were slaughtered on October 7th.

Laying aside one for one moment (if such a thing is possible) the appalling horror and tragedy of the current situation, I can’t quite pinpoint how I feel about this little snippet of rhetoric.

My first response is to feel as though I’ve been transported back to an era when women, like children, where kept and cared for by men. I hear echoes of the Titanic and cries of ‘save the women and children’. Sort of feels regressive in this day and age, why not speak of civilians, or of ‘children, the elderly and infirm’, if wanting to highlight the plight of the vulnerable?

In the next moment I’m reflecting on how it must feel to be a young man these days, to hear outcry at the death of women and children, but little said about fathers and brothers. I wonder if it is any coincidence that it is young men who are shooting and stabbing each other in our inner cities, and what the value our society places on their lives.

Not really an AIBU, but what do you think? Should ‘women and children’ still be a phrase we use today and why/why not?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
DancesWithDucks · 01/11/2023 18:40

About women leaders being as bad as men leaders for starting war, given that the proportion of women rulers in comparison to male rulers is miniscule I simply don't see how one can reliably extrapolate. The imbalance is massively too great.

About Thatcher, dreadful woman as she was, she went to war because Argentina attacked first. So you can't call her the originator of the war. That was a man.

DancesWithDucks · 01/11/2023 18:36

"Rape isn't as bad as death" is a blanket statement without nuance and without acknowledging that for some women it is indeed worse than death. The suicide statistics of women post-rape go up significantly in war zones, apparently. "Furthermore, 25 [out of 68] victims had suicidal ideas and impulses." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2080379/

If you want to make sure that the women of the country think of or try to commit suicide, rape is a good way to go about it. For those who survive and their families, it's very often permanently devastating.

In Ukraine the view is that some Russian soldiers commit rapes with extreme violence in order to ensure that the woman never has sex again; physically unable in some cases, mentally far too traumatized in many others.

It destroys the family too, it's a deliberate policy to make sure that family members watch in many cases and then to leave the woman alive so they are a constant reminder of the horror.

There are reports of men being castrated as well as being raped. But as far as is known (and the fog of war is thick) these are far less common than the very frequent rapes of women.

distressing
"Rape isnt as bad as death" - there are children who have not yet reached puberty whose genitals have been so badly damaged the ability to distinguish between anus and vagina will not be possible, without future surgery.

There is a claim that Pramila Patten, Special Representative of the Secretary-General on Sexual Violence in Conflict, said that Russian soldiers were issued with viagra at the start of the war to encourage rape.

Psychological Consequences of Rape on Women in 1991-1995 War in Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina

To explore the short- and long-term psychological consequences of rape on women victims of rape during the 1992-1995 war against Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina.The study included 68 women victims of rape and was conducted at the Medical Center for...

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2080379

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 18:36

Rape rape rape, like it is the only suffering that is inflicted in war. It isn’t. We cannot claim to suffer the most in war on the basis of one type of the horrific violence. I cannot ever agree with that point of view. Not after Bosnia where women and girls were evacuated in buses and the men and boys left behind who were almost immediately massacred. Sebrenica was a genocide of 8,000 male victims. Toddlers in pyjamas to old pensioners. All killed and dumped in mass graves.

Somanycats · 01/11/2023 17:13

Its because women are much much MUCH more vulnerable in war. Both from their own compatriot soldiers and either as combatants in enemy hands or definitely (and I'm going to go so far as to say always) as civilians who fall into enemy hands. That's without mentioning the obvious fact that they are less able to struggle for resources and they feel more responsible for the care of infants, so do not in general prioritise themselves.
Distressing statistics to follow - be aware...
'...estimates of the numbers of German women raped by Soviet soldiers have ranged up to 2 million. According to historian William Hitchcock in many cases women were the victims of repeated rapes, some as many as 60 to 70 times. At least 100,000 women are believed to have been raped in Berlin based on surging abortion rates in the following months and contemporary hospital reports, with an estimated 10,000 women dying in the aftermath. Female deaths in connection with the rapes in Germany, overall, are estimated at 240,000.'
Ditto, Ukraine, The Congo, Sudan etc. Its too disgusting to even write down.
We do women a disservice if we let them think they are on an equal footing in war.

Berlin - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin

Ponderingwindow · 01/11/2023 16:27

Men’s lives are not worth less. Men are not in as much danger.

when resources are scarce men as a class will have better access. When there is violence, men as a class are better able to defend themselves.

Memememestillme · 01/11/2023 16:07

I don't really understand the argument that rape is worse than other forms of torture.
And I don't get the argument that since men are mostly the ones that start wars that their lives are somehow worth less.
I mean as the mother of 2 young boys who was brought up by a single father after my mother walked out on us when I was aged 7 and my sister was aged 3, maybe I have a slightly different view of males than a lot of other posters, but to me, men's lives matter just as much as women's.
I do understand that in places like Gaza women have a much harder life than men.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 01/11/2023 14:37

And actually I imagine repeated gang rape which again is a common weapon is probably not far off being worse than death.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 01/11/2023 14:36

Rape is also uses as a way to intentionally make a woman pregnant. Thus giving birth to and bringing up the child of your enemy.

vivainsomnia · 01/11/2023 12:46

Rape requires a special kind of evil beyond murder
And where do you put torture? It's a special kind of evil that gets a kick from witnessing horrible suffering and pain.

Ponderingwindow · 01/11/2023 12:17

Rape requires a special kind of evil beyond murder. The man has to be sexually aroused while harming another person. There is something fundamentally broken inside a man who can commit a violent rape. As both an individual crime and a crime of war, the punishment should reflect that.

Ponderingwindow · 01/11/2023 12:10

I used to worry about the sexism in the term, but over time I realized I was naive.

When the U.S. pulled out of Afghanistan, we saw huge crowds of men getting those last flights. Where were the women and children?

Hamas did not just murder, it used rape as an attack method. That method targets one group.

i started to list other examples, but they were all from the Middle East because that is where we have seen conflict recently. I don’t think it would be fair to blame one region .

i am under no illusion that all the wonderful rights and comforts i have as a woman in a western country are solid. The truth is that they exist because the men collectively find it advantageous for me to have rights and to have a voice.

when an area is ruled by words, women and children are equals. When an area is ruled by force, we are always going to be at a disadvantage and suffer.

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/11/2023 12:02

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 11:36

We don’t suffer disproportionately. It’s men that are tortured and are killed at a much higher rate. Rape isn’t a fate worse than death.

You are wrong according to the United Nations.and other reputable sources. Google it.

And that is a wholly ignorant comment that shows a complete lack of understanding of the impact of rape.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 01/11/2023 11:57

I do think there is a discussion to be had, yes.

I would however also consider that Palestine is a society where the opportunities available to women and the rules they must abide by are NOT the same as they are for men.
This is not the same situation as in 21rst century Britain (or any other Western country).

there is also the issue that war tends to affect women (and girls) differently.

The likelihood of rape and sexual violence against women (and girls!) is much higher during active conflict and the aftermath (such as refugee camps, during displacement etc).

And that is without touching the very real issue of rape and forced pregancy being used systematically in various armed conflicts. Something that has NOT been paid enough attention to in the past and is crucial in the peace processs and for transitional justice.

There is also the issue that war related childhood trauma has the potential to severely impact a child´s development with potentially severe have longterm consequences.

I personally am uncomfortable if we simply say "women and children" but do not talk about how armed conflict and war specifically impacts them.
We should talk much more openly and frequently about these specific issues!

Especially because saying "women and children" invokes the old-timey attitude the OP mentioned. Instead of highlighting issues and problems that are (still) relevant today.

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 11:51

I like the term PP used - non-combatants. That encapsulates the innocent, whatever their age or gender. Or just call them innocent people.

Yep, that’s what all civilians, medics, press, UN, and aid workers are. It’s how we should be counting death toll. Right now the news is adding the deaths of Israeli soldiers to their death toll, but the Palestinian death tool is 100% non-combatants. It’s not apples to apples.

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 11:49

On average a man would be able to "defeat" a woman if similarly "tooled up"

Assuming the same training, an average man and woman if similarly tooled up it would be more about luck as to who wins. While the man has the advantage of strength, running stride and ability to carry more ammunition, the woman would have the advantage of being a sneakier and smaller target, usually more likely to be a sharpshooter, and would also be able to survive on less water and less food than a man- increasing stealth and endurance in the field. Women can also more readily disguise themselves as civilians and infiltrate or escape situations than a man can. In addition, certain enemy soldiers still hesitate for a fraction when faced with a woman, that split second gives a woman the edge to get the first shot off.

When it comes to drone, fighter jet & helicopter pilots and tank drivers, no difference between a man or a woman at the controls.

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 11:38

Manadou · 01/11/2023 11:31

The Uk was pretty indifferent to the lives of German women and children during the war. the bombing raids on e.g. Hamburg, Dresden, etc, intentionally killed thousands. Plus the fire raids on Japanese cities and of course the two nuclear weapons.

WWII was the reason why the UN was created and why the international laws defining war crimes were written. The objective was to not repeat indiscriminate targeting and murdering of civilians.

SideBob · 01/11/2023 11:38

Generally agree, I don't like the phrase women and children etc.

But when you think about it, women are often the caretakers of children (when men are fighting) so the idea of women also being targeted is pretty awful.

vivainsomnia · 01/11/2023 11:37

Do posters who think women have it so much don't think husbands, father's, sons are significantly affected by seeing their family killed in horrific circumstances?

Men come back from war suffering from PTSD that often affect life forever, and that's with their family safe at home.

It's not a fight over who is more traumatised. War traumatised everyone one way or the other. Battling over who has it worse is pathetic in the scheme of the traumas wars cause.

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 11:36

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/11/2023 11:22

This.

Yabu OP not to acknowledge that it's women and children who suffer disproportionately in times such as this.

Women are 2nd class citizens to begin with in Gaza and their suffering is amplified now at the hands of men. Its always men.

We don’t suffer disproportionately. It’s men that are tortured and are killed at a much higher rate. Rape isn’t a fate worse than death.

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 11:34

EtiennePalmiere · 31/10/2023 22:40

With apologies to @marmaladeandpeanutbutter, that's the dumbest thing I've ever heard in my life.

Ah such a compliment. No way to mount a persuasive counter argument so you go for the ad hominem. Must mean I have made some very convincing points.

Grouping women by default with children infantilises us. We are fully capable of bearing arms for our countries, and many of us have for over a century. Grouping men or even teenage boys by default with combatants blurs the line between warring with combatants or breaking international law by targeting civilians or other non-combatants like medics, aid workers, press or UN officials.

Saying this is “the dumbest thing” you have “ever heard” in your “life” erases the many female veterans- those that have sacrificed their lives for their country, those currently serving and those that have retired from service.

Dotjones · 01/11/2023 11:33

I dislike the term "women and children" because of the assumption that it conveys - women and children are innocent, men are guilty. Lots of Israeli women are in their armed forces. Lots of women and children are supporters of terrorism. The (valid) arguments that "it's men that start wars" and "women in general are weaker than men" don't cancel out the fact that women and children can be just as dangerous as adult men.

On average a man would be able to "defeat" a woman if similarly "tooled up". But a woman with a gun would be able to defeat an unarmed man. A child with a bomb would be able to kill unarmed pensioners.

I like the term PP used - non-combatants. That encapsulates the innocent, whatever their age or gender. Or just call them innocent people.

Manadou · 01/11/2023 11:31

The Uk was pretty indifferent to the lives of German women and children during the war. the bombing raids on e.g. Hamburg, Dresden, etc, intentionally killed thousands. Plus the fire raids on Japanese cities and of course the two nuclear weapons.

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/11/2023 11:29

gannett · 31/10/2023 15:34

I suggest you read up on war crimes in Bosnia and Rwanda, for starters, if you think men aren't susceptible to rape and sexual assault in war.

Certainly not on the scale of women they aren't.

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/11/2023 11:27

Bluesea123 · 01/11/2023 11:23

I’m sick of hearing women and children too. There are only some men who are choosing war, the rest are gravely impacted by it and will suffer trauma the rest of their lives.
and my goodness it annoys me about mothers of only daughters who somehow feel superior that they would not have to send their daughters to fight. It’s not 1914

Israel has conscription for all females.

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/11/2023 11:25

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 22:37

I really do not understand the hyper focus on rape.

It is one of many forms of torture. Girls/boys, men/women are all vulnerable to torture by enemy soldiers. Combatants captured, whether male or female are also vulnerable to torture including rape (Abu Grahib?, Guantanamo?).

So the females can be raped argument doesn’t wash for me as to why casualties are listed as a total with this many women and children. The only guaranteed non-combatant innocents are children in my opinion. Adults should be split into civilian non-combatants and combatants (soldiers), not by male or female because that is based on traditional and outdated sex roles.

Dumbest comment I've read in a long time.