Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“women and children” in war

166 replies

Diolchynfawr · 30/10/2023 15:00

Just catching up with Any Questions on R4. Much talk of ‘women and children’ being bombed in Gaza, and who were slaughtered on October 7th.

Laying aside one for one moment (if such a thing is possible) the appalling horror and tragedy of the current situation, I can’t quite pinpoint how I feel about this little snippet of rhetoric.

My first response is to feel as though I’ve been transported back to an era when women, like children, where kept and cared for by men. I hear echoes of the Titanic and cries of ‘save the women and children’. Sort of feels regressive in this day and age, why not speak of civilians, or of ‘children, the elderly and infirm’, if wanting to highlight the plight of the vulnerable?

In the next moment I’m reflecting on how it must feel to be a young man these days, to hear outcry at the death of women and children, but little said about fathers and brothers. I wonder if it is any coincidence that it is young men who are shooting and stabbing each other in our inner cities, and what the value our society places on their lives.

Not really an AIBU, but what do you think? Should ‘women and children’ still be a phrase we use today and why/why not?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
DancesWithDucks · 02/11/2023 15:43

How often is modern warfare unarmed hand to hand combat?

I can't see that the war between Israel and Hamas has much to do with men being bigger or stronger.

Russia is sending absolute masses of low-armed or literally unarmed soldiers forward around Avdiivka for the last weeks. On many days around 800 - 1000 are dying /being seriously wounded.

In clearing trenches there is indeed quite some hand-to-hand stuff, from the clips I've seen - and I've seen a lot now.

HBGKC · 02/11/2023 14:48

"How often is modern warfare unarmed hand to hand combat? A woman can fly the plane that drops the bomb or launch the missile as easily as a man. A man can die in the explosion or buried in the rubble as easily as any woman.

I can't see that the war between Israel and Hamas has much to do with men being bigger or stronger."

Still quite a significant amount of it, apparently.

"A 2014 study found that, amongst US soldiers deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan between 2004 and 2008, 19% reported the use of hand-to-hand techniques in at least one encounter, in a variety of circumstances and contexts (such as close combat, prisoner handling, crowd control and security checkpoints), supporting prior research that indicated that, despite advances in technology, hand-to-hand combat remained a persistent aspect of modern warfare.[8]"

The weight of the kit that soldiers need to carry varies, obviously (not least on the climate and the amount of water they need to keep with them), but it ranges from approx 25kg (half my body weight) to 45kg (a few kilos off my weight). I am a particularly petite woman, but women as a group are smaller and lighter than men as a group. I stand by my point.

I read an article recently by a soldier who'd fought hand-to-hand clearing villages in Afghanistan, saying that Israeli forces would likely end up in similar situations trying to clear militants out of Gaza, who would rather die defending their territory than retreat.

Not all wars are big countries dropping bombs from the sky at a great distance. Smaller rebel forces/guerilla/civil wars are happening all over the world, and some close combat is the exception rather than the rule.

Iwasafool · 02/11/2023 12:45

HBGKC · 01/11/2023 19:44

"Not really an AIBU, but what do you think? Should ‘women and children’ still be a phrase we use today and why/why not?"

I think this phrase connects with very deep, atavistic human instincts, which are genuine, and 'good', but perhaps hard to define.

Some random musings:

Women and children are the future of any society (obviously some men are required too...) As such, they occupy a special, even privileged position in the minds of a society under threat from war. To safeguard women and children is to safeguard the continuation and prosperity of all that one holds most dear. I think men have demonstrated this protective instinct throughout history.

Any framing of women as 'different' from men is always going to provoke a knee-jerk 'feminist' reaction, and an assumption that to admit of differences between the sexes is also therefore to insert a hierarchy, in which either men are better/more important/more powerful than women, or vice versa.

I think war highlights the unarguable differences between men and women (and children, at one further remove). Feminism will never be able to dispense with the physical reality of human biology, ie most men are bigger and stronger than most women, so in a combat situation, women (and children) must rely on men for protection, whether they fits with their worldview or not.

In an era where girls and women are constantly told they can do everything that a man can, and generally do it better as well, to be reminded that women are actually at the mercy of men's choosing to behave well towards them, in a civilised manner, is a little hard to accept - particularly by those of us fortunate enough never to have got close to the harsher realities of war, in which for sure women and children are physically more vulnerable (because weaker) than men.

This is OF COURSE not to say that men do not suffer in war, nor that they are not also vulnerable to all kinds of horrific violence. The vast majority of men do not want to fight in wars, yet do so anyway when called upon to protect their wives/children/way of life/society/civilisation. I am very grateful to the many millions of men who gave their lives for my country in both World Wars of the last century (in which my grandfather also fought, and from which experience he never recovered.)

*war highlights the unarguable differences between men and women (and children, at one further remove). Feminism will never be able to dispense with the physical reality of human biology, ie most men are bigger and stronger than most women, so in a combat situation, women (and children) must rely on men for protection, whether they fits with their worldview or not."

How often is modern warfare unarmed hand to hand combat? A woman can fly the plane that drops the bomb or launch the missile as easily as a man. A man can die in the explosion or buried in the rubble as easily as any woman.

I can't see that the war between Israel and Hamas has much to do with men being bigger or stronger.

TutuDesi · 02/11/2023 11:45

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 01/11/2023 22:04

Tutu just read your further posts and I'm sorry you went through that. I'm also sorry if my last sentence reads as dismissive of this as it wouldn't have been my intention.

I'm a victim also and was a wee bit riled by your post before that.

But we are all different in how we respond to trauma and I think it's important not to downplay how rape is used in war and it's long term effects.

This doesn't at all take away the disgusting waste of all human life

I’m sorry it looks as though I am downplaying, that isn’t my intent. It’s more that I can’t agree that our disproportionate suffering from rape therefore makes us suffer more than men in war as a blanket generalisation. War causes untold suffering on everyone caught up in it, but to my mind children are the most vulnerable. We women, while still vulnerable, are not as vulnerable as a child and so should not be lumped in with children.

TutuDesi · 02/11/2023 11:37

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 01/11/2023 21:57

No one is saying it is but instead are acknowledging that due to biology women are at risk in a very different way and that rape is not solely used as a way to inflict physical long term pain.

Hopefully my mentioning the R word again wont make you too cross

Confused

Thats not the message I am getting. It’s more than acknowledging rape is the one form of torture that women disproportionally suffer which I have done, there is an insistence that it is fair to extrapolate from this one thing that women suffer overall more than men in war and are overall more vulnerable than men in war. When factually, more men are injured and die in wars than do women.

Furthermore, there is a view that women are weaker, slower, and cannot possibly be in combat roles - when the truth is that those female troops that have been permitted into combat roles have more than proven themselves. I have posted 2x the article on the all female squad of 13 IDF soldiers who beat at least 100 Hamas fighters just two weeks ago. These women were outnumbered by 7 to 1. There are many more examples of Kurdish female battalions beating ISIS. Women have been in combat roles for over decade and in the past five years, they are now being allowed to join special forces. We now have females in the SAS. In the past, it wasn’t that women failed the fitness tests or combat exercises, it was that they were not even allowed to try out. As soon as the gatekeepers let women try for these roles, women have volunteering and been passing the tests.

It’s the same sort of shift that happened when society started letting women try out for police and firefighting.

Yes obviously an untrained and unarmed woman is no match for a trained, armed male enemy soldier, but it’s the same for an untrained and unarmed man. It is more the lack of military training and lack of arms that puts us at a disadvantage these days- along with enduring sexist bias that paints us as damsels in distress at the mercy of men at arms who need knightly protection.

TutuDesi · 02/11/2023 11:19

Delpf · 01/11/2023 19:59

"Our female physical limits are pretty much null and void when you’re using advanced weaponry"

This is just not true. Yeah, there's probably no difference between a female and a male drone pilot, but female infantry are a rarity because of the very many disadvantages; females are slower and weaker - less able to carry and handle heavy weaponry, easily disarmed. In close combat women would just be canon fodder.

I disagree, female infantry are only a rarity because society sees women as slower, weaker, more vulnerable and is not willing to envision women coming home in flag draped caskets or body bags from a war like they are perfectly desensitised to men KIA coming home that way.

It takes a kg of pressure to pull a trigger- toddlers have pulled triggers. We are at no disadvantage in a small arms fire fight. We are at no disadvantage driving a tank or piloting a fighter jet, helicopter or drone. We would only be at a disadvantage at hand to hand combat which is not the usual form of combat in modern day warfare. Everyone on the battlefield is equally “canon fodder” if by that you mean vulnerable to mortar shells, air strikes, tank fire and 50 cal machine guns. Men do not have any advantage in surviving those sorts of explosives over women.

Women have been barred from combat and special forces roles for decades due to this societal perception, but in those military forces where a small % of women have been permitted to engage in front line combat and special forces roles, they have proven themselves to be just as capable as men.

Falzarega · 01/11/2023 22:09

Oh ffs.

Almost all violence is by men.

So yes it is sad that women and children bear the brunt of it.

YABU.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 01/11/2023 22:04

Tutu just read your further posts and I'm sorry you went through that. I'm also sorry if my last sentence reads as dismissive of this as it wouldn't have been my intention.

I'm a victim also and was a wee bit riled by your post before that.

But we are all different in how we respond to trauma and I think it's important not to downplay how rape is used in war and it's long term effects.

This doesn't at all take away the disgusting waste of all human life

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 01/11/2023 21:57

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 18:36

Rape rape rape, like it is the only suffering that is inflicted in war. It isn’t. We cannot claim to suffer the most in war on the basis of one type of the horrific violence. I cannot ever agree with that point of view. Not after Bosnia where women and girls were evacuated in buses and the men and boys left behind who were almost immediately massacred. Sebrenica was a genocide of 8,000 male victims. Toddlers in pyjamas to old pensioners. All killed and dumped in mass graves.

No one is saying it is but instead are acknowledging that due to biology women are at risk in a very different way and that rape is not solely used as a way to inflict physical long term pain.

Hopefully my mentioning the R word again wont make you too cross

Confused
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2023 20:32

The reason women can’t be conscripted in modern times and didn’t used to be allowed on the front lines until quite recently is because they/ we can become pregnant. Specifically, if raped by the enemy. Men also suffer rape and sexual assault in war but crucially can’t become pregnant.

It’s not because we’re weaker, not for a long time.

DancesWithDucks · 01/11/2023 20:13

@Delpf in terms of reflexes are women and men roughly equal? Men are faster presumably.

Delpf · 01/11/2023 19:59

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 00:43

I do think “women and children” is outdated. It should be switched to “civilians and children” to count deaths of non-combatants.

Both IDF and Hamas have female combatants and leaders. Our female physical limits are pretty much null and void when you’re using advanced weaponry. https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/defense-news/article-769134

"Our female physical limits are pretty much null and void when you’re using advanced weaponry"

This is just not true. Yeah, there's probably no difference between a female and a male drone pilot, but female infantry are a rarity because of the very many disadvantages; females are slower and weaker - less able to carry and handle heavy weaponry, easily disarmed. In close combat women would just be canon fodder.

DancesWithDucks · 01/11/2023 19:51

eh, @Rudderneck said it better yesterday at 10:37

also, I think @HBGKC has the galling truth of it just above :(

In an era where girls and women are constantly told they can do everything that a man can, and generally do it better as well, to be reminded that women are actually at the mercy of men's choosing to behave well towards them, in a civilised manner, is a little hard to accept - particularly by those of us fortunate enough never to have got close to the harsher realities of war, in which for sure women and children are physically more vulnerable (because weaker) than men.

DancesWithDucks · 01/11/2023 19:48

As far as I can see there's a great deal of outrage about the rapes of the adult females during the massacre.

But the phrase is applied to all wars, not just Israel and Hamas so the principle of it has to be extended further, which makes the Israel/Hamas conflict a very small proportion of conflict situation.

Israel is the only country in the world (I think) that has female conscription, and even there only 7% of the front line troops are women. Front line or not, if you're in the military forces the concept of 'women and children' can't apply to you. But it could apply to the rest of the women, ie the majority.

Couldn't find any information on what proportion of HAMAS fighters are female. I'd guess a very low proportion but that's all it is, a guess.

So given the relative proportions at least in Israel, and presumably with less female fighters in Gaza, I can't see that there's all that much difference- and that is, as said, a really small proportion of the conflicts that the phrase 'women and children' apply to.

HBGKC · 01/11/2023 19:44

"Not really an AIBU, but what do you think? Should ‘women and children’ still be a phrase we use today and why/why not?"

I think this phrase connects with very deep, atavistic human instincts, which are genuine, and 'good', but perhaps hard to define.

Some random musings:

Women and children are the future of any society (obviously some men are required too...) As such, they occupy a special, even privileged position in the minds of a society under threat from war. To safeguard women and children is to safeguard the continuation and prosperity of all that one holds most dear. I think men have demonstrated this protective instinct throughout history.

Any framing of women as 'different' from men is always going to provoke a knee-jerk 'feminist' reaction, and an assumption that to admit of differences between the sexes is also therefore to insert a hierarchy, in which either men are better/more important/more powerful than women, or vice versa.

I think war highlights the unarguable differences between men and women (and children, at one further remove). Feminism will never be able to dispense with the physical reality of human biology, ie most men are bigger and stronger than most women, so in a combat situation, women (and children) must rely on men for protection, whether they fits with their worldview or not.

In an era where girls and women are constantly told they can do everything that a man can, and generally do it better as well, to be reminded that women are actually at the mercy of men's choosing to behave well towards them, in a civilised manner, is a little hard to accept - particularly by those of us fortunate enough never to have got close to the harsher realities of war, in which for sure women and children are physically more vulnerable (because weaker) than men.

This is OF COURSE not to say that men do not suffer in war, nor that they are not also vulnerable to all kinds of horrific violence. The vast majority of men do not want to fight in wars, yet do so anyway when called upon to protect their wives/children/way of life/society/civilisation. I am very grateful to the many millions of men who gave their lives for my country in both World Wars of the last century (in which my grandfather also fought, and from which experience he never recovered.)

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 19:37

“I'm very sorry you went through that and I sincerely hope your results come back clear. Still, and this is harsh of me I realise, you don't speak for all women, indeed, and I sincerely hope you weren't ostracised or divorced or your husband never touched you again because of your experience, or your family did not have to observe it.”
Thank you for your kind words and understanding my perspective.

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 19:35

“When the U.S. pulled out of Afghanistan, we saw huge crowds of men getting those last flights. Where were the women and children?”

The families with women and children were on the evacuation flights? You might be remembering the photos of the mad rush of men who tried to storm their way onto the final flights- many lost their lives as the planes took off with them clinging to the outside and then falling to their deaths.

“women and children” in war
“women and children” in war
“women and children” in war
“women and children” in war
“women and children” in war
TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 19:32

@DancesWithDucks

“a very great deal of the world still operates on different principles.”

Quite, but we are talking about the conflict in Israel and Israel and Hamas both have female combatants. So that part of the world does not adhere to the old-fashioned European “women” are automatically non-combatants and therefore lumped in with the children.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12669623/israeli-lionesses-kill-hamas-gunmen.html
Why do you think most of the outrage from the ME is in regards to child deaths?

All-female Israeli unit of 13 troops 'killed nearly 100 Hamas gunmen'

Lieutenant Colonel Or Ben Yehuda and her 12 women soldiers of the Caracal Battalion led the frontline fightback from armoured personnel carriers against dozens of Hamas fighters

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12669623/israeli-lionesses-kill-hamas-gunmen.html

DancesWithDucks · 01/11/2023 19:21

I'm very sorry you went through that and I sincerely hope your results come back clear.

Still, and this is harsh of me I realise, you don't speak for all women, indeed, and I sincerely hope you weren't ostracised or divorced or your husband never touched you again because of your experience, or your family did not have to observe it. You are speaking from your own experience and own cultural values and a great deal - most - of the world work on different and older fashioned (and worse) principles and practice.

Adults should be split into civilian non-combatants and combatants (soldiers), not by male or female because that is based on traditional and outdated sex roles.

I'm afraid that you may believe that but again, a very great deal of the world still operates on different principles.

I think myself that 'women and children' is an old fashioned phrase, but understand it's a shorthand for all non-combatants and it seems that in most wars, it still accurately describes the situation. The UK and the US haven't been invaded and so we have the (necessary) luxury of rethinking the underlying concept of 'women and children'. But it's pressing reality for the inhabitants of most war zones.

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 19:16

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 01/11/2023 18:57

It’s an interesting question.
personally I see why the term “women and children” is used. Probably because largely it is males who are the fighters, politicians etc and women more often in less powerful Positions and women caring for children and elderly.

However that’s not to say male civilian lives aren’t important too and maybe “innocent civilians and vulnerable civilians” is a better phrase.

Yes, similar to you, I think it should be “civilians and children” where civilians are all non-combatants male or female. It is understood most non-combatants will be female, given that we have gender gaps in terms of civilians vs combatants. But this covers the men that are innocent with the women that are innocent.

In this day and age where women serve in the armed forces, it is antiquated and a bit sexist to lump all women in with children and all men in with combatants.

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 19:07

It's a slow death instead of a fast one. Is that better?
Maybe, in some cases a fast death is better, but not all.

I’m facing the real possibility of that myself. My rapist gave me HPV. I’m now on the cancer pathway with suspected cervical cancer due to that HPV. So my rapist quite literally could also be my murderer, not that he’d actually serve a day in prison as dying from a rape imposed STI doesn’t count as murder.

But if he’d killed me then and there instead of raped me, I would not have seen my children grow. I would have missed out on all of that, and they’d have lost their mum. I’m happy to have had that extra years of life, if it is cervical cancer and if it does kill me. I will be finding out in the next year or so. I hope I survive this too.

So from where I am standing, I don’t think that death from rape many years later is necessarily always worse than instant death. It might be, as I cannot speak for all women. But I do think the majority of women are strong and have a desire to live.

And besides, most rape doesn’t result in death. When it does, it’s no longer a question of rape vs death, but death now vs rape + death later so the entire paradigm of what we are discussing has shifted up a notch.

DancesWithDucks · 01/11/2023 19:05

Are you deliberately misunderstanding @TutuDesi to be unpleasant?

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 01/11/2023 18:57

It’s an interesting question.
personally I see why the term “women and children” is used. Probably because largely it is males who are the fighters, politicians etc and women more often in less powerful Positions and women caring for children and elderly.

However that’s not to say male civilian lives aren’t important too and maybe “innocent civilians and vulnerable civilians” is a better phrase.

TutuDesi · 01/11/2023 18:55

“"Rape isn't as bad as death" is a blanket statement without nuance and without acknowledging that for some women it is indeed worse than death. The suicide statistics of women post-rape go up significantly in war zones, apparently. "Furthermore, 25 [out of 68] victims had suicidal ideas and impulses."

You are using suicide statistics (death) to argue that rape is worse than death? Has it eluded you that if women are told to choose death over rape, they’d all be dead? Instead of only some women wanting to be dead? All you’ve done is show that rape is not worse than death for the vast majority of women.

DancesWithDucks · 01/11/2023 18:49

When you say "rape is not as bad as death", how exactly are you comparing them? Because a blanket statement like that just doesn't cover the complex reality.

Rape in more sexist, patriarchal cultures is also known to lead to silence, often social isolation and in some cases ostracisation.

"Also, we found that more Bosniak (Muslim) than Croat women thought the relationship with their partner worsened after the trauma. This could be explained by the fact that Bosniak women come from a more traditional culture. The social environment and personal upbringing influence the victim's reaction to rape. In societies with patriarchal social structure, victims refuse to talk about the trauma and do not want the event to be documented even in medical files."

The effects, physical and mental, of rape don't go away just because the woman is silenced.

In the Congo and I think elsewhere there are many cases of raped women being divorced by their husbands. They are sent away, with or without children, and sometimes with no means of support at all. Sometimes they die. It's a slow death instead of a fast one. Is that better?

Swipe left for the next trending thread