Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“women and children” in war

166 replies

Diolchynfawr · 30/10/2023 15:00

Just catching up with Any Questions on R4. Much talk of ‘women and children’ being bombed in Gaza, and who were slaughtered on October 7th.

Laying aside one for one moment (if such a thing is possible) the appalling horror and tragedy of the current situation, I can’t quite pinpoint how I feel about this little snippet of rhetoric.

My first response is to feel as though I’ve been transported back to an era when women, like children, where kept and cared for by men. I hear echoes of the Titanic and cries of ‘save the women and children’. Sort of feels regressive in this day and age, why not speak of civilians, or of ‘children, the elderly and infirm’, if wanting to highlight the plight of the vulnerable?

In the next moment I’m reflecting on how it must feel to be a young man these days, to hear outcry at the death of women and children, but little said about fathers and brothers. I wonder if it is any coincidence that it is young men who are shooting and stabbing each other in our inner cities, and what the value our society places on their lives.

Not really an AIBU, but what do you think? Should ‘women and children’ still be a phrase we use today and why/why not?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
DancesWithDucks · 04/11/2023 16:41

I'm actually in favour of women being able to go into front line combat, if it is very clearly spelled out what might happen. As this thread shows, there's a very considerable naivety about the level of horror that can be inflicted on a captured woman. But if women then decide they'll accept that risk, and if they are the best fit for the relevant role, then imo that should be fine.

But it will always be a very small proportion overall of women who go into front line combat. To bring it back to the original thread question about is the phrase "women and children" still relevant, yes I think it is. When it comes to soldiers advancing on unsuspecting civilians who then have to run for as has literally just happened in Israel on 7th October, then if rescue is only available for a proportion of the victims then the decent thing is to save the slowest/weakest first - the children, the old people and the majority of women.

User135644 · 04/11/2023 10:29

Green777 · 03/11/2023 21:50

Men start wars, not women.

So men start wars and women wave white feathers at men who don't go off to die in them.

Memememestillme · 04/11/2023 06:17

Green777 · Yesterday 21:50

Men start wars, not wome

This is such a shitty comment. A tiny minority of men start wars. So we blame them all? They're all just expendable because of the actions of 1 or 2 men at a particular point in history? I'm sure most men hate war just as much as women do. Why wouldn't they? They're the ones who'll be sent to the front lines and potentially lose their lives or be forced to kill.

Green777 · 03/11/2023 21:50

Men start wars, not women.

saffronsoup · 03/11/2023 21:49

I think children and other dependents who can't make any decisions for themselves compared to adults of any sex. I do not think a man's life has less value than a woman's nor do I think the physical advantages of being a man matter much when a bomb drops on your home. A man dying is as tragic as a woman dying. And men and women both train as soldiers, including in the IDF. Many aspects of this war - setting off bombs and mortars doesn't require brute physical strength. There are many roles for women in a war. I do think the view that men are disposable and have little value is a problem. I also think people often ignore and deny that men also have complex emotions and can love and be attached to people and truly suffer during wars as well. It seems they are expected to not really be affected or to only be aggressive, angry, and violent. I pretty much put all adults together and see any of their deaths as tragic.

HBGKC · 03/11/2023 21:43

*unarguable.

HBGKC · 03/11/2023 21:42

"They still appear to be armed though, I don't know why an armed, trained soldier is deciding to use grappling techniques but if women aren't suited to grappling there are plenty of other roles where they won't be needed."

"IF women aren't suited to grappling" WITH MEN....?? You really think there's some doubt on that point?

No-one's arguing that there aren't plenty of other roles for women to play elsewhere; plenty of us are arguing that the front line is not a good place for women or children to be, because they are fundamentally, biologically, physically more vulnerable (as a generic group). I'm sorry if this reality doesn't fit with your worldview, but it's u arguable

Iwasafool · 03/11/2023 21:18

HBGKC · 02/11/2023 20:38

@Iwasafool "Were the 19% armed?"

This is the Abstract of the study referenced:

"Despite technological advances, hand-to-hand combat remains a persistent aspect of the contemporary operating environment Wojadkowski, 2007. To develop a more detailed understanding on the use of hand-to-hand combat, the researcher analyzed 30 Post-Combat Surveys administered to US Army Soldiers from 2004 to 2008 after their return from deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan. 216 out of 1,226 Soldiers 19.0 reported using hand-to-hand combat skills in at least one encounter. The Soldiers descriptions indicated that hand-to-hand combat occurred in a variety of tactical situations and that the most common skills employed were grappling techniques 72.6, followed by the use of weapons e.g., rifle butt strikes 21.9 with striking as the least reported skill i.e., punching and kicking 5.5. These results further reinforce that hand-to-hand combat remains a relevant demand and the US Army should continue such training with an emphasis on grappling skills practiced across a variety of performance settings."

Grappling was the most common form of melèe combat. There's a reason we don't allow mixed-sex boxing matches, even at the same weight class (see Fallon Fox for a cautionary tale of what can happen when we do).

So do you think they questioned a cross section of military personnel? Or if you wanted to know what might happen when you come face to face with the enemy they might select people that is likely to happen to? So would they ask the catering corp well behind the lines, the nurses and doctors or communication personnel well behind the lines or would they ask the ones who are you know on the front line?

They still appear to be armed though, I don't know why an armed, trained soldier is deciding to use grappling techniques but if women aren't suited to grappling there are plenty of other roles where they won't be needed.

HBGKC · 02/11/2023 20:38

@Iwasafool "Were the 19% armed?"

This is the Abstract of the study referenced:

"Despite technological advances, hand-to-hand combat remains a persistent aspect of the contemporary operating environment Wojadkowski, 2007. To develop a more detailed understanding on the use of hand-to-hand combat, the researcher analyzed 30 Post-Combat Surveys administered to US Army Soldiers from 2004 to 2008 after their return from deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan. 216 out of 1,226 Soldiers 19.0 reported using hand-to-hand combat skills in at least one encounter. The Soldiers descriptions indicated that hand-to-hand combat occurred in a variety of tactical situations and that the most common skills employed were grappling techniques 72.6, followed by the use of weapons e.g., rifle butt strikes 21.9 with striking as the least reported skill i.e., punching and kicking 5.5. These results further reinforce that hand-to-hand combat remains a relevant demand and the US Army should continue such training with an emphasis on grappling skills practiced across a variety of performance settings."

Grappling was the most common form of melèe combat. There's a reason we don't allow mixed-sex boxing matches, even at the same weight class (see Fallon Fox for a cautionary tale of what can happen when we do).

DancesWithDucks · 02/11/2023 18:43

Spendonsend · 02/11/2023 18:24

I've been wondering whether women are also at risk from their own side in a way that men arent during war.

It's been known yes. At massively lower levels than from enemy soldiers ofc. There have been quite a lot of incidents of rape and sexual coercion by UN 'peacekeepers'; those are only the reported ones.

@LadyThatLaunches
Wow, so I'm guessing a lot more than I thought stayed to defend the country - I knew it was a fair few but didn't realise how many. I don't think that would happen here tbh.

Actually, most are just getting on with their ordinary lives. Many left at first and then came back once it was clear Russia wasn't going to be able take all of Ukraine over. Many more work in industries that support the army than used to, even if it's only making warm socks at home - not to be underrated for soldiers in the trenches. Some are making camoflage netting and gear. But Kyiv still has nightclubs and cafes and life goes on; it's just that you know people who have been conscripted and then some of them die. I get the impression that people take life less for granted and the losses make living seem much sharper and less certain.

There are about 5,000 women on the front line in Ukraine. Another 55,000 not on the front line. Of the front line women, I have the impression that a fair percentage are snipers. Many more medics of course. What happens to them if they are captured does not bear thinking about. After the first couple of incidents I tried very hard to avoid it. It seems that captured women get much more intense attention than captured men in some cases.

Spendonsend · 02/11/2023 18:24

I've been wondering whether women are also at risk from their own side in a way that men arent during war.

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 18:12

Somanycats · 02/11/2023 17:51

Come on get real. DS has a similar role and tbf neither him or your sister should ever find themselves on the front line and if they do something has gone very wrong indeed. But if they do it's not DS who is going to be the victim of sustained sexual violence. And he's never going to find himself pregnant or be given away as a wife. Even peacekeeping in bloody Kosovo who are our allies he walked freely wherever he fancied and the women soldiers were harassed all the time.

Get real about what?

That women can be of value in technical roles, that most war isn't melee combat, or that the frontline soldiers aren't usually the instigators of war?

I still stand by all three statements.

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 18:09

DancesWithDucks · 02/11/2023 18:05

It's not entirely easy to be sure as Russia controls 20% of the country and there aren't any reliable censuses.

But in 2021 there were, it's believed, ~ 22 million women and now there are ~13million, plus whatever is in the Russian controlled area.

So plenty still there.

Wow, so I'm guessing a lot more than I thought stayed to defend the country - I knew it was a fair few but didn't realise how many. I don't think that would happen here tbh.

DancesWithDucks · 02/11/2023 18:05

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 17:41

Most Ukrainian women have left the country now anyway I thought?

It's not entirely easy to be sure as Russia controls 20% of the country and there aren't any reliable censuses.

But in 2021 there were, it's believed, ~ 22 million women and now there are ~13million, plus whatever is in the Russian controlled area.

So plenty still there.

Somanycats · 02/11/2023 17:51

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 15:51

Tbf, most wars nowadays aren't fought in melee combat - my sister has honorary rank of Captain due to working in military intelligence. Also, the men on the front row aren't the ones starting the wars. You won't see Putin up front with a machine gun anytime soon.

Come on get real. DS has a similar role and tbf neither him or your sister should ever find themselves on the front line and if they do something has gone very wrong indeed. But if they do it's not DS who is going to be the victim of sustained sexual violence. And he's never going to find himself pregnant or be given away as a wife. Even peacekeeping in bloody Kosovo who are our allies he walked freely wherever he fancied and the women soldiers were harassed all the time.

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 17:41

Most Ukrainian women have left the country now anyway I thought?

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 17:36

TutuDesi · 02/11/2023 11:45

I’m sorry it looks as though I am downplaying, that isn’t my intent. It’s more that I can’t agree that our disproportionate suffering from rape therefore makes us suffer more than men in war as a blanket generalisation. War causes untold suffering on everyone caught up in it, but to my mind children are the most vulnerable. We women, while still vulnerable, are not as vulnerable as a child and so should not be lumped in with children.

Men also get raped in war. It's not a homosexual thing so much as a humiliation thing. I actually saw a link to exactly this in the Ukraine war but didn't really fancy watching it.

DancesWithDucks · 02/11/2023 17:13

https://twitter.com/wartranslated/status/1708983532326990202

one of quite a few examples, though Im not going to search back through them all. They run out of ammunition and then are told to go forward anyway. Chechen and Wagner forces in Bahkmut would shoot Storm Z soldiers who refused. They used the heaps of their own dead to get closer to the Ukrainian positions, a little closer each time, before sending the next wave over the raised mounds of the dead.

https://twitter.com/wartranslated/status/1708983532326990202

DancesWithDucks · 02/11/2023 17:05

I find it hard to believe that soldiers go into war with no weapons. It isn't 1939 with Dad's army training with broomsticks.

Yes, they are. Ive been following the Ukraine war closely for 18 months.

Russia has actually managed to get to the end of its incredible number of missiles, tanks and other weopons, including smaller arms. Hence why they are getting masses from North Korea now.

But the convict-soldiers and ones who are sent to the punishment batallions, the storm-Z units, have terrible or no equipment https://www.newsweek.com/russia-storm-z-penal-battalions-ukraine-1837234 quoting the UK govt. A rather notable oldie was this https://twitter.com/wartranslated/status/1716118591827751064 from the 1930's being sent into battle, but there are references to some rifles from pre-1900.

Over the months I've on several occasions seen references to Storm Z soldiers going forward with literally no weopons at Bahkmut. Not many, but some.

War is not tidy and neat, especially wars that grind on. Russia expected to take Ukraine over in 3 days. Now it's over a year and a half and they've run out of equipment in many (not all areas).

Russian Soldiers in Ukraine

Russia's elite "Storm-Z" units now effectively "penal battalions"—UK

Russia likely hoped Storm-Z recruits would make up "relatively elite organizations which could seize the tactical initiative," the U.K. said on Tuesday.

https://www.newsweek.com/russia-storm-z-penal-battalions-ukraine-1837234

strawberrysea · 02/11/2023 16:17

I would love to be as sheltered as you are.

Iwasafool · 02/11/2023 16:11

DancesWithDucks · 02/11/2023 15:43

How often is modern warfare unarmed hand to hand combat?

I can't see that the war between Israel and Hamas has much to do with men being bigger or stronger.

Russia is sending absolute masses of low-armed or literally unarmed soldiers forward around Avdiivka for the last weeks. On many days around 800 - 1000 are dying /being seriously wounded.

In clearing trenches there is indeed quite some hand-to-hand stuff, from the clips I've seen - and I've seen a lot now.

I find it hard to believe that soldiers go into war with no weapons. It isn't 1939 with Dad's army training with broomsticks.

Googling this shows they aren't being used to fight, they are digging trenches and carrying equipment.

Iwasafool · 02/11/2023 16:08

HBGKC · 02/11/2023 14:48

"How often is modern warfare unarmed hand to hand combat? A woman can fly the plane that drops the bomb or launch the missile as easily as a man. A man can die in the explosion or buried in the rubble as easily as any woman.

I can't see that the war between Israel and Hamas has much to do with men being bigger or stronger."

Still quite a significant amount of it, apparently.

"A 2014 study found that, amongst US soldiers deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan between 2004 and 2008, 19% reported the use of hand-to-hand techniques in at least one encounter, in a variety of circumstances and contexts (such as close combat, prisoner handling, crowd control and security checkpoints), supporting prior research that indicated that, despite advances in technology, hand-to-hand combat remained a persistent aspect of modern warfare.[8]"

The weight of the kit that soldiers need to carry varies, obviously (not least on the climate and the amount of water they need to keep with them), but it ranges from approx 25kg (half my body weight) to 45kg (a few kilos off my weight). I am a particularly petite woman, but women as a group are smaller and lighter than men as a group. I stand by my point.

I read an article recently by a soldier who'd fought hand-to-hand clearing villages in Afghanistan, saying that Israeli forces would likely end up in similar situations trying to clear militants out of Gaza, who would rather die defending their territory than retreat.

Not all wars are big countries dropping bombs from the sky at a great distance. Smaller rebel forces/guerilla/civil wars are happening all over the world, and some close combat is the exception rather than the rule.

Were the 19% unarmed?

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 15:54

Another question is whether you actually owe it to others to risk your life on account of being better equipped to fight?

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 15:51

itsmyp4rty · 30/10/2023 15:07

Yes I think it should. In any kind of fight a women is never going to beat a man. The idea that women are physically weaker is not regressive it's biology. I agree that the elderly and infirm should be included though.

Also it's also never women starting these hideous fucking wars is it.

Tbf, most wars nowadays aren't fought in melee combat - my sister has honorary rank of Captain due to working in military intelligence. Also, the men on the front row aren't the ones starting the wars. You won't see Putin up front with a machine gun anytime soon.

DancesWithDucks · 02/11/2023 15:46

One aspect of the male/female soldiers thing is that in cultures where the roles between women and men are more differentiated, male soldiers can respond differently to women enemies in that some will find it harder to shoot/kill them.