Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not refund this buyer?

286 replies

Sellerseller1 · 30/10/2023 14:48

Have an online website selling handmade items.

Buyers item was shipped with royal mail tracked delivery, tracking info says it was delivered to a safe place.

Customer has now emailed to say item must have been stolen from said safe place and therefore they want me to refund.

Aibu to say no? I have sympathy if it genuinely was stolen but firstly I can't just refund everyone who messages to say something has been stolen with no evidence it actually has been and secondly, I've fulfilled my obligation in that it's been sent and marked as delivered on the tracking page.

If they come back and it seems they are actually telling the truth I.e. trying to correspond with royal mail/ the police then I may as a gesture of good will replace it but I don't think I need to straight away? (Or even at all technically).

Fwiw item wasn't cheap and took a lot of work.

OP posts:
Speedygonzales78 · 31/10/2023 05:12

When buying online I've seen "leave in a nominated safe place" being followed by "at your own risk" etc.
It's the buyers fault for allowing it to be left unattended.
Maybe add "at buyers own risk" to your website?

Aibu to not refund this buyer?
YireosDodeAver · 31/10/2023 04:10

Sellerseller1 · 30/10/2023 14:59

Unfortunately I don't think royal mail will pay out their insurance if their tracking is saying delivered to the correct address.

I have responded and asked the buyer to contact royal mail and said that I will do so as well to show willing on my part to help.

I just don't know how I can be expected to refund or replace every item that someone just decides to tell me has been stolen, obviously I would if the tracking wasn't showing as delivered but how can I know its not a scam and what's to stop every other buyer just saying the same and getting a refund?

If you are selling valuable items then it's your responsibility as the seller to ensure that both the courier service you choose and the insurance cover level you pay for as part of the P&P is sufficient to cover things like this. If you failed to do that this time then it will be an expensive lesson to learn but you won't need to do it "every time" because in future you will have insurance in place and the courier will cover the cost.

The recipient cannot deal with Royal Mail/other couriers - you are the customer so you have to deal with the admin to make a claim against the courier. The item is your property and the courier's responsibility until it is in the customer's hands so the customer has not been stolen from, you have. The theft needs to be reported to police and in the event that it was actually stolen by the customer and they are lying, they will be guilty of fraud and liable to prosecution. However it's much more likely that the issue is that you didn't choose an appropriate delivery service for the item so you should bear the cost this time.

I bought a Dell computer online which was delivered to the "safe place" of the local convenience store, who promptly lost it. Dell had appropriate insurance in place and the courier service had to pay for a replacement but I wasn't responsible for having those conversations as it wasn't my responsibility to do so, it was a matter between Dell and the Courier that the courier had failed to fulfill their contract. That is how it is supposed to be.

Yabu.

Riola · 31/10/2023 04:05

AnneValentine · 30/10/2023 23:28

Then complain because that is not their policy.

Also molly said USUALLY not always. Her reply is bang on as far as I’m concerned.

We know it’s not their policy, but it’s become a common practice hence we are saying it’s very possible it happened in this instance.

Well this isn’t really about whether we should complain or not - but yes I agree if you mean OP has to take it up with Royal Mail. Which is what most posters are saying. This is her legal responsibility IF the buyer didn’t choose the safe place from where it was taken.

Also molly said USUALLY not always. Her reply is bang on as far as I’m concerned

I didn’t address that poster, I was responding directly to your post saying in your experience you had to specify safe place for Royal Mail . My point is that’s great, but for many of us that’s not the case.

Mothership4two · 31/10/2023 03:57

According to royal mail website either person (buyer or seller) can make a claim, but they will only compensate one party. If both buyer and seller claim then the compensation will automatically go to the seller.

OP you could inform your customer that you will compensate when you have been compensated.

You need to find out if the customer nominated their safe space too as if they did then it is then that falls under their responsibility not yours.

urbanbuddha · 31/10/2023 03:35

The problem is that Royal Mail just arbitrarily decide on the “safe place”. The recipient isn’t consulted. In my case they didn’t even bother to ring the bell - that’s not uncommon.
Once I’d calmed down, and after I’d fired off a furious complaint to Royal Mail, I figured they had delivered it to the wrong address because it was easier to pull in at that spot that day.

X6hfyib4ms · 31/10/2023 03:25

My understanding with Royal mail that if you (as the parcel recipient) pick a safe place and they prove delivery then it disappears, then they take no further responsibility. You can opt out of the safe place and they will not deliver it and you have to re arrange delivery.

I think you can be sympathetic but ultimately it's their responsibility if they opted for delivery to a safe place and then it has been stolen, you have to know your neighbourhood and what is likely.

urbanbuddha · 31/10/2023 03:21

I had this at the weekend.

As requested the seller marked the parcel in LARGE letters -

”RING ONLY BELL X AND DELIVER TO URBANBUDDHA”

Royal Mail texted instead (I was in) and said that they had delivered to my “safe place”. I eventually found my parcel three doors down at the top of the steps leading down to their meters.

I much prefer click and collect - never any problems with that.

Aibu to not refund this buyer?
Mydogmybestfriend · 31/10/2023 02:26

Only the sender can raise a claim via royal mail not the buyer

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 31/10/2023 00:52

justanothermanicmonday1 · 31/10/2023 00:43

I work in insurance and we get this constantly. Stolen items are only covered if they are locked in a safe and secure place and out of sight.

Tell him to jog on. Not your fault his safe place wasn't safe.

And if he didn’t designate a safe place and it was the RM (acting as an agent of the seller) who chose to leave it somewhere vulnerable?

Legally that would be the OP (via her agent) who didn’t take proper care and she would be legally responsible for the loss.

Someone posted the link to the guidance that confirms this some pages back.

justanothermanicmonday1 · 31/10/2023 00:43

I work in insurance and we get this constantly. Stolen items are only covered if they are locked in a safe and secure place and out of sight.

Tell him to jog on. Not your fault his safe place wasn't safe.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 31/10/2023 00:26

Ohnoooooooo · 30/10/2023 23:54

Buyer choose the postal option, buyer choose the 'safe' place and now you are possible out of pocket. I get why you would be annoyed. Frankly, I think if you end up needing to take the hit for this I would issue them a refund rather than redoing it as this may happen again.

Except there is nothing to say the buyer did choose the safe place (RM has a bad habit of doing that themselves) and the postal option is to protect the seller not the buyer - and the OP chose to allow non-signed for post.

MidnightMeltdown · 31/10/2023 00:01

It entirely depends on whether the buyer specified the 'safe place' for the parcel to be delivered to

If they didn't, then the seller is responsible for the missing parcel because it wasn't delivered as expected. You will have to take it up with the courier.

ACGTHelixA · 31/10/2023 00:00

EasterIssland · 30/10/2023 23:51

Im a bit surprised by your attitude to be honest. Also , unsure how much the item was worth and whether you’re a business , but if I was the buyer and you refused to refund the money (that you can claim off Royal Mail) I’d make sure everyone knows about your behaviour when things go wrong leaving you a bad review

the problem then is if royal mail absolve themselves of the issue and if it was delivered correctly then how can royal mail be liable ?

Ohnoooooooo · 30/10/2023 23:54

Buyer choose the postal option, buyer choose the 'safe' place and now you are possible out of pocket. I get why you would be annoyed. Frankly, I think if you end up needing to take the hit for this I would issue them a refund rather than redoing it as this may happen again.

EasterIssland · 30/10/2023 23:51

Im a bit surprised by your attitude to be honest. Also , unsure how much the item was worth and whether you’re a business , but if I was the buyer and you refused to refund the money (that you can claim off Royal Mail) I’d make sure everyone knows about your behaviour when things go wrong leaving you a bad review

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 30/10/2023 23:47

EsmeSusanOgg · 30/10/2023 23:38

YABU it wasn't delivered. Royal Mail did not have it to a resident. Legally, as the retailer, you are obliged to refund then. You then claim from Royal Mail. Ensure you use signed for in future.

Actually, legally it does look like if the buyer chooses ‘safe space’, they are assuming the risk and (providing the item was left in the correct place), no refund is required.

The difficulty comes with establishing:

  1. The buyer chose ‘safe space’ (since RM has a habit of doing this themselves); and if so
  2. The item was left in the correct safe space (again, not some random location the postman thought was suitable).
ACGTHelixA · 30/10/2023 23:40

Sellerseller1 · 30/10/2023 15:21

Yes this is my point. They have just sent me a short email saying "parcel has been stolen, i require a refund from you as ive been unable to use the item"

thats very suspect, could you email them and say they may need to discuss the matter with the police as you have contacted them and have said about x item going missing and see what the buyer says, to see if they are bluffing ?

rrrrrreatt · 30/10/2023 23:38

I never mark leave in a safe place because I don’t have one, this doesn’t deter people delivering in the slightest - apparently my cardboard bin in front yard is the safe place I didn’t know I wanted. Not only is it not secure at all but, if it’s been recently emptied, I can’t reach the bottom so I have to wait for my partner to come home to get it out.

Royal Mail did it last week and Amazon keep doing it, no matter how many times I ask them not to. They shouldn’t but they do.

EsmeSusanOgg · 30/10/2023 23:38

YABU it wasn't delivered. Royal Mail did not have it to a resident. Legally, as the retailer, you are obliged to refund then. You then claim from Royal Mail. Ensure you use signed for in future.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 30/10/2023 23:34

AnneValentine · 30/10/2023 23:28

Then complain because that is not their policy.

Also molly said USUALLY not always. Her reply is bang on as far as I’m concerned.

You appear to have missed the following paragraph where she said

To do this the buyer would have to use the tracking for the parcel and
select ‘leave in a safe place’

No ‘usually’ included, just an incorrect statement that the buyer must have chosen the safe space.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 30/10/2023 23:29

AnneValentine · 30/10/2023 22:39

Not in my experience, you have to specify with Royal Mail.

And multiple people on this thread have a different experience.

For the avoidance of doubt, none of the parcels left in full view on my doorstep by RM have ever been stolen so I’ve never had to ask for a refund - I’ve got no reason to lie and I’d appreciate it if you’d stop implying that’s what we are all doing.

AnneValentine · 30/10/2023 23:28

Riola · 30/10/2023 22:46

Well as you can read on this thread many of us - including me - haven’t chosen a safe space and Royal mail or other delivery couriers have decided for us.

Then complain because that is not their policy.

Also molly said USUALLY not always. Her reply is bang on as far as I’m concerned.

ExTheCheater · 30/10/2023 23:27

Would you not have to raise it with royal mail? My elderly grandmother sent me something that went missing and I contacted royal mail and was told she has to do it as she sent it. I didn't want to cause her hassle so we left it.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 30/10/2023 23:26

AnneValentine · 30/10/2023 22:38

So what exactly did Molly say that was wrong then?

The bit where she said:

To do this the buyer would have to use the tracking for the parcel and
select ‘leave in a safe place’

In the experience of multiple people on this thread, if you don’t pick ‘leave in a safe space’, RM will leave it somewhere on / near your property and mark tracking as ‘left in a safe space’ anyway.

Falzarega · 30/10/2023 23:16

Oh no!

I’m going to blame royal mail. Today they left my parcel in my wheelie bin, balanced on bags of dog poo. I’ve told them numerous times not to leave items if I’m out, just return to the post office like you’re supposed to and I’ll pick it up, but postmen absolutely love throwing parcels in bins it seems. And if it’s bin day and the bin men empty the bin, there goes your parcel straight into landfill.

Whoever paid roual mail needs to take it up with royal mail. This isn’t your buyer’s fault.

Sorry about your hard work :( next time do recorded signed-for delivery and charge the seller for it.