Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not refund this buyer?

286 replies

Sellerseller1 · 30/10/2023 14:48

Have an online website selling handmade items.

Buyers item was shipped with royal mail tracked delivery, tracking info says it was delivered to a safe place.

Customer has now emailed to say item must have been stolen from said safe place and therefore they want me to refund.

Aibu to say no? I have sympathy if it genuinely was stolen but firstly I can't just refund everyone who messages to say something has been stolen with no evidence it actually has been and secondly, I've fulfilled my obligation in that it's been sent and marked as delivered on the tracking page.

If they come back and it seems they are actually telling the truth I.e. trying to correspond with royal mail/ the police then I may as a gesture of good will replace it but I don't think I need to straight away? (Or even at all technically).

Fwiw item wasn't cheap and took a lot of work.

OP posts:
Dinglewoop · 30/10/2023 17:10

Sorry that's happened OP! That must be really gutting as it's a hand made item and I assume took you a long time.

I think you're right in that the customer could be telling the truth or just as easily could be lying and trying to get a freebie from you. I would keep on to royal mail to find out what happened/ see if they'll refund you. Can you say to seller that you will provide a refund or replacement if/when royal mail is unable to trace the parcel?

Perhaps so this doesn't happen again in the future, you should change your delivery options so there is only delivery with signature. Good luck!

C152 · 30/10/2023 17:05

I think YABU, OP. Royal Mail are notoriously bad at delivering anything and often completely invent a 'safe space', if they bother to dump the parcel at all, rather than just leave it at the sorting office and claim they tried to deliver.

If the items you make are of a high value, I would reconsider the delivery options you have available on your site. Either that or put the price of each item up a little bit to cover the occassional lost item.

KeeefBurtain · 30/10/2023 17:04

I’ve literally had the same thing as the buyer happen to me yesterday.

there’s a gate you need to get through to get to my house, it’s on the high street. There’s photo evidence that the Courier left it outside the gate on the street (my safe space is a neighbours house) and it was inevitably stolen.
the company I bought from immediately actioned a replacement order which will be delivered tomorrow. It wasn’t a small amount, just shy of £130 worth of goods.

if it was a one of a kind handmade item I think it unlikely the buyer would ask for a replacement if they had actually received the item. I’d be more wary if they pushed for a refund tbh.

Your customer ordered and didn’t receive goods from you, and are due either their order or the money back. If they were inclined they could kick up a stink and bad mouth your business online, which could damage your brand. I think the right thing to do would be to refund/replace and coordinate with the courier yourself.

GoonieGang · 30/10/2023 17:02

I don’t think you should refund. If I got home to find the package wasn’t in my safe place then I wouldn’t automatically ask for a refund because they delivered it. I can’t blame the seller for as it was actually delivered 🤷‍♀️

roibustea · 30/10/2023 16:57

Sorry, but onus is on you as seller. Contact Royal Mail as they will need to prove they have left it somewhere that the buyer has agreed to be used as a safe space; if they can't then they will be liable, but only for the amount you've insured it for. I often don't get deliveries that they say have been delivered as I have quite a confusing entry, I call up and have the order resent or refunded. I have no idea if it's the company or the courier who refund, it's up to them to argue about it - the contract I have entered demands that the seller deliver me my goods and so I expect the parcel to be handed to me directly or left in a prearranged safe space. Would you just shrug your shoulders and chalk it up to a loss if you ordered something and the courier said it was put in a safe space but you never received it?

DreamingofGinoclock · 30/10/2023 16:54

I think after experiencing something from your customers side of things:

  1. If she asked Royal mail to leave in the safe space she doesn't have a leg to stand on (we had an item left in an unrequested (un)safe space.)
  1. If she didn't leave in a safe space she needs to log it with royal mail so they can investigate
  1. Then you need to take it up with royal mail as contract for delivery with royal mail was with you.

4..then only refund your customer of royal mail re fund you

I may be totally wrong though

donquixotedelamancha · 30/10/2023 16:41

If it wasn't left in a safe place then it's on Royal Mail/ the courier to refund them, not you OP. I'd advise them to contact the courier and raise a refund request that way.

As pp said, not a safe place then was it. Ignore them unless they can provide evidence of pursuing it with the carrier.

Either the royal mail is responsible or they need to claim on their house insurance. I don't think you are liable.

The item was 'stolen' whilst in the buyer's property/possession, not yours.

Why do people give completely incorrect advice with such certainty? If you don't know something it's really unhelpful to just spout your random opinion.

As PPs have said, the buyers contract is with OP, they have nothing to do with the courier who is working on behalf of OP. You want to google the Consumer Rights Act 2015 @Sellerseller1.

You will find that you either need to deliver the goods you contracted for to the purchaser (not dumped outside their address) or refund the money. If you think RM is negligent you need to take that up with them.

fuzzleberry · 30/10/2023 16:38

Sellerseller1 · 30/10/2023 14:59

Unfortunately I don't think royal mail will pay out their insurance if their tracking is saying delivered to the correct address.

I have responded and asked the buyer to contact royal mail and said that I will do so as well to show willing on my part to help.

I just don't know how I can be expected to refund or replace every item that someone just decides to tell me has been stolen, obviously I would if the tracking wasn't showing as delivered but how can I know its not a scam and what's to stop every other buyer just saying the same and getting a refund?

Have you shared the GPS coordinates / photos from your tracking with the buyer?

You have to raise the claim with Royal Mail ( ask them to open an investigation if you doubt she's telling the truth which means they will raise the issue with the local office and can ask her postie where they left it - let her know you're going down this route to help her track it down and it might 'appear'
)

But you need to raise the claim with RM and you need to refund her - her contract is with you, RM will not deal with her as the end customer ( nor should they have to her contract is with you )

margotrose · 30/10/2023 16:31

Jewelspun · 30/10/2023 16:18

I alway thought the onus was on the seller to get the item to the buyer and in the event of their chosen courier cocking it up, the seller should immediately refund the buyer and take up the complaint with the courier to claim on the postage insurance.

It is.

margotrose · 30/10/2023 16:31

Mumwithqs · 30/10/2023 16:09

The buyer chose to ask the driver to leave it in a safe place. The place clearly wasn't safe. That's not your problem.

The item was 'stolen' whilst in the buyer's property/possession, not yours.

We don't know that.

Royal Mail often pick their own random "safe space".

Jewelspun · 30/10/2023 16:18

I alway thought the onus was on the seller to get the item to the buyer and in the event of their chosen courier cocking it up, the seller should immediately refund the buyer and take up the complaint with the courier to claim on the postage insurance.

Mumwithqs · 30/10/2023 16:09

The buyer chose to ask the driver to leave it in a safe place. The place clearly wasn't safe. That's not your problem.

The item was 'stolen' whilst in the buyer's property/possession, not yours.

Autumnleaves89 · 30/10/2023 15:55

margotrose · 30/10/2023 15:22

They often do make up a safe space.

Agreed! My most recent “safe space” was my FULL wheelie bin, on the curb outside my house waiting for collection!! Luckily I found it first!

princefamilypaper · 30/10/2023 15:50

I got told an item was left in a safe place- I hadn't specified one DPD justx decided to pick one. Several months later I found a parcel right in the bottom of a bush 🙄 so maybe it's not actually stolen it's just in a random location?

TenderDandelions · 30/10/2023 15:49

I would be very suspicious of someone that's ordered a personalised item but once it's "stolen" demands a refund rather than another item. I would be very unsure whether it wasn't actually delivered correctly and they're now claiming that it's gone missing.

Common sense would say - OP contacts Royal Mail. If RM claim it's been delivered to a "safe place", then whether that safe place was noted by the buyer (therefore their fault if the safe place isn't actually safe) or RM (then I would say it's their fault they chose a non-safe place).

Buyer should be entitled to a replacement item at most - not a refund.

As I say, that's what would be sensible to me, but I know common sense doesn't always prevail!

Viviennemary · 30/10/2023 15:41

Either the royal mail is responsible or they need to claim on their house insurance. I don't think you are liable.

Mrsm010918 · 30/10/2023 15:38

Fellow handmade seller 🙋‍♀️

If the buyer nominated the safe place then they are responsible and you do not have to refund. I would ask them if they had nominated a safe space.

If they didn't nominate and it was just left then it's your responsibility as a seller to cover either a refund or replacement.

Was there an image taken of the delivery?

I don't like to assume people are liars but... there's an increasing number of people who seem to be after free stuff in the handmade circles.

In the event they nominated a safe place themselves and you have an image of the delivery I would point them towards reporting parcel theft and would not refund. I recently had one delivery delivered without GPS coordinates and no image of delivery so I sent a replacement in that instance as no-one would be able to prove either way if it had been delivered or not.

Ophy83 · 30/10/2023 15:35

If the customer nominated the safe space they will also have had to confirm to Royal mail that they are responsible for any loss or damage that occurs as a result

Neriah · 30/10/2023 15:27

Sellerseller1 · 30/10/2023 15:26

No it isn't. I have had this - the contract is between the person who ordered the delivery to be made (the seller) and Royal Mail / the courier. Royal Mail / courier will only refund or even speak to the person who is their client

According to royal mail website either person (buyer or seller) can make a claim, but they will only compensate one party. If both buyer and seller claim then the compensation will automatically go to the seller.

Well they've changed their minds then because they refused point blank to deal with me - and I was the one with CCTV of them putting the parcel in the bin!

Neriah · 30/10/2023 15:26

BaconMassive · 30/10/2023 15:21

Royal Mail wouldn't make up a safe space it will have been designated by the recipient.

In March 2020 - I recall the date well, Royal Mail left an expensive delivery in a "safe space" - the rubbish bin, on the pavement OUTSIDE my house, on collection day. If they don't make them up, then they need a different definition of "safe space".

Sellerseller1 · 30/10/2023 15:26

No it isn't. I have had this - the contract is between the person who ordered the delivery to be made (the seller) and Royal Mail / the courier. Royal Mail / courier will only refund or even speak to the person who is their client

According to royal mail website either person (buyer or seller) can make a claim, but they will only compensate one party. If both buyer and seller claim then the compensation will automatically go to the seller.

OP posts:
Sellerseller1 · 30/10/2023 15:25

Merryoldgoat · 30/10/2023 15:24

If it’s a valuable item why did you not send it requiring a signature on delivery?

The customer selected this option at checkout.

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 30/10/2023 15:24

If it’s a valuable item why did you not send it requiring a signature on delivery?

Neriah · 30/10/2023 15:24

mummabubs · 30/10/2023 14:57

If it wasn't left in a safe place then it's on Royal Mail/ the courier to refund them, not you OP. I'd advise them to contact the courier and raise a refund request that way.

As you say, you've fulfilled all the parts of your contract with her- it's the delivery company that have failed on their part if the buyer is telling the truth x

No it isn't. I have had this - the contract is between the person who ordered the delivery to be made (the seller) and Royal Mail / the courier. Royal Mail / courier will only refund or even speak to the person who is their client.

The "safe place" that my courier yesterday left my very large parcel was in full view of the entire street on the doorstep - I was in and he didn't even bother to ring.

margotrose · 30/10/2023 15:22

BaconMassive · 30/10/2023 15:21

Royal Mail wouldn't make up a safe space it will have been designated by the recipient.

They often do make up a safe space.