Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not refund this buyer?

286 replies

Sellerseller1 · 30/10/2023 14:48

Have an online website selling handmade items.

Buyers item was shipped with royal mail tracked delivery, tracking info says it was delivered to a safe place.

Customer has now emailed to say item must have been stolen from said safe place and therefore they want me to refund.

Aibu to say no? I have sympathy if it genuinely was stolen but firstly I can't just refund everyone who messages to say something has been stolen with no evidence it actually has been and secondly, I've fulfilled my obligation in that it's been sent and marked as delivered on the tracking page.

If they come back and it seems they are actually telling the truth I.e. trying to correspond with royal mail/ the police then I may as a gesture of good will replace it but I don't think I need to straight away? (Or even at all technically).

Fwiw item wasn't cheap and took a lot of work.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YireosDodeAver · 21/12/2023 14:17

Ok yeah that makes sense

Haffiana · 21/12/2023 11:02

YireosDodeAver · 21/12/2023 07:27

@Haffiana this isn't about the iten quality at all though.

In this case the customer was given a choice between a fully insured and guaranteed courier delivery at one price, or a basic Royal Mail postage without insurance at a cheaper price and they chose the latter. If an ordinary uninsured item of post like that goes astray, Royal Mail will not cover the full cost. They may refund up to £20 if the value of the missing item can be proven. The limit gors up to £50 if you pay extra for Signed For which didn't happen here.

I don't think it's sensible to offer customers this choice if items are valuable, the insured courier option should be the only option. However given that the customer was given the choice and chose as less secure method without insurance the customer does bear some responsibility and it shouldn't be OP taking the loss. The responsibility lies mainly with Royal Mail but the recompense to the customer is rightly linked to Royal Mail's policies.

If the item was delivered and was bad then of course the customer should be refunded in full but that hasn't happened.

The choice of courier is not relevant to the customer.

The choice to insure is for the benefit of the SENDER. The sender pays for the courier or postage, and therefore the SENDER has the contract for insurance (or not) with the courier. The sender needs to select the level of protection that THEY need, and pass on the cost of that to the buyer. If items go missing, then it is the SENDER who is covered.

The buyer has a contract with the seller to whom they gave their money, NOT with the courier. They have not entered into any contract with the courier because they have not booked them or paid them. They are not insured with the courier at any point. Only the sender is. The sender is the only one who can make a claim.

I am staggered that people do not understand this. You do not get to dump your obligation to a buyer by blaming them for the seller not sufficiently insuring the item that they are sending.

TheCave · 21/12/2023 08:36

@YireosDodeAver unfortunately that's not what the law says though.

YireosDodeAver · 21/12/2023 07:27

@Haffiana this isn't about the iten quality at all though.

In this case the customer was given a choice between a fully insured and guaranteed courier delivery at one price, or a basic Royal Mail postage without insurance at a cheaper price and they chose the latter. If an ordinary uninsured item of post like that goes astray, Royal Mail will not cover the full cost. They may refund up to £20 if the value of the missing item can be proven. The limit gors up to £50 if you pay extra for Signed For which didn't happen here.

I don't think it's sensible to offer customers this choice if items are valuable, the insured courier option should be the only option. However given that the customer was given the choice and chose as less secure method without insurance the customer does bear some responsibility and it shouldn't be OP taking the loss. The responsibility lies mainly with Royal Mail but the recompense to the customer is rightly linked to Royal Mail's policies.

If the item was delivered and was bad then of course the customer should be refunded in full but that hasn't happened.

Haffiana · 20/12/2023 23:23

If you ordered a turkey to be delivered from Tesco, then opened it and found it was bad - would you be happy if Tesco told you they would have to send it back to Bernard Matthews, and that they would refund you when Bernard Matthews refunded them?

Or would you expect them to replace it immediately so that you had the turkey that you paid for, or immediately refund your money?

Swanfeet · 20/12/2023 23:00

Haffiana · 20/12/2023 22:20

I also have an online business. This has happened to me twice. Both times I’ve contacted Royal Mail. One time the delivery proof photo didn’t actually prove anything so they refunded me the cost of postage and the cost of the item, in that case I then refunded the customer too after I’d received my refund.

You won't have an online business for long if that is how you treat your customers. What on earth are you thinking, making a customer wait until you had been refunded? Are you actually saying that their money is less important than yours?? That they should just wait around when you have not provided what they paid for? You are really lucky that customer did not go straight to SM to warn others about your appalling service.

If you are unable to understand your legal obligations or how to cost your product to account for the possibility of loss then you should not be in business.

Gosh you’re angry aren’t you! Lots of very cross, opinions based on one comment by someone whose business you know nothing about. I bet you’re fun to deal with as a customer!

If I refunded people immediately without question, I would have no business! As it happens I have wonderful reviews, happy customers, many of whom are repeat customers.

Haffiana · 20/12/2023 22:20

Swanfeet · 20/12/2023 18:42

I also have an online business. This has happened to me twice. Both times I’ve contacted Royal Mail. One time the delivery proof photo didn’t actually prove anything so they refunded me the cost of postage and the cost of the item, in that case I then refunded the customer too after I’d received my refund.

second time I contacted Royal Mail, they said it had been delivered so my customer had to then take up the claim with them…I didn’t hear back from the customer and didn’t provide a refund.

i think most people are honest, but sadly some try to get something for nothing.

I also have an online business. This has happened to me twice. Both times I’ve contacted Royal Mail. One time the delivery proof photo didn’t actually prove anything so they refunded me the cost of postage and the cost of the item, in that case I then refunded the customer too after I’d received my refund.

You won't have an online business for long if that is how you treat your customers. What on earth are you thinking, making a customer wait until you had been refunded? Are you actually saying that their money is less important than yours?? That they should just wait around when you have not provided what they paid for? You are really lucky that customer did not go straight to SM to warn others about your appalling service.

If you are unable to understand your legal obligations or how to cost your product to account for the possibility of loss then you should not be in business.

Swanfeet · 20/12/2023 18:42

I also have an online business. This has happened to me twice. Both times I’ve contacted Royal Mail. One time the delivery proof photo didn’t actually prove anything so they refunded me the cost of postage and the cost of the item, in that case I then refunded the customer too after I’d received my refund.

second time I contacted Royal Mail, they said it had been delivered so my customer had to then take up the claim with them…I didn’t hear back from the customer and didn’t provide a refund.

i think most people are honest, but sadly some try to get something for nothing.

Mothership4two · 20/12/2023 15:22

What happened @Sellerseller1?

Someone on another site posted this recently: The Consumer Rights Act, holds the retailer legally responsible for goods until they are safely received. “The burden of proof is on the retailer to show goods were delivered, not on the customer to show they were not. If the seller tries to wash their hands of this then customers who pay by credit or debit card can issue a chargeback via their bank.

Which confirms what I said upthread.

CrebillionFils · 07/11/2023 04:46

I have never nominated a safe space with any courier, however have been notified that packages were left in a safe space many times, usually the photo depicts my front door, which is in full view of the street on which an drugs addicts treatment centre exists, so anything left out in view of the street is stolen.

Evri and Royal Mail are the worst culprits.
@LondonJax gives good advice imo.

Tambatamba · 07/11/2023 03:47

fearfuloffluff · 04/11/2023 10:40

There must be a gap in the market for a courier that is not shit (even if it costs slightly more?)

There is - UPS

LondonJax · 05/11/2023 18:35

I've had a small on line business for almost 8 years now. In that time I've probably had half a dozen items go astray and have had to refund about three times. My normal response is:

  1. Ask the person to check around the 'safe area' and with neighbours. One woman in Covid lockdown had a parcel supposedly left on her doorstep. It was actually in the bushes next to the doorstep...I'm guessing the postie tried to hide in for safety but didn't tell her that.

  2. If it's still missing I offer a new item (cheaper for me to remake than to refund obviously as I add on a profit margin when I sell)

  3. If that's not acceptable (and it usually is as customers don't want the hassle finding a replacement as long as you can get it to them quickly) then I refund. I can't accuse a customer of lying - I have no proof and I've been in that situation myself before. It's not nice to be doubted.

  4. I then take it up with the courier (I use RM) and we go from there. Not the customer's problem to sort out.

I've either been very lucky with my customers or most people are very honest.

I've even had a customer get back in touch with me after Christmas a couple of years ago. She'd been away for the weekend when the parcel had been delivered, her neighbour had taken it off her doorstep as it was raining and then subsequently went away themselves without telling her they had her parcel!

Then, when they got home, came round with the missing parcel! She made arrangements to pay for it again. And, as I'd been civil about it, it was a funny conversation to have. So most people are honest.

You can't do anything about dishonest people unfortunately. The consumer acts are very clear and you have to follow the law if you're in business. But you can ask them to double check with neighbours, other people in the house, and other 'safe' areas just in case.

stichguru · 04/11/2023 12:48

If the package was not delivered correctly - YOU will need to refund the customer and then make the claim against Royal Mail. When you the customer paid for the item, you agreed to get the item to her. The item hasn't turn up so YOU have broken the agreement and need to refund the customer. When you posted the item a second agreement was made between YOU and ROYAL MAIL that they would safely deliver the item for you. If they have failed in this, THEY need to refund you, but you the can't pass this to the customer, because they had no part in your agreement with Royal Mail. It would be reasonable to check with Royal Mail what they think happened though. Royal Mail should either show you evidence that they did a reasonable thing to fulfill your request, like deliver to the customers safe place. In which case you can show this to the customer to say that you fulfilled your agreement and what happen next is on them so they don't need a refund. Or Royal Mail did something stupid like lost the parcel or threw it over the fence into her pond. In which case YOU broke your agreement to the customer, and so you refund her, and then you get that money back from Royal Mail who broke their agreement to you.

suchandsuchandsuchandsuch · 04/11/2023 11:29

The refund is down to you sorry, and as for the what ifs, what if the person is telling the truth and the courier you selected lost it? They’re hardly going to use you again or recommend you to a friend and if anything they’ll tell people to avoid using you I would if my parcel hadn’t turned up.

you and only you can raise a claim with Royal Mail, I’ve had parcels say they’ve been delivered in the past and haven’t received them, they say they’ve been left in a “safe place”, I’ve never specified a safe place and if people ring I ask them to leave it with a neighbour. We’ve had parcels left at the bottom of the drive before when anyone can take it, also my postman has a tendency to leave me other people’s mail etc and I have to walk up to their house and drop it off what’s to say this hasn’t happened and the persons house it was left at hasn’t just decided to keep it, this happened with my dad.

Personally I think you have to refund it in good faith and chase with Royal Mail yourself.

fearfuloffluff · 04/11/2023 10:40

There must be a gap in the market for a courier that is not shit (even if it costs slightly more?)

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 04/11/2023 10:33

Jaybail · 03/11/2023 21:54

When I get notified that a delivery is being made for something purchased online, there is a box to tick as an option for Royal Mail should I be away from home at the time of delivery. I get choices such as with neighbour - specific number - outbuilding, porch, safe place etc. If selecting safe place it asks for details - behind Wheely bin, back of building, behind gate etc.
IF, and it is only an if, the recipient has advised Royal Mail of their safe place preference then surely that is for them to ensure that they have nominated somewhere actually safe?

Of course it is (both legally and morally) - no one is disputing that. What a lot of people are disputing is the suggestion that the only way RM will leave an item is if the recipient has chosen a safe place and therefore the fact RM left the item at the address must mean the OP can deny all responsibility (not legally true if the RM picked their own safe place and left the item there or if they left the item somewhere other than the chosen safe place).

Jaybail · 03/11/2023 21:54

When I get notified that a delivery is being made for something purchased online, there is a box to tick as an option for Royal Mail should I be away from home at the time of delivery. I get choices such as with neighbour - specific number - outbuilding, porch, safe place etc. If selecting safe place it asks for details - behind Wheely bin, back of building, behind gate etc.
IF, and it is only an if, the recipient has advised Royal Mail of their safe place preference then surely that is for them to ensure that they have nominated somewhere actually safe?

Mumofferralkid3 · 03/11/2023 20:52

Royal mail have been known to say it is delivered but it isn't to make theit quota. It happened to me and then they delivered a day later. Also, RM aren't the best. I've had items that are signed for parcels and they have faked my signature. I'd raise it as it goes around in circles and I would want to seem as though I was helpful to my customer. A lot to be said for repeat business.

Sn1859 · 03/11/2023 20:40

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 03/11/2023 20:24

It would never occur to me not to go straight to the seller since I know I have no contract with the delivery company. Also, as far as I’m concerned, if the seller’s chosen delivery company has screwed up, the seller can put in the time and effort sorting things out - their responsibility, their problem.

I never said they didn’t have that responsibility but I’ve always found I’ve had better assistance from the delivery company instead of waiting for the seller to deal with the issue. Luckily it’s only happened to me a few times and it’s always been rectified quickly.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 03/11/2023 20:24

Sn1859 · 03/11/2023 19:30

I’ve had items misplaced during delivery before and I’ve never gone straight to the seller unless I’ve contacted the delivery company first and they’ve told me to speak to them. The fact they went straight to you for a refund instead of asking you to see if you can check anything first seems a bit iffy to me. It clearly went to their property if they know it was ‘stolen’ so it’s not lost, in someone else’s shed or at Petes down the next road.

It would never occur to me not to go straight to the seller since I know I have no contract with the delivery company. Also, as far as I’m concerned, if the seller’s chosen delivery company has screwed up, the seller can put in the time and effort sorting things out - their responsibility, their problem.

Sn1859 · 03/11/2023 19:34

TheCave · 03/11/2023 18:15

There's a lot of bad advice on here. Denying refunds / demanding why she wants a refund / asking for a police report etc are all contrary to the buyer's rights IF the item was not delivered to a place the buyer specifically indicated. The OP has not clarified this very critical point. If the buyer is entitled to a refund by law, she doesn't have to justify why (the fact that her item wasn't delivered is sufficient) or provide a police report (the police may refuse to provide one anyway if there is no evidence of any crime being committed).

Leaving aside WHAT the law requires, it does seem there is a real gap here where the law protects consumers including ones who are not acting honestly. It seems like a real issue for businesses. But the alternative is to only deliver things when someone opens their front door (or nominates a safe place), and then no one would ever get their stuff and we would probably all complain about that more (and order less stuff). So ultimately the sellers and delivery companies take a risk because it's preferable to the risk of customers not ordering stuff at all.

They police may not issue a full report but all calls have a CAD number that can be used in these situations. I had to have a broken window fixed.

Sn1859 · 03/11/2023 19:30

I’ve had items misplaced during delivery before and I’ve never gone straight to the seller unless I’ve contacted the delivery company first and they’ve told me to speak to them. The fact they went straight to you for a refund instead of asking you to see if you can check anything first seems a bit iffy to me. It clearly went to their property if they know it was ‘stolen’ so it’s not lost, in someone else’s shed or at Petes down the next road.

TheCave · 03/11/2023 18:15

There's a lot of bad advice on here. Denying refunds / demanding why she wants a refund / asking for a police report etc are all contrary to the buyer's rights IF the item was not delivered to a place the buyer specifically indicated. The OP has not clarified this very critical point. If the buyer is entitled to a refund by law, she doesn't have to justify why (the fact that her item wasn't delivered is sufficient) or provide a police report (the police may refuse to provide one anyway if there is no evidence of any crime being committed).

Leaving aside WHAT the law requires, it does seem there is a real gap here where the law protects consumers including ones who are not acting honestly. It seems like a real issue for businesses. But the alternative is to only deliver things when someone opens their front door (or nominates a safe place), and then no one would ever get their stuff and we would probably all complain about that more (and order less stuff). So ultimately the sellers and delivery companies take a risk because it's preferable to the risk of customers not ordering stuff at all.

mrsmartins85 · 03/11/2023 17:54

I don’t have a safe place registered with Royal Mail. Two weeks ago I couldn’t find a package that they said was delivered to “safe place”. The seller was confused as although they hadn’t taken a picture, they pinned my address correctly on the map. The buyer can’t raise the issue with Royal Mail, the seller has to, as it says on their website. I found it, after a neighbour suggested I check my recycling bin!!! That’s where it was, luckily it was bins week… I’m still really angry, apparently putting things in recycling is very much a thing. Hate Royal Mail.

Swipe left for the next trending thread