Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what happens next? 5yo being naughty and violent at school

59 replies

EasterBonbon · 30/10/2023 08:51

5yo SS started reception this year and is being very badly behaved. His teacher has been telling us and his mum and step-dad almost daily at pick-up and email that he’s not paying attention and being violent and unkind to other children.

He’s one of the oldest in his class, was 5 in Sept, and has been in full-time nursery since he was 1 and the school’s pre-school since 3, so it’s not that it’s new to him, though the need to focus and follow instructions has increased. Pre-school also flagged the lack of attention but the violence is new. He’s doing fine academically. He doesn’t seem to like school or any of his classmates, nor did he like preschool.

I’ve asked what happens next to the teacher and she’s just said they’ll keep an eye on it. We only have SS and his siblings on weekends and holidays (mum had an affair then moved away, we all get on fairly peacefully, the distance means we can’t have them more and his mum’s been very clear that she’d never agree to it) and we know his mum and stepdad are much more relaxed on discipline and rules, but there’s no abuse or anything, just little attention in a busy household. He’s honestly very well-behaved with us, including with his siblings and our friends’ kids, so it’s hard to comprehend.

Is he likely to be expelled if it continues? Sent to a PRU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Gaslit3 · 01/11/2023 07:41

Being naughty (unable to meet the needs of the classroom) and being violent (during a meltdown) can be signs of neurodivergence like ADHD or autism in some children, but giving people sly digs behind the teachers back does not relate to neurodivergence. He might also have one of those conditions, but this seems more like he is acting something out he has seen. How is his relationship with his siblings?

AbbeyGailsParty · 31/10/2023 19:09

CeciliaMars · 30/10/2023 17:14

Hold on - your child witnesses his stepdad hitting the dogs? This kinda changes everything for me. He is witnessing abuse of animals, and to be honest if the stepdad can hit an innocent animal, I'm pretty sure he's not a nice guy generally to be around. Watching unsupervised Youtube with older step siblings is a recipe for disaster too. I would be really worried about what this child is being expose to in his mum's home.

This. The violence to animals stood out for me too.
His home with mum and stepdad sounds chaotic in the sense that there’s little routine, kids left to do their own thing ie watch YouTube that me not be suitable. Behaviour is usually playing out what they see ( and hear) or what they feel about home and the more chaotic the home life the more chaotic the behaviour.
As he is so different with your neighbours children there is something, I think, going on at home.

Gaslit3 · 31/10/2023 18:59

If he's seeing the dog controlled that way, maybe that's where he's got it from?

cestlavielife · 31/10/2023 13:39

Why wait? Make an appt now

EasterBonbon · 31/10/2023 12:44

We’re going to see how the next few weeks go and then ask to see the SENCO if the behaviour doesn’t improve. It’s heartening to read that so many have grown out of it, and good to read of successful school interventions too.

Ultimately we are concerned about SS’s other home life but our hands are tied. From what the teacher has said, it’s not meltdowns or attacks, but sly punches when other children aren’t obeying him and the teacher or TA isn’t directly supervising. He must have picked up the message that violence is a form of control from somewhere. We don’t think there’s any domestic violence at his other home, but we can’t be sure.

We’re hopeful he will grown out of it and this will have just been a phase.

OP posts:
Littlefish · 31/10/2023 09:47

Jellycats4life · 30/10/2023 09:31

ADHD was mentioned in pre-school, but his current teacher doesn’t think it’s likely, and it doesn’t excuse the violence either way.

If I had a pound for every teacher who convinced a parent to dismiss any notion of autism/ADHD/whatever, I’d be rich.

They are not experts. Sometimes they can spot the signs that parents miss, but equally a LOT of children fly under the radar.

I’m not saying your description of your stepson suggests ADHD particularly, but you need to have an open mind. There is something going on. There have been concerns around behaviour and inattention since preschool.

It’s a cliche but behaviour is communication. He’s telling everyone that he’s struggling and unhappy. This could be “normal” issues around settling into Reception, but it could be something else.

I absolutely agree.

Something is causing this level of overwhelm.

Witchcraftandhokum · 31/10/2023 05:50

Leah5678

He's not going to a Pru at 5 lol prus are for teenagers.

Nope. I've worked in a Primary PRU where the youngest child was 5.

BettyBakesCakes · 30/10/2023 23:14

neverbeenskiing · 30/10/2023 09:23

Children do not behave this way for no reason. In my school a child who struggles with inattention and has been repeatedly hurting classmates would have been flagged up to the SEND team by now. The fact that issues with focus and attention were noted in pre-school could be relevant. It would be reasonable for the parents to ask for a meeting with the SENCO.

This

b0zza1 · 30/10/2023 22:55

The key factor here is the school. My son was excluded every day from midday for his entire reception year. In order to 'keep himself and others safe' due to his violent behaviour. We changed schools and he hasn't been excluded once for the entirety of year 1.

I'm not saying his current school is bad, but the direction this takes will be driven by the school. Similarly he does not require a special needs diagnosis to gain the support he needs - the school can apply for funding for additional staff to support him (not all schools will do this though). Most support is also directed at behaviours these days, and so it's about finding what works for him. The right school can do this.

Again regardless of the cause what you know is that he is struggling in deal with the pressures of the school environment - he's fine with you, when those pressures aren't there - and so again it comes back to the school to put things in place to help him cope better.

TwinkleDinkleStarDar · 30/10/2023 21:45

This sounds a lot like my DS was 2 years ago. It was an awful awful time. I hated school pick up time as there was an incident every other day at one point

School said they thought he might have ADHD and he is waiting for an assessment ( ironically, I was diagnosed with ADHD in January this year as after reading about ADHD I was horrified to find It was like reading about myself! )

They do grow out of it, eventually. DS is nearly 7 now and keeps his hands to himself.

This isnt helpful but no punishment or negative consequences had any affect on my DC. He had/has poor self control and is very impulsive. Even at home he was the Same

He still lashes out at home now, but not at school anymore which is a bonus.

Hes in a mixed class now and is getting annoyed with a younger boy who keeps hurting him, I hear other children complaining about this little boy too and it breaks my heart a little as I know for a fact 2 years ago parents and children disliked my son because of his behaviour

My son started being able to go and have breaks when he was feeling overwhelmed ect. Hes on the list for SENCo ect. Hes started to make proper friends this year but I'm worried his reputation will never recover as he was that horrible boy you hear people talking about every year

cakecoffeecakecoffee · 30/10/2023 21:36

DS 4 has just started reception and he also had difficulties immediately. The school had us in on day 2 to discuss his needs and he was given a risk assessment and behaviour management plan within days. He now has a TA, a breakout area, various strategies being used and they’ve put a referral into the gp for an adhd assessment.

Shinyandnew1 · 30/10/2023 21:22

He's not going to a Pru at 5 lol prus are for teenagers.-

I wish people wouldn’t make things up and present them as fact! Of course there are pupil referral units and alternative provisions for primary aged children.

Screwballs · 30/10/2023 21:15

berksandbeyond · 30/10/2023 12:43

@Screwballs you can leave an unhappy relationship without introducing new partners into your very young children’s life, and often without uprooting them / moving away, I am sorry that this thought didn’t occur to you!

I'm glad life is so simple for you. Let's hope you never eat your words, or that your children never dare move on from unhappy relationships from which they spawned children.

Changednamesforthis22 · 30/10/2023 18:09

My child (7) has issues with following instructions and paying attention, adhd suspected and he's under the school senco. He's never hurt another child in school as far as I know, even when other children have physically hurt him on a couple of occasions he didn't even hit them back.

I would ask for a meeting with the senco but violent behaviour is more likely to have an emotional reason behind it than anything else.

Octavia64 · 30/10/2023 17:39

You are right the 5 year olds are not routinely violent.

However, it's not always neurodiversity. It can be attachment issues, and less palatably parenting issues.

I've seen all of them, and in some cases the violence went after support and intervention.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/10/2023 17:31

This is a child who’s parents have split up and both now have new partners, he’s the eldest in class and doesn’t like school, all are valid reasons why he is struggling

5 year olds aren’t routinely violent. It’s usually driven by anxiety. Which is usually driven by ND

Sugargliderwombat · 30/10/2023 17:26

All behaviour is a form of communication. I would request a meeting with them, as an eyfs teacher they should be observing them playing so should know : is it specific children or any children ? Is it in a certain area ? A certain time of day ? A certain activity? When it's noisy ? What is he like after he calms down ? Are there any positive friendships you could encourage with playdates ? I think you need to be given a clearer picture rather than just a briefing at the end of every day. I'd ask whether they can contact the senco incase there is something else going on, and maybe ask for a referral to cahms?

Escaperoom · 30/10/2023 17:17

DGD (6) has had some similar issues to those you describe. I think it is really difficult to tell the difference between behavioural issues they will just grow out of/can be helped and supported to overcome and some form of neurodiversity that needs proper diagnosis and specific strategies. Sometimes I think she is growing out of it as she can be perfectly well behaved and no problem at all and then the next time the smallest thing can set her off. The meltdowns and hitting out are definitely much improved though compared to the pre-school stage which makes me think probably not ND. Mum and Dad are very much on the same page as the school however and there is no split family which probably helps. In your situation OP I'm not sure you can reasonably do more than you are already, just loving and supporting him the best you can.

Beepbopadooda · 30/10/2023 17:16

COVID has had a big impact on this cohort of children - whilst not born in 2020, they were around 1 year old at the start of the pandemic and on the cusp of toddlerhood and learning important communication skills.

How is his spoken language/understanding? Developmental language disorder is more common than autism and rarely diagnosed as language difficulties are more hidden. It often manifests as behaviour you have described in younger children - www.oxfordhealth.nhs.uk/cit/resources/dld/

CeciliaMars · 30/10/2023 17:14

Hold on - your child witnesses his stepdad hitting the dogs? This kinda changes everything for me. He is witnessing abuse of animals, and to be honest if the stepdad can hit an innocent animal, I'm pretty sure he's not a nice guy generally to be around. Watching unsupervised Youtube with older step siblings is a recipe for disaster too. I would be really worried about what this child is being expose to in his mum's home.

Gaslit3 · 30/10/2023 17:02

Encouraging them to keep secrets is really concerning. I really hope that there is nothing ominous going on. It must be really hard to see this 5 year old in distress and not be able to help him. Hopefully if you and your DP remain positive parents and people in his life he will come to you should he need to. I hope his Mum will wake up to his needs not being met, be that due to neurodivergence, something in the household, a bullying situation or anything else. I would keep a note of any safeguarding concerns and keep showing up for him. Hopefully it will come to nothing, and it's just a rocky start to reception.

EasterBonbon · 30/10/2023 16:29

Gaslit3 · 30/10/2023 15:28

Defensive mum, lack of safe limits on viewing and behaviour, lack of input from grown ups (lack of supervision?), a chaotic household with lots of people, and a step dad who is violent with pets, that is a lot of red flags in that household. Whether he is neurodivergent or not it's a lot, and I wouldn't be so sure there isn't DV as his mum not wanting professional involvement and the stepdad mistreating animals and opting out of cop parenting both seem like pretty big red flags that there's something more going on. Obviously nobody knows, but it does sound like she is resistant to getting her son help, and that is neglecting his health/education needs if he does have ADHD or another condition he doesn't get diagnosis or treatment before because she's too emotionally immature to listen to any one else as regards her sons behaviour (which is becoming a significant problem in school). Sounds like he's a little boy in desperate need of somebody advocating for him if he isn't going to go down the path of multiple exclusions, permanent exclusion, PRU and potentially prison or other criminal charges if the violence continues into adulthood. I'm further on in that, and wish I had pushed harder for my child back when it was a smaller thing before things got significantly worse

Well, yes, those are my fears too. But nothing that’s going on is going to cross social services’ radar and the chances of SS’s mum voluntarily relinquishing custody is slim to none. So I’m not sure what else we can do. We are in regular contact with their school, but they’re not very proactive and we’re limited in how much of an impact we can have on SS’s behaviour when we only have him weekends and holidays.

She’s also very reluctant to get medical help for SC when they need it and is very defensive when we try to. Her family and friends won’t speak to us and SC have been told not to discuss what they do at their other home with us as it’s “invasive” apparently.

I’m really hopeful that SS can grow out of this behaviour, or that the school can put in some early interventions that work, but if it continues/escalates I’m really worried for him.

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 30/10/2023 15:35

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 30/10/2023 09:01

Sounds to me like you're blaming the mother and step-father. I'd have thought this issue was for the actual mother and father to be dealing with.

But it seems that the mother only allows limited access to the father, the child is mostly under her influence. If she is not allowing more access then she needs to shoulder this responsibility, she can't have it both ways when it suits her.

Gaslit3 · 30/10/2023 15:28

Defensive mum, lack of safe limits on viewing and behaviour, lack of input from grown ups (lack of supervision?), a chaotic household with lots of people, and a step dad who is violent with pets, that is a lot of red flags in that household. Whether he is neurodivergent or not it's a lot, and I wouldn't be so sure there isn't DV as his mum not wanting professional involvement and the stepdad mistreating animals and opting out of cop parenting both seem like pretty big red flags that there's something more going on. Obviously nobody knows, but it does sound like she is resistant to getting her son help, and that is neglecting his health/education needs if he does have ADHD or another condition he doesn't get diagnosis or treatment before because she's too emotionally immature to listen to any one else as regards her sons behaviour (which is becoming a significant problem in school). Sounds like he's a little boy in desperate need of somebody advocating for him if he isn't going to go down the path of multiple exclusions, permanent exclusion, PRU and potentially prison or other criminal charges if the violence continues into adulthood. I'm further on in that, and wish I had pushed harder for my child back when it was a smaller thing before things got significantly worse

Merseymum992 · 30/10/2023 15:08

He wasn't violent at home or with family, ever. Not perfect but just typical 4-5 year old behaviour. I still don't understand why he behaved in that way but he got through it...your boy will too :)