Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends surrogacy

483 replies

Fatcat00 · 30/10/2023 08:01

Not a particularly close friend, but friend enough for me to be invited to social events etc. has recently told me she is having a baby due in April, I was shocked and congratulated her, she then says “surrogate… obviously”. I was a bit lost for words.

for context friend has recently divorced, they had been trying for a baby for 5 years, had IVF etc. I furthered the conversation and asked if it was her egg. Her response was “nah, I’m not bothered if it’s not my biological baby.. I just want a baby”. Followed by “I can’t be assed putting hormones into my body for the sake of my own egg”. I am just so shocked and speechless, I don’t agree with surrogacy for a number of reasons. Some of them being I don’t agree with the hiring of a woman’s body. I don’t agree with a baby being ripped away from its mother to suit someone else’s needs and the physical and psychological implications to both baby and mother as such. Why not just adopt?? If you don’t care for the child to be your biological anyway, why not adopt a baby who needs a parent?

it’s kind of made me look at her in a different light. She seemed very flippant about it (I’m aware this is just how she has came across I’m sure it’s a lengthy and draining process). She says she was put in touch with this woman through a friend who had used her.

essentially, this surrogate has just got pregnant for the purpose of handing over the baby to someone else in exchange for cash. I think I’d still be a bit 🤔 even if it was her own egg if truth be told.

I just can’t get my head around it. Am I being a bit of a bigot? Aibu to want to distance myself a bit? I don’t like feeling as though someone’s path to parenthood or happiness is “wrong” but it really doesn’t sit right with me and I’m not entirely sure why.

OP posts:
Ididivfama · 01/11/2023 07:42

DisquietintheRanks · 31/10/2023 22:20

@HunterBidensBurnerPhone could you link to this research please?
Given how many babies used to lose their mother's at birth I'm really skeptical about such claims. It seems extraordinarily maladaptive to fail to bond with the people providing you with love and care just because you emerged from a different vagina.

I would like to see some evidence about this trauma. Yes babies do bond with the smells and tastes of the birth mother but when they’re first born they very quickly attach to whoever looks after them. That’s why within the first month or so you don’t have all those attachment sleep issues.

Personally I think a good surrogate relationship can be wonderful. There is also the greater good of loving parents providing a baby with a home. Of course there can be major issues with the idea but it doesn’t mean it can’t work out for the people who do it properly.

WhatNoRaisins · 01/11/2023 06:51

That's the problem for me, when it comes to child protection we recognise the gravity of removing a newborn from their mother and try to avoid it unless absolutely necessary but it surrogate babies are somehow different?

Do people really think the fluffy intentions of the adults involved make a difference to the baby?

NotBadConsidering · 31/10/2023 22:23

Vistada · 31/10/2023 22:06

Can someone explain to me why it's traumatic for a surrogate baby to be taken from its biological mother, so traumatic for the baby that it's inhumane.

But for adopted babies it's fine?

Parking all other arguments for one moment, am I missing something or is the above argument a contradiction?

It’s not fine Confused. It’s a major decision that is known to cause trauma. And as such, to remove a baby from its mother and put the baby in foster care and up for adoption requires a Family Court judge to decide it’s best for baby. And judges only decide it’s necessary in absolute circumstances.

But not in surrogacy. The baby is just handed over.

DisquietintheRanks · 31/10/2023 22:20

@HunterBidensBurnerPhone could you link to this research please?
Given how many babies used to lose their mother's at birth I'm really skeptical about such claims. It seems extraordinarily maladaptive to fail to bond with the people providing you with love and care just because you emerged from a different vagina.

Changingplace · 31/10/2023 22:15

Vistada · 31/10/2023 22:06

Can someone explain to me why it's traumatic for a surrogate baby to be taken from its biological mother, so traumatic for the baby that it's inhumane.

But for adopted babies it's fine?

Parking all other arguments for one moment, am I missing something or is the above argument a contradiction?

Anyone who actually knows anything about adoption will tell you it’s not fine and adopted children need an incredible amount of support for all kinds of reasons.

But the people who typically reply ‘just adopt’ as if it’s the simplest thing in the world for all concerned rarely have any real knowledge about what it entails.

Vistada · 31/10/2023 22:06

Can someone explain to me why it's traumatic for a surrogate baby to be taken from its biological mother, so traumatic for the baby that it's inhumane.

But for adopted babies it's fine?

Parking all other arguments for one moment, am I missing something or is the above argument a contradiction?

CoddledAsAMommet · 31/10/2023 21:23

I wouldn't be friends with anyone who is a human trafficker. If I bought an adult, there would be outrage. Why does the age of the human being bought or sold make a difference?

NotBadConsidering · 31/10/2023 21:20

like what if a woman becomes pregnant and dies without a will

Even if you just stick with this example, if a surrogate dies in child birth without a will or without anything in place, her partner is the baby’s legal parent. There have been cases where the baby has remained with the partner and not given to the intended parents. So imagine the difficulty solving this problem on its own, without even looking at the infinite other possibilities of what could go wrong.

People who are pro-surrogacy need to acknowledge that they believe either

a) there are a multitude of things that could go wrong but they’re not prepared to do the work to solve them or
b) there are a multitude of things that could go wrong, including death, but they don’t care.

TheKeatingFive · 31/10/2023 21:16

I agree there are a lot of ethical issues, which is why these are often discussed beforehand.

I don't think they are though. That's the problem

TheKeatingFive · 31/10/2023 21:12

But you could apply that logic to so many things, like what if a woman becomes pregnant and dies without a will. What happens to her baby? So many what ifs.

Well you could. But if a woman dies in the process of providing a baby for someone else, then it's not really something that person can wash their hands of.

Lelophants · 31/10/2023 20:44

I think the most logical thing is to look at children who have been born from surrogates and look at how it affects them longterm. There are a lot of assumptions made on these posts.

Ididivfama · 31/10/2023 20:43

Stupidnighty · 31/10/2023 19:52

@Ididivfama you can discuss the issues all you like, it doesn’t mean anything if the purchaser changes their mind, or the surrogate dies or becomes disabled. And all the discussion in the world means nothing to the baby taken from its mother.

But you could apply that logic to so many things, like what if a woman becomes pregnant and dies without a will. What happens to her baby? So many what ifs.

Ididivfama · 31/10/2023 20:42

NotBadConsidering · 31/10/2023 20:17

I agree there are a lot of ethical issues, which is why these are often discussed beforehand.

A few years ago a surrogate came on MN and did an “Ask Me Anything” thread. She had just had twin embryos implanted for a gay couple. She was asked on the first page what would happen if the couple died in a car crash before the babies were born? She replied she hadn’t considered that. Then she returned to the thread later and said she would put the babies up for adoption Confused.

These sorts of issues are not discussed beforehand because if they were all parties would realise it is impossible to come up with a framework that protects everyone in all outcomes. Those with morals would realise that it would not be ethical to continue if all outcomes are considered - “what if the surrogate dies?”

So it’s either not discussed or hand waved away - “that won’t be us” - and everyone sets their morals aside and hopes for the best.

And that’s why I think there should be more in place.

Regardless, you could say this about lots of things!

NotBadConsidering · 31/10/2023 20:17

Ididivfama · 31/10/2023 19:38

I agree there are a lot of ethical issues, which is why these are often discussed beforehand. Pregnancy can be dangerous for absolutely anyone, no matter whether you keep the child or not.

I agree there are a lot of ethical issues, which is why these are often discussed beforehand.

A few years ago a surrogate came on MN and did an “Ask Me Anything” thread. She had just had twin embryos implanted for a gay couple. She was asked on the first page what would happen if the couple died in a car crash before the babies were born? She replied she hadn’t considered that. Then she returned to the thread later and said she would put the babies up for adoption Confused.

These sorts of issues are not discussed beforehand because if they were all parties would realise it is impossible to come up with a framework that protects everyone in all outcomes. Those with morals would realise that it would not be ethical to continue if all outcomes are considered - “what if the surrogate dies?”

So it’s either not discussed or hand waved away - “that won’t be us” - and everyone sets their morals aside and hopes for the best.

Stupidnighty · 31/10/2023 19:52

@Ididivfama you can discuss the issues all you like, it doesn’t mean anything if the purchaser changes their mind, or the surrogate dies or becomes disabled. And all the discussion in the world means nothing to the baby taken from its mother.

Ididivfama · 31/10/2023 19:38

henrysugar12 · 31/10/2023 18:42

The way you say it makes it sound like the baby is being ripped from its birth mother's arms and being stolen basically. And that's not what's happening is it?

No, it's the sale of a human that's repugnant.

What happens if the mother (who is birthing the child) dies or suffers complications? Who will compensate her family?

What happens if there is something wrong with the child? If it's disabled or poorly or doesn't look right or isn't what the purchaser wants. What then happens to that child?

Or, the mother decides that she wants to keep the baby?

So many ethical issues here...

I agree there are a lot of ethical issues, which is why these are often discussed beforehand. Pregnancy can be dangerous for absolutely anyone, no matter whether you keep the child or not.

henrysugar12 · 31/10/2023 18:42

The way you say it makes it sound like the baby is being ripped from its birth mother's arms and being stolen basically. And that's not what's happening is it?

No, it's the sale of a human that's repugnant.

What happens if the mother (who is birthing the child) dies or suffers complications? Who will compensate her family?

What happens if there is something wrong with the child? If it's disabled or poorly or doesn't look right or isn't what the purchaser wants. What then happens to that child?

Or, the mother decides that she wants to keep the baby?

So many ethical issues here...

BannedfromChristmas · 31/10/2023 09:22

Adoption is not something sort of sticking plaster bargain basement solution to becoming a parent neither is surrogacy you sound like a teenager OP.....simple view of hr world.

Tinklyheadtilt · 31/10/2023 09:18

Aqua20 · 30/10/2023 18:12

All of you 'perfect' women, you don't have a clue what it's like having fertility issues. YOU do not knowcwhat lengths you would have gone too.YOU do not know what it's like and YOU do not know how you would have coped!! It's easy to say, I wouldn't do this and that! So yes, all those opinions against using a surro is judgemental!!

So what, because you have fertility issues its ok to take part in human trafficking? Having a baby is not an automatic right.

Tinklyheadtilt · 31/10/2023 09:16

shockwaze · 30/10/2023 15:07

Have you got children?

What difference does that make?

Rachie1973 · 30/10/2023 23:00

Fatcat00 · 30/10/2023 08:13

Your comment did make me LOL. I have very much had fertility struggles actually. Nice try though.

Your comment in turn makes me ‘LOL’

why not ‘just adopt a baby’?

You talk about your friend being blasé and come out with that gem.

TheKeatingFive · 30/10/2023 22:51

All about you, what about the poor child ?

Or the woman whose womb is being rented out

MrsMarzetti · 30/10/2023 22:21

Aqua20 · 30/10/2023 18:12

All of you 'perfect' women, you don't have a clue what it's like having fertility issues. YOU do not knowcwhat lengths you would have gone too.YOU do not know what it's like and YOU do not know how you would have coped!! It's easy to say, I wouldn't do this and that! So yes, all those opinions against using a surro is judgemental!!

All about you, what about the poor child ?

TwinkleDinkleStarDar · 30/10/2023 21:58

KimberleyClark · 30/10/2023 08:37

Animals, humans alike are known for taking on other peoples/animals newborns, some dogs will take on newborn kittens ect, people raise baby cows/sheep when theyve been rejected from their mother. So the concept of having a baby that isbt biologically yours isnt a dark fetched idea really, weve been doing it forever

Out of necessity. Not because they just want a baby.

When have you ever seen an animal take on another baby or breed because its necessary? From what I've seen ( I could be wrong 🤔 ) dogs for example will take on other newborns because they want to mother them. Some will reject them because they dont want to mother them.

NotBadConsidering · 30/10/2023 20:52

Aqua20 · 30/10/2023 20:40

@NotBadConsidering In the grand scheme of things what my opinion or yours don't matter. It's how the person feels in the moment!! Something that all you 'perfect' women are not understanding!

You can see your side, the side of the surro but not the side of person who I'd struggling with these issues... thank god none of you have have friends who have struggled to this level!!

Your answer was inevitable. It’s the same one given every time I ask that question, a vague indication about emotions with no willingness to do the hard yards on addressing the problems they advocate for.

I do see the side of those struggling with fertility, but the emotion they/you may be feeling does not override the fact that the issues I’ve raised need solving. If you’re not willing to attempt this I understand. Because it can’t be solved. No framework exists. You have to acknowledge that someone is going to get fucked over one way or another.

But if you’re saying that those emotions you and other infertile women feel trump the significant risks that surrogacy relationships bring, you’re wrong. Unfortunately this is what happens in reality. The desperation of really wanting a baby outweighs these risks, people ignore these potential risks and hope, dear God they hope that none of them will apply to them. Then when they do, the fallout is horrendous. When surrogacy goes wrong, it goes really wrong and is never resolved peacefully or amicably and can involve death. But it’s the very fact that we are supposed to just accept “you don’t know how it feels” as being most important overriding aspect of surrogacy that leads to these life changing issues.

No.

Swipe left for the next trending thread