Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends surrogacy

483 replies

Fatcat00 · 30/10/2023 08:01

Not a particularly close friend, but friend enough for me to be invited to social events etc. has recently told me she is having a baby due in April, I was shocked and congratulated her, she then says “surrogate… obviously”. I was a bit lost for words.

for context friend has recently divorced, they had been trying for a baby for 5 years, had IVF etc. I furthered the conversation and asked if it was her egg. Her response was “nah, I’m not bothered if it’s not my biological baby.. I just want a baby”. Followed by “I can’t be assed putting hormones into my body for the sake of my own egg”. I am just so shocked and speechless, I don’t agree with surrogacy for a number of reasons. Some of them being I don’t agree with the hiring of a woman’s body. I don’t agree with a baby being ripped away from its mother to suit someone else’s needs and the physical and psychological implications to both baby and mother as such. Why not just adopt?? If you don’t care for the child to be your biological anyway, why not adopt a baby who needs a parent?

it’s kind of made me look at her in a different light. She seemed very flippant about it (I’m aware this is just how she has came across I’m sure it’s a lengthy and draining process). She says she was put in touch with this woman through a friend who had used her.

essentially, this surrogate has just got pregnant for the purpose of handing over the baby to someone else in exchange for cash. I think I’d still be a bit 🤔 even if it was her own egg if truth be told.

I just can’t get my head around it. Am I being a bit of a bigot? Aibu to want to distance myself a bit? I don’t like feeling as though someone’s path to parenthood or happiness is “wrong” but it really doesn’t sit right with me and I’m not entirely sure why.

OP posts:
Stupidnighty · 01/11/2023 19:12

Abbimae · 01/11/2023 18:37

Adoption in the UK is very hard. Jump through a lot of hoops to prove you are the perfect person even though if you had your own child no one would ask any of these things. It takes years

It’s difficult for a reason.

TheKeatingFive · 01/11/2023 19:04

pregnancy and childbirth is a normal physiological state of a woman, it’s not a health problem or disease

Pregnancy and childbirth can cause all kinds of long term issues for women's bodies, up to and including death

Abbimae · 01/11/2023 18:37

Adoption in the UK is very hard. Jump through a lot of hoops to prove you are the perfect person even though if you had your own child no one would ask any of these things. It takes years

Stupidnighty · 01/11/2023 18:34

lightinthebox · 01/11/2023 15:05

The anti surrogacy arguments are always just people policing what women can do with their bodies. It’s never ok to do that just because you don’t agree with surrogacy.

This massively misses a vital point in the debate-

The ethical issues of treating babies as if they are a commodity - people have the right not to be bought/sold or donated. Just because you created a life or paid for one to be created doesn’t mean you can do what you like with them.

Younghearts · 01/11/2023 15:26

You’re also flippant and ignorant for the “just adopt” comment.

Tandora · 01/11/2023 15:08

Teder · 01/11/2023 14:16

You can live a full and healthy life with 1 kidney. Why don’t we allow people to sell them? You can donate part of your liver too and live a fulfilled and healthy life. You also don’t need 2 full lungs.

Yes you can live a normal and healthy life, but losing a kidney or part of your liver is not a normal or healthy physiological state if a person.
pregnancy and childbirth is a normal physiological state of a woman, it’s not a health problem or disease, and in fact has some significant health benefits (in terms of reducing risks of various cancers etc).

EarthlyNightshade · 01/11/2023 15:07

lightinthebox · 01/11/2023 15:05

The anti surrogacy arguments are always just people policing what women can do with their bodies. It’s never ok to do that just because you don’t agree with surrogacy.

Would you be ok with a woman changing her mind half way through the pregnancy, deciding that she actually didn't want to do it?

lightinthebox · 01/11/2023 15:05

The anti surrogacy arguments are always just people policing what women can do with their bodies. It’s never ok to do that just because you don’t agree with surrogacy.

EarthlyNightshade · 01/11/2023 15:04

Tandora · 01/11/2023 14:58

its not the “side of the surrogate” though. You are presuming to speak for these women, instead of allowing them to speak for themselves.

I am not stopping anyone who wants to be a surrogate from speaking for themselves.
I may have missed it if there are any surrogates on this thread. I am genuinely interested in their reasons for wanting to do it.

Tandora · 01/11/2023 14:58

EarthlyNightshade · 30/10/2023 20:46

There probably isn't anyone on here who does not know someone who struggled with fertility issues. It can be heartbreaking.
But as you say yourself, they are not the only person to consider, there is also the surrogate, and of course, the child.

its not the “side of the surrogate” though. You are presuming to speak for these women, instead of allowing them to speak for themselves.

Teder · 01/11/2023 14:20

Ididivfama · 01/11/2023 08:14

I actually tend to agree. Clearly most people have never met a grown woman desperate to be a surrogate.

I also find it strange how some of these people are pro abortion up until birth but then think surrogacy is cruel.

IMO it’s completely incomparable. In the UK, a foetus has no legal rights and no legal recognition. The surrogate gives away a baby which has human rights at birth. Also you can’t pop along to a clinic and request a termination at 39 weeks because you’ve changed your mind; it’s highly regulated, unlike surrogacy.

Teder · 01/11/2023 14:16

Ididivfama · 01/11/2023 09:37

They only difference is we may need our kidneys. You can produce multiples babies. Kidney donation is also much worse physically than pregnancy for a lot of women.

In an ideal world if we had multiple kidneys - yes!!

You can live a full and healthy life with 1 kidney. Why don’t we allow people to sell them? You can donate part of your liver too and live a fulfilled and healthy life. You also don’t need 2 full lungs.

EarthlyNightshade · 01/11/2023 12:45

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 12:13

Kind of a false equivalency. Selling a kidney isn't really a natural process.

How is surrogacy natural - unless you plan to give away a baby that was the result of having sex?

Ididivfama · 01/11/2023 12:20

TheKeatingFive · 01/11/2023 12:11

I believe that what a woman does with her body is her choice and her choice only.

Should she be allowed to sell a kidney then?

I’ve already posted about the differences with kidney selling. If you had multiple kidneys then yes.

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 12:13

TheKeatingFive · 01/11/2023 12:11

I believe that what a woman does with her body is her choice and her choice only.

Should she be allowed to sell a kidney then?

Kind of a false equivalency. Selling a kidney isn't really a natural process.

TheKeatingFive · 01/11/2023 12:11

I believe that what a woman does with her body is her choice and her choice only.

Should she be allowed to sell a kidney then?

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 12:03

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2023 11:13

I believe that what a woman does with her body is her choice and her choice only.

Ok, as I posted above, now explain how you will ensure she isn’t being coerced, or doing it out of guilt or desperation. If I wanted to donate a kidney to a sibling who needed one I would have to undergo extensive psychological assessment to ensure I was doing it genuinely freely. What do you propose to put in place to make sure women are genuinely doing it out of choice in order to prevent exploitation?

I don't know. It's not really my remit to rewrite the surrogacy legislation. However, the possibility of a good thing being abused doesn't IMO change the fact that the thing in question can still be a good thing.

For example, the fact that aid money which gets sent to Africa sometimes gets embezzled doesn't mean that trying to help Africans is wrong.

Stupidnighty · 01/11/2023 11:49

Ididivfama · 01/11/2023 10:53

I did see it. Surely it’s just a spectrum of different methods and interventions used.

I don’t think your example really works. It’s not exactly the same is it. You don’t spend 11 years bonding with a newborn. It’s also not fair on a 11 year old whereas as I’ve pointed out, it can work with a newborn in their fourth trimester.

It’s ok to disagree on this. I’ve tried to look at studies and the main issues I can find are due to the baby not understanding their background and not having it talked about from a young age (like adoption). For a surrogate, there are higher levels of depression due to society’s treatment of the surrogate and social stigma. I will happily read and reputable, up to date study stating otherwise.

Im not so steadfast I’ll never to listen to any other information. I think there needs to be more in place to support all parties and I agree more research needs to be done on the matter.

This is interesting-

On the vicissitudes of early primary surrogate mothering II: Loss of the surrogate mother and arrest of mourningHarry T Hardin, Daniel H Hardin
Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 48 (4), 1229-1258, 2000

Also this

Adopted children: The risk of interactive misattunement between the infant and adoptive mother in the child relinquished at birthSheila B Honig
Adoption Quarterly 17 (3), 185-204, 2014

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2023 11:13

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 11:02

This is kinda how I feel, although it gets a bit dodgier for me when people are only doing it for the money (especially if they're financially struggling and feel pressured). I believe that what a woman does with her body is her choice and her choice only.

I believe that what a woman does with her body is her choice and her choice only.

Ok, as I posted above, now explain how you will ensure she isn’t being coerced, or doing it out of guilt or desperation. If I wanted to donate a kidney to a sibling who needed one I would have to undergo extensive psychological assessment to ensure I was doing it genuinely freely. What do you propose to put in place to make sure women are genuinely doing it out of choice in order to prevent exploitation?

LarkspurLane · 01/11/2023 11:07

Would you agree then with the woman being able to change her mind partway through?
If she decided once pregnant that she didn't want to do it and wanted to have an abortion?

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 11:02

Dinnerdate1 · 30/10/2023 08:10

I've looked into being a surrogate before. Wouldn't bother me to grow a baby for someone and then hand it to them. It's not as easy to just adopt.
And as long as both parties consent I don't see the harm.

This is kinda how I feel, although it gets a bit dodgier for me when people are only doing it for the money (especially if they're financially struggling and feel pressured). I believe that what a woman does with her body is her choice and her choice only.

Lelophants · 01/11/2023 10:57

Stupidnighty · 01/11/2023 10:50

In this situation the the trauma to the child of being removed from it’s mother isn’t present- the baby wants it’s birth mother, it doesn’t know about the genetic intricacies.

The research I’ve read and my experience of donor born children shows that the biggest indicator of future harm to the child is if they aren’t brought up knowing they are born from a donor and don’t have the opportunity to find out about the donor in the future- your friend is planning to inform her child so that mitigates a lot of the issues.

Yes, it is still using a woman’s body- but many would argue to a much lesser extent. There is still the possible ethical issues around whether egg donation was truly altruistic (many egg donors do it because they couldn’t otherwise afford ivf treatment)-

I don’t know whether egg donation has the same commercial side as surrogacy ie, women from richer backgrounds buying from women from poorer backgrounds who are basically being used like a commodity- if so then it has the same ethical problems.

And the goods changing hands are not a human life- it is some cells that are regularly discarded as waste by women- for me that makes the biggest difference.

My friend said that the donors tended to be medical professionals (doctors, nurses, midwives) who understood the difficulties of fertility. She deliberately chose the UK despite the far fewer eggs available due to this. I don’t know though, in some ways you could argue it at less ethical because a woman could donate her eggs without giving it as much thought (imo) than you would to take on surrogacy.

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2023 10:56

The pro surrogacy arguments always come up short.

“If a woman wants to, she should be able to.” Ok, then explain how you’re going to ascertain and ensure that she really wants to and isn’t being coerced.

“Surrogacy is ok if the baby shares biology with the intended parents.” Ok, now explain how you’re going to enforce this.

”Surrogacy is ok if no money other than expenses is changed hands.” Ok, now explain how you’re going to enforce this. And explain what is covered under expenses. Death and lifetime disability?

”Surrogacy is ok if the child is going to a loving home.” Ok, explain how you’re going to safeguard children and make sure this happens, because currently there are no checks on intended parents so see if they will be the living home we would expect.

And so on, and so on.

No one can ever explain how they see it working with all areas of difficulty covered.

Ididivfama · 01/11/2023 10:53

Stupidnighty · 01/11/2023 10:32

I already did answer it but @Ididivfama ignored my answer, presumably because it doesn’t fit with her narrative.

I did see it. Surely it’s just a spectrum of different methods and interventions used.

I don’t think your example really works. It’s not exactly the same is it. You don’t spend 11 years bonding with a newborn. It’s also not fair on a 11 year old whereas as I’ve pointed out, it can work with a newborn in their fourth trimester.

It’s ok to disagree on this. I’ve tried to look at studies and the main issues I can find are due to the baby not understanding their background and not having it talked about from a young age (like adoption). For a surrogate, there are higher levels of depression due to society’s treatment of the surrogate and social stigma. I will happily read and reputable, up to date study stating otherwise.

Im not so steadfast I’ll never to listen to any other information. I think there needs to be more in place to support all parties and I agree more research needs to be done on the matter.

Stupidnighty · 01/11/2023 10:50

Lelophants · 01/11/2023 09:40

I have a friend who’s only just turned 30 and for various medical reasons no longer has her own eggs. She is going down the egg donation route and using her husband’s sperm. Yes she is paying for the egg so she is paying for her baby. She has done a lot of counselling and intends to inform her child and bring them up with the ability to contact their egg donor if he/she wishes. Is this also immoral and wrong? Probably for a lot of you it is, which is very sad.

In this situation the the trauma to the child of being removed from it’s mother isn’t present- the baby wants it’s birth mother, it doesn’t know about the genetic intricacies.

The research I’ve read and my experience of donor born children shows that the biggest indicator of future harm to the child is if they aren’t brought up knowing they are born from a donor and don’t have the opportunity to find out about the donor in the future- your friend is planning to inform her child so that mitigates a lot of the issues.

Yes, it is still using a woman’s body- but many would argue to a much lesser extent. There is still the possible ethical issues around whether egg donation was truly altruistic (many egg donors do it because they couldn’t otherwise afford ivf treatment)-

I don’t know whether egg donation has the same commercial side as surrogacy ie, women from richer backgrounds buying from women from poorer backgrounds who are basically being used like a commodity- if so then it has the same ethical problems.

And the goods changing hands are not a human life- it is some cells that are regularly discarded as waste by women- for me that makes the biggest difference.

Swipe left for the next trending thread