Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends surrogacy

483 replies

Fatcat00 · 30/10/2023 08:01

Not a particularly close friend, but friend enough for me to be invited to social events etc. has recently told me she is having a baby due in April, I was shocked and congratulated her, she then says “surrogate… obviously”. I was a bit lost for words.

for context friend has recently divorced, they had been trying for a baby for 5 years, had IVF etc. I furthered the conversation and asked if it was her egg. Her response was “nah, I’m not bothered if it’s not my biological baby.. I just want a baby”. Followed by “I can’t be assed putting hormones into my body for the sake of my own egg”. I am just so shocked and speechless, I don’t agree with surrogacy for a number of reasons. Some of them being I don’t agree with the hiring of a woman’s body. I don’t agree with a baby being ripped away from its mother to suit someone else’s needs and the physical and psychological implications to both baby and mother as such. Why not just adopt?? If you don’t care for the child to be your biological anyway, why not adopt a baby who needs a parent?

it’s kind of made me look at her in a different light. She seemed very flippant about it (I’m aware this is just how she has came across I’m sure it’s a lengthy and draining process). She says she was put in touch with this woman through a friend who had used her.

essentially, this surrogate has just got pregnant for the purpose of handing over the baby to someone else in exchange for cash. I think I’d still be a bit 🤔 even if it was her own egg if truth be told.

I just can’t get my head around it. Am I being a bit of a bigot? Aibu to want to distance myself a bit? I don’t like feeling as though someone’s path to parenthood or happiness is “wrong” but it really doesn’t sit right with me and I’m not entirely sure why.

OP posts:
LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 17:48

the situation is ripe for exploitation of poorer women, often from poorer countries. And it is certainly not what the baby would want, if they could speak.

I'm not so sure tbh. Another 20 years and they might be trying to come here on a dingy so I don't think we can say that for sure.

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 17:45

Not really sure where the Handmaid's Tail comes into it, but I'd happily bear a child for my sister if she were unable to and I could.

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 17:41

Pemba · 02/11/2023 16:08

@LadyThatLaunches Well that currently is the case in the UK, as I understand it. But there are many voices saying that UK law on surrogacy needs to be 'modernised'. There's actually a piece on Netmums at the moment where a couple (male, gay think they were on some reality show, although I don't recognise the names) are saying this. They are also saying how unfair it is that lower income families are not able to access surrogacy. So it should be available on the NHS should it? That'll go down well with the current funding crisis that's happening. Or perhaps they think fertile women should be drafted in to help out or something like that. Shades of 'Handmaid's Tale'. But as long as the intended parents get what they want, that is their primary concern.

I would not like the UK to go down the road that the USA has, and for surrogacy to become completely normalised. Not saying that there are no happy stories, but the situation is ripe for exploitation of poorer women, often from poorer countries. And it is certainly not what the baby would want, if they could speak. The state should protect their best interests as obviously they cannot do so for themselves.

In all fairness, how do you know that’s not what the baby would want? Again, so many big assumptions from a very paternalistic point of view.

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 17:40

For those of you against surrogacy full stop, are you also against someone donating an organ?

Pemba · 02/11/2023 16:08

@LadyThatLaunches Well that currently is the case in the UK, as I understand it. But there are many voices saying that UK law on surrogacy needs to be 'modernised'. There's actually a piece on Netmums at the moment where a couple (male, gay think they were on some reality show, although I don't recognise the names) are saying this. They are also saying how unfair it is that lower income families are not able to access surrogacy. So it should be available on the NHS should it? That'll go down well with the current funding crisis that's happening. Or perhaps they think fertile women should be drafted in to help out or something like that. Shades of 'Handmaid's Tale'. But as long as the intended parents get what they want, that is their primary concern.

I would not like the UK to go down the road that the USA has, and for surrogacy to become completely normalised. Not saying that there are no happy stories, but the situation is ripe for exploitation of poorer women, often from poorer countries. And it is certainly not what the baby would want, if they could speak. The state should protect their best interests as obviously they cannot do so for themselves.

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 15:30

I would be happy for it to be made illegal to receive money for being a surrogate, aside from expenses covered.

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 15:15

Tandora · 02/11/2023 14:56

Of course there is a question as to when and whether “consent” is meaningful, and when and whether someone has “agreed” to something because they are desperate and they have no other choice. And there is of course a role for the law in protecting vulnerable people from the latter.
But it’s also dangerous and oppressive to be overly paternalistic about these things, and not prioritise the voices of those who are the ones actually undergoing and being affected by the issue. Do I think surrogacy needs to be regulated because there is potential for exploitation? Yes. Do I think having a baby for someone else is the same as selling an organ? No. Do I support kidney donation? Yes.
Do I think all surrogacy arrangements are inherently exploitative and wrong. No.
Listen to women affected by the issue talk about it , and what it means to them, before you judge.

Yup, agree with this.

Tandora · 02/11/2023 14:56

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2023 19:55

But if a woman wanted to donate a kidney/liver part and it was her choice to do it, who are you to police what she does with her body?

Of course there is a question as to when and whether “consent” is meaningful, and when and whether someone has “agreed” to something because they are desperate and they have no other choice. And there is of course a role for the law in protecting vulnerable people from the latter.
But it’s also dangerous and oppressive to be overly paternalistic about these things, and not prioritise the voices of those who are the ones actually undergoing and being affected by the issue. Do I think surrogacy needs to be regulated because there is potential for exploitation? Yes. Do I think having a baby for someone else is the same as selling an organ? No. Do I support kidney donation? Yes.
Do I think all surrogacy arrangements are inherently exploitative and wrong. No.
Listen to women affected by the issue talk about it , and what it means to them, before you judge.

Tandora · 02/11/2023 14:47

Teder · 01/11/2023 21:52

This is patently untrue especially if a donor egg (to the surrogate) is used.
I have no ethical concerns with people having fertility treatments but it not a “normal physiological state”.
The method of getting pregnant via IVF, for example, is riskier than a standard conception. The drugs and procedures are not “normal” and yes, I’ve been through it. Nobody is saying don’t do it but it’s untrue to pretend otherwise.

I said bring pregnant is an ordinary and healthy physiological state, which it is.
not the same as only having one kidney.

EarthlyNightshade · 02/11/2023 08:55

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 21:57

I don't think it really matters tbh. If a woman wants to have a baby for somebody else she'll do it and there's nothing you can really do about it.

I don't think the issue is that there are thousands of woman wanting to have babies for other people. If there was, then fine.
The issue for me is money changing hands and exploitation of women. And selling a child, who has no rights in this situation.

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 08:54

Witchcraftandhokum · 02/11/2023 06:29

CampervanKween

I think surrogacy is awful. I'm sure these kids will grow up damaged but no-one seems to care. It's so selfish.

So you think everyone who is adopted is damaged too?

The default position of adoption as a general process is that the child will experience trauma at some stage in their lives. Lots of research, protocols and support is put in place to help the adoptive parents and the child (throughout their lives) deal with this experience. If the child doesn’t need support or experience trauma at any stage, great! It’s not needed. But the framework is in place if it is.

How’s that going in the world of surrogacy?

EarthlyNightshade · 02/11/2023 08:48

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 21:46

Pregnancy is natural and seen in all mammals. I've never seen a monkey do a kidney transplant though.

Do you not agree with abortion?

Witchcraftandhokum · 02/11/2023 06:29

CampervanKween

I think surrogacy is awful. I'm sure these kids will grow up damaged but no-one seems to care. It's so selfish.

So you think everyone who is adopted is damaged too?

Stupidnighty · 02/11/2023 00:23

ToadOnTheHill · 01/11/2023 22:44

If you dig down deep I dont think your issue is your friend or "hiring" a woman to have a baby.

It's actually judgement that a woman could sell her baby.

I don’t know how you wouldn’t judge someone who is buying or selling a human being.

ToadOnTheHill · 01/11/2023 22:44

If you dig down deep I dont think your issue is your friend or "hiring" a woman to have a baby.

It's actually judgement that a woman could sell her baby.

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2023 22:15

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 21:57

I don't think it really matters tbh. If a woman wants to have a baby for somebody else she'll do it and there's nothing you can really do about it.

It doesn’t matter? Because it proves how surrogacy isn’t something that occurs in nature?

There’s plenty that can be done about it. Many progressive countries have banned surrogacy in all forms. I’m still waiting for any of the pro-surrogacy posters to outline how they propose to protect women and babies. You seem to be advocating for a free market of baby exchange? And any negative consequences are outweighed by the tiny minority of women who freely choose to do it?

Teder · 01/11/2023 22:05

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 21:57

I don't think it really matters tbh. If a woman wants to have a baby for somebody else she'll do it and there's nothing you can really do about it.

So why can’t I sell my kidney? I will need a very generous amount in expenses for time off work and travel to and from medical appointments. I want some compensation for the potential risk and scarring etc.

Teder · 01/11/2023 22:03

lightinthebox · 01/11/2023 15:05

The anti surrogacy arguments are always just people policing what women can do with their bodies. It’s never ok to do that just because you don’t agree with surrogacy.

This has been repeated multiple times throughout the thread but…..we are already policed on our bodies! You do not have the legal right to demand an abortion at any time nor sell your organs.

In the UK;
You cannot legally give your kidney away for “expenses”.
You cannot legally walk into a clinic and request to terminate an otherwise healthy foetus at 36 weeks.

You’re only focused on the pregnancy and bodily autonomy but completely ignoring the baby. A woman can choose to get pregnant, of course and indeed her body - and the pregnancy - is her choice. Once that baby is born, it automatically has human rights and legal protections.

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 21:57

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2023 21:54

Have you ever seen a monkey give its baby away to another monkey for the price of some nuts?

I don't think it really matters tbh. If a woman wants to have a baby for somebody else she'll do it and there's nothing you can really do about it.

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2023 21:54

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 21:46

Pregnancy is natural and seen in all mammals. I've never seen a monkey do a kidney transplant though.

Have you ever seen a monkey give its baby away to another monkey for the price of some nuts?

Teder · 01/11/2023 21:52

Tandora · 01/11/2023 15:08

Yes you can live a normal and healthy life, but losing a kidney or part of your liver is not a normal or healthy physiological state if a person.
pregnancy and childbirth is a normal physiological state of a woman, it’s not a health problem or disease, and in fact has some significant health benefits (in terms of reducing risks of various cancers etc).

This is patently untrue especially if a donor egg (to the surrogate) is used.
I have no ethical concerns with people having fertility treatments but it not a “normal physiological state”.
The method of getting pregnant via IVF, for example, is riskier than a standard conception. The drugs and procedures are not “normal” and yes, I’ve been through it. Nobody is saying don’t do it but it’s untrue to pretend otherwise.

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 21:46

EarthlyNightshade · 01/11/2023 12:45

How is surrogacy natural - unless you plan to give away a baby that was the result of having sex?

Pregnancy is natural and seen in all mammals. I've never seen a monkey do a kidney transplant though.

Monetm · 01/11/2023 20:01

Fatcat00 · 30/10/2023 08:01

Not a particularly close friend, but friend enough for me to be invited to social events etc. has recently told me she is having a baby due in April, I was shocked and congratulated her, she then says “surrogate… obviously”. I was a bit lost for words.

for context friend has recently divorced, they had been trying for a baby for 5 years, had IVF etc. I furthered the conversation and asked if it was her egg. Her response was “nah, I’m not bothered if it’s not my biological baby.. I just want a baby”. Followed by “I can’t be assed putting hormones into my body for the sake of my own egg”. I am just so shocked and speechless, I don’t agree with surrogacy for a number of reasons. Some of them being I don’t agree with the hiring of a woman’s body. I don’t agree with a baby being ripped away from its mother to suit someone else’s needs and the physical and psychological implications to both baby and mother as such. Why not just adopt?? If you don’t care for the child to be your biological anyway, why not adopt a baby who needs a parent?

it’s kind of made me look at her in a different light. She seemed very flippant about it (I’m aware this is just how she has came across I’m sure it’s a lengthy and draining process). She says she was put in touch with this woman through a friend who had used her.

essentially, this surrogate has just got pregnant for the purpose of handing over the baby to someone else in exchange for cash. I think I’d still be a bit 🤔 even if it was her own egg if truth be told.

I just can’t get my head around it. Am I being a bit of a bigot? Aibu to want to distance myself a bit? I don’t like feeling as though someone’s path to parenthood or happiness is “wrong” but it really doesn’t sit right with me and I’m not entirely sure why.

I don’t agree with asking someone (not even a close friend) whether it’s their egg when they tell you they’re having a baby. Absolutely none of your business. If she chooses to volunteer that information, it’s up to her.

Realistically, she is likely to have gone through a lot to get to a place where she is willing to use a donor egg, and saying something flippant on the surface doesn’t mean that’s how she’s feeling underneath.

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2023 19:55

Tandora · 01/11/2023 15:08

Yes you can live a normal and healthy life, but losing a kidney or part of your liver is not a normal or healthy physiological state if a person.
pregnancy and childbirth is a normal physiological state of a woman, it’s not a health problem or disease, and in fact has some significant health benefits (in terms of reducing risks of various cancers etc).

But if a woman wanted to donate a kidney/liver part and it was her choice to do it, who are you to police what she does with her body?

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2023 19:53

LadyThatLaunches · 01/11/2023 12:03

I don't know. It's not really my remit to rewrite the surrogacy legislation. However, the possibility of a good thing being abused doesn't IMO change the fact that the thing in question can still be a good thing.

For example, the fact that aid money which gets sent to Africa sometimes gets embezzled doesn't mean that trying to help Africans is wrong.

But you acknowledge the thing that you think is a good thing can sometimes be a bad thing? The vast majority of surrogacy that occurs around the world is exploitation: a rich western couple using a destitute woman from a country with no other options open to her.

So the thing you say is a good thing is mostly a bad thing. So does that still make it a good thing?

Your example doesn’t work. That’s solvable. Give the money directly to those who need it, or if that’s not possible it has to be acknowledged that foreign aid should stop (an argument many already make.)

But no one is ever willing to offer a solution to the exploitation side of surrogacy.