Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends surrogacy

483 replies

Fatcat00 · 30/10/2023 08:01

Not a particularly close friend, but friend enough for me to be invited to social events etc. has recently told me she is having a baby due in April, I was shocked and congratulated her, she then says “surrogate… obviously”. I was a bit lost for words.

for context friend has recently divorced, they had been trying for a baby for 5 years, had IVF etc. I furthered the conversation and asked if it was her egg. Her response was “nah, I’m not bothered if it’s not my biological baby.. I just want a baby”. Followed by “I can’t be assed putting hormones into my body for the sake of my own egg”. I am just so shocked and speechless, I don’t agree with surrogacy for a number of reasons. Some of them being I don’t agree with the hiring of a woman’s body. I don’t agree with a baby being ripped away from its mother to suit someone else’s needs and the physical and psychological implications to both baby and mother as such. Why not just adopt?? If you don’t care for the child to be your biological anyway, why not adopt a baby who needs a parent?

it’s kind of made me look at her in a different light. She seemed very flippant about it (I’m aware this is just how she has came across I’m sure it’s a lengthy and draining process). She says she was put in touch with this woman through a friend who had used her.

essentially, this surrogate has just got pregnant for the purpose of handing over the baby to someone else in exchange for cash. I think I’d still be a bit 🤔 even if it was her own egg if truth be told.

I just can’t get my head around it. Am I being a bit of a bigot? Aibu to want to distance myself a bit? I don’t like feeling as though someone’s path to parenthood or happiness is “wrong” but it really doesn’t sit right with me and I’m not entirely sure why.

OP posts:
FannyCann · 03/11/2023 06:58

Twitter thread

x.com/emlwaters/status/1719677083201220964?s=46

FannyCann · 03/11/2023 06:58

A USA study into gestational surrogacy commissioned by foreign clients reveals the scale of this international trade in babies.
The largest proportion to men, from China, often over 42 years old.
This trade has been noted before, with the babies referred to as "Anchor babies" as they can be used to obtain US citizenship.
Often they are not collected until sometime after birth , though there are no figures for this but there have been cases in the news and surrogate mothers / "nannies" on TikTok
discussing the babies they are caring for.

Anyone who can't see that surrogacy is a disgusting world wide trade in babies is a fool. If the law changes in the UK to make commissioning parents legal parents at birth there is likely to be an increase in international trade here due to the attractiveness of reduced costs thanks to all medical treatment being on the NHS. So called protections around domicile and Habitual Residence will just be paperwork issues to get around.

Women who support surrogacy and think it is a loving act are just turkeys voting for Christmas. Soon there will be a breeder class. In fact there already is in some parts of the world. I'd care less if there was an open and honest plan to go full Brave New World with the breeding done by the Deltas and Epsilons.

www.fertstert.org/article/S0015-0282(23)00392-8/fulltex

mailchi.mp/stopsurrogacynow/egg-freezing-parties-and-artificial-wombs-425150?e=63ad6d7206

Friends surrogacy
Friends surrogacy
NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 21:16

Teder · 02/11/2023 20:48

If surrogacy was as well regulated as organ donation, it would be a whole different kettle of fish.

The fact that is it unregulated has caused ethical issues. I see a lot of people talk about the surrogate and her right to bodily autonomy. I see little consideration for other factors such as; the actual baby who has rights too.

I am not completely opposed to surrogacy but in its current form, it has serious flaws and the ability to abuse it is far too easy.

But this is the rub. Once it’s acknowledged that surrogacy can’t exist as a complete free-for-all and needs protections and legislation, you then have to decide whose rights are prioritised which is ultimately impossible.

If the rights of the mother are prioritised then the intended parents have no rights or protections.

If the rights of the intended parents are prioritised then the mother has no rights and protections.

If the rights of the baby are prioritised then how can you ever separate it from its mother?

If you want to do some rights for the mother and some rights from the intended parents, how do you determine which go which way?

This is why we have the current state of surrogacy around the world.

There are countries that let it happen as a free-for-all or countries that pretend this clash of rights doesn’t exist, who run into trouble whenever a surrogacy case goes wrong.

Or there are countries that have looked at all this and realised it’s insolvable, rights can’t be balanced, and have banned it.

There’s no middle ground: either you just shrug and accept that at some point in surrogacy that someone will get fucked over eventually - as evidenced by many, many examples - or you ban it.

I refuse to shrug.

Fionaville · 02/11/2023 21:07

I don't particularly agree with surrogacy either. It's a bit 'Handmaid's tale' to me.
But I've never met anybody who's gone through it, so I cant say how I'd react. I have had family members with fertility issues, who've adopted and I feel like that's the way to go. It's worked out wonderfully for them and the children.

Teder · 02/11/2023 20:48

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 20:20

So now there’s been a progression. You’re for surrogacy, but you acknowledge there needs to be better frameworks in place to protect the woman and the future child. None of this happens currently. So how do you propose to bring this about and how do you counter the people who want NONE of these things to get in the way of surrogacy?

If surrogacy was as well regulated as organ donation, it would be a whole different kettle of fish.

The fact that is it unregulated has caused ethical issues. I see a lot of people talk about the surrogate and her right to bodily autonomy. I see little consideration for other factors such as; the actual baby who has rights too.

I am not completely opposed to surrogacy but in its current form, it has serious flaws and the ability to abuse it is far too easy.

Teder · 02/11/2023 20:42

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 19:21

Oh for goodness sake it’s ivf. Women can and do choose ivf every day. I did. It’s fab!

I did too. I didn’t say it was a bad thing. I said it’s not an ordinary physiological state. Not sure what you’re disagreeing with!

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 20:20

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 20:14

or you could see it as a positive that she is aware of her background and identity from a young age. I don’t know this situation and whether she can meet her surrogate mum. As a general rule I think the process should be much more regulated and surrogate and child have a chance to reconnect if they are not already in each other’s lives.

So now there’s been a progression. You’re for surrogacy, but you acknowledge there needs to be better frameworks in place to protect the woman and the future child. None of this happens currently. So how do you propose to bring this about and how do you counter the people who want NONE of these things to get in the way of surrogacy?

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 20:18

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 20:12

Well then there should be.

My old colleague donated a kidney btw.

Ok, so you acknowledge that currently surrogacy does not meet adequate standards. So you say there should be. What should happen? How should this work and who should do it?

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 20:14

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 20:02

Exactly. And this is why there is no such thing as successful surrogacy. Because even IF the woman consents freely, and even IF she has full control over her body, and even IF, by sheer luck there are no major complications to her or the baby, and even IF the relationship stays positive and is ended appropriately and amicably, even IF all that

there is still no way of knowing if the child will grow up and feel trauma or negative impact around the circumstances of their birth. Which could take decades.

Like the little girl I know who thinks one day she’ll get to travel to India to meet her mother. Life for her is lovely right now, she has two dads who love her. But at some point when she reaches a level of maturity there will be a realisation that she’s not going to meet her mum and will likely never know who she is.

Edited

or you could see it as a positive that she is aware of her background and identity from a young age. I don’t know this situation and whether she can meet her surrogate mum. As a general rule I think the process should be much more regulated and surrogate and child have a chance to reconnect if they are not already in each other’s lives.

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 20:12

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 19:38

Do you know the extent of the process a person has to go through to be living related kidney donor? It’s not just medical checks for compatibility, there are also extensive social and psychological checks to make sure you’re doing it for the right reasons. People want to donate because of family guilt, family pressure, coercion, or they need to be checked they have the capacity to truly understand the implications of what living with one kidney means, implications for if their own child needs one later but now they can’t, and so on, and so on. It’s a process that takes months and months.

There are no such checks with surrogacy. Why?

Well then there should be.

My old colleague donated a kidney btw.

Hellers · 02/11/2023 20:04

I personally wouldn't agree with her choice or her attitude. It's obviously made you view her in a different light and you realise you have quite different ideas about an important issue. It's possible to disagree with people and still be civil to them on a personal basis, which you should, but ultimately it's up to you if you wish to remain friendly, you don't have to explain yourself to anyone.

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 20:02

Stupidnighty · 02/11/2023 19:55

No- organs don’t have thoughts, feelings or human rights of their own…

Exactly. And this is why there is no such thing as successful surrogacy. Because even IF the woman consents freely, and even IF she has full control over her body, and even IF, by sheer luck there are no major complications to her or the baby, and even IF the relationship stays positive and is ended appropriately and amicably, even IF all that

there is still no way of knowing if the child will grow up and feel trauma or negative impact around the circumstances of their birth. Which could take decades.

Like the little girl I know who thinks one day she’ll get to travel to India to meet her mother. Life for her is lovely right now, she has two dads who love her. But at some point when she reaches a level of maturity there will be a realisation that she’s not going to meet her mum and will likely never know who she is.

Stupidnighty · 02/11/2023 19:57

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 17:48

the situation is ripe for exploitation of poorer women, often from poorer countries. And it is certainly not what the baby would want, if they could speak.

I'm not so sure tbh. Another 20 years and they might be trying to come here on a dingy so I don't think we can say that for sure.

Wtf are you on about?

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 19:56

But it’s also dangerous and oppressive to be overly paternalistic about these things

It’s not paternalistic to assume a woman providing a service for others with her body might be being exploited, given that is the default position of our society. Surrogacy is like sex work in that sense: the paternalistic attitude is “these women love it!” Sure they do mate🙄. The vast majority of surrogacy around the world is exploitative, so it’s not unreasonable to assume that every case is and really, seriously do a deep check to make sure it isn’t.

But the point is, no one checks.

And IF it’s determined that the woman presenting is 100% doing to freely, no one can explain how to make sure she won’t be exploited from that point on. No one pro-surrogacy can explain how they protect women from being coerced in their pregnancy decision-making, or their delivery choices, or health choices. There are surrogacy contracts that stipulate what the woman can and can’t eat, stopping her from having sex with her husband etc. This is coercion. No one pro-surrogacy has any idea how to protect women ongoing after the initial decision they consented to. What if they change their minds? About any of it?

Stupidnighty · 02/11/2023 19:55

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 17:40

For those of you against surrogacy full stop, are you also against someone donating an organ?

No- organs don’t have thoughts, feelings or human rights of their own…

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 19:38

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 17:40

For those of you against surrogacy full stop, are you also against someone donating an organ?

Do you know the extent of the process a person has to go through to be living related kidney donor? It’s not just medical checks for compatibility, there are also extensive social and psychological checks to make sure you’re doing it for the right reasons. People want to donate because of family guilt, family pressure, coercion, or they need to be checked they have the capacity to truly understand the implications of what living with one kidney means, implications for if their own child needs one later but now they can’t, and so on, and so on. It’s a process that takes months and months.

There are no such checks with surrogacy. Why?

Bublebathe · 02/11/2023 19:34

Whispers I don't see anything wrong with altruistic surrogacy.

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2023 19:34

Tandora · 02/11/2023 14:56

Of course there is a question as to when and whether “consent” is meaningful, and when and whether someone has “agreed” to something because they are desperate and they have no other choice. And there is of course a role for the law in protecting vulnerable people from the latter.
But it’s also dangerous and oppressive to be overly paternalistic about these things, and not prioritise the voices of those who are the ones actually undergoing and being affected by the issue. Do I think surrogacy needs to be regulated because there is potential for exploitation? Yes. Do I think having a baby for someone else is the same as selling an organ? No. Do I support kidney donation? Yes.
Do I think all surrogacy arrangements are inherently exploitative and wrong. No.
Listen to women affected by the issue talk about it , and what it means to them, before you judge.

Do I think surrogacy needs to be regulated because there is potential for exploitation? Yes.

Ok, so how do you propose to do this?

Do I think all surrogacy arrangements are inherently exploitative and wrong. No.
Listen to women affected by the issue talk about it , and what it means to them, before you judge.

Even if you can be sure the woman is doing it 100% freely, how do you protect her rights? Who gets to decide the decisions before, during and after the pregnancy? Like if she needs a CVS? Or it’s recommended she terminates for a severe abnormality? Or if she wants to for her own personal reasons? Or if she wants a vaginal delivery and the intended parents want a section? Who decides all these things?

When you say “talk to the women” you mean talk to the women who, by sheer luck, nothing went wrong. They didn’t develop major complications. They weren’t openly willing but died - this has happened. So even IF women freely choose to do it, whose rights get prioritised?

Lelophants · 02/11/2023 19:23

I think some of the people who are so against surrogacy are because they just can’t imagine being able to do it themselves. To them, the idea of doing it purely willingly seems impossible.

But everyone is different. Some people can’t imagine having children, others can’t imagine life without. For some people, being a surrogate is literally the most incredible thing you can do in your entire life. You get to be pregnant and go through birth and all through the altruism of doing it for someone else. It’s pretty incredible if that’s your thing. Plus you can relax and not work whilst going through it. This is what I know of Americans who do it anyway. They’re ex sahm who miss pregnancy so much and love helping someone else create life. Good on them.

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 19:21

Teder · 02/11/2023 18:55

The method of getting pregnant isn’t an ordinary and healthy physiological state. Many women get pregnant with lots of medical intervention which is ethically and morally fine. But let’s not act like being a surrogate is an “ordinary physiological state”.

Oh for goodness sake it’s ivf. Women can and do choose ivf every day. I did. It’s fab!

Ididivfama · 02/11/2023 19:21

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 17:45

Not really sure where the Handmaid's Tail comes into it, but I'd happily bear a child for my sister if she were unable to and I could.

Exactly. And I’d also give her a kidney. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Teder · 02/11/2023 18:55

Tandora · 02/11/2023 14:47

I said bring pregnant is an ordinary and healthy physiological state, which it is.
not the same as only having one kidney.

The method of getting pregnant isn’t an ordinary and healthy physiological state. Many women get pregnant with lots of medical intervention which is ethically and morally fine. But let’s not act like being a surrogate is an “ordinary physiological state”.

Pemba · 02/11/2023 18:28

Well that's a hypothetical situation in 20 years time involving a hypothetical young adult But the newborn baby of right now knows nothing about what country they live in etc., they just want their mum.

Anyway if international surrogacy didnt exist then that person wouldn't exist at all.

LadyThatLaunches · 02/11/2023 18:21

Pemba · 02/11/2023 18:03

@LadyThatLaunches not really sure what you mean with your point about dinghies, but the birth mother is the only familiar thing the baby knows from being inside her for 9 months. The sound of her voice etc. Comfort in the big scary outside world. The fourth trimester and all that. I thought this was widely recognised.

It is not a good thing in general to deliberately create babies to immediately remove them from the birth mother.

In some limited scenarios surrogacy might work well, for example a sister of the intended parent, as you mention, provided she is under no pressure and will continue a family relationship with the baby. It is a huge ask of any woman though.

I'm suggesting it's by no means a given that somebody from a poorer country wouldn't want to grow up here instead.

Pemba · 02/11/2023 18:03

@LadyThatLaunches not really sure what you mean with your point about dinghies, but the birth mother is the only familiar thing the baby knows from being inside her for 9 months. The sound of her voice etc. Comfort in the big scary outside world. The fourth trimester and all that. I thought this was widely recognised.

It is not a good thing in general to deliberately create babies to immediately remove them from the birth mother.

In some limited scenarios surrogacy might work well, for example a sister of the intended parent, as you mention, provided she is under no pressure and will continue a family relationship with the baby. It is a huge ask of any woman though.