Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends surrogacy

483 replies

Fatcat00 · 30/10/2023 08:01

Not a particularly close friend, but friend enough for me to be invited to social events etc. has recently told me she is having a baby due in April, I was shocked and congratulated her, she then says “surrogate… obviously”. I was a bit lost for words.

for context friend has recently divorced, they had been trying for a baby for 5 years, had IVF etc. I furthered the conversation and asked if it was her egg. Her response was “nah, I’m not bothered if it’s not my biological baby.. I just want a baby”. Followed by “I can’t be assed putting hormones into my body for the sake of my own egg”. I am just so shocked and speechless, I don’t agree with surrogacy for a number of reasons. Some of them being I don’t agree with the hiring of a woman’s body. I don’t agree with a baby being ripped away from its mother to suit someone else’s needs and the physical and psychological implications to both baby and mother as such. Why not just adopt?? If you don’t care for the child to be your biological anyway, why not adopt a baby who needs a parent?

it’s kind of made me look at her in a different light. She seemed very flippant about it (I’m aware this is just how she has came across I’m sure it’s a lengthy and draining process). She says she was put in touch with this woman through a friend who had used her.

essentially, this surrogate has just got pregnant for the purpose of handing over the baby to someone else in exchange for cash. I think I’d still be a bit 🤔 even if it was her own egg if truth be told.

I just can’t get my head around it. Am I being a bit of a bigot? Aibu to want to distance myself a bit? I don’t like feeling as though someone’s path to parenthood or happiness is “wrong” but it really doesn’t sit right with me and I’m not entirely sure why.

OP posts:
Flori7 · 30/10/2023 13:10

Hermittrismegistus · 30/10/2023 11:48

It is so often privileged (often white) women who tell a ‘victim’ in some way how they should think or feel. So patronising and deeply ironic, as if they need something pointing out and it couldn’t have possibly occurred to them without the saviour’s intervention. Also as if they can possibly relate from their towers

It's a white womans privilege to be against the buying and selling of humans? Absolutely crazy.

Hmm, not quite what I said and definitely not ‘crazy’ to point out that’s it’s so often privileged women who have this outrage on behalf of women who aren’t so privileged for whatever reason- who are often perfectly capable of deciding how to live their life and perfectly capable of understanding the world and its injustices.

But ‘crazy’ is just another (ill-mannered) way to try to dismiss or silence people with different views.

Teder · 30/10/2023 13:10

Tandora · 30/10/2023 10:23

Your opinions on this subject are , in my view, wild, out of touch and ignorant (and deeply unpleasant/ offensive). So, yes, I say someone else’s reproductive choices are none of your goddam business. (That goes for the choices of OP’s friend and her surrogate/ gamete donor(s)). You sound like the kind of person who’d be harassing women outside abortion clinics, in the name of “baby murdering is everyone’s business!”

If you resort to saying having ethical concerns about surrogacy is the same as being anti abortion protestor, clearly you have no valid points to make.
In the UK, an unborn foetus does not have legal rights. A baby that has been born is immediately afforded the same legal rights as every other human. The surrogate is giving away an actual being who has human rights. The woman having an abortion is not. Legally, it’s incomparable.

labamba007 · 30/10/2023 13:08

CampervanKween · 30/10/2023 08:08

I think surrogacy is awful. I'm sure these kids will grow up damaged but no-one seems to care. It's so selfish.

Why would they be damaged? I question the ethics of it but not sure how it would lead to damaged children?

Lesserspottedmama · 30/10/2023 12:39

The two women I have met who were surrogates were both very autistic and the multiple surrogates I’ve seen on YT/Instagram are also autistic. There’s definitely a link and these women are being terribly taken advantage of.

RunningFromInsanity · 30/10/2023 12:39

Didimum · 30/10/2023 08:10

You can obviously do what you wish and are entitled to your opinion. But at the end of the day it’s none of your business. As you describe her as not a close friend, her ‘flippant’ attitude is likely keeping her intimate emotions at bay regarding her own egg use. If she gone through IVF she will have been through that incredibly invasive and painful process already, possibly a number of times. And as it was unsuccessful, she may have even found her egg quality to be so low that it wouldn’t be a good idea to use them in surrogacy. Regardless if that’s the case, it’s not your business.

Edited

Exactly my thoughts. Her flippant remarks about not wanting hormones in her body are probably a defense mechanism after years of putting her body through a lot of hormone treatment for IVF.

Stupidnighty · 30/10/2023 12:38

Lesserspottedmama · 30/10/2023 12:37

Surrogacy is incredibly wrong from an ethical point of view. Heartbreaking to think of the damage to a baby being taken from its mother, even if the surrogate isn’t using her own egg, she’s still the mother from a physiological point of view and the critically important mother-baby dyad. I really hope more people wake up to this. Egg donation, IVF, adoption.. there are other options. It’s just so selfish.

This.

She is the mother from a legal point of view too.

Lesserspottedmama · 30/10/2023 12:37

Surrogacy is incredibly wrong from an ethical point of view. Heartbreaking to think of the damage to a baby being taken from its mother, even if the surrogate isn’t using her own egg, she’s still the mother from a physiological point of view and the critically important mother-baby dyad. I really hope more people wake up to this. Egg donation, IVF, adoption.. there are other options. It’s just so selfish.

NotBadConsidering · 30/10/2023 12:36

This (white🙄) woman consented. She consented to the pregnancy. She consented to giving birth. She consented to giving away her baby to two men.

But she didn’t consent to being filmed in labour. She didn’t consent to being made fun of for not waxing. She didn’t consent to those two things being shown on TV long after she had given up the baby.

So if people think women can consent, and it’s a “saviour complex” to want to prevent misogynistic shit like this happening to women, what legal framework do you propose to make sure there is true consent and women aren’t going to be exploited?

https://twitter.com/xxclusionary/status/1716144284682846485

https://twitter.com/xxclusionary/status/1716144284682846485

NotBadConsidering · 30/10/2023 12:20

Didimum · 30/10/2023 12:04

You still have no evidence the surrogacy is being paid or that the child is being exploited – so human trafficking still doesn't wash in this case. By all means, save it for an instance where you do have that evidence.

It also doesn't make much sense that you subscribe to Australia's definition of human trafficking, and yet Australia permits surrogacy in the same boundaries as the UK. If the OP's friend is abiding by UK law, then what is the issue when relating it to Australia's definition of human trafficking or Australia allows this itself?

The Australian definition doesn’t require exploitation. The point is that definitions exist that don’t require that. You are correct that it hasn’t been clarified that expenses are being paid, but it’s highly likely. As such, money is changing hands.

Australia’s surrogacy laws are state-based but many changed surrogacy laws after it was discovered the man at the centre of the Baby Gammie case was a paedophile.

In order to adopt, intended parents need to undergo scrutiny to minimise this. In surrogacy, no such checks take place. So even if there is no expected exploitation of the child, surrogacy is a ripe environment for those who wish to exploit a child to obtain one freely if they have enough money and a woman to exploit also. Are most children born via surrogacy exploited in the legal sense by their new parents? No, of course not. Are there checks and balances in place to ensure the child is not exploited? No, none whatsoever.

So it meets some jurisdictions of human trafficking without the inclusion of exploitation, and by default exploitation of the child is a non-protected outcome of the financial transaction.

Ohnoooooooo · 30/10/2023 12:19

Fatcat00 · 30/10/2023 10:50

Read the thread hun. I have had fertility issues. Calm yourself down and make a brew while you read through and get some perspective hey? X

Your thread has made me think more deeply about the issues around surrogacy and I thank you for that. But you are just a plain rude and condescending to people which is shame - because if you are really passionate about educating people on what the real issues and your concerns around surrogacy - you personally are doing the issue a disservice as you are tainting and distracting any valid points to your argument because people are just going to respond emotionally to your condensing remarks rather than be in a mindset to think intellectually about the issues. In the process of educating yourself on surrogacy, you might want to educate yourself on how to be an effective communicator because its likely your approach to others is spilling into real life.

Didimum · 30/10/2023 12:04

NotBadConsidering · 30/10/2023 11:53

https://www.afp.gov.au/crimes/human-trafficking-and-people-smuggling/human-trafficking-and-slavery

Human trafficking and slavery come in many forms, but every form violates human rights and involves the exploitation of people. Human trafficking comprises 2 key elements – movement and control.

People who have been trafficked have been moved from their locations, sometimes internationally. The control their abusers have over them takes many forms and can be difficult to identify. It could look like:

  • abduction
  • deception
  • abuse of power or a position of leadership
  • fraud
  • paying other people to gain 'consent'
  • taking advantage of vulnerability.
This control means ongoing exploitation, which could look like:
  • slavery
  • servitude
  • deceptive recruiting
  • debt bondage
  • forced labour
  • forced marriage
  • domestic child trafficking
  • trafficking of persons between countries and within Australia
  • organ trafficking.

Personally I like the broad definition of the Australian Federal Police which recognises moving humans from one place to another after paying for control of them if a form of human trafficking.

You still have no evidence the surrogacy is being paid or that the child is being exploited – so human trafficking still doesn't wash in this case. By all means, save it for an instance where you do have that evidence.

It also doesn't make much sense that you subscribe to Australia's definition of human trafficking, and yet Australia permits surrogacy in the same boundaries as the UK. If the OP's friend is abiding by UK law, then what is the issue when relating it to Australia's definition of human trafficking or Australia allows this itself?

NotBadConsidering · 30/10/2023 11:59

Flori7 · 30/10/2023 11:41

Well said.

It is so often privileged (often white) women who tell a ‘victim’ in some way how they should think or feel. So patronising and deeply ironic, as if they need something pointing out and it couldn’t have possibly occurred to them without the saviour’s intervention. Also as if they can possibly relate from their towers.

So I’ll ask again what I asked earlier, a modified version:

why is it always either:

a) very poor women, often from poor countries including India or Thailand
b) women who aren’t poor like in India but are just coping and “could do with the money”

and never

c) rich white women with loads of time and money who want to do a nice thing for a financially destitute infertile Indian woman?

Surrogacy as an international trade has a huge discrepancy between rich white women exploiting poor women of colour in their own country or another. Why is that less of a concern to you than supposedly privileged white women here expressing concern for those who are exploited worldwide?

ManateeFair · 30/10/2023 11:57

Coffeerum · 30/10/2023 10:37

This is literally a textbook goady post.

Yes, this

ManateeFair · 30/10/2023 11:56

I can’t be assed putting hormones into my body

This doesn't tally with the claim that she's previously had IVF, though.

If this is real, and you aren't just making stuff up as a means of expressing your own distaste for surrogacy, then I'm afraid it's not really any of your business. If you have a strong moral/ethical objection to surrogacy then don't stay in contact with her.

It's obviously very reasonable to be against the practice of surrogacy (I wouldn't say I was entirely against it, but I certainly think the circumstances in which it's justifiable are very limited indeed and I can definitely envisage a lot of harmful possibilities in relation to it). But your friend is presumably acting within the law so there's nothing you can do about this. If you can't support her choice (and there's no reason why you should) then you need to end the friendship rather than carrying on being friends with someone you think has crossed a line for what you consider to be morally acceptable behaviour.

NotBadConsidering · 30/10/2023 11:53

Didimum · 30/10/2023 11:38

Unfortunately, your own personal definition of human trafficking is not relevant or useful. If you disagree with the UN's definition, perhaps you might agree with the definitions from Anti-slavery International, Department of Homeland Security, Gov.Uk, The Met, Europol ... except they all share the definition, so maybe not.

https://www.afp.gov.au/crimes/human-trafficking-and-people-smuggling/human-trafficking-and-slavery

Human trafficking and slavery come in many forms, but every form violates human rights and involves the exploitation of people. Human trafficking comprises 2 key elements – movement and control.

People who have been trafficked have been moved from their locations, sometimes internationally. The control their abusers have over them takes many forms and can be difficult to identify. It could look like:

  • abduction
  • deception
  • abuse of power or a position of leadership
  • fraud
  • paying other people to gain 'consent'
  • taking advantage of vulnerability.
This control means ongoing exploitation, which could look like:
  • slavery
  • servitude
  • deceptive recruiting
  • debt bondage
  • forced labour
  • forced marriage
  • domestic child trafficking
  • trafficking of persons between countries and within Australia
  • organ trafficking.

Personally I like the broad definition of the Australian Federal Police which recognises moving humans from one place to another after paying for control of them if a form of human trafficking.

Human trafficking and exploitation - AFP

Australian Federal Police leads a policing response to disrupt, investigate and prosecute perpetrators of modern slavery

https://www.afp.gov.au/crimes/human-trafficking-and-people-smuggling/human-trafficking-and-slavery

Stupidnighty · 30/10/2023 11:53

The vitriol being aimed at someone for pointing out the legal intricacies of surrogacy in the uk, is daft. You believe it’s fine- surely knowing the legal status is beneficial to you? It’s hardly an irrelevance is it?

Separate to that, I haven’t accused the op’s friend of buying a baby from abroad- why @TeaKitten thinks I can’t comprehend my own posts I don’t know. I’ve just pointed out that people do take part in human trafficking, and I think it’s immoral. @Tandora is free to think it is fine, or it doesn’t exist and is a fantasy I invented for my own entertainment if she wants. It says a lot more about her than me!

Far too many people think ‘I want’ should equal ‘I get’, - it does them no harm to hear that actually, grown up life doesn’t work like that.

Tinklyheadtilt · 30/10/2023 11:50

Aqua20 · 30/10/2023 10:48

@Fatcat00 Wow!! How judgemental are you?! Thank goodness she didn't ask for your opinion! You are lucky you have not had fertility issues!! You don't have a clue what it's like struggling to to have a baby, miscarriage after miscarriages, the strength to keep your head above the water when when someone announces their pregnancy, congratulating to them and then having to watch their baby bump grow. You do it because they are your friend!!

Adoption is nit easy, when I enquired I was told to go to a different council tp ask about ethnic babies, because don't have any of your kind in this Borough 🙄 the council don't help! I even applied to be a Foster parent, told them my health condition and they said, it not an issue. I went through 8 months of training for them to say sorry, we can approve you because of your health!! If they can't listen to grown adults what makes you thin they listen to the children!!

Fyi you are such an ignorant person!

So that justifies 'buying a baby' does it? Grow up.

Tandora · 30/10/2023 11:49

Flori7 · 30/10/2023 11:41

Well said.

It is so often privileged (often white) women who tell a ‘victim’ in some way how they should think or feel. So patronising and deeply ironic, as if they need something pointing out and it couldn’t have possibly occurred to them without the saviour’s intervention. Also as if they can possibly relate from their towers.

100%

Tandora · 30/10/2023 11:49

KimberleyClark · 30/10/2023 11:32

Why do you find it so hard to believe that women who have experienced infertility can still be against surrogacy?

It’s not that she is against surrogacy per se, of course it’s possible to be both infertile and against surrogacy, it’s the total lack of sensitivity / insight into the challenge of infertility displayed in her OP.

Hermittrismegistus · 30/10/2023 11:48

It is so often privileged (often white) women who tell a ‘victim’ in some way how they should think or feel. So patronising and deeply ironic, as if they need something pointing out and it couldn’t have possibly occurred to them without the saviour’s intervention. Also as if they can possibly relate from their towers

It's a white womans privilege to be against the buying and selling of humans? Absolutely crazy.

MrsMiddleMother · 30/10/2023 11:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Flori7 · 30/10/2023 11:41

Tandora · 30/10/2023 11:23

No there are those who seek to police other women’s reproductive choices and what they do with their own bodies, and those who believe in women’s (bodily) autonomy and reproductive freedom.

YOU do not get to dictate what constitutes other women’s “misery”.

Well said.

It is so often privileged (often white) women who tell a ‘victim’ in some way how they should think or feel. So patronising and deeply ironic, as if they need something pointing out and it couldn’t have possibly occurred to them without the saviour’s intervention. Also as if they can possibly relate from their towers.

Didimum · 30/10/2023 11:38

NotBadConsidering · 30/10/2023 11:24

I disagree with the UN’s definition. They’re not the final authority on such matters. A child doesn’t have to be exploited for it to have been trafficked in my view. If the word “trafficked” requires exploitation, then it’s treating children like chattel at least.

Money is exchanged. “Expenses” is a lose term. No one checks. It’s still money being exchanged to gain a physical entity, in this case, a child.

Unfortunately, your own personal definition of human trafficking is not relevant or useful. If you disagree with the UN's definition, perhaps you might agree with the definitions from Anti-slavery International, Department of Homeland Security, Gov.Uk, The Met, Europol ... except they all share the definition, so maybe not.

TeaKitten · 30/10/2023 11:34

Stupidnighty · 30/10/2023 11:29

No I didn’t- go back and actually read what I have posted.

I said one thing about the op’s friend, I later responded to a specific post about paying for babies abroad- I made no mention of the op’s friend in that post because she is not buying the baby from abroad.

If you need to fabricate in order to ‘win’, then it’s usually a sign you are on tricky ground.

Go back and read it yourself, your comprehension is clearly struggling here.

Stupidnighty · 30/10/2023 11:33

Didimum · 30/10/2023 11:18

Kindly I disagree. The UN defines human trafficking as "through force, fraud or deception, with the aim of exploiting them for profit, forced labour, sexual slavery, or commercial sexual exploitation".

You and no one else on this thread (bar the OP) has evidence of the above, and not even that money is being exchanged beyond expenses.

https://www.ohchr.org/en/special-procedures/sr-sale-of-children/surrogacy

Swipe left for the next trending thread