Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants to take kids to his mum for a few days

245 replies

ditzzy · 30/10/2023 06:53

This comes up every half term, I thought I’d made my feelings clear when I stopped it last time but it came up again last night.

DH (well partner, we’re not married) is a SAHD and is in charge of activities for half term this week. It’s his first holiday in charge of both DD as DD2 is in reception (DD1 is 8). I’ve managed to take Wednesday and Thursday off and was starting to look for some nice days out.

He asked last night whether I could swap to Thursday and Friday off so that he could take them 100 miles away to his mum’s for the first half of the week.

I know I’m working, so it’s it’s my own fault for not being able to go too, hence maybe I’m being unreasonable for not wanting them to go and have fun without me, but I don’t like it because:

I like going there too.
Whenever we go there he and his mum do all her household admin and leave me looking after DDs, so I think they’ll be told to be quiet and play on their own there and not enjoy it (and I don’t want them to have a bad memory of their Granny).
He’s not asked her - she likes warning of visitors as she has her own social life as well!
I usually do all the food sorting etc for DDs when we go there, as well as early morning wake ups - he’s going to tell them to be quiet, go back to bed, when they would normally get up.
It’s a two hour plus drive which I entertain kids for in the back of the car.
The car also has a battery problem at the moment, so I don’t think he should risk taking it that far until it’s fixed.

Surely he knows these things too? Some is just DH being inconsiderate to his mum; some is his own anxiety about being in charge of them both on his own so wants her help; some is presumably just because he wants to make the point that I’m being awkward (and he thinks I prioritise work over family too much).

Any thoughts? Should I just bite my tongue and help him pack? Or point out that he’s really not thinking about everyone else by suggesting it?

OP posts:
Sunnydays0101 · 30/10/2023 08:15

Let him do the packing himself.

ditzzy · 30/10/2023 08:12

Not sure my replies are tagging to the posts!

I don’t mind them going out and having fun without me, they usually go on day trips and local activities in the holidays. It’s just the multi-day nature of visiting Granny and how far away it is.

OP posts:
ditzzy · 30/10/2023 08:10

That’s a bit of what concerns me. Sometimes the 8 year old asks me how to tell him things to avoid the “wrong” response which sends a red flag up to me. Although I will caveat that concern a bit, because learning how to work around other people’s emotion is probably better than the zero emotion household I grew up in.

He has a couple of health issues that make him short tempered sometimes and that impact his confidence in looking for work.

OP posts:
sparepantsandtoothbrush · 30/10/2023 08:08

Stop being such a martyr and leave him to it. He's probably more capable than you know...but you don't know because you're too controlling and won't give him the chance to do anything alone!

Why are you making lunches while working from home if he's the Sahp? Leave him to get on with it.

I get the feeling you don't WANT him to succeed with this

WiIIow · 30/10/2023 08:07

YABVVU

Pinkpinkpink15 · 30/10/2023 08:05

MidnightOnceMore · 30/10/2023 07:03

maybe I’m being unreasonable for not wanting them to go and have fun without me This would be very unreasonable.

My friends DH was a brilliant SAHD. My friend was like this, really such a downer on them going places without her. I understand feeling sad about missing out, but I couldn't understand her not being happy the kids were having fun. She'd whinge & bitch about it & say he should stay home & get the laundry/housework/garden done & only go out with her.

@ditzzy don't be like my friend.

if HE wants to go to HIS MUMS then let him crack on, the kids will be fine or whinge at him. His issue.

if he wants to go, HE can do the packing. If he forgets things, he'll cope & learn for next time. The only thing I'd check is if the kids have any comforters.

kitchenhelprequired · 30/10/2023 07:59

You are trying to control all environments & scenario's which in the end will be detrimental to you. I appreciate you think you are doing the best for the DC but you can't be all things to all man. Entertaining the DC in the car on what really is quite a short trip so DP doesn't get stressed and shout at them is ridiculous as is you going to his DM's just so they aren't ignored by both DP & DGP. You are effectively walking on eggshells creating an environment in which DP won't be abusive in one way shape or form. He thinks work is beneath him as well as parenting and household tasks. What is he actually good for?

Spookymormonhelldream · 30/10/2023 07:57

You’re imagining scenarios that may or may not happen. If they do, he will have to deal with them! Your older DD is certainly capable of saying she didn’t have a good time or whatever, so if it’s a rubbish few days, well he won’t go again.
re: the rest of your post. Well he needs to buck his ideas up. Doing the school runs and telling himself he’s great is not exactly pulling his weight either financially or logistically. You need to put your foot down OP.

GoodnightJude1 · 30/10/2023 07:57

He’s their dad.

Any problems and HE can sort them. Or learn.

MRSMTO · 30/10/2023 07:55

Just let your joint children go to their grandparents house with their dad. So what if they're made to play on their own for a bit, that's good for them. They will survive without your input for a couple of days.

DontListenToWhatYouveConsumed · 30/10/2023 07:55

I had a father we had to tip toe round, especially in the car. We dreaded those holiday journeys. Couldn't even ask to stop for a pee without evoking satans wrath. Bloody awful 😖.
Is this the only time he shouts at the children for minor issues?
Is he actually doing anything useful while being a sahp (not working)?

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 07:51

None of your worries sound serious, you've probably just got used to being the 'organised one'.

Even mil forgetting to eat over lunchtime ... if she did it again and fainted, you wouldn't need to ambulance next time round as you'd know she just needed to eat something. No big deal

Isthisexpected · 30/10/2023 07:50

Having read your update it sounds like he's not a very good SAHD at all but is doing it reluctantly and has little patience for them. Sounds like this would be their first and only trip to Granny's without you.

Mariposista · 30/10/2023 07:49

The key thing here is that OP has a bit of FOMO…

HardcoreLadyType · 30/10/2023 07:48

if you are not there, the dynamic will be different, so because you are not there to get the DC their breakfasts someone else (either DP or DGM) will do it. They will need to fit the admin around the DC’s needs. The DC will be fine in the car, and the driver can always e.g. instigate games of eye-spy, or play music or audio books to entertain them.

The reasonable objections are that the car may not be reliable, and that he hasn’t asked DGM. Can the car be fixed before he goes? And so long as he checks it’s convenient with her, first, and doesn’t just rock up at her house with 2 DC expecting to be hosted, that will be fine.

Normandy144 · 30/10/2023 07:46

The only unreasonable things are that he hasn't asked his mum if it's ok. He really needs to call her and ask if it is ok if they stay. Also the car battery. Everything else is not an issue. 100 miles is not far at all.

PinkRoses1245 · 30/10/2023 07:46

YABVU. All minor points. Let him parent as he wants, you can’t control everything. You don’t need to ‘entertain’ kid in the car

OldBilge · 30/10/2023 07:44

Donotshushme · 30/10/2023 07:39

I think it's an excellent idea for him to take them without you smoothing every single possible bump in the road. Can't quite get my head around sitting in the back with them for a relatively short drive to entertain them. Don't they have books/toys/ipads?

To be honest you all sound like really hard work - Granny needs a train booking for her and told when to eat, dh doesn't want to work for anyone (do any of us?!) And you need to be in control of everything otherwise the kids might get told off. All of you.. chill out.

Yes. What strikes me in all the OP’s posts is a lot of fear and stress about what might happen if she didn’t smooth all the bumps — when the stakes are very low, surely? The worst case scenario is that her MIL is mildly miffed at the short notice, the kids are bored in the car and on the visit, or can’t get up at their usual time.

Bobtheamazinggingerdog · 30/10/2023 07:42

So the real issue is you feel you have to mitigate his shitness by doing everything...
FGS why are you with him and enabling the lazy useless man?? Your life will be better (and cheaper) if you aren't carrying a man who is too good to work and doesn't even care for the kids properly...

whatchagonnado · 30/10/2023 07:42

Let them get on with it and enjoy the peace and quiet. They will be fine.
Arrange a night out with a friend while they're away and make the most of it!

Ilovelurchers · 30/10/2023 07:41

With respect, you don't sound like you think very highly of him at all - you are extremely critical of his parenting and without exactly saying it, make him sound like a real twat. Is this a happy relationship for either of you? I wouldn't want to be with someone I thought so little of that I didn't trust them to look after their own kids properly for a few days. And from his perspective, I wouldn't want to be with someone who thought so poorly of me.

Apart from the car battery (that is a genuine and extremely legitimate concern - my fella is a cat dealer and I hate him driving a long way in dodgy vehicles even without a child!) in this instance it would seem very very controlling of you not to "let" them go (can you stop them?). We are obviously all protective of our kids, that's natural, but when you have a coparent you have to accept that their way of doing things will be different to yours - they are a different person. But as long as it is not abusive, they are a parent too and you have to let them get on with it. Of course you can discuss ways of doing things and make suggestions. But you can't demand he does things your way just because you think you are a better parent.

2chocolateoranges · 30/10/2023 07:40

Your dh is a SAHD as he doesn’t want to work for someone who doesn’t appreciate him!! Do any bosses really appreciate their staff?😂😂

he’s a SAHD but it’s you that does lunches etc due to working from home, he’s got it easy!

if he was as useless as you are making out he is I wouldn’t want him taking the kids either away either.

Donotshushme · 30/10/2023 07:39

I think it's an excellent idea for him to take them without you smoothing every single possible bump in the road. Can't quite get my head around sitting in the back with them for a relatively short drive to entertain them. Don't they have books/toys/ipads?

To be honest you all sound like really hard work - Granny needs a train booking for her and told when to eat, dh doesn't want to work for anyone (do any of us?!) And you need to be in control of everything otherwise the kids might get told off. All of you.. chill out.

Ellie1015 · 30/10/2023 07:38

Yabu not to try and swap days or to ever "put a stop to it"

If mil thinks too short notice she can have that conversation with her son. He will learn to deal with them in car amd any other practicalities, they arent toddlers so it isnt as high stress as it was when younger.

If I were your partner i would be letting you know we are going not asking permission.

NoSquirrels · 30/10/2023 07:37

So the issue is that your ‘D’H is a dick, rather than him taking them to see his mum on his own?

You still do all the parenting and organising whilst working as well, and he does a few school runs and applies (or not!) for jobs and shouts at his kids for being kids.