Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stingy friend send wrong wrong money

410 replies

Rossannah · 29/10/2023 23:15

I have just been away with a friend for 2 nights. An event plus hotel. Cost for the two altogether was £416. I paid for both on my card and told friend to send £200 for her share. She said she would send this weekend, after the event. This was fine.
We went, had a good time. Whilst there, we spent equally. We drank and ate the same. Sometimes paid by round, sometimes separate for eg in a prepay cafe. I don't feel I spent or took any more than my fair share, friend never moaned.
I reckon I spent around £180 in fuel, no mention of this was made, no arrangement for half to be paid by friend and I would have gone alone and spent the same so I was not bothered about paying for fuel myself.
On the way home we stopped at a garage. I filled up the tank, paid at the pump. Friend went in the petrol station and asked if I wanted anything. I gave her an order from subway which was in there, sandwich and drink and some boiled sweets.
We then got on the way. Nice time had by all.
Tonight, she messaged to say she's sent the money she owed. I check and she's put in £290(£90 too much) I reply to say I've got it but it's not what we agreed, confused face, kisses etc ( I did not expect her to pay for petrol) she then goes off on a rant about how she paid for my subway when she went in the petrol station and I didn't offer her any money for it and I was cheeky to expect her to pay for my food. I realised then she had meant to send £190 but has got it wrong.
I wonder how to approach this error given her rudeness and cheekiness over a bloody tenner! Considering I've spent on petrol.
Should I leave it until she realises let her come crawling? Refund her the £100 or £90 as agreed ? No idea. So shocked at her stinginess

I cannot edit the title, I can see the error, haha ironic

OP posts:
Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 30/10/2023 13:48

I really can't see how anyone, when asked to pay £200 and actually paying £290, would think a message saying 'you haven't paid what we agreed ' would mean they hadn't paid enough.

I would. I don't understand why the OP didn't mention in her text that she thought that her friend had paid too much, seems like a huge omission to me. Huge misunderstandings all round.

JudgeJ · 30/10/2023 13:44

Ibravedaflood · 30/10/2023 12:20

Just been to Mull from NE. Spent 300 on fuel..

I've done Edinburgh and back, about 375 miles each way, for under £120, I drive an old 2 litre car.

Honeyroar · 30/10/2023 13:34

I don’t think she accidentally paid too much. Banks ask you to check a few times before you press the send button, it would be hard to not notice. I think she’d probably sent you petrol money and deducted some for the sandwich. And your “you’ve paid the wrong amount” didn’t say it was too much. It sounds like a mess due to poor communication on both sides.

Tighginn · 30/10/2023 13:26

Is this what the holiday fund was spent on?

WonderingWanda · 30/10/2023 13:21

Reply and say, I think we got our wires crossed. What I meant was thank you for the money, I appreciate the extra but you didn't need to, we'd only agreed that you'd pay 200. I wasn't implying you should have paid me more and sorry it came across that way. It was generous of you to add the fuel money.

Custardslices · 30/10/2023 13:13

Why did she not pay you £280 and take the tenner herself off for subway?

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 13:13

I really can't see how anyone, when asked to pay £200 and actually paying £290, would think a message saying 'you haven't paid what we agreed ' would mean they hadn't paid enough.

It's quite possible she got confused and thought it was £300 each though, and she's deducted the £10 for Subway. She knew it was cheeky, hence the aggressive response. So she may never realise it was meant to be £200 each.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 30/10/2023 12:38

OP when you responded with the confused face etc did you say that she'd paid more than you expected? If not, I agree with other posters, she deliberately paid you more to cover petrol so no wonder she's pissed off if you appear to be suggesting that it isn't enough. If that's the case, if I was her I too would be petty and ask you to pay for the Subway.

Riola · 30/10/2023 12:25

Seaweed42 · 30/10/2023 11:45

Why did you not offer to pay for the Subway and stuff at the petrol station?
That was weird behaviour on your part.
She might be calling you Stingy friend.

Maybe Because in her mind she was already covering the entire cost of travel. The friend hadn’t said she’d pay anything towards petrol at that point . So she might have assumed her friend was trying to be halfway decent by paying for a Subway since she was getting to travel free

Tbh if my friend drove us a long distance, even if I had split the petrol costs with them, I’d still be happy to get them a free sandwich for the fact they’re the one driving while I get to relax in the passenger seat.

Ibravedaflood · 30/10/2023 12:20

Just been to Mull from NE. Spent 300 on fuel..

Emotionalsupportviper · 30/10/2023 12:16

Whichever way the text was intended, it's a great shame - it looks like it's not only cast a shadow over what was obviously a very enjoyable weekend, but may even have destroyed a friendship.

Riola · 30/10/2023 12:16

Rossannah · 29/10/2023 23:42

I've sent her £10 with reference subway.
I originally thought it was£90 extra for fuel but given it wasn't mentioned in her reply, I think it was £100 extra in error. I'll wait for her reply 😄

well played 😂 next time since you know what she’s like, make her pay a contribution to petrol. Don’t do any favours for people like that since they wouldn’t for you. If she eventually realises what’s happened just stick to your guns. Don’t refund her

Me and my boyfriend did a few days away recently, I paid accommodation and he paid for all food & expenses.

He said he wondered if I’d paid more than him for the weekend, and did I want any more £ from him. I had to remind him of his petrol costs which more than evened things out! It’s rude for the non-driver, not to take petrol costs into account.

Lucyintheskywithlove · 30/10/2023 12:08

I'd assume she intended to pay for petrol on top of it.
I doubt she would make a mistake and not have realised by now.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 30/10/2023 11:53

On first glance of your OP, it could well be that she has sent you extra money for fuel, and when you told her that the amount wasn't as agreed, she thought you were asking for more - which she felt was unreasonable as she had paid you half already - and so pointed out the food difference .

There's nothing in your post that suggests any difference- or that she hadn't intended to pay the extra she did for the petrol .

321user123 · 30/10/2023 11:53

Thank god it’s “tomorrow” and I can’t wait for her to realise the mistake! 😂

Seaweed42 · 30/10/2023 11:45

Why did you not offer to pay for the Subway and stuff at the petrol station?
That was weird behaviour on your part.
She might be calling you Stingy friend.

SoftSheen · 30/10/2023 11:41

Sounds like a misunderstanding to me. I would interpret this as she has sent you £200 for the room plus £90 for the fuel (seems reasonable), but thinks that you are asking her for more money on top of that. Try talking to her, and if there is any disagreement then just write her an itemised bill so she can see the exact costs for herself.

mushroom3 · 30/10/2023 10:45

You are actually now financially quits and so I would leave it at that. You have paid her for the sandwich and she has paid you for the weekend plus 50% of the fuel cost.

Rockstarqueen · 30/10/2023 10:39

Ceebeegee · 30/10/2023 09:14

I think she has overracted but I think your message has been misinterpreted.

£200 was agreed. She sent £290.
Your message : "I've got it but it's not what we agreed, confused face, xx" - I would interpret that message as you are saying I haven't paid enough.
So, she's now annoyed that she has paid more than agreed and instead of receiving a message like "thank you for sending me £90 extra, you didn't have to, but thank you" she thinks you're having a go for her not paying enough!

Yes I think you’ve got it right.
The whole thing is just a complete drama due to miscommunication.
It sounds like your friend thought you was asking for more money from her, that’s why she mentioned about purchasing your Subway and not being paid for it.
Honestly, what a palaver over nothing.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 30/10/2023 10:35

I also think your friend is including petrol money in the £290 she sent you. As a passenger, she would have easily been able to see how much you were filling up each time and could have just added it up to £180 and then divided by 2.

An awfully large proportion of people - especially if they don't drive themselves - don't fully realise/understand how much fuel costs.

Also, to people with a record of stinginess, it's the very first thing they usually discount the prospect of them paying anything towards. Some CFs are very good at blustering that filling the car with fuel is your responsibility as the driver, as a given, without any acknowledgement of how expensive it is nor that the cost is directly proportional to distance travelled by both/all of you.

Add to this that many people will fill up the day before a big trip, to save time on the day, so the travelling companion isn't there to see that large sum of money being spent upfront.

Rockstarqueen · 30/10/2023 10:32

I’m confused, she sent £290 which was for half the hotel and event and half of fuel. I can’t see any indication from the friend saying she sent the wrong amount, unless she said?
You asked her to buy you a sub-way, she bought it for you and was expecting to be paid back for that. I fail to see where the friend has gone wrong!

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 30/10/2023 10:27

It was maybe a clumsy way of responding, but I'm presuming that it came from a place of open-mouthed astonishment on receiving the full amount that left OP spluttering for how to respond?!

Fantasea · 30/10/2023 10:25

I also think your friend is including petrol money in the £290 she sent you. As a passenger, she would have easily been able to see how much you were filling up each time and could have just added it up to £180 and then divided by 2.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 30/10/2023 10:25

You should have told me I was busy filling up the car with fuel, I'd have got it myself my mistake!

Yes, this. Even the responsibility of having to fill up the car, let alone doing hundreds and hundreds of miles of driving. As a passenger, buying somebody a sandwich is the tiniest token of appreciation for that.

I would pay her back what she overpaid (£90). Your lunch was already likely covered in the total demanded that you rounded down (depending on how much she paid for sweets, I suppose, at petrol station prices).

You can't in conscience keep the amount she overpaid accidentally just because it appears she's been a bit unpleasant over £10. Ring her and talk it out.

But she didn't actually overpay at all. OP assumed that she was going to swerve paying her fair share, including the petrol, and is astounded that she DID actually end up paying her fair share (whether deliberately or not).

I may be unfairly reading between the lines here, but the fact that OP describes the friend as 'stingy' is telling. The amazement has surely come from the friend adding on her share of the petrol, even though she was never asked to do this.

MILLYmo0se · 30/10/2023 10:22

Are you certain that she didnt think you were asking for more money in your first text? Thats how I would have read it