Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stingy friend send wrong wrong money

410 replies

Rossannah · 29/10/2023 23:15

I have just been away with a friend for 2 nights. An event plus hotel. Cost for the two altogether was £416. I paid for both on my card and told friend to send £200 for her share. She said she would send this weekend, after the event. This was fine.
We went, had a good time. Whilst there, we spent equally. We drank and ate the same. Sometimes paid by round, sometimes separate for eg in a prepay cafe. I don't feel I spent or took any more than my fair share, friend never moaned.
I reckon I spent around £180 in fuel, no mention of this was made, no arrangement for half to be paid by friend and I would have gone alone and spent the same so I was not bothered about paying for fuel myself.
On the way home we stopped at a garage. I filled up the tank, paid at the pump. Friend went in the petrol station and asked if I wanted anything. I gave her an order from subway which was in there, sandwich and drink and some boiled sweets.
We then got on the way. Nice time had by all.
Tonight, she messaged to say she's sent the money she owed. I check and she's put in £290(£90 too much) I reply to say I've got it but it's not what we agreed, confused face, kisses etc ( I did not expect her to pay for petrol) she then goes off on a rant about how she paid for my subway when she went in the petrol station and I didn't offer her any money for it and I was cheeky to expect her to pay for my food. I realised then she had meant to send £190 but has got it wrong.
I wonder how to approach this error given her rudeness and cheekiness over a bloody tenner! Considering I've spent on petrol.
Should I leave it until she realises let her come crawling? Refund her the £100 or £90 as agreed ? No idea. So shocked at her stinginess

I cannot edit the title, I can see the error, haha ironic

OP posts:
FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 30/10/2023 16:47

If I were the friend I'd be thinking 'FFS, I've paid my share plus I've paid for half the petrol when I was told I needn't do and I bought her a bloody sandwich and that isn't enough'

Because the OP hasn't actually thanked her for the overpayment, just assumed it was a mistake.

Do you really think your friend should be grateful if you pay your share of the petrol - and that it's an 'overpayment'? Even if she said you don't need to, surely any reasonable person accepts that you should pay half of your joint travel costs?

MamaInManolos · 30/10/2023 16:34

Is Rossannah going to update us?!! We are all waiting with baited breath and are invested in the outcome? What did your friend say?!! Let us know 🙈😊

Firebug007 · 30/10/2023 16:26

I'd keep it for petrol and not speak to her again 🤷‍♀️

Stravaig · 30/10/2023 16:21

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 30/10/2023 16:10

I really hope the OP comes back and clarifies what the friend's genuine intentions were.

Not sure that OP can be relied on for an accurate interpretation of events.

Redpaisley · 30/10/2023 16:15

RomeoandJomeo · 30/10/2023 00:14

This is my thinking too.

You've then complained, and implied that she should pay more, so she has argued back to point out she paid for your subway.

Correction : Op never complained to the friend.

This is what op says -

I reckon I spent around £180 in fuel, no mention of this was made, no arrangement for half to be paid by friend and I would have gone alone and spent the same so I was not bothered about paying for fuel myself.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 30/10/2023 16:10

I really hope the OP comes back and clarifies what the friend's genuine intentions were.

Redpaisley · 30/10/2023 16:06

Rossannah · 29/10/2023 23:15

I have just been away with a friend for 2 nights. An event plus hotel. Cost for the two altogether was £416. I paid for both on my card and told friend to send £200 for her share. She said she would send this weekend, after the event. This was fine.
We went, had a good time. Whilst there, we spent equally. We drank and ate the same. Sometimes paid by round, sometimes separate for eg in a prepay cafe. I don't feel I spent or took any more than my fair share, friend never moaned.
I reckon I spent around £180 in fuel, no mention of this was made, no arrangement for half to be paid by friend and I would have gone alone and spent the same so I was not bothered about paying for fuel myself.
On the way home we stopped at a garage. I filled up the tank, paid at the pump. Friend went in the petrol station and asked if I wanted anything. I gave her an order from subway which was in there, sandwich and drink and some boiled sweets.
We then got on the way. Nice time had by all.
Tonight, she messaged to say she's sent the money she owed. I check and she's put in £290(£90 too much) I reply to say I've got it but it's not what we agreed, confused face, kisses etc ( I did not expect her to pay for petrol) she then goes off on a rant about how she paid for my subway when she went in the petrol station and I didn't offer her any money for it and I was cheeky to expect her to pay for my food. I realised then she had meant to send £190 but has got it wrong.
I wonder how to approach this error given her rudeness and cheekiness over a bloody tenner! Considering I've spent on petrol.
Should I leave it until she realises let her come crawling? Refund her the £100 or £90 as agreed ? No idea. So shocked at her stinginess

I cannot edit the title, I can see the error, haha ironic

You tell her you were not cheeky as you spent 180 on petrol and you never asked her to contribute to this cost and were free driver for journey both ways. Also, the cost of hotel plus even was 208 per person but you asked her for 200 as she paid for subway.

No need to say anything extra as she had nerves to call you cheeky. Also, it's upto you if you want to correct her error bit if you don't, rember you did nothing wrong as she has shown you that she would not even be spend £10 over you, why are you being so generous with such a person. Objectively, 290 is completely fair, none of you spend any money on other. 416 divided by 2 is 208 plus 90 for petrol minus 10 for subway, so she owed you 288, she paid you £2 extra, if you like return her 2.

Donkeyseason · 30/10/2023 16:04

I don’t understand all the replies saying the friend deliberately added on the petrol
costs. The friend surely would not have known how much the petrol cost, so could have known she was paying half.

Plus, only a total tight arse would begrudge spending a tenner on a sandwich and drink for someone who booked the weekend away and did all the considerable driving there and back. Most people would want to buy the sandwich and drink as a thank you.

Which means the most likely explanation is that friend is a tight arse who held back a tenner to pay for the subway.

BlueEyedPeanut · 30/10/2023 15:58

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 15:53

Ah now we are all mich more Father Ted in my friendship group.

If contactless cards weren't a thing, that would pretty much be me and my best friend too. Instead we battle to see whose card makes contact with the payment machine first. No one assumes they are getting a free ride or a free subway. We always try to pay.

Sadandhurt23 · 30/10/2023 15:57

'oh you are funny, that made me laugh. What are you like. PS thanks for paying towards the petrol!'

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 15:53

BlueEyedPeanut · 30/10/2023 15:49

Because the OP sounded like she was complaining. Most people would say "thank you", not launch into something that sounds like a criticism.

Ah now we are all mich more Father Ted in my friendship group.

Father Ted - Mrs. Doyle Fight Scene

This is the fight between Mrs. Doyle and friend in the resteraunt in the Father Ted Episode called the Mainland

https://youtu.be/571YIyOkAEM?si=TJIEV43i2EX1yQGq

Donkeyseason · 30/10/2023 15:53

Why on earth did you send her £10 for subway?! She’s already taken the tenner!

No need for the indirect suggestions on this thread.

Say nothing or tell the truth. ‘ I was going to cover the £180 petrol cost myself but being as your attitude over the subway shows you want to split all costs 50/50, I’m keeping the £90 extra you paid to cover petrol’

Then just never see her again. Because this is one dead friendship.

Panaa · 30/10/2023 15:53

BurbleBumleBleep · 30/10/2023 14:45

That makes no sense either though. If you've agreed £200 and you give your friend more on purpose, you know they are only expecting £200. So any message from the friend about confusion is exactly that. There's no "missing money" when you've paid extra.

It only makes sense if you know your friend is expecting £200 but you've taken £10 off unilaterally.

Nope, lots of us have came to the same conclusion/assumption so the possibility does make sense.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 30/10/2023 15:51

Sounds to me like the friendship is pretty much over now anyway because the OP's immediate thought was that their friend had tried to rip them off and accidently overpaid £90 rather than thinking how lovely that the friend has coughed up for fuel as well even though they didn't have to.

BlueEyedPeanut · 30/10/2023 15:49

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 15:47

But then why would ops friend see her arse about the phrase 'you didn't pay what we agreed'?

The only agreement here is the £200

Because the OP sounded like she was complaining. Most people would say "thank you", not launch into something that sounds like a criticism.

Riola · 30/10/2023 15:48

@PosterBoy yeah IMO that would be a perfect way to solve things and shut her down in advance. If she really is a CF she may still ask for the money back anyway though. Will be interesting to read OP updates clarifying what the confusion was.

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 15:47

BlueEyedPeanut · 30/10/2023 15:45

Yes to cover the hotel and event. Not the travel costs. They didn't agree on the travel costs. The OP never specifically told her that it was a free ride.

If I was the friend in that situation, I wouldn't expect to not contribute to the fuel costs.

But then why would ops friend see her arse about the phrase 'you didn't pay what we agreed'?

The only agreement here is the £200

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 15:46

I hope either way that op messages to clarify

(oh no, poor dear friend, I meant you had overpaid me but it's so kind of you to include petrol costs and the actual ticket price and of course I don't expect you to cover my subway meal as well, even though I did drive 500 miles , too too kind of you, I have sent you the money for my meal, so sorry I didn't do that earlier)

It's a win-win really as it boxes her in if she had accidentally overpaid and just about covers the cracks if her friend thought she was having a go about not paying enough to cover the petrol

BlueEyedPeanut · 30/10/2023 15:45

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 15:36

"I paid for both on my card and told friend to send £200 for her share. She said she would send this weekend, after the event."

She was asked to send £200.

Yes to cover the hotel and event. Not the travel costs. They didn't agree on the travel costs. The OP never specifically told her that it was a free ride.

If I was the friend in that situation, I wouldn't expect to not contribute to the fuel costs.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 30/10/2023 15:44

She was asked to send £200.

Yes she was but maybe she thought that it was only fair to also pay for half of the £180 fuel so decided to send £290.

Riola · 30/10/2023 15:44

But my initial point is even if she did deliberately pay more than agreed, she should’ve known that it was not what they agreed hence that was the meaning of OP’s text when she said “this isn’t what we agreed”

a reasonable reply to that would be to say “yeah no worries - I know it’s not what we agreed but I decided to put an extra £90 in to cover petrol. Hope that’s enough. Thanks for driving us through ”

Not to jump on the defensive and accuse OP.

Who complains about a payment not being enough when it’s more than expected. Common sense should’ve told her that isn’t what Op meant.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 30/10/2023 15:40

she knew she had paid £90 more than she was asked to

but also thinks 'you haven't paid what we agreed' (which she knows because she knows how much she was asked to pay and chose to add £90) means she needs to pay more again than the more she already paid?

Yes and that's why she's pissed off with OP and texted about the Subway. That makes the most sense to me. Plus they'd agreed £200 and £90 is half the fuel. I don't understand why the OP thinks the friend has overpaid by £100, surely it's only £90 which is coincidentally exactly half the price of the fuel.

Riola · 30/10/2023 15:39

I paid for both on my card and told friend to send £200 for her share.She said she would send this weekend, after the event

That counts as an agreement. They had a clear agreement.

Yes, they hadn’t discussed petrol costs or anything else so why would friend just pay a £100 extra of her own accord with no discussion? It’s clear she’d ask Op how much fuel costs were or how much she wanted for fuel if she wanted to contribute
to that.

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 15:36

BlueEyedPeanut · 30/10/2023 15:30

I don't think they "agreed" on anything. The friend was just told £200 would cover the event and hotel. They hadn't discussed everything else. So when the friend sent the OP money, she sent the £200 plus money for fuel.

"I paid for both on my card and told friend to send £200 for her share. She said she would send this weekend, after the event."

She was asked to send £200.

PosterBoy · 30/10/2023 15:34

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 30/10/2023 15:09

How does 'you haven't paid what we agreed' (and quick reminder, that's £200) mean 'you haven't paid enough?

Because most people in that situation would put, thanks for the payment but you've given me too much (and the the OP didn't put 'and quick reminder that's £200'). If you can't see that, I can't help you.🙄

So you think

she knew she had paid £90 more than she was asked to

but also thinks 'you haven't paid what we agreed' (which she knows because she knows how much she was asked to pay and chose to add £90) means she needs to pay more again than the more she already paid?

Ok. Well if that's how your brain works I guess that's how it works.