Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband won’t call grandchild by his name

582 replies

Blyther · 29/10/2023 22:18

our grandchild (5 months) has an unusual name. It’s a made up name which is a bit ‘out there’- think along the lines of ‘starry-Skye’ or ‘misty-bridge’. Our daughter in law is a bit whacky.

It’s of course entirely up to the parents to choose the name of their child but my husband won’t even say his name as it makes him cringe so much. He refers to the baby as ‘the little one’ or will call him by his middle name.

It’s now become apparent to the parents how he refuses to use his name and it’s causing an atmosphere. I just don’t know what to say to them as I completely understand his point and feel very sorry about the potential bullying he (the baby) is likely to encounter further down the road.

Advice on moving forward please.

OP posts:
Clarinet1 · 30/10/2023 08:08

It’s odds on the GS will change his name ehen
he gets older - lots of celebrity children have.
Zowie Bowie - now Duncan Jones
Leaf Phoenix - went back to Joaquin Phoenix
Chastity Bono - now Chas Bono

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 30/10/2023 08:08

Sayitaintso33 · 30/10/2023 06:55

This is nothing to do with you.

And even if it were, your husband is entirely right. Giving children absurd names is a ridiculous, vain affectation and one that should not be indulged.

Your husband is also right because mother's do not own children and do not get to insist on what their children are called. Most MNers wouldn't dream of insisting on a certain haircut for their toddling child, after-all her hair, her choice, but the demanding mother believes she is entitled to insist on a certain name.

Your husband might also be right because men, even neuro-divergent ones, frequently use nick-names and shortened names. If he does, you should respect male culture rather than just ride roughshod over it, encouraging the world to think you are a bullying bastard (Karen is misogynistic term I refuse to use, so I use the one applied to unbearably bossy men).

Leave your husband to live his life/ fight his own battles.

What a load of puffed up nonsense.

How do you propose that people "refuse to indulge" parents choosing a child's name you deem silly? Just not using it? Using something else?

A baby can't choose their own name - when they're older they can, but for now they need to be called something and who is better placed to choose what than their parents? You can't just have one person calling them Archibald and one calling them Phillip and one calling them Moonchild on a whim - they have a name, it should be used until a nickname the child likes naturally evolves. Personally I think calling a child John is a bit like calling them "Male Child no.4,564" but I wouldn't call them Archer or something just because I happened to like it better, because it's ridiculous to try and overrule their parents choice (and their legal birth certificate!) because some random doesn't like it. Maybe John is a beloved family member's name, or has a religious connotation to the family, or any other number of legitimate reasons you might give your precious child a super boring, undistinguished name. None of my business.

Seriously what an epically pompous post.

Pulverised · 30/10/2023 08:07

Him not using the name is not going to reduce the likelihood of bullying. He is being very very unreasonable.

Carmargo · 30/10/2023 08:05

I think in certain countries there is a state approved list of names.
As regards children, I'm with this all the way. 100%. If the child wants to change it as an adult to something wacky, they can.
Your dil sounds a nightmare. You've
raised a wet blanket son who is totally led by his wife.
She'll divorce him any way as he is so weak and he foolishly believes that doing everything she wants will make her 'happy'. If she's using him for resources she'll cheat anyway and pour scorn on it as his type 'forgives' such transgressions making him more worthy of contempt.

The kid will then have bigger problems than its stupid fucking name.

Utterly weak dad, domineering mother.

You're focusing on the wrong thing. Like rearranging the tables while the Titanic's sinking.

What is it anyway? I hate these posts where the OP half says stuff because it's outing. Nobody gives a toss and frankly if it IS that bizarre and unusual your dh has a point.

There must be a shortening of the name that is acceptable but unless you tell what it is, no random on the Internet can can help.

ClairDeLaLune · 30/10/2023 08:03

Is it Button Bear OP? We need to know!

So awkward. My cousin’s niece has a terrible name, she just calls her the baby or Baby but she’s nearly 2 now and she knows she has to start using the name but just can’t!

flowerr · 30/10/2023 08:03

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request

Safxxx · 30/10/2023 08:02

The other day I saw a post of a DIL complaining about the in-laws not calling their child by the name and calling it a baby only. As you can tell it's upsetting for any parents when names are not being used.
Unfortunately whether he likes it or not the name is staying and it's his name...so start using it, tell him to say it out loud and repeat it when his not around to get used to it so it won't be too difficult to call him by his name when he sees him.
Not worth the arguments so get used to it

TreePineapple · 30/10/2023 07:56

Your husband sounds like a spiteful, childish bully. You are enabling his behaviour. For example, him “practicing” saying the name sounds like the two of you having a laugh at the expense of your grandchild. Call the child by it’s name and stop making a big deal out of it. It might be the most stupid name in the world but it’s not worth damaging the relationship over - or making the child feel self conscious over. If the child is bullied, they’ll feel worst if they remember eve their own granddad was weird about it.

AbbeyGailsParty · 30/10/2023 07:54

applepieandtea · 29/10/2023 23:22

I think in the long run some kids are going to change their names when they are adults.
I no of 3 people so far that have changed their names one was 18 one was 20 & 22 .
Maybe outing but one was called atmosphere changed to amy .
The other one called boo changed to bonnie.
Last was atlas changed to adam.

Maybe outing but one was called atmosphere
Bloody hell, that’s cruel.

gotomomo · 30/10/2023 07:54

Poor kid.

Not sure if they still do, but the French used to have a sanctioned list of names, I think we do too!

At tots we have a River, an Ocean (not related), a Bear, and a Juniper (guessing mum loves ginGrin)

DogInATent · 30/10/2023 07:54

There's not really a problem with a grandfather and grandchild having pet names for each other. Unless the other adults make it a problem.

It's unlikely that little Button-Moon is going to call his granddad Keith. So let let them call each other Pops and Sonny if that works for them.

ChristmasQuestions · 30/10/2023 07:48

I am with your husband actually. If people insist on calling their children these ridiculous names they are going to have to expect some flak for it

I agree with this to be honest.

In the meantime I'd go for 'wee man' or 'big guy' or something similar, with the occasional use of his name dropped in so that started to become more natural.

ShatteredPeace · 30/10/2023 07:44

I'm guessing it's Peace-something given OP says it's exceptionally close to something on a list someone suggested. That's not that awful if so - just saying Peace is fine, and doesn't sound rude in some accents anyway.

Surely there have been many situations in your husband's life where he's had to suppress his emotions? He's had a boss? He's been to funerals? This is just another of those things. He needs to practice alone, of course he laughs when he practices with you because anyone would with one other person.

Going forward, he needs to cope with saying the name.

Desperatenow1 · 30/10/2023 07:42

I am with your husband actually. If people insist on calling their children these ridiculous names they are going to have to expect some flak for it.

I would be exactly the same, if it was that ridiculous I wouldn't be able to say it without laughing, that's all there is to it, nothing to do with feelings towards the DIL or anything else, just simply - stupid name, nope can't do it.

CwmYoy · 30/10/2023 07:39

If people call their poor children ridiculous names they have to accept the flak that comes with it. As the poor child will have to learn to live with the bullying.

WonderingWanda · 30/10/2023 07:34

I feel like you've got quite a bit of stick op. If your dh is neurodiverse could you quietly speak with your son and dil and explain the problem, tell them he might just refer to the baby as something like 'sunshine' 'pumpkin' 'bubba' or something for a bit longer. I am certain that this problem will resolve itself when your grandson is actually walking and talking and responding to his name with no problem. Just ask them to be patient with him.

Woahtherehoney · 30/10/2023 07:27

Blyther · 29/10/2023 23:17

That’s a very good suggestion- thank you

I very very much hope nobody would stoop so low as to lie about dementia.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 30/10/2023 07:24

Hopskiplou · 29/10/2023 23:08

@Pinkpinkpink15 Cunty Bear! 😂🤣 Country, maybe?

I am loving this thread, which I suspect is a wind up, but has me laughing out loud

@Hopskiplou

Gid only knows?!?! But anything with bear in it he could call him 'cub'

dontforgetme · 30/10/2023 07:21

@LunaNorth absolutely!!

HeadNorth · 30/10/2023 07:20

OP - can you imagine any way of moving forward that does not involve your husband using his grandson's name? Because I can't. So your hunsband is going to have to adult up on this one, or stop seeing his grandson.

Stokey · 30/10/2023 07:20

Generally anything goes with names these days. My kids have friends with quite odd names and none of the children really notice as they don't have the preconceived ideas that older people do. I doubt he'll get bullied at school for that particularly. But do agree you need to get on board or risk alienating your DiL.

LunaNorth · 30/10/2023 07:20

God I’m dying to know this name.

Uniquuue · 30/10/2023 07:20

I hope I never hate my DIL.

Pooooochi · 30/10/2023 07:17

Id find a diminutive, any diminutive. Are there cute sounding initials he can use? Eg JJ etc

Just tell DiL he's getting on a bit and finds the name a mouthful and keep mispronouncing it to sound rude & is mortified by it.

heretogrow · 30/10/2023 07:11

Never mind being bullied at school, his own fucking grandparents are mocking the name! Laughter coming from a 5 year old is more understandable than a grown ass man. I’m afraid this is very sad behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread