Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Pumpkin picking" WTF

388 replies

HauntedGusset · 29/10/2023 17:21

Driving home from a visit to family today there was an absolutely massive traffic jam caused by cars entering/leaving a farm shop that also has a small events centre attached. I last passed the farm shop a few weeks ago and they had some other event on with cars parked all over the field nearest the road. Anyway today the same field was covered in huge pumpkins with families trudging round in the mud "picking" them - but they didn't grow there, they can't have done as the same field was a car park last month Confused They've just been plonked there. Someone tell me why this is a thing?

(And no, I don't have small DC anymore so I suppose I've missed this becoming popular, I was vaguely aware people pick pumpkins but imagined it to be like picking strawberries where you actually pick them fresh from the plant, not like a crapper muddier version of just buying one from Lidl!)

OP posts:
PersephonePomegranate23 · 29/10/2023 19:36

I literally can't see a single negative.

Kids having fun - that's the negative for some people. 😂

It's seems as though doing something fun and shock horror, giving children pleasant memories of childhood is some kind of moral failure to some.

SpatulaSpatula · 29/10/2023 19:36

It's such a fun thing to do! Gets the kids out and talking about nature and farming. I also think farmers really struggle these days so anything to keep them going is a good thing imo. If this were inspired by a festival from any other culture, I don't think it would get so much vitriol. I'm half American and I just this evening had a mini argument with my boyfriend about only being allowed to put our pumpkins out on Halloween night because he thinks Halloween is stupid. I was so excited about sharing Halloween with my daughter but I've felt shamed into doing a really half-arsed job. Luckily, she absolutely loved going pumpkin picking and helping with the carving so I'll put my foot down and go big next year. It's just a bit of fun!

Jellykat · 29/10/2023 19:35

Small children playing with little wheelbarrows, petting animals, doing a treasure hunt in the woods, toasting marshmallows, playing in a playground, excited on a tractor. None of that feels materialistic to me, it's as wholesome as it gets.

Colleen, sorry i do think its hilarious, that to you the above is as 'wholesome as it gets', its a commercial venture cashing in on Halloween tourism, but hey knock yourself out..
To me the reality of farming here in West Wales is very different!

Hayliebells · 29/10/2023 19:35

If people want to spend their money on that, I can't get het up about it. People spend their money on all sorts of rubbish, so if they have a nice family day out then each to their own. At least it's not contributing to crap in landfill. I've never actually been pumpkin picking myself, so I might be way off the mark, but I know people who've been year after year so there must be something to it. Farming needs to diversify after all!

webuiltthiscityonrockandwheat · 29/10/2023 19:32

All those saying it's naff and it's American nonsense. I think what you mean is, this activity isn't for me, I wouldn't enjoy it and I wouldn't pay for it. Doesn't mean it's naff and not worth doing.

My kids had a blast slipping in the mud getting pumpkins yesterday. Ours are grown, cut and then left where they grew. They had face painting, a fun fare, a play park and you could carve pumpkins there and leave the mess.

mollypuss1 · 29/10/2023 19:32

The mumsnet snobs are out in force on this thread.

Backagain23 · 29/10/2023 19:30

I don't get it either. My 4 year old was absolutely thrilled to pick his own out of the stand in Aldi so I'm not sure what a muddy field would have added.
People enjoy different things 🤷‍♀️

welshweasel · 29/10/2023 19:29

It's fun! We go to the garden centre across the road. Kids get to run around with wheelbarrows, I get some nice photos, they can choose their pumpkins (we got 2 large ones for £6 so not extortionate) and we had a coffee and cake. I wouldn't pay to go to one though.

NerrSnerr · 29/10/2023 19:24

Blinky21 · 29/10/2023 19:22

I hate this, another stupid import from the US

What's your actual issue? The family photos? Supporting a local farm? Getting outside for a couple of hours? Children enjoying themselves?

Or is it just the America bit?

Blinky21 · 29/10/2023 19:22

I hate this, another stupid import from the US

FlissyPaps · 29/10/2023 19:21

HauntedGusset · 29/10/2023 18:38

Oh do calm down, I'm not saying it should be banned Hmm People are welcome to engage in whatever "fun" they see fit if it's not causing harm to people/animals/environment, I'm not the fun police, just baffled by why on earth this was a thing in the first place. It was a new one for me, seeing literally hundreds of people queuing to get their hands on a load of plonked pumpkins (plonkins?) in such a shizzy setting. But ok, if other people and their DC enjoy it then crack on and have fun!

Honestly you do sound like the fun police.

What on earth is the point in this thread? What did you want to achieve from it?

Some people enjoy it. Some don’t. And both are totally okay.

What’s not okay, is insinuating that people who do enjoy it are daft…

Bedazzling · 29/10/2023 19:19

I have been pumpkin picking in America and you did choose and pick from the vine they also had cider and apples for sale. I went to one in the UK so was disappointed there was no actual picking. There was a maze with animated Halloween figures which was quite good and horses, goats and pigs to feed. We actually didn’t buy a pumpkin in the end. We had zero children with us :)

FrogFighter · 29/10/2023 19:19

sunnyseed · 29/10/2023 18:22

It’s harmless fun for families with small children so why not? Should this be banned as well as fireworks, Christmas etc? Is no one all allowed any fun at all?

No, no one is saying ‘it should be banned’!! Only if people personally think this is a good value, fun day our or not. Calm down 😆.

IsItFinallySeptemberYet · 29/10/2023 19:15

There are some proper snobs on this thread 🙄 don’t go pumpkin picking if you don’t want to, what’s it to you if others want to do it?

PicturesOfLily · 29/10/2023 19:14

I felt similar but we went for a day out at a farm attraction with friends this week and it included a voucher to pick a pumpkin and then carve it. It was expensive at £17 each but we were there all day for animals and other activities virtually had to be thrown out when it closed. We went to the pumpkin field towards the end and dds loved choosing a pumpkin each (dd2 chose a small white one that I haven’t seen in the supermarkets) and then going to carve it in a special tent they had set up. I was surprised how much they enjoyed it tbh.

Flori7 · 29/10/2023 19:10

I think it’s a bit more wholesome than other activities for kids so I think it’s okay. I’d rather go to an actual farm though if so inclined. I don’t think “boo boxes” are necessary though. Anyone else heard of those? But I also don’t think kids really need a Christmas Eve box as well as everything for Christmas. Bah Humbug! 😁

ColleenDonaghy · 29/10/2023 19:10

Greyarea12 · 29/10/2023 19:03

I took my dd to it last year and maybe I am naive but i expected to pick the pumpkin. But yes, when i got there, i was shocked to see they had been basically put down in a very muddy field for us to just pick up. It cost me a fortune.

As math explained above there's very good reasons why it's pumpkin selecting and not pumpkin harvesting (the word picking of course having more than one meaning in this context).

Giving a load of people with small children sharp knives to cut the pumpkins off the vine (or whatever it's called) would be a very very bad idea.

Alexandra2001 · 29/10/2023 19:07

CandyLeBonBon · 29/10/2023 17:27

It's no different to picking out a freshly cut Christmas tree from the garden centre.

It's a but of a fun family activity and is not, believe it or not, compulsory!

Traffic is shit everywhere. Life is a bit grim and miserable atm so I can't begrudge a bit of wholesome family fun like this!

People have no imagination...

ColleenDonaghy · 29/10/2023 19:07

Jellykat · 29/10/2023 18:43

Durrr let me think..., how about, 'hey kids lets go for a walk', versus 'hey kids, lets go to a Pumpkin patch, and choose one to bring it home'
Spot the difference Colleen?? or shall i spell it out? 😂

Small children playing with little wheelbarrows, petting animals, doing a treasure hunt in the woods, toasting marshmallows, playing in a playground, excited on a tractor. None of that feels materialistic to me, it's as wholesome as it gets.

I literally can't see a single negative. Kids are outside, the four of us get some time together without work or chores encroaching, farm gets some money to keep going. I guess the marshmallows are high in sugar, bad me.

Vet73 · 29/10/2023 19:06

I took my dog to one for some photos. It was free to enter and pumpkins started from £1. We were there for 2 hours and took home a giant £6 pumpkin to support the small family run farm. It brightened my mood in a difficult week and it didn’t hurt anyone

Greyarea12 · 29/10/2023 19:03

I took my dd to it last year and maybe I am naive but i expected to pick the pumpkin. But yes, when i got there, i was shocked to see they had been basically put down in a very muddy field for us to just pick up. It cost me a fortune.

BetiYeti · 29/10/2023 19:02

£10 at a local farm for my daughter to pick out her pumpkin, squelch around in her wellies, see the farm animals, toast some marshmallows and have a hot chocolate. Bit nicer than grabbing a pumpkin from Tesco.

AutumnFroglets · 29/10/2023 19:02

HangingStars · 29/10/2023 17:57

We did pumpkin picking at a PYO farm - the pumpkins were grown there but pre-cut and moved to the undercover pumpkin picking area - there were thousands of them, and DC massively enjoyed rooting through them all to find the perfect one that was just the right size and shape with the right type of handle. It was an hour and a half in the fresh air where they weren’t on screens, and they actually got along with eachother, and well worth the £3 fee! Pumpkins themselves were no more expensive than the supermarket.

Though there is a place closer to us that charges like £18 per person for a “pumpkin experience”, and that is clearly insane, but it’s sold out every year!

Edited

What you did actually sounds lovely. Grown at the farm, big pile under cover, not too expensive. I can see the attraction with that.

I can't however see the attraction traipsing over muddy fields where they've been dumped in a line. At least let them literally pick off the plant if that has to be done imo.

Orchidgarden · 29/10/2023 19:00

It benefits the farmers, who can make a tidy profit from pumpkin picking. Lots of farmers struggle just now and I'm sure the extra income is appreciated.