Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you allow your boys to fight/roughhouse

279 replies

Pooooochi · 29/10/2023 16:01

DS is 7. I've recently noticed after school, at parties etc that most of the parents of his classmates smile & allow boys to be always punching at each other, wrestling.

If you let your kids fight, why do you?

We've always been absolutely zero tolerance on this sort of aggressive behaviour so DS just doesn't do it at all now - to the extent other adults have commented.

However, it seems like socially it means his peers sometimes push him around, they know he wont fight back. I find this sad. Why don't want a world full of aggressive men who jump at a fight any chance they get, so why do we allow it in little boys

OP posts:
sunglassesonthetable · 29/10/2023 19:48

*can't you teach boundaries without letting people playfight.

I've always taught my children not to lay their hands on others. Why do they need to lay their hands on others to learn not hurt others?

I simply do not understand.

And no, before you say wild animals do it, humans are not wild animals.*

I let my children playfight and rough house because they enjoy ithe physical and sensory expression of it. They laugh and get great pleasure from it. Emphasis on the play.

Scientists and academics a lot cleverer than me have done the studies that show it teaches boundaries. Because you do not understand and are not drawn to that type of physicality yourself does not mean it doesn't exist or it is not positive.

Physicality and violence are two different things. Boundaries are very important.

Ylvamoon · 29/10/2023 19:47

I think allowing it perpetuates male privilege

I disagree. There is a fundamental difference between the average boy and averge girl.
The way they play and interact with people, their likes and dislikes when young is different.
Rough play between boys is just one of the obvious differences, nothing to do with male privilege.

Obviously, the exception makes the rule!

3WildOnes · 29/10/2023 19:44

mugboat · 29/10/2023 19:39

why would an adult want to playfight with a child? why is it fun for you?

perhaps they think it's funny because I imagine a grown adult fighting looks ridiculous.

It's fun for me because it make my children laugh and smile! Im sure I do look ridiculous fake throwing them on the floor and holding the them down whilst their sibling wrestles the ball out of their hands. They love it when I am silly!

UsingChangeofName · 29/10/2023 19:43

Mine used to play fight. Emphasis on the word "play". They were able to understand the difference between being aggressive and just play fighting. Actual aggression was not tolerated. They are well adjusted non-aggressive adult men now.

This, although I have both dds and dss.

From my pov, it is those who can't differentiate between rough, physical play and children throwing punches and actually fighting that I find strange. To me, it is akin to those posters on MN who don't seem to think that it is possible to have a glass or two of wine with a meal or go out for the evening without getting completely wrecked, as if everyone letting alcohol touch their lips is a drunk. Same here, enjoying an element of physical play, or wrestling doesn't make you an aggressive child.

Vivi0 · 29/10/2023 19:40

mathanxiety · 29/10/2023 19:28

I had one boy and four girls. I did not allow it.

I think allowing it perpetuates male privilege. Boys who are allowed to do this, whether at home or in public spaces, are being allowed to dominate a space in a way that girls are rarely permitted to.

Then we wonder why men are loud and boorish in public spaces, why they allow testosterone to get the better of them behind the wheel, why man spreading is a thing, why men feel free to piss in public, and all the other anti social behaviour we see, from disruption in classrooms to hooliganism and all the way to domestic violence.

You might think something, but that doesn’t make it true.

There are plenty of studies into the effects and benefits of playfighting in childhood.

There are also plenty of studies into the causes of antisocial behaviour in men, and funnily enough, playfighting in childhood isn’t one of them.

tiggergoesbounce · 29/10/2023 19:39

How many sisters have been bullied over the years due to being fought by their brothers because it is normal boyish behaviour?

And that's obviously a parent problem for not identifying and stopping this behaviour as most parents would, even those who allow playfighting.

mugboat · 29/10/2023 19:39

3WildOnes · 29/10/2023 19:37

OK. Well I do it because my children think it is hilarious and get a lot of joy from this type of play. None of them have ever been in a physical fight with anyone. I've read the research and I can't see any reason not to.

why would an adult want to playfight with a child? why is it fun for you?

perhaps they think it's funny because I imagine a grown adult fighting looks ridiculous.

Terfosaurus · 29/10/2023 19:39

AthenaPopodopolous · 29/10/2023 16:04

Wee boys love to chase, tig and roughhouse. It’s just part of who they are. Your kids been turned into a wimp by you and will be an easy target for bullies now. You need to get a grip!

What a load of bollocks. Mine never liked it. My niece otoh seems to love nothing more than play fighting/rough housing.

3WildOnes · 29/10/2023 19:37

mugboat · 29/10/2023 19:25

No, I read the thread. I understand what people are saying.

I still don't understand why anyone would playfight. Or want to playfight. Or actually encourage their children to playfight.

OK. Well I do it because my children think it is hilarious and get a lot of joy from this type of play. None of them have ever been in a physical fight with anyone. I've read the research and I can't see any reason not to.

mugboat · 29/10/2023 19:37

mathanxiety · 29/10/2023 19:28

I had one boy and four girls. I did not allow it.

I think allowing it perpetuates male privilege. Boys who are allowed to do this, whether at home or in public spaces, are being allowed to dominate a space in a way that girls are rarely permitted to.

Then we wonder why men are loud and boorish in public spaces, why they allow testosterone to get the better of them behind the wheel, why man spreading is a thing, why men feel free to piss in public, and all the other anti social behaviour we see, from disruption in classrooms to hooliganism and all the way to domestic violence.

100% agree

mugboat · 29/10/2023 19:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

strawman argument.

Btw I didn't play fight, neither did my brother. We're not trans.

mugboat · 29/10/2023 19:35

sunglassesonthetable · 29/10/2023 19:30

Like why would you want to playfight. I literally do not understand.

Fine. 👍🏻 Room for all types in this world.

But lots of people are different.

But it's also a normal, healthy thing for kids to do if they want to. It teaches boundaries and releases energy.

can't you teach boundaries without letting people playfight.

I've always taught my children not to lay their hands on others. Why do they need to lay their hands on others to learn not hurt others?

I simply do not understand.

And no, before you say wild animals do it, humans are not wild animals.

FieldInWhichFucksAreGrownIsBarren · 29/10/2023 19:34

Not exclusive to boys, I used to play fight with my brother and male cousins, mainly because it was a laugh -presumably this is why DD & DS do so now. Also I join in on occasion, my bad.

idiotsguide · 29/10/2023 19:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

sunglassesonthetable · 29/10/2023 19:33

I think allowing it perpetuates male privilege. Boys who are allowed to do this, whether at home or in public spaces, are being allowed to dominate a space in a way that girls are rarely permitted to.

What even if girl ms are allowed to do it too?

SoupDragon · 29/10/2023 19:30

My son is now in his early teens and he is gentle, lovely, has a great sense of humour our, and he is popular, he has lots of friends. And so far he is not moody or angry etc. He doesn't display what is considered "typical male teenage" behaviour. Maybe because he was encouraged to speak and not to fight, (same as the girls) now he is able to put in words what is happening to him.

Well, my DSs are adults and are all the things you mention plus I had no problems whatsoever through their teenage years and they were allowed to play fight.

sunglassesonthetable · 29/10/2023 19:30

Like why would you want to playfight. I literally do not understand.

Fine. 👍🏻 Room for all types in this world.

But lots of people are different.

But it's also a normal, healthy thing for kids to do if they want to. It teaches boundaries and releases energy.

girlswillbegirls · 29/10/2023 19:28

crumblingschools · 29/10/2023 19:07

So @Vegetus can you explain why you see more boisterous behaviour with boys in playgrounds than you do with girls. Appears it is allowed in the home with girls with siblings/parents but not out and about, but more acceptable for boys. As ‘boys will be boys’. In the same way initiation ceremonies in rugby teams, ritual humiliation of the groom on a stag do is seen as acceptable as ‘boys will be boys’. Same way going to strip club on a stag do is acceptable as ‘boys will be boys’. It all follows a pattern.

Posters on here saying boys will be ridiculed if they don’t take part in this sort of behaviour and will be seen as a wimp.

How many sisters have been bullied over the years due to being fought by their brothers because it is normal boyish behaviour?

This is spot on

mathanxiety · 29/10/2023 19:28

crumblingschools · 29/10/2023 16:32

Interesting that in most cases there is a male involved, including a dad. If a totally female house would this be happening, encouraged?

Also interesting that one poster said it had to happen otherwise a boy would end up being a wimp, so being violent (even if only in play) is necessary to be a man. Isn’t that going down the route of Andrew Tate.

Safeguarding guidance now specifically discourages behaviour that falls within ‘boys will be boys’

I had one boy and four girls. I did not allow it.

I think allowing it perpetuates male privilege. Boys who are allowed to do this, whether at home or in public spaces, are being allowed to dominate a space in a way that girls are rarely permitted to.

Then we wonder why men are loud and boorish in public spaces, why they allow testosterone to get the better of them behind the wheel, why man spreading is a thing, why men feel free to piss in public, and all the other anti social behaviour we see, from disruption in classrooms to hooliganism and all the way to domestic violence.

mugboat · 29/10/2023 19:25

3WildOnes · 29/10/2023 19:18

@mugboat I think it possible that the posters you are referring to just have a different definition of playfighting than you do? I would say that I roughouse with my children, we have a game where we rugby tackle each other to the ground to get the ball of each other. My kids think it is hilarious when I 'throw them on the ground', it's all fun and games. My children never hit or kick each other when they are rough housing, its rubgy tackling and wrestling.

No, I read the thread. I understand what people are saying.

I still don't understand why anyone would playfight. Or want to playfight. Or actually encourage their children to playfight.

tiggergoesbounce · 29/10/2023 19:24

I understand roughhousing as playfighting/play wrestling.
We used to do it with my Dad when we were younger, yes it ended in tears sometimes but we learnt boundaries on hurting eachother and managing how we "fought".

Other kids used to play harder than us, but we were just taught that if they were playfighting and it was getting to rough for us, walk away. We had 2 neighbours who were very rough with eachother but wouldn't dream of hurting anyone else.

We now playfight with our DS, he jumps all over us, we play back. I dont allow him to kick me but my dad used to be a good boxer, so he punches my dad and kicks him, thats for them to agree on boundaries. Our DS knows not to do it in school or to anyone else. Most his friends do the same with their parents/grandparents but dont take it into school.

SamAndEIIa · 29/10/2023 19:21

Vegetus · 29/10/2023 18:49

Oh fuck off will you, this thread referred to boys.

You seem like a lovely person, capable of a very well thought out, intelligent response.

mumonthehill · 29/10/2023 19:20

Absolutely never ever allowed rough housing or in fact any sort of violence. No play guns either. Neither ds has ever had any need to play in this way.

mathanxiety · 29/10/2023 19:20

AthenaPopodopolous · 29/10/2023 16:04

Wee boys love to chase, tig and roughhouse. It’s just part of who they are. Your kids been turned into a wimp by you and will be an easy target for bullies now. You need to get a grip!

Nonsense.

They do it because adults who are part Neanderthal themselves smile benignly and let them get away with it.

3WildOnes · 29/10/2023 19:18

@mugboat I think it possible that the posters you are referring to just have a different definition of playfighting than you do? I would say that I roughouse with my children, we have a game where we rugby tackle each other to the ground to get the ball of each other. My kids think it is hilarious when I 'throw them on the ground', it's all fun and games. My children never hit or kick each other when they are rough housing, its rubgy tackling and wrestling.