Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to think that off-duty police shouldn't go to a strip club?

180 replies

TheIckFactor · 29/10/2023 13:20

Name change here.

My STBXH has admitted that when we were still very much together, he and his police buddies (only the blokes) went to a strip club in another city on their Christmas get-together...

Now it makes sense why they'd travel 100 miles - not for the Christmas markets...

I got the bullshit 'didn't want to be left out/I was drunk'. Yep, a married man, a copper, in his 40s can succumb to peer pressure apparently, poor thing. Yeah, right.

Oh yeah, and it was two Christmases! So that bullshit excuse is stretched real thin the second time. Lovely. Happy Christmas, darling.

So, the rights and wrongs of strip clubs in general - and I'm very much of the view that they're exploitative of women; and of husbands/partners doing this on the sly aside,
what do you all think of off-duty police officers going as a group (probably 10+, I'd guess) to strip clubs?

I feel it speaks to a culture of misogyny within the police, that they would think this is ok, but AIBU?

OP posts:
BubziOwl · 31/10/2023 15:34

Nonplusultra · 29/10/2023 13:31

It absolutely speaks to their character and work culture.

The expectation that people in public office maintain certain moral standards has really only slipped in the last half century - still well within living memory.

I agree with you op but we’re probably in the minority.

Totally agree. We should be holding police officers to higher moral standards than other people imo.

TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 15:24

ginasevern · 31/10/2023 15:17

@TheIckFactor

Yep, it's like an episode from "Life on Mars". As you say, it is an exclusionary event. What about female colleagues or those with other faiths and the welfare of the women at the venue itself? Below is a paragraph from the Hansard Report presented to the House of Commons after Sarah Everard was murdered. There is much more to the report and most of it very damning. Any woman who thinks it's fair game for police officers to organise a works do at a sex venue should read the full report.

"Women fear that an internal culture of misogyny might also affect how police treat members of the public. I have had women get in touch with me to share their experiences of having complaints of stalking and harassment dismissed—even laughed at—by Metropolitan police officers, leaving them feeling powerless and abandoned, and as though the behaviour of their perpetrators had been normalised."

Wow, gina, thanks for this.
I hope people do read it. I hadn't seen it and am grateful to you for flagging it. 🙏

OP posts:
Bookworm20 · 31/10/2023 15:22

I get what you mean. Its grim and no YANBU.

Strip clubs are gross anyway, as are men who frequent them.
But for a police officer to choose to go on a works do no less, is just even more grim somehow.

I mean he is in a profession which is supposed to protect people. Including women and vulnerable people.

Yet how can he do that when he has a view of women as objects to get his sexual kicks from?
The two just don't match up.

If you choose a profession which holds such high responsibility, then you need to hold yourself to that responsibility!

If you view 50% of society as objects there for your entertainment and missing out on strip clubs is an issue - change your fucking profession to something which isn't going to hold you morally accountable and isn't about protecting the general public (including women!).

ChristmasQuestions · 31/10/2023 15:20

At least it sounds as though your ex-husband has grown/matured. That's cheered me up on an otherwise bleak thread.

TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 15:18

Sorry, Tutu, I didn't see this:
Quote: "Perhaps I did jump to a conclusion. Can you explain then why you think women in strip clubs would then automatically have less confidence in police if off duty police were occasionally in their strip club? I think you can only have this conclusion if you think only a “bad” cop would be in a strip club. So if it’s not that then, why?"

No, I don't think only a bad cop would be in strip club. My husband isn't bent or bad by any stretch. But his shame in telling me is because he knows that the women are being objectified. That regardless of how much people will say these women are in control or well-paid (surely a generalisation - there's undoubtedly a scale), the men are there to objectify them.

He knows too, that I've known several women who've been raped, all in 'date rape' situations, where they were objectified by the perpetrators. He knows that I would have less confidence in the police, knowing this, if I had to report another rape. That's where I'm coming from. If I'm wrong to think other women, strippers included, would feel less confident, then I'm wrong.

The cherry on top: He knows that I know that a former colleague of his (trained together, then joined different forces) was up on rape and coercive control charges in recent years.

I really am going to bow out now.

OP posts:
ginasevern · 31/10/2023 15:17

@TheIckFactor

Yep, it's like an episode from "Life on Mars". As you say, it is an exclusionary event. What about female colleagues or those with other faiths and the welfare of the women at the venue itself? Below is a paragraph from the Hansard Report presented to the House of Commons after Sarah Everard was murdered. There is much more to the report and most of it very damning. Any woman who thinks it's fair game for police officers to organise a works do at a sex venue should read the full report.

"Women fear that an internal culture of misogyny might also affect how police treat members of the public. I have had women get in touch with me to share their experiences of having complaints of stalking and harassment dismissed—even laughed at—by Metropolitan police officers, leaving them feeling powerless and abandoned, and as though the behaviour of their perpetrators had been normalised."

TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 15:04

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 14:42

I think you are conflating two things, covertly recording or gathering evidence doesn’t have to be done as part of an official covert operation by on duty law enforcement.

Any member of the public can do it. Many cases in the courts involving assault, robbery, murder, terrorism, hate speech and so on rely on covertly recorded evidence by a member of the public- off duty cops have the same right to do this.

The circumstances in which evidence is gathered very much dictates whether that evidence is admissible in court.
You've introduced this line of argument to somehow justify the boys' boozy strip club Christmas jolly along the lines of an evidence gathering opportunity. It's not rooted in reality. The CPS would bounce back any such 'evidence' long before a defence barrister could laugh it out of court.

Remember, my question was specific to those particular circumstances. I should have framed it better, I see that now. 'AIBU to think that a police Christmas work night out shouldn't take place in a strip club', perhaps?

I'm guessing you might want to keep justifying your line of argument but I'm going to politely bow out of this exchange, if you don't mind. I think it's gone off on a tangent.

OP posts:
TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 14:47

ToadOnTheHill · 31/10/2023 14:34

@TheIckFactor not being funny but if you thin its against a code, dont you have a moral duty to report your ex husband?

Morals are personal. Do you think it's more important to grass up Stbxh because he has broken the Code or are you going to turn a blind eye because you wanted validation from mumsnet that hes a bastard (but wont hold yourself to the same standards by reporting a breach of the Code?)

No, Toad, it's a good question.
A few people on here have wrongly thought I'm hellbent on revenge - when the reality is that our split has been as amicable as possible. I'm not that sort of person anyway and neither could I see how 'ruining his life' as one put it would benefit me.

But I have thought about whether their professional standards people are aware and indeed if I have an obligation. That code that I quoted in an earlier post is undoubtedly open to interpretation - by everybody. So I was wanting, genuinely, to get a sense of whether the majority of people would see it as a problem. If a straw poll on Mumsnet suggests a majority don't see it as a problem, then I may just have to accept that these guys aren't doing something that goes against public opinion, bringing the force into disrepute, if you will - which is what the code is based on. Do you get me?

OP posts:
user1483387154 · 31/10/2023 14:46

if we are willing to pay all these public sector workers 24/7 365 wages, maybe you have a point. Free time is free time. Having personally taught the children of many women who worked at strip clubs ... Peter stringfellows etc ,they are the ones in control and had more disposable income and a better home than I could ever imagine They were totally in control and made 10x i did as a teacher

sex trade is a different topic !

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 14:42

TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 14:24

For clarity, there's a world of difference between 'covertly' - a covert operation, and just going in on your own time in civvies. I don't think you can conflate the two.

I think you are conflating two things, covertly recording or gathering evidence doesn’t have to be done as part of an official covert operation by on duty law enforcement.

Any member of the public can do it. Many cases in the courts involving assault, robbery, murder, terrorism, hate speech and so on rely on covertly recorded evidence by a member of the public- off duty cops have the same right to do this.

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 14:38

TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 14:19

What you've said doesn't make sense to me.
'Dirty cop' is a pretty strong description and usually implies serious corruption and often a link to organised crime. I don't for a moment imagine that the average police officer would be corrupt to that level, or even a bit 'bent'. You're way off in what you think I'm saying here.

As to going in covertly, then they would be on duty - otherwise the 'evidence' you suggest they could be gathering wouldn't be of use in a prosecution. As I've outlined in posts above, police are required to stick to a code of conduct that applies even off-duty. They're not my rules. A judge would toss 'evidence' gathered when officers were pissed in a strip club on a jolly - which is what I'm talking about. A boozed-up work Christmas party - reiterating here for the benefit of everyone who seems to have failed to grasp that.
I think you jumped to a conclusion and are now trying to validate that - but it doesn't hold weight.

You can gather evidence covertly whether off duty or on duty as part of a covert op. So it isn’t true that everything seen & done covertly is always whilst on duty.

A judge isn’t going to toss evidence because the cop was off duty. Evidence gathered off duty when the police are where they have a legal right to be as a member of the public is completely admissible evidence.

Perhaps I did jump to a conclusion. Can you explain then why you think women in strip clubs would then automatically have less confidence in police if off duty police were occasionally in their strip club? I think you can only have this conclusion if you think only a “bad” cop would be in a strip club. So if it’s not that then, why?

Also, answer me this, how can police protect the vulnerable if strip clubs become a no go zone when off duty? They’d be limited to going for a shake down in uniform- which will leave them empty handed because snitches get stitches. Or doing the official covert operation- which they are not funded to do because society doesn’t give two shits about working class girls dancing naked on a stage. They’d rather have the police catching murderers and drug runners. So, no plain clothes off duty police in any strip club means owners need not worry about trying to stay legal. They can abuse the women, traffick them. It will all be behind closed doors- what do you think that feeling of “no cop is going to come in here- they’d lose their job” would do? It would embolden the ones we know ARE exploiting women in the sex industry.

TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 14:34

ginasevern · 30/10/2023 15:49

@TheIckFactor

Sorry I'm so late responding to you. I completely "got" the context you were talking about and I knew we were on the same page. I was reading another MN thread a few days ago where the OP was horrified to discover on some Government site the sheer number of police officers under disciplinary action for sexual offences (and other vile behaviour) against women. How can any woman justify an all male piss up with naked women thrown in as a suitable works party for public servants where misogyny and sexual assault is rife. Don't they read the papers?

Please don't apologise, gina. I'm only getting back to this myself.
Exactly that - an all-male piss up at a sexual entertainment venue. All very 1970s. And as ChristmasQuestions and mewkins allude to, there's the question of the women who work with these guys. Their female colleagues were not in attendance and very much aware of the men going - what they felt about it, I don't know.

OP posts:
ToadOnTheHill · 31/10/2023 14:34

@TheIckFactor not being funny but if you thin its against a code, dont you have a moral duty to report your ex husband?

Morals are personal. Do you think it's more important to grass up Stbxh because he has broken the Code or are you going to turn a blind eye because you wanted validation from mumsnet that hes a bastard (but wont hold yourself to the same standards by reporting a breach of the Code?)

Onethingatatime23 · 31/10/2023 14:31

I was just wondering the other day whether strip clubs still existed. They seemed to becoming normalised in the early 2000s and it seemed we just had to get on with feeling unsafe.

There used to be one on Gray's Inn Road and another near Warren St and I resented them being there and having to walk past them to work with a load of dodgy punters hanging about.

I think anyone in the police force should be thinking really carefully about what they do in their spare time these days and what it says about them.

GilberMarkham · 31/10/2023 14:31

I'm also of the opinion that the vast vast majority of men who go into them while in relationships would find their partners doing the equivalent totally inappropriate/unacceptable.

GilberMarkham · 31/10/2023 14:29

Anyway, they probably justify the strip clubs and being entirely legal and ignoring any ethical issues ...both with the strippers'backgrounds ... and with their relationships.

I am of the opinion they are inappropriate for anyone in an exclusive relationship, end of.

GilberMarkham · 31/10/2023 14:25

My h has a friend/acquaintance who did a stint on the Met...he and his colleagues went to brothels.

When it comes to protecting women, they are foxes "guarding" the chickens. (Or should that be wolves?)

TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 14:24

TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 14:19

What you've said doesn't make sense to me.
'Dirty cop' is a pretty strong description and usually implies serious corruption and often a link to organised crime. I don't for a moment imagine that the average police officer would be corrupt to that level, or even a bit 'bent'. You're way off in what you think I'm saying here.

As to going in covertly, then they would be on duty - otherwise the 'evidence' you suggest they could be gathering wouldn't be of use in a prosecution. As I've outlined in posts above, police are required to stick to a code of conduct that applies even off-duty. They're not my rules. A judge would toss 'evidence' gathered when officers were pissed in a strip club on a jolly - which is what I'm talking about. A boozed-up work Christmas party - reiterating here for the benefit of everyone who seems to have failed to grasp that.
I think you jumped to a conclusion and are now trying to validate that - but it doesn't hold weight.

For clarity, there's a world of difference between 'covertly' - a covert operation, and just going in on your own time in civvies. I don't think you can conflate the two.

OP posts:
TheIckFactor · 31/10/2023 14:19

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 13:59

Because you said the women working there would end up with “less confidence” in the police. That only makes sense if you assume all police that go to a strip club off duty are there to exploit women, hassle them for sex, and act as enforcers for their pimps (if they are trafficked). It’s usually off duty law enforcement that is able to blend in enough to see the signs of exploitation and trafficking, and covertly get evidence. If cops go in on duty and in uniform, no one is going to tell them, anything, and the entire club will be putting on the performance of their lives to convince the police that everything is above board.

What you've said doesn't make sense to me.
'Dirty cop' is a pretty strong description and usually implies serious corruption and often a link to organised crime. I don't for a moment imagine that the average police officer would be corrupt to that level, or even a bit 'bent'. You're way off in what you think I'm saying here.

As to going in covertly, then they would be on duty - otherwise the 'evidence' you suggest they could be gathering wouldn't be of use in a prosecution. As I've outlined in posts above, police are required to stick to a code of conduct that applies even off-duty. They're not my rules. A judge would toss 'evidence' gathered when officers were pissed in a strip club on a jolly - which is what I'm talking about. A boozed-up work Christmas party - reiterating here for the benefit of everyone who seems to have failed to grasp that.
I think you jumped to a conclusion and are now trying to validate that - but it doesn't hold weight.

OP posts:
ginasevern · 31/10/2023 14:12

@Cosywintertime

Well, given that there are only 150k police officers in the UK and at least one of them is in the paper every day, that's a pretty damning percentage. It's not even headline news any more.

ReadySalty · 31/10/2023 14:11

Men are so weak when out as a tribe, it's pitiful really.

JudgeJ · 31/10/2023 14:05

KimberleyClark · 29/10/2023 13:54

Decent men don’t go to strip clubs full stop.

Are shows like the Chippendales still around?

TutuDesi · 31/10/2023 13:59

TheIckFactor · 29/10/2023 16:54

I've no idea where you get the idea that I am 'assuming they are also dirty cops'. That's a bizarre conclusion you've drawn.

Because you said the women working there would end up with “less confidence” in the police. That only makes sense if you assume all police that go to a strip club off duty are there to exploit women, hassle them for sex, and act as enforcers for their pimps (if they are trafficked). It’s usually off duty law enforcement that is able to blend in enough to see the signs of exploitation and trafficking, and covertly get evidence. If cops go in on duty and in uniform, no one is going to tell them, anything, and the entire club will be putting on the performance of their lives to convince the police that everything is above board.

JudgeJ · 31/10/2023 13:58

Cosyblankets · 29/10/2023 13:22

His job is irrelevant
He was off duty

I would agree with the OP if she were to apply the same rules to parents, people are easily critical of teachers having a social life but never say anything about parents doing the same.

bombastix · 31/10/2023 13:52

Not surprised. It's only a generation from the time some police regarded this stuff as a perk of being on duty, never mind off duty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread